Old New York Deli & Bakery Co. Menu

4.0

(475+ Reviews)

$Bagel shop, Bakery, Breakfast

Drinks Online
- Chocolate Milk
  $3.29
- Dr Browns Soda
  $3.99
- Fresh Squeezed Grapefruit Juice
  $6.99
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
  $6.99
- Gatorade
  $3.99
- Martinelli's Apple Juice
  $3.29
- Milk
  $3.29
- Perrier Water
  $3.99
- Organic Tractor Soda/Iced Tea
  $3.79
- Voss Water (or similar)
  $2.99
Organic Coffee, Espresso & Tea
- Drip Coffee
  $3.79
- Hot Tea
  $3.79
- Chai Tea Latte
  $5.49
- Matcha Tea Latte
  $5.49
- Americano
  $3.99
- Cappuccino
  $4.99
- Caramel Macchiato
  $5.79
- Latte
  $4.99
- Mocha
  $5.49
- Redeye
  $4.49
- Vanilla Latte
  $5.59
- White Chocolate Mocha
  $5.79
- Espresso
  $2.69
Signature Sips
- Hot Chocolate
  $4.49
- Blended Mocha
  $5.99
- Mammoth Dream
  $5.99
- Strawberry Banana Smoothie
  real fresh fruit, non fat vanilla yogurt
  $5.99
Bagels
Made from scratch, kettle-boiled and hearth-baked daily. No preservatives added.
- Just A Bagel
  PLAIN IN A BAG, NO TOPPINGS , NOT SLICED OR TOASTED. MADE FROM SCRATCH, NO OILS OR PRESERVATIVES ADDED
  $2.99
- Bagel w/ Schmear
  Bagel with cream cheese, butter etc. Made from scratch, kettle boiled and hearth baked daily. No preservatives. $2.99-$6.99
- Baker's Dozen
  Made from scratch, kettle-boiled and hearth-baked daily. No preservatives added.
  $22.99
- Bagel Dog
  $7.29
- Pizza Bagel
CREAM CHEESE
HOUSE MADE USING ONLY THE BEST....PHILADELPHIA BRAND!
- Plain CC 1/2lb
  $6.99
- Plain CC 1lb
  $11.99
- Butter 1/2lb
  $4.99
- Butter 1/4lb
  $2.49
- H Walnut CC 1/2
  $7.99
- Roasted Red Bell Pepper Hummus 1/2lb
  $7.99
- Jalapeno CC 1/2
  $7.99
- Lite CC 1/2
  $7.99
- Lox CC 1/2 lb
  $9.99
- Scallion CC 1/2
  $7.99
- Strawbrry CC 1/2
  $7.99
- Veggie CC 1/2
  $7.99
- Tofu CC Plain 1/2lb
  $7.99
Bagel Breakfast Sandwiches
cage-free egg cooked with real butter, seed oil free, served on your choice of bagel or bialy. kick it up a notch and add a latke
- Egg & Cheese
  Cage free egg, American cheese, Choice of bagel
  $8.99
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese
  Cage free fried egg, bacon, American cheese, Choice of bagel
  $11.99
- Ham, Egg & Cheese
  Cage free fried egg, Black Forest Ham, American cheese, Choice of bagel
  $11.99
- Turkey Sausage, Egg & Cheese
  Cage free fried egg, turkey sausage, American cheese, Choice of bagel
  $11.99
- Avocado, Egg & Cheese
  Cage free fried egg, avocado, American cheese, Choice of bagel
  $11.99
- Chorizo, Egg & Cheese
  Cage free fried egg, chorizo, American cheese, Choice of bagel
  $11.99
- Pastrami, Egg & Swiss Cheese
  Cage free fried egg, pastrami, Swiss cheese, Choice of bagel
  $11.99
- Fast Hash
  Cage free egg, corned beef hash, American cheese, choice of bagel
  $11.99
- Popeye
  Egg whites, turkey sausage, organic spinach, feta cheese, choice of bagel
  $11.99
Breakfast Burritos
cage-free eggs cooked with real butter, seed oil free, served with housemade salsa or spicy salsa on the side
- Classic Breakfast Burrito
  Cage free eggs, bacon, cheddar/jack cheese
  $11.99
- Corned Beef Hash Breakfast Burrito
  Cage free eggs, house made corned beef hash cheddar/jack cheese
  $12.99
- Healthy Choice Breakfast Burrito
  Egg whites, turkey sausage, organic spinach, feta cheese, whole wheat tortilla
  $12.99
- Mammoth Breakfast Burrito
  Cage free eggs, bacon, potato's, cheddar/jack cheese
  $12.99
- Redline Breakfast Burrito
  Cage free eggs, chorizo, avocado, potato's, cheddar/jack cheese
  $12.99
- Veggie Breakfast Burrito
  Cage free eggs, avocado, sautéed organic spinach, tomato, bell pepper, broccoli, mushrooms, onion, cheddar/jack cheese, whole wheat tortilla
  $11.99
Favorites
some of our favorites that we hope will be yours too!
- Classic Nova (Lox) Sandwich
  ACME NOVA FROM BROOKLYN, CREAM CHEESE, ONION, TOMATO, CAPERS, BAGEL
  $16.99
- Whitefish Salad Sandwich
  cream cheese, onion, tomato, capers, choice of bagel
  $16.79
- John's Famous BOAT
  bacon, onion, avocado, tomato, cream cheese, choice of bagel
  $9.99
- Veggie Delight
  veggie cream cheese, avocado, tomatoes, cucumber, sprouts, choice of bagel. (sub hummus or tofu cream cheese $.99)
  $9.99
- Avocado Toast
  fresh avocado, cage-free hard-boiled eggs, diced green onions, goat cheese, lemon pepper, house-made sourdough toast
  $14.99
- Potato Latkes
  3 house made latkes with sour cream and apple sauce *not a vegetarian item
  $14.99
- Cheese Blintz (3)
  filled with farmers cheese blend, grilled, topped with powdered sugar, served with sour cream and strawberry preserves
  $14.99
- Granola Bowl
  our homemade granola mix topped with low-fat strawberry yogurt, fresh strawberries, fresh blueberries, and fresh bananas
  $14.99
- Organic Steel Cut Oatmeal
  brown sugar, cranberries, raisins, walnuts
  $11.99
- Matzo Brei
  scrambled eggs & matzo with strawberry preserves & fresh fruit
  $15.99
Eggs & Three Egg Omelets
cooked with real butter, seed oil free. served with your choice of bagel with plain cream cheese or buttered toast and one of the following: home potato's,, fresh tomato's, cottage cheese or fresh fruit, sub potato latke $1.99, egg whites $1.49
- Two Free Range Eggs
  2 FREE RANGE EGGS, CHOICE OF SIDE, CHOICE OF BAGEL WITH CREAM CHEESE OR BUTTERED TOAST
  $15.99
- Keto Power Plate
  Two cage-free scrambled eggs, four pieces of Honey Cured Bacon, half of fresh Avocado (no side, no bagel/bread)
  $18.99
- Lox, Eggs & Onions
  sautéed onions, scrambles eggs and nova
  $19.99
- California Omelet
  fresh avocado, honey cured bacon and jack cheese
  $18.99
- Chorizo con Queso Omelet
  chorizo, avocado, potato's, bell pepper, onion & pepper jack cheese
  $18.99
- Fitness Omelet
  egg whites, sautéed organic spinach, turkey sausage & feta cheese
  $18.99
- Veggie Omelet
  avocado, sautéed tomato's, mushrooms, broccoli, organic spinach, onion, bell peppers and cheddar cheese
  $18.99
- Western Omelet
  black forest ham, onion & bell peppers
  $18.99
Smoked Fish Boards
all boards (platter) served with choice of bagel or bialy
- Smoked Salmon Board
  acme nova from Brooklyn, cream cheese, onions, tomato, capers, cucumbers, Kalamata olives, choice of bagel
  $22.99
Pancakes & French Toast
- Pancakes Reg Stack (3)
  light & fluffy served with 100% real maple syrup and dusted with powdered sugar
  $14.99
- Classic French Toast
  thick-cut housemade challah served with 100% real maple syrup, dusted with powdered sugar
  $14.99
- Yummy Stuffed French Toast
  whipped strawberry cream cheese layered between three slices of battered challah and topped with sliced strawberries. served with 100% real maple syrup and dusted with powdered sugar
  $17.99
- Pancake Combo
  two pancakes served with 100% real maple syrup, two eggs and two pieces of bacon or turkey sausage
  $19.99
- French Toast Combo
  two pieces of housemade challah french toast served with 100% real maple syrup, two eggs and two pieces of bacon or turkey sausage
  $19.99
Smoked Fish Pre Packs Online
Only the best......Acme Smoked Fish from Brooklyn, these are 3oz pre-packs, Whitefish pre-packs are approximately 7oz
- Acme Nova Salmon Pkg
  $13.99
Sandwiches Online
on made from scratch, made by hand bread, rolls or bagels. served with your choice of one of the following: beef tallow fries, coleslaw, potato salad, fresh fruit or chips. substitute house salad with balsamic vinaigrette, onion rings or sweet fries $1.49
- BLAT
  bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, seed oil free mayo, sourdough
  $16.99
- California Style Turkey
  ALL NATURAL TURKEY, AVOCADO, CUCUMBER, SPROUTS, TOMATO, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, SEED OIL FREE HONEY MUSTARD, SOURDOUGH
  $17.99
- Chicken Salad
  roasted in house daily, made with seed oil free mayo, lettuce, tomato, multi grain wheat
  $17.99
- Hot Brisket
  piled high with deli mustard on our homemade rye
  $19.99
- Hot Corned Beef
  cooked in house daily...piled high with deli mustard on our homemade rye
  $19.99
- Hot Pastrami
  black pastrami from RC provisions, piled high with deli mustard on our homemade rye
  $19.99
- Italian Hero Sandwich
  salami, ham, turkey pastrami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, pepperoncini, white onion, mustard, seed oil free Balsamic dressing, club roll
  $17.99
- Sky High Sandwich
  your choice of any meat with swiss, coleslaw, russian dressing, rye
  $21.99
- Triple Decker Turkey Club
  ALL NATURAL TURKEY, HONEY CURED BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO, MAYO, SOURDOUGH
  $18.99
- Albacore Tuna Salad
  solid albacore tuna, made with seed oil free mayo, lettuce, tomato, rye
  $17.99
- Turkey Breast
  ALL NATURAL, ANTIBIOTIC, HORMONE FREE TURKEY BREAST, LETTUCE, TOMATO, MAYO, HOUSEMADE RYE
  $17.99
- Vegetarian
  avocado, cucumber, sprouts, lettuce, tomato, smoked gouda, cheese, roasted red bell pepper hummus, multi grain wheat
  $15.99
Reubens Online
- Pastrami Reuben
  our famous reubens are served on grilled rye with sauerkraut, melted swiss cheese & russian dressing. Served with coleslaw and fries.
  $22.99
- Corned Beef Reuben
  our famous reubens are served on grilled rye with sauerkraut, melted swiss cheese & russian dressing. Served with coleslaw and fries. make it a RACHEL...sub the sauerkraut for coleslaw!
  $22.99
- Turkey Reuben
  our famous reubens are served on grilled rye with sauerkraut, melted swiss cheese & russian dressing. Served with coleslaw and fries.
  $22.99
Grilled Sandwiches Online
on made from scratch, made by hand bread, rolls or bagels. served with your choice of one of the following: beef tallow fries, coleslaw, potato salad, fresh fruit or chips. substitute house salad with balsamic vinaigrette, onion rings or sweet fries $1.49
- Brisket Dip
  on house made club roll served with au jus
  $19.99
- California Grilled Chicken
  avocado, bacon, tomato, swiss, seed oil free mayo, sourdough
  $19.99
- Chipotle Grilled Chicken
  avocado, tomato, pepper jack, seed oil free chipotle aioli, sourdough
  $19.99
- Grilled Cheese
  cheddar on thick cut challah
  $9.99
- Philly Cheesesteak
  Angus beef, grilled peppers & onions, provolone, seed oil free mayo, club roll
  $19.99
- Albacore Tuna Melt
  Albacore tuna, swiss, tomato, seed oil free mayo, sourdough
  $17.99
- Turkey Melt
  avocado, tomato, pepperoncini, pepper jack, chipotle aioli, sourdough
  $19.99
- 1/4lb All Beef Hot Dog
  1/4 pound plain all beef Hebrew National hot dog on our split roll
  $8.99
Angus Beef Burgers Online
hand formed certified humane, no antibiotics or hormones' on made from scratch, made by hand rolls. served with your choice of one of the following: beef tallow fries, coleslaw, potato salad, fresh fruit or chips. substitute house salad with balsamic vinaigrette, onion rings or sweet fries $1.49
- Avocado Bacon Burger
  avocado, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, russian dressing
  $17.99
- Classic Burger
  lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, russian dressing
  $16.99
Wraps Online
- BBQ Chicken Club Wrap
  avocado, BBQ chicken, bacon, tomato, organic field greens, seed oil free chipotle ranch
  $11.99
- Chipotle Chicken Wrap
  grilled chicken, organic field greens, tomato, seed oil free chipotle aioli
  $11.99
Salads Online
our salads are served with our housemade seed oil free dressings and bagel chips
- Chinese Chicken Salad
  grilled chicken, organic field greens, carrots, mandarin oranges, chinese noodles, chopped green onions, roasted almonds, sesame seeds & house made asian dressing
  $17.99
- Southwestern BBQ Chicken Salad
  organic field greens, grilled hickory chicken, avocado, black beans, roasted corn, cilantro, red onion, carrots, tomato & tortilla strips, house made chipotle ranch
  $17.99
Soups
OUR SOUPS ARE SERVED WITH OUR FRESH HOUSE MADE BAGEL CHIPS. (CALL FOR SOUP OF THE DAY QUESTIONS)
- Cup Chicken Noodle
  house-made chicken stock, fresh roasted pulled chicken, carrots, celery, noodles
  $7.99
- Bowl Chicken Noodle
  house-made chicken stock, fresh roasted pulled chicken, carrots, celery, noodles
  $8.99
- QT Chicken Noodle Soup
  house-made chicken stock, fresh roasted pulled chicken, carrots, celery, noodles
  $10.99
- Bowl Matzo Ball Soup
  house-made chicken stock, fresh roasted pulled chicken, carrots, celery, noodles, house-made matzo ball
  $10.99
- QT Matzo Ball Soup
  house-made chicken stock, fresh roasted pulled chicken, carrots, celery, noodles, house-made matzo ball
  $12.99
- Cup Soup of the Day
  Monday/Wed-Organic Chicken Tortilla Tues/Sun-Mushroom Angus Beef Barley Thursday/Sat-Organic Tomato Bisque Friday-New England Clam Chowder
  $7.99
- Bowl Soup of the Day
  Monday/Wed-Organic Chicken Tortilla Tues/Sun-Mushroom Angus Beef Barley Thursday/Sat-Organic Tomato Bisque Friday-New England Clam Chowder
  $8.99
- QT Soup of the Day
  Monday/Wed-Organic Chicken Tortilla Tues/Sun-Mushroom Angus Beef Barley Thursday/Sat-Organic Tomato Bisque Friday-New England Clam Chowder
  $10.99
Little Bakers Online
UNDER 10 PLEASE
- Kid's One Egg
  one cage free egg, fresh fruit, toast or bagel and milk
  $9.99
- Kid's Silver Dollar Pancakes
  silver dollar pancakes, 100% real maple syrup, fresh fruit & milk
  $9.99
- Kid's Turkey Sandwich
  FRESH OVEN ROASTED IN HOUSE TURKEY with cheddar, mayo and served on multigrain wheat bread. Served with fresh fruit and soda
  $9.99
- Kid's Chicken Strips
  chicken strips, fries and soda
  $9.99
Sides/Misc
- Bagel Chips Assorted
  $7.99
- Banana
  $1.49
- Fresh Fruit Pre Pack
  $9.99
- Hal’s NY Kettle Chips/ Pretzels
  ASSORTED FLAVORS
  $2.99
- Side (1) Egg
  $3.79
- Side Potato Salad
  $3.99
- Side (1) Egg White
  $3.99
- Side (1) Pancake
  $4.99
- Side Avocado
  $2.49
- Side Bacon
  $3.49
- Side BBQ Sauce
  $0.75
- Side Beyond Sausage
  $3.99
- Side Coleslaw
  $3.99
- Side Tallow Fries
  *not a vegetarian item
  $7.99
- Side Onion Rings
  *not a vegetarian item
  $7.99
- Side Ranch Dressing
  $0.75
- Side Salsa
  $0.75
- Side Sour Cream
  $1.49
- Side Sweet Potato Fries
  *not a vegetarian item
  $7.99
- Side Turkey Sausage
  $3.49
- Yogurt Parfait Cup
  $6.99
- Acme Nova Salmon Pkg
  $13.99
- Deli Sours Pre Pack
  Four Old New York Full Sour Pickles in brine.
  $7.99
South of the Border
- Chilaquiles*
  Scrambled eggs with our signature spicy sauce, onions, cilantro, tomato, sour cream, avocado and corn tortillas.
  $15.99
- Torta Cubana*
  $15.99
- (3) Carne Asada Tacos
  $15.99
- Fish Tacos (3) Online
  Three Pub Style Wild Caught battered Cod, cabbage, pico de gallo, cheese, corn tortillas, lemon & fish sauce
  $17.99
Cookies Online
- Black & White Cookie
  our famous east coast treat!
  $4.49
- Chocolate Chip Cookie
  $3.99
- Jumbo Gluten Free Cookie
  $4.49
- M & M Cookkie
  $3.99
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
  $3.99
- Peanut Butter Cookie
  $3.99
- Smiley Face Cookie
  $4.99