NY Pizza Department Menu

4.2
(650+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Create Your Own 14' Pizza

      Cheese Pizza to start. Toppings available for additional charge.
      $19.54
    • Create Your Own 18' Pizza

      Cheese Pizza to start. Toppings available for additional charge.
      $26.44
    • Traditional Wings

      New Traditional Wings
      $10.34
    • Create Your Own 8' Pizza

      Cheese Pizza to start. Toppings available for additional charge.
      $10.91
    • Garlic Knots

      Vegetarian delights. Freshly baked and brushed with garlic, sesame seeds, and Romano cheese. Served with marinara sauce. 6 knots.
      $6.31
    • Garlic Cheese Knots

      Same as above, but we’ve added bubbly melted golden mozzarella. 6 or 12 knots.
      $7.23
    • Crispy Fresh Mozzarella

      New, vegetarian delights. Delicious, fresh Mozzarella is hand dipped in panko breadcrumbs and lightly fried to golden brown perfection. Served with a side of fresh basil and balsamic reduction, this is one delicious appetizer you don't want to miss.
      $11.49
    • Boneless Wings

      These gems are prepared with bbq sauce and real honey – tantalizin’ your tongue with a dash of sweet and sour. Served with celery and Blue cheese or ranch dressing.
      $8.61
    • NYPD House Salad

      Vegetarian delights. Mixed greens topped with tomatoes, cucumbers, and homemade croutons.
      $8.04
    • San Gennaro Zeppolis

      Fried and tossed with powdered sugar, these little nuggets of pizza dough are so sweet and tasty. Served with Ghirardelli chocolate and raspberry sauces. Even a New Yorker can’t help but say nice things about this little Italy favorite.
      $9.19
    • Caesar Salad

      Our classic Asiago Caesar salad with fresh romaine, asiago cheese, romano, and homemade croutons. Served with Caesar dressing.
      $8.04
    • Chelsea Chopped Salad

      Talk about a melting pot. This salad is a healthy serving of mixed chopped greens, Gorgonzola cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, sliced almonds, bacon, cucumbers and NYPD's own blend of its house and ranch dressings.
      $11.03
  • Wings

    • Boneless Wings

      These gems are prepared with bbq sauce and real honey – tantalizin’ your tongue with a dash of sweet and sour. Served with celery and Blue cheese or ranch dressing.
      $8.61
    • Traditional Wings

      New Traditional Wings
      $10.34
    • 6pcs Boneless 6pcs Traditional

      $17.50
  • 8' Traditional Pizzas

    Our pizza is a traditional New York hand-tossed, thin-crust pie baked in a stone oven & served in 8 slices
    • Brooklyn Family

      Pepperoni, sausage and fresh basil – our pie of choice, don’t be surprised if the kitchen steals a slice.
      $13.79
    • BBQ Chicken

      Barbecue sauce, smoked Mozzarella, chicken, sliced red onions and fresh cilantro baked NY-style.
      $13.79
    • Buffalo Chicken

      Featuring grilled chicken breast smothered in tangy upstate-style buffalo sauce, celery, Gorgonzola and smoked mozzarella, this is one pie you’ll want more off!
      $13.79
    • Margherita

      Vegetarian delights. Fresh Mozzarella, fresh basil, sliced Roma tomatoes and our homemade pizza sauce. Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $13.79
    • Pesto Chicken

      Sliced chicken breast, pesto and Mozzarella.
      $13.79
    • Da Works

      Pepperoni, green peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, sausage and Roma tomatoes. Take our advice, ask for it crispy!
      $14.36
    • Pizza Blanca WHITE PIE

      Vegetarian delights. Olive oil, crushed garlic, ricotta and Mozzarella with your choice of fresh spinach or Roma tomatoes.
      $13.79
    • The Big Kahuna

      Ham, pineapple and fresh basil. Hana hou!
      $13.79
    • Quattro Formaggi

      New, vegetarian delights. Calling all cheese lovers! Our four cheese pie is topped with smoked mozzarella, traditional Asiago, and fresh and shredded mozzarellas. This is serious cheese love.
      $13.79
    • Joey’s Favorite

      Vegetarian delights. Mushrooms, onions, peppers, black olives and Roma tomatoes. Joey, a vegetarian, lives in Brooklyn and this is his pie of choice. Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $13.79
    • Pesto Tomato

      Vegetarian delights. Pesto topped with Mozzarella and sliced Roma tomatoes.
      $13.79
    • Wall Street

      Our delicious pie topped with three types of meat – pepperoni, sausage and bacon. Plus mushrooms to make it extra rich.
      $14.36
    • Bruschetta

      Vegetarian delights. This white pie features olive oil, crushed garlic, ricotta, Mozzarella, Asiago, fresh basil and our homemade bruschetta.
      $13.79
    • Fran’s Favorite

      Roma tomatoes, mushrooms and fresh basil – everyone’s favorite nanny says “it’s to die for.” Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $13.79
    • Veganizza™

      Vegetarian delights. Our famous NYPD pizza topped with Daiya® (vegan cheese), Roma tomatoes, fresh spinach, basil, and garlic.
      $13.79
    • Vinny’s Favorite

      Any five toppings. Vinny always liked something a little different. *** Please note that premium toppings count as two toppings. Any toppings over the five included may result in an extra charge not displayed in the final total and will be adjusted on the store level. ***
      $14.36
    • Mott Street Meat Lover

      Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs – a taste that takes you right to Little Italy, without the airfare.
      $13.79
  • Create Your Own Traditional Pizzas

    Our pizza is a traditional New York hand-tossed, thin-crust pie baked in a stone oven & served in 8 slices.
    • Create Your Own 18' Pizza

      Cheese Pizza to start. Toppings available for additional charge.
      $26.44
    • Create Your Own 8' Pizza

      Cheese Pizza to start. Toppings available for additional charge.
      $10.91
    • Create Your Own 14' Pizza

      Cheese Pizza to start. Toppings available for additional charge.
      $19.54
    • Gluten- Free 12' Create Your Own

      Enjoy any of our specialty pizzas on our gluten-free crust for an upcharge. Make your NYPD Pizza vegan by substituting Daiya®.
      $19.54
  • Appetizers

    • Crispy Fresh Mozzarella

      New, vegetarian delights. Delicious, fresh Mozzarella is hand dipped in panko breadcrumbs and lightly fried to golden brown perfection. Served with a side of fresh basil and balsamic reduction, this is one delicious appetizer you don't want to miss.
      $11.49
    • Garlic Knots

      Vegetarian delights. Freshly baked and brushed with garlic, sesame seeds, and Romano cheese. Served with marinara sauce. 6 knots.
      $6.31
    • French Fries

      A delicious serving of crispy fries, lightly seasoned with salt & pepper.
      $4.93
    • Garlic Cheese Knots

      Same as above, but we’ve added bubbly melted golden mozzarella. 6 or 12 knots.
      $7.23
    • Broadway Bruschetta

      Vegetarian delights. Chopped tomatoes, fresh basil, red onions, fresh garlic and olive oil give the performance of a lifetime. Served with crustettes and topped with shaved Asiago cheese. It's a hit!
      $6.89
  • Salads

    • NYPD House Salad

      Vegetarian delights. Mixed greens topped with tomatoes, cucumbers, and homemade croutons.
      $8.04
    • Chelsea Chopped Salad

      Talk about a melting pot. This salad is a healthy serving of mixed chopped greens, Gorgonzola cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, sliced almonds, bacon, cucumbers and NYPD's own blend of its house and ranch dressings.
      $11.03
    • Soho Salad Pizza

      Vegetarian delights. Is it a pizza with salad on top or is it a salad with pizza on the bottom? We know one thing, it’s served on a “pizza crisp” baked with garlic, spices, mozzarella and topped with mixed baby greens, bruschetta, almonds, and Feta, with NYPD’s own blend of its house and ranch dressings.
      $10.91
    • Tossed Antipasto

      Salami, capicola ham, provolone, grape tomatoes, marinated mushrooms, red onions, artichokes, mild peppers, roasted red peppers, green olives and lettuce tossed with our house dressing and topped with Romano.
      $10.91
    • Caesar Salad

      Our classic Asiago Caesar salad with fresh romaine, asiago cheese, romano, and homemade croutons. Served with Caesar dressing.
      $8.04
    • Greek Salad

      Vegetarian delights. Mixed greens topped with fresh Feta cheese, red onions, kalamata olives, green peppers, pepperoncini, cucumbers, and tomatoes.
      $9.76
    • Buffalo Chicken Caesar Salad

      Crispy sliced chicken tossed in a tangy upstate-style buffalo sauce over a traditional caesar complemented with Gorgonzola and Asiago cheeses. Hail buffalo!
      $10.34
    • Spinach Salad

      A classic mix of fresh spinach, bacon, red onion, mushrooms, sliced almonds and smoked mozzarella garnished with black pepper and tossed with NYPD's own blend of its house and ranch dressings.
      $9.19
    • Crispy Chicken Spinach Salad

      Sliced, crispy chicken tops our classic spinach salad.
      $11.49
  • 14' Traditional Pizzas

    Our pizza is a traditional New York hand-tossed, thin-crust pie baked in a stone oven & served in 8 slices
    • Da Works

      Pepperoni, green peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, sausage and Roma tomatoes. Take our advice, ask for it crispy!
      $28.74
    • The Big Kahuna

      Ham, pineapple and fresh basil. Hana hou!
      $25.86
    • BBQ Chicken

      Barbecue sauce, smoked mozzarella, chicken, sliced red onions and fresh cilantro baked NY-style.
      $25.86
    • Wall Street

      Our delicious pie topped with three types of meat – pepperoni, sausage and bacon. Plus mushrooms to make it extra rich.
      $28.74
    • Brooklyn Family

      Pepperoni, sausage and fresh basil – our pie of choice, don’t be surprised if the kitchen steals a slice.
      $25.86
    • Joey’s Favorite

      Mushrooms, onions, peppers, black olives and Roma tomatoes. Joey, a vegetarian, lives in Brooklyn and this is his pie of choice. Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $25.86
    • Margherita

      Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sliced Roma tomatoes and our homemade pizza sauce. Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $25.86
    • Bruschetta

      This white pie features olive oil, crushed garlic, ricotta, mozzarella, asiago, fresh basil and our homemade bruschetta.
      $25.86
    • Fran’s Favorite

      Roma tomatoes, mushrooms and fresh basil – everyone’s favorite nanny says “it’s to die for.” Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $25.86
    • Pesto Tomato

      Pesto topped with mozzarella and sliced Roma tomatoes.
      $25.86
    • Pesto Chicken

      Sliced chicken breast, pesto and mozzarella.
      $25.86
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

      Featuring grilled chicken breast smothered in tangy Upstate-style Buffalo sauce, celery, Gorgonzola and smoked mozzarella, this is one pie you’ll want more of!
      $25.86
    • Quattro Formaggi Pizza

      Calling all cheese lovers! Our four cheese pie is topped with smoked mozzarella, traditional asiago, and fresh and shredded mozzarellas. This is serious cheese love.
      $25.86
    • Veganizza™

      Our famous NYPD pizza topped with Daiya® (vegan cheese), Roma tomatoes, fresh spinach, basil and garlic.
      $25.86
    • Pizza Blanca WHITE PIE

      Olive oil, crushed garlic, ricotta and mozzarella with your choice of fresh spinach or Roma tomatoes.
      $25.86
    • Mott Street Meat Lover

      Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs – a taste that takes you right to Little Italy, without the airfare.
      $25.86
    • Vinny’s Favorite

      Any five toppings. Vinny always liked something a little different. *** Please note that premium toppings count as two toppings. Any toppings over the five included may result in an extra charge not displayed in the final total and will be adjusted on the store level. ***
      $28.74
  • 18' Traditional Pizzas

    Our pizza is a traditional New York hand-tossed, thin-crust pie baked in a stone oven & served in 8 slices
    • Brooklyn Family

      Pepperoni, sausage and fresh basil – our pie of choice, don’t be surprised if the kitchen steals a slice.
      $33.91
    • Pizza Blanca WHITE PIE

      Olive oil, crushed garlic, ricotta and mozzarella with your choice of fresh spinach or Roma tomatoes.
      $33.91
    • The Big Kahuna

      Ham, pineapple and fresh basil. Hana hou!
      $33.91
    • Bruschetta

      This white pie features olive oil, crushed garlic, ricotta, mozzarella, asiago, fresh basil and our homemade bruschetta.
      $33.91
    • Wall Street

      Our delicious pie topped with three types of meat – pepperoni, sausage and bacon. Plus mushrooms to make it extra rich.
      $36.21
    • Margherita

      Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, sliced Roma tomatoes and our homemade pizza sauce. Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $33.91
    • Joey’s Favorite

      Mushrooms, onions, peppers, black olives and Roma tomatoes. Joey, a vegetarian, lives in Brooklyn and this is his pie of choice. Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $33.91
    • Quattro Formaggi Pizza

      Calling all cheese lovers! Our four cheese pie is topped with smoked mozzarella, traditional asiago, and fresh and shredded mozzarellas. This is serious cheese love.
      $33.91
    • Da Works

      Pepperoni, green peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, sausage and Roma tomatoes. Take our advice, ask for it crispy!
      $36.21
    • Fran’s Favorite

      Roma tomatoes, mushrooms and fresh basil – everyone’s favorite nanny says “it’s to die for.” Take our advice, ask for it “crispy!”
      $33.91
    • Pesto Chicken

      Sliced chicken breast, pesto and mozzarella.
      $33.91
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

      Featuring grilled chicken breast smothered in tangy Upstate-style Buffalo sauce, celery, Gorgonzola and smoked mozzarella, this is one pie you’ll want more of!
      $33.91
    • BBQ Chicken

      Barbecue sauce, smoked mozzarella, chicken, sliced red onions and fresh cilantro baked NY-style.
      $33.91
    • Pesto Tomato

      Pesto topped with mozzarella and sliced Roma tomatoes.
      $33.91
    • Veganizza™

      Our famous NYPD pizza topped with Daiya® (vegan cheese), Roma tomatoes, fresh spinach, basil and garlic.
      $33.91
    • Mott Street Meat Lover

      Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs – a taste that takes you right to Little Italy, without the airfare.
      $33.91
    • Vinny’s Favorite

      Any five toppings. Vinny always liked something a little different. *** Please note that premium toppings count as two toppings. Any toppings over the five included may result in an extra charge not displayed in the final total and will be adjusted on the store level. ***
      $36.21
  • Pastas

    Topped with parsley, oregano and Romano and served with freshly baked garlic knots. Whole wheat pasta available.
    • Chicken Parmigiana

      Breaded chicken breast smothered in marinara and melted Mozzarella. Served with spaghetti.
      $19.54
    • Spaghetti with Homemade Meatballs

      Traditional comfort food you’ll really love!
      $16.66
    • Traditional New York Baked Ziti

      Vegetarian delights. Oven baked penne pasta, marinara, ricotta and melted Mozzarella.
      $16.66
    • Penne a la Vodka with Sausage & Peppers

      Italian sausage, onions and crushed red peppers sautéed in a creamy marinara sauce, tossed with penne pasta and topped with fresh basil and Asiago cheese.
      $19.54
    • Pasta of Your Choice

      Vegetarian delights. Penne or spaghetti with marinara or olive oil.
      $12.64
  • Calzones

    A traditional New York calzone baked in our stone oven. A cheesy combination of seasoned ricotta cheese and mozzarella wrapped in pizza dough. Served with marinara sauce on the side.
    • Frank Sinatra (Small)

      Our traditional calzone stuffed with up to 3 toppings of your choice. Additional toppings available for additional fee. Served with marinara.
      $11.49
    • Frank Sinatra (Large)

      Our traditional calzone stuffed with up to 3 toppings of your choice. Additional toppings available for additional fee. Served with marinara.
      $18.39
    • Cheese Calzone (Small)

      A cheesy combination of seasoned ricotta and mozzarella wrapped in pizza dough and served with marinara sauce on the side.Note** This is only a cheese calzone. If you would like toppings, please order a Frank Sinatra and choose your topping(s) accordingly!
      $9.19
    • Cheese Calzone (Large)

      A cheesy combination of seasoned ricotta and mozzarella wrapped in pizza dough and served with marinara sauce on the side.Note** This is only a cheese calzone. If you would like toppings, please order a Frank Sinatra and choose your topping(s) accordingly!
      $13.79
    • Al Capone (Small)

      Our traditional calzone stuffed with sausage, pepperoni and onions. Served with marinara.
      $11.49
    • Al Capone (Large)

      Our traditional calzone stuffed with sausage, pepperoni and onions. Served with marinara.
      $18.39
  • Dessert

    • New York Cheesecake

      Smooth and rich. Served with choice of Ghirardelli Chocolate, Raspberry or Caramel sauce.
      $9.19
    • San Gennaro Zeppolis

      Fried and tossed with powdered sugar, these little nuggets of pizza dough are so sweet and tasty. Served with Ghirardelli chocolate and raspberry sauces. Even a New Yorker can’t help but say nice things about this little Italy favorite.
      $9.19
    • Empire State Chocolate Cake

      A delicious six layer chocolate cake with mini chips and fudge!
      $9.19
    • Zeppoli Sundae

      We’ve taken our classic zeppolis and topped them with even more goodness. Fried and tossed with cinnamon and sugar, these little nuggets of sweet pizza dough are topped with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate sauce and a cherry!
      $10.34
    • Limoncello Cake

      New. A slice of spongy, sweet lemon cake, layered with mascarpone and covered with creamy icing.
      $9.19
    • New York’s Finest Cookie n’ Cream

      Your choice of a freshly baked chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin or peanut butter cookie topped with Ghirardelli chocolate, raspberry or caramel sauce. So good, you’ll want to protect it with your life.
      $9.19
  • Beverages

    • Sierra Mist 2-liter

      $4.59
    • Mountain Dew 2-liter

      Exhilarate and quench your thirst with a one of a kind taste.
      $3.99
    • Pepsi 2-liter

      The bold, refreshing, robust cola
      $4.59
    • Orange Crush 2-Liter

      $4.59
    • Diet Pepsi 2-liter

      A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
      $4.59
  • Ranch Dressing

    Sides of our delicious made-from-scratch Ranch dressing!
    • Ranch Dressing Portion Cup

      A 2 ounce portion cup side of our Ranch dressing.
      $0.58
    • Ranch Dressing Squeeze Bottle

      A 12 ounce squeeze bottle of our delicious Ranch dressing.
      $4.59

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

McDonald's
McDonald's
3.0
(123 Reviews)
Breakfast, Coffee shop, Hamburger
BoSa Donuts
BoSa Donuts
4.4
(520 Reviews)
Donut shop
Subway
Subway
3.4
(85 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Mesquite Fresh Street Mex
Mesquite Fresh Street Mex
4.3
(158 Reviews)
Mexican
Pasta Joint
Pasta Joint
4.9
(110 Reviews)
Italian
Scooter's Coffee
Scooter's Coffee
3.8
(58 Reviews)
Coffee shop
Filibertos
Filibertos
3.8
(389 Reviews)
Mexican
Black Rock Coffee Bar
Black Rock Coffee Bar
4.5
(304 Reviews)
Coffee shop
Tifa Chocolate & Gelato
Tifa Chocolate & Gelato
4.9
(174 Reviews)
Ice cream shop, Coffee shop
Papa Chevo's Taco Shop
Papa Chevo's Taco Shop
4.0
(465 Reviews)
Mexican, Breakfast

(480) 782-6973

2743 S Market St, Gilbert, AZ 85295


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms