Old Mill Restaurant Menu

5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, IN 47720
  • Family Style Dinners

    • Adults: Available For 2 Or More People

      Choice of: Fried Chicken, Honey Roasted Ham or Roast Beef. Served with: Mashed Potatoes, Cream Gravy, Green Beans, Sweet Corn, German Cole Slaw and Homemade Rolls
      $12.95
    • Kids

      Choice of: Fried Chicken, Honey Roasted Ham or Roast Beef. Served with: Mashed Potatoes, Cream Gravy, Green Beans, Sweet Corn, German Cole Slaw and Homemade Rolls
      $6.50
  • Dinner Appetizers

    • New England Clam Chowder - Bowl

      $4.00
    • Soup Of The Day- Bowl

      $4.00
    • French Fried Mushrooms

      $9.95
    • Breaded Cauliflower

      $4.95
    • Homemade Onion Rings

      $4.95
    • (2) Shrimp Egg Rolls

      $4.95
    • Ranch Mix For Four

      $10.50
    • Shrimp Cocktail

      $7.95
    • Bread Basket For Two

      $5.00
    • Mozzarella Sticks

      $4.95
    • Chicken Tenders

      $5.95
    • Hot Wings

      $5.95
  • Entrees

    • Filet Mignon: 6oz

      $16.95
    • Filet Mignon: 8oz

      $19.95
    • Filet Mignon: 12oz

      $21.95
    • Rib Eye Steak: 8oz

      $14.95
    • Rib Eye Steak: Additional Oz

      $2.50
    • New York Strip: 10oz

      $15.95
    • New York Strip: 12oz

      $17.95
    • Porterhouse

      $18.95
    • Center Cut Pork Chop: 1/2 Lb

      $11.95
    • Center Cut Pork Chop: Whole Lb

      $15.95
    • Ground Steak

      $10.95
    • Prime Rib

      $15.95
    • Texas Cut Prime Rib

      $20.95
    • Sauteed Mushrooms & Onions

      $3.75
    • Baby Back Ribs: 1/2 Rack

      $12.95
    • Baby Back Ribs: Full Rack

      $18.95
  • Seafood

    • Catch Of The Day: Ask Your Server

    • Shrimp Maui

      $13.95
    • Filet Of Sole Almandine

      $12.95
    • Orange Roughy

      $14.95
    • Baked Scrod

      $12.95
    • Fiddlers

      $11.95
    • Trout

      $12.95
    • Frog Legs

      $13.95
    • Breaded Shrimp

      $12.95
    • Stuffed Shrimp

      $13.95
    • Stuffed Flounder

      $12.95
    • Red Snapper Florida

      $15.95
    • Alaska King Crab Legs: Mkt Price

    • Lobster Tail: Mkt Price

  • Combinations Dinners

    • Surf & Turf: Mkt Price

    • Sea & Shore

      $20.95
    • Beef & Claw: Mkt Price

  • Fowl

    • Chicken Ala Kiev

      $11.95
    • Chicken Cordon Bleu

      $11.95
    • Fried Chicken: Mixed

      $9.95
    • Fried Chicken: Qtr Dark

      $8.50
    • Fried Chicken: Qtr White

      $9.00
    • Fried Chicken: Half Dark

      $9.95
    • Fried Chicken: Half White

      $10.50
    • Fried Chicken Gizzards Or Livers

      $8.95
    • Charbroiled Chicken Breast: 8oz

      $11.95
    • Charbroiled Chicken Breast: 12oz

      $13.95
  • Pasta

    • Chicken Marinara

      $11.95
    • Fresh Vegetable Fettuccine

      $9.95
    • Pasta Seafood

      $12.95
  • German Specialties

    • Weiner Schnitzel

      $14.95
    • SauerBraten

      $12.95
  • Sandwiches

    • Reuben

      $8.95
    • Old Mill Tenderloin

      $8.95
    • Hot Brown

      $8.95
    • Club Sandwich

      $7.95
    • Hamburger

      with American or Swiss cheese- additional $0.50
      $7.95
    • Marinated Chicken Breast

      $6.95
    • B.L.T

      $5.95
    • Fish Fillet

      $6.95
    • Prime Rib Sandwich

      $9.95
  • Salads

    • Combination Salad

      $3.50
    • Sliced Tomatoes

      $2.50
    • Cottage Cheese

      with fruit- $3.00
      $2.75
    • Cole Saw

      $2.75
    • Pop Eye

      Fresh spinach topped with real bacon bits, chopped eggs & our own popeye dressing
      $4.50
    • Caesar Salad

      with grilled chicken- $8.95
      $5.95
    • Old Mill Chicken

      Grilled chicken breast, dried cranberries and rubs
      $9.95
    • Choice Of Vegetable

      $2.75
  • Chef Salad

    • Ham & Cheese

      $8.95
    • Shrimp

      $9.95
    • Chicken Breast

      $8.95
    • Breaded Chicken

      $8.95
    • Cobb Salad

      $9.95
  • Children's Menu

    • Hamburger And Fries

      $4.95
    • Chicken Tenders And Fries

      $4.95
  • Side Potatoes

    • French Fries

      $2.75
    • Baked Potato

      Sour Cream- additional $0.50
      $3.75
    • American Fries

      $2.75
    • German Fries

      $3.75
    • Mashed Potatoes With Gravy

      $2.75
    • German Potato Salad

      $3.75
  • Dessert

    • New York Style Cheesecake

      with strawberries
      $4.50
    • Carrot Cake

      $4.50
    • Sundae

      Chocolate or Strawberry
      $3.95
    • Sinfully Chocolate

      Name says it all!
      $3.95
    • Pecan Pie

      $3.95

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms