OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Menu

4.1
(350+ Reviews)
  • Tubs

    • Vegan Chocolate Chunk

      Vegan macadamia-cashew-milk dark chocolate base with chunks of dark chocolate. Contains macadamia, cashew, coconut oil.
      $12.50
      Vegan Chocolate Chunk
    • Exotic Fruits Sorbet

      Mango, banana, papaya, passionfruit, guava, kalamansi sorbet. Vegan and gluten free. Contains: Coconut oil.
      $12.50
      Exotic Fruits Sorbet
    • Vanilla Bean

      Sweet cream vanilla base with real Madagascar vanilla beans. Contains dairy, eggs.
      $12.50
      Vanilla Bean
    • Strawberry Jam

      Strawberry sweet cream base studded with gems of oregon strawberry jam. Contains dairy.
      $11.50
      Strawberry Jam
    • Cookies & Cream

      Sweet cream base with chunks of chocolate cookie. You might be interested to learn that cookies and cream was invented here in New York city. We were surprised to learn that it was invented at all - we assumed it evolved from the ooze with us humans. Contains dairy, egg, gluten.
      $12.50
      Cookies & Cream
    • Vegan Coconut Caramel Chip

      Coconut milk base with chunks of caramelized coconut milk and magicked dark chocolate chips. Vegan and gluten free. Contains coconut.
      $12.50
      Vegan Coconut Caramel Chip
    • Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice

      Coconut-based ice cream with mango swirls & gobs of mochi rice. Contains: Coconut, Gluten.
      $12.50
      Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
    • Sprinkles

      Sweet cream ice cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. Contains dairy, eggs, and sprinkles.
      $12.50
      Sprinkles
    • Peanut Butter S'mores

      You wanted a hit. This is how we do hits. Our collaboration ice cream flavor with LCD Soundsystems. Peanut butter ice cream base with graham cracker crumbs, magicked dark chocolate, and burnt marshmallows. It won't be your baby till you take it home. Contains dairy, egg, gluten, coconut oil, gelatin.
      $12.50
      Peanut Butter S'mores
    • Coffee Crunch

      Coffee based ice cream with a coffee cookie crumble
      $12.50
      Coffee Crunch
    • Vegan Grasshopper

      Vegan chocolate cashew-based ice cream flavored with mint and spun with tons of chocolate sandwich cookies. Minty chocolate goodness. Allergens: cashew, gluten.
      $12.50
      Vegan Grasshopper
    • Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio

      Saffron passionfruit ice cream base with candied apricots and pistachios. contains dairy, egg, pistachio.
      $12.50
      Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches

    • DIY Ice Cream Sandwich

      Two chewy chocolate chip cookies with OddFellows ice cream sandwiched inside! Yum.
      $8.50
      DIY Ice Cream Sandwich
  • Beverages

    • Milkshake

      16oz milkshake made with our homemade ice cream.
      $12.00
      Milkshake
    • Boylans Cane Soda

      Order a bottle of Boylans delicious Cane Soda and make your own ice cream float at home!.
      $5.00
      Boylans Cane Soda
    • Water Bottle

      16.9 fl oz poland springs water bottle
      $3.00
      Water Bottle

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

dips
dips
4.7
(1,038 Reviews)
Kosher, Deli
Meisner's Take Home Food
Meisner's Take Home Food
4.9
(114 Reviews)
Kosher
Noribar
Noribar
4.5
(719 Reviews)
Sushi, Kosher
Panino Toasty Delicious
Panino Toasty Delicious
4.6
(308 Reviews)
Sandwich shop
1982 Coffee Roasters
1982 Coffee Roasters
4.7
(404 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Breakfast, Cafe
Grill Zone
Grill Zone
3.8
(25 Reviews)
Deli
The Nuttery
The Nuttery
4.8
(403 Reviews)
Cafe, Chocolate cafe
Shloimy's Bake Shoppe
Shloimy's Bake Shoppe
4.8
(136 Reviews)
Bakery, Cafe, Coffee shop
Luzee
Luzee
4.9
(114 Reviews)
Kosher
Flaming Grill
Flaming Grill
4.5
(44 Reviews)
Deli

(718) 683-5755

44 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms