O'Toole's Libertyville Menu

4.5

(1,650+ Reviews)

$American, Family, Gastropub

Small Bites
- Crispy Brussels Sprout Chips
  Herb finishing salt
  $7.00
- Creamy Deviled Eggs
  Boursin cheese
  $6.00
- Bloody Mary Deviled Eggs
  Bacon and bloody mary spice
  $7.00
- Roasted Curry Cauliflower
  Hummus and tahini
  $7.00
- Pork Belly Burnt Ends
  Chipotle dry rub and Alabama white BBQ sauce
  $7.00
- Pork Belly Bao Buns
  Teriyaki glazed pork belly, radish, shredded carrots, green onions, and sesame sriracha aioli
  $7.00
Start & Share
- 10 Pieces Bone-In Wings
  $18.00
- 20 Pieces Bone-In Wings
  $36.00
- 1/2 LB Boneless Wings
  $10.00
- 1 LB Boneless Wings
  $20.00
- Giant Bavarian Pretzel
  Featured item. Beer cheese, IPA mustard, and honey mustard
  $17.00
- Chips, Salsa & Guacamole
  Fresh made guacamole, salsa and tortilla chips
  $13.00
- Mezze Board
  Whipped feta, hummus, cucumbers, cauliflower, radish, tomatoes, carrots, olives, and toasted pita
  $17.00
- Pretzel Trio
  Flash fried, locally sourced pretzels, beer cheese fondue, IPA mustard, and Guinness honey mustard
  $13.00
- Nachos
  Featured item. Tortilla chips, black beans, tomatoes, three cheese blends, house pickled jalapeños, scallions, salsa, and sour cream
  $13.00
- Lobster Mac & Cheese
  Lobster claw and tail meat, campanelle pasta, mascarpone cream sauce, Parmesan bread crumbs
  $23.00
- Reuben Egg Rolls
  Corned beef, jack cheese, sauerkraut, caraway seeds, spicy mustard, and 1000 Island for dipping
  $13.00
- Whipped Feta
  Local honey, black pepper, and toasted pita
  $13.00
Salads
- Michigan Avenue Salad
  Arcadian greens, goat cheese, avocado, corn, craisins, almonds, tomatoes, croutons, and citrus vinaigrette
  $15.00
- Classic Cobb Salad
  Arcadian greens, avocado, egg, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, bacon, scallions, and choice of dressing
  $15.00
- Caesar Salad
  Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan Reggiano, and croutons
  $14.00
- Sonoma Salad
  Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, corn, green onion, artichoke hearts, celery, radish, green goddess dressing, and deviled egg on top
  $15.00
- Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna Salad
  Avocado, kale, fried wontons, shredded carrots, green onion, and yuzu vinaigrette
  $22.00
- BBQ Chicken Salad
  Arcadian greens, grilled or crispy chicken, tomatoes, three cheeses, fried onions, BBQ sauce, and ranch dressing
  $18.00
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  Romaine lettuce, grilled or crispy chicken, tomatoes, celery, bleu cheese crumbles, and ranch dressing
  $18.00
- Truffle Kale Caesar Salad
  $14.00
Wraps
- Michigan Avenue Wrap
  $15.00
- Classic Cobb Wrap
  $15.00
- Caesar Wrap
  $14.00
- Sonoma Wrap
  $15.00
- BBQ Chicken Wrap
  $18.00
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap
  $18.00
- Truffle Kale Caeser Wrap
  $14.00
O'Toole's Classics
- Baja Fish Tacos
  Beer battered fresh cod, jalapeño aioli, baja slaw, pico de gallo, corn tortillas, rice, and beans
  $17.00
- Bowl French Onion Soup Entree
  Caramelized onions, beef stock, crouton, and bubbling cheese
  $10.00
- Classic Pot Roast
  $20.00
- Fish & Chips
  Featured item. Beer battered cod, fries, tartar sauce, coleslaw, lemon, and malt vinegar
  $20.00
- Lobster Mac & Cheese
  Lobster claw and tail meat, campanelle pasta, mascarpone cream sauce, Parmesan bread crumbs
  $23.00
- Mac & Cheese Entree
  $15.00
- Maple Bourbon Glazed Salmon
  $23.00
- Shepherd's Pie
  Featured item. O'Toole's Guinness beef stew, vegetables, Parmesan potato crust, and Irish soda bread
  $19.00
Burgers
- O'Toole's Original Burger
  Featured item. Cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onion
  $16.00
- Tiny Tim Smashburger
  Smash patty, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onion
  $14.00
- Chicago Fire
  Featured item. Avocado, fried egg, bacon, Irish ghost sauce, Cheddar cheese, and pretzel bun
  $20.00
- Garlic Cheddar
  Caramelized onion, garlic Cheddar cheese, roasted garlic aioli, and crispy garlic
  $18.00
- Bacon Jam
  Smoked bacon, Cheddar cheese, caramelized onion bacon jam, and garlic aioli
  $18.00
- Alabama Smokehouse
  Smoked gouda, pork belly burnt ends, house pickled jalapeño, coleslaw, and Alabama white BBQ sauce
  $20.00
- French Onion Burger
  $19.00
- All American Smash Burger
  $17.00
- Pickle Ghost Smash Burger
  (2) 4 oz patties, shaved onion, American cheese, pickles, and pickle ghost sauce
  $18.00
- Little Timmy
  BBQ sauce, Cheddar cheese, mozzarella, Jack, Swiss cheeses, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, fried onions, and bacon
  $19.00
- Big Timmy
  (2) 1/2 lb burger patties, Jack, Cheddar, mozzarella, Swiss, bacon, fried onions, BBQ, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and red onion. Served with Irish nachos
  $30.00
Bowls
- Za'atar Cauliflower Shawarma Pita Bowl
  Featured item. Cauliflower, rice pilaf, hummus, tomatoes, cucumber and red onion salad, kalamata olives, cabbage, sesame seeds, garlic tahini, Shug sauce, and pita
  $15.00
- Bulgogi Bowl
  Rice, Korean marinated beef, shredded carrots, cucumbers, kimchi, fried egg, sesame seeds, and cilantro, drizzled with sesame sriracha sauce
  $19.00
- Orange Chicken Sticky Rice Bowl
  Crispy orange chicken over sticky rice with wontons broccoli, bell peppers, sesame seeds, and scallions
  $17.00
- Ahi Tuna Bowl
  Sesame crusted tuna, jasmine rice, avocado, cucumber, radish, green onion, spicy sesame aioli drizzle, teriyaki glaze, and wasabi peas
  $22.00
- Wild Mushroom Bowl
  Ancient grains, herb roasted mushrooms, grilled broccolini, roasted tomatoes, crispy brussel sprout chips, sunflower seeds, and green goddess drizzle
  $16.00
- Birria Beef Bowl
  Featured item. Rice, shredded birria beef, charred corn, avocado, radish, pico de gallo, cilantro, crumbled cheese, and corn tortillas
  $19.00
- Teriyaki Bowl
  Sticky rice, broccoli, bell peppers, pineapple, sesame seeds, crispy wontons, and teriyaki sauce
  $13.00
Desserts
- Chocolate Walnut Brownie
  Caramel, chocolate sauce, vanilla ice cream, and whipped cream
  $7.00
- Pretzel Bread Pudding
  Vanilla ice cream and caramel sauce
  $7.00
- Warm Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet
  Vanilla ice cream
  $9.00
Sides
- Fries
  $5.00
- Tater Tots
  $5.00
- Classic Coleslaw
  $5.00
- Rice Pilaf
  $5.00
- Housemade Chips
  $5.00
- Mashed Potatoes
  $5.00
Premium Sides
- Bowl - Soup of the Day
  $8.00
- Cup - Soup of the Day
  $5.00
- Cup of French Onion Soup
  $6.00
- Garlic Parmesan Fries
  $6.00
- Garlic Parmesan Tots
  $6.00
- Grilled Broccolini
  $6.00
- Mac & Cheese Side
  $6.00
- Mashed Potatoes
  $6.00
- Side Caesar Salad
  $6.00
- Side Salad
  $6.00
- Steamed Broccoli
  $6.00
- Truffle Fries*
  $6.00
Handhelds
- Bacon Turkey Cheddar Melt
  $17.00
- French Dip
  $18.00
- Classic Reuben
  $18.00
- Spicy Blackened Chicken Melt
  $17.00
- Turkey Club
  $17.00
- Adult Grilled Cheese
  $15.00
- BLT
  $16.00
- Birria Grilled Cheese
  $18.00
Specials
- Corned Beef on Rye
  $17.00
- Corned Beef & Cabbage
  $21.00
- Guinness Beef Stew
  $19.00
- Loaf of Soda Bread
  $7.00
- Fish & Chips
  Featured item. Beer battered cod, fries, tartar sauce, coleslaw, lemon, and malt vinegar
  $20.00
- Baja Fish Tacos
  Beer battered fresh cod, jalapeño aioli, baja slaw, pico de gallo, corn tortillas, rice, and beans
  $17.00
- Blackened Shrimp Taco
  $18.00
- Shrimp Po' Boy
  $18.00
Side of
- 4oz Guacamole
  $4.00
- 4oz Whipped Feta
  $7.00
- Cup of Guacamole
  $8.00
- Cup of Salsa
  $5.00
- Side of 4oz Beer Cheese
  $3.00
- Side of 1000 Island
  $1.50
- Side of Applesauce
  $1.50
- Side of Avocado
  $2.00
- Side of BBQ
  $1.50
- Side of Bleu Cheese
  $2.00
- Side of Garlic Aioli
  $1.50
- Side of Honey Mustard
  $1.50
- Side of Horseradish Aioli
  $1.50
- Side of Jalapeño
  $1.50
- Side of Mayo
  $1.00
- Side of Orange Sauce
  $2.00
- Side of Pickles
  $1.00
- Side of Ranch
  $1.50
- Side of Salsa
  $1.00
- Side of Shug Sauce
  $2.00
- Side of Sour Cream
  $1.50
- Side of Soy Sauce
  $1.00
- Side of Sriracha Aioli
  $1.50
- Side of Teriyaki
  $1.50
- Wing Sauce
  $1.50
Small Bites
- Crispy Brussels Sprout Chips
  Bacon and bloody mary spice
  $7.00
- Creamy Deviled Eggs
  Hummus and tahini
  $6.00
- Grilled Broccolini
  Chipotle dry rub and Alabama white BBQ sauce
  $6.00
- Roasted Curry Cauliflower
  Hummus and tahini
  $7.00
- Pork Belly Burnt Ends
  Chipotle dry rub and Alabama white BBQ sauce
  $7.00
Start & Share
- Chips, Salsa & Guacamole*
  Fresh made guacamole and salsa served with warm tortilla chips
  $13.00
- Mezze Board*
  Whipped feta, hummus, cucumbers, cauliflower, radish, tomatoes, carrots, olives, and toasted pita
  $17.00
- Nachos*
  Featured item. Tortilla chips, black beans, tomatoes, three cheese blends, house pickled jalapeños, scallions, salsa, and sour cream
  $13.00
- Dip Trio
  Whipped feta, boursin cheese, hummus, and veggies
  $15.00
- 10 Pieces Bone-In Wings*
  $18.00
- 20 Pieces Bone-In Wings*
  $36.00
Salads
- Michigan Avenue Salad
  Featured item. Arcadian greens, goat cheese, avocado, corn, craisins, almonds, tomatoes, croutons, and citrus vinaigrette
  $15.00
- Classic Cobb Salad
  Arcadian greens, avocado, egg, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, bacon, scallions, and choice of dressing
  $15.00
- Caesar Salad
  Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan Reggiano, and croutons
  $13.00
- Wedge Salad
  Pork belly, heirloom tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, green onion, and house bleu cheese dressing
  $15.00
- Sonoma Salad
  Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, corn, green onion, artichoke hearts, celery, radish, green goddess dressing, and deviled egg on top
  $15.00
- BBQ Chicken Salad
  Arcadian greens, grilled or crispy chicken, tomatoes, three cheeses, fried onions, BBQ sauce, and ranch dressing
  $18.00
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  Romaine lettuce, grilled or crispy chicken, tomatoes, celery, bleu cheese crumbles, and ranch dressing
  $18.00
- Truffle Kale Caesar Salad
  $14.00
Burgers & Chicken
- O'Toole's Original Burger*
  Cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onion
  $19.00
- Tiny Tim*
  Smash patty, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, and onion
  $17.00
- Chicago Fire*
  Avocado, fried egg, bacon, Irish ghost sauce, Cheddar cheese, and pretzel bun
  $23.00
- Garlic Cheddar*
  Caramelized onion, garlic Cheddar cheese, roasted garlic aioli, and crispy garlic
  $21.00
- Pickle Ghost Smash Burger*
  (2) 4 oz patties, shaved onion, American cheese, pickles, and pickle ghost sauce
  $21.00
- Bacon Jam*
  Smoked bacon, Cheddar cheese, caramelized onion bacon jam, and garlic aioli
  $21.00
- Alabama Smokehouse*
  Smoked gouda, pork belly burnt ends, house pickled jalapeño, coleslaw, and Alabama white BBQ sauce
  $23.00
- All American Smash Burger
  $17.00
Entrees & Bowls
- Wild Mushroom Bowl*
  Ancient grains, herb-roasted mushrooms, grilled broccolini, roasted tomatoes, crispy Brussels sprout chips, sunflower seeds, and green goddess drizzle
  $16.00
- Birria Beef Bowl*
  Featured item. Rice, shredded birria beef, charred corn, avocado, radish, pico de gallo, cilantro, crumbled cheese, and corn tortillas
  $19.00
- Za'atar Cauliflower Shawarma Bowl*
  Featured item. Rice pilaf, hummus, tomatoes, cucumber and red onion salad, kalamata olives, cabbage, sesame seeds, garlic tahini, and schug sauce
  $15.00
- Burrito Bowl *
  Rice pilaf, black beans, three cheeses, pico de gallo, avocado, and cilantro lime crema
  $13.00
- Classic Pot Roast
  $20.00
- Pan Roasted Glazed Salmon*
  $23.00
Tacos
- Grilled Chicken Tacos
  Grilled chicken thigh, pico de gallo, lettuce, avocado, cilantro lime crema, corn tortillas, rice, and beans
  $14.00
Handhelds
- Classic Reuben*
  Featured item. Corned beef, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing, swiss cheese, and marbled rye
  $21.00
- Turkey Club*
  Local Michigan turkey, lettuce, tomato, applewood smoked bacon, and mayo
  $19.00
- Spicy Blackened Chicken Melt*
  Blackened chicken, bacon, avocado, Jack cheese and jalapeño aioli, on grilled Tuscan bread
  $20.00
Sides
- Fries*
  $5.00
- Tater Tots*
  $5.00
- Classic Coleslaw*
  $5.00
- Rice Pilaf*
  $5.00
- Housemade Chips*
  $5.00
Premium Sides
- Garlic Parmesan Fries*
  $6.00
- Garlic Parmesan Tots*
  $6.00
- Truffle Fries**
  $6.00
- Lemon Parmesan Broccolini
  $6.00
- Side Salad*
  $6.00
- Steamed Broccoli*
  $6.00