Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
Sweet Pie Slices
Fresh slice of pie made with the highest quality ingredients
$7.00
Leslie's Lime Pie
Our own superior version of a key lime pie. Also, the only pie with my name on it so it must be special. Tart, creamed lime filling made with fresh Turkish limes, topped with lime zest. Always leaves me feeling refreshed.
$15.50+
Black Dirt Chocolate Cream
Flaky bottom crust, house made chocolate pudding, house made whipped cream, rich dark chocolate shavings representing the black dirt farming region of the Hudson Valley.
$15.50+
Hudson Valley Apple Pie
Warwick Apple fest Winner. Variety of apples from small farms in the Hudson Valley.
$15.50+
Chicken Pot Pie
The Classic: Chicken, Carrots, Peas, Celery, Onion in a cream sauce. Top and bottom crust. The ultimate comfort food.
$16.00
Will You Marry Me Cherry
I made this pie for my husband, Tom. He proposed to me after his first bite. Made with both sweet and tart cherries. Be careful who you serve it to! Recently chosen to be the pie on all billboard and playbill ads for the Waitress!
$15.50+
Very Blueberry Pie
The perfect pie to eat when you're feeling blue. Fresh or IQF NJ wild blueberries when in season. zest of lemon
$15.50+
Shepherds Pie With Beef
Bottom crust, grass fed ground beef slow cooked with carrots, onion, and celery combined own special spice blend. Your top crust is our homemade mashed potato recipe. Fully endorsed by our British customers. Here to stay for the winter!
We make our pies in small batches from scratch using the highest quality ingredients we can find. Most of the fruit in our pies are sourced from various farms in our region. We never used canned fruit or preservatives.
Very Blueberry Pie
The perfect pie to eat when you're feeling blue. Fresh or IQF NJ wild blueberries when in season. zest of lemon
$15.50+
Will You Marry Me Cherry
I made this pie for my husband, Tom. He proposed to me after his first bite. Made with both sweet and tart cherries. Be careful who you serve it to! Recently chosen to be the pie on all billboard and playbill ads for the Waitress!
$15.50+
Hudson Valley Apple Pie
Warwick Apple fest Winner. Variety of apples from small farms in the Hudson Valley.
$15.50+
Mixed Berry Pie
Strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, and raspberries. Perfect with vanilla ice cream!
$15.50+
Merry Me Cherry
9" or 6".
$15.50+
Savory Pies
Our savory pies are fresh baked, ready to be heated in your oven for eating.
Chicken Pot Pie
The Classic: Chicken, Carrots, Peas, Celery, Onion in a cream sauce. Top and bottom crust. The ultimate comfort food.
$16.00
Shepherds Pie With Beef
Bottom crust, grass fed ground beef slow cooked with carrots, onion, and celery combined own special spice blend. Your top crust is our homemade mashed potato recipe. Fully endorsed by our British customers. Here to stay for the winter!
$16.00
Buffalo Chicken Pot Pie
Homemade dollops of ranch, some dill, diced potatoes and hand pulled chicken perfectly mixed inside our buttery crust that soaks up our special secret buffalo sauce is just !!! too !!! good !!!
$16.00
Vegetable Curry Pie
Sweet potatoes, cauliflower, zucchini, onions, celery, garlic and spices simmered in a mild curry sauce and baked in our handmade butter crust
$15.00
Cream Pies
Leslie's Lime Pie
Our own superior version of a key lime pie. Also, the only pie with my name on it so it must be special. Tart, creamed lime filling made with fresh Turkish limes, topped with lime zest. Always leaves me feeling refreshed.
$15.50+
Black Dirt Chocolate Cream
Flaky bottom crust, house made chocolate pudding, house made whipped cream, rich dark chocolate shavings representing the black dirt farming region of the Hudson Valley.
Tender chicken, carrots, peas, and celery in a savory gravy, encased in a flaky, golden crust.
$9.00
Sweet Pie Slices
Fresh slice of pie made with the highest quality ingredients
$7.00
Buffalo Chicken Pot Pie Slice
Tender chicken pieces with buffalo sauce, vegetables, and a flaky golden crust.
$9.00
Sheherds Pie with beef slice
Bottom crust, grass fed ground beef slow cooked with carrots, onion, and celery combined own special spice blend. Your top crust is our homemade mashed potato recipe. Fully endorsed by our British customers. Here to stay for the winter!
$8.95
Vegetable Curry Slice
Sweet potatoes, cauliflower, zucchini, onions, celery, garlic and spices simmered in a mild curry sauce and baked in our handmade butter crust