Noble Pies Bakery and Cafe Menu

4.6

(300+ Reviews)

$Cafe, Coffee shop, Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Sweet Pies Savory Pies Cream Pies Quiches Slices

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Sweet Pie Slices
  Fresh slice of pie made with the highest quality ingredients
  $7.00
- Hudson Valley Apple Crumb
  Warwick Apple fest Winner. Variety of apples from Ochs Orchard. Crumb topping: oats, brown sugar, butter.
  $15.00
- Black Dirt Chocolate Cream
  Flaky bottom crust, house made chocolate pudding, house made whipped cream, rich dark chocolate shavings representing the black dirt farming region of the Hudson Valley.
  $15.00
- Leslie's Lime Pie
  Our own superior version of a key lime pie. Also, the only pie with my name on it so it must be special. Tart, creamed lime filling made with fresh Turkish limes, topped with lime zest. Always leaves me feeling refreshed.
  $15.00
- Hudson Valley Apple Pie
  Warwick Apple fest Winner. Variety of apples from small farms in the Hudson Valley.
  $15.00
- Very Blueberry Crumb Pie
  The perfect pie to eat when you're feeling blue. Fresh or IQF wild blueberries. zest of lemon
  $15.00
- Will You Marry Me Cherry
  I made this pie for my husband, Tom. He proposed to me after his first bite. Made with both sweet and tart cherries. Be careful who you serve it to! Recently chosen to be the pie on all billboard and playbill ads for the Waitress!
  $15.00
- Very Blueberry Pie
  The perfect pie to eat when you're feeling blue. Fresh or IQF NJ wild blueberries when in season. zest of lemon
  $15.00
- Vegetable Quiche
  Zucchini, Broccoli, Goat Cheese, Onion, Sundried Tomato, Swiss, pastured eggs, local cream
  $15.00
- Mixed Berry Pie
  Strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, and raspberries. Perfect with vanilla ice cream!
  $15.00
Sweet Pies
- Very Blueberry Crumb Pie
  The perfect pie to eat when you're feeling blue. Fresh or IQF wild blueberries. zest of lemon
  $15.00
- Very Blueberry Pie
  The perfect pie to eat when you're feeling blue. Fresh or IQF NJ wild blueberries when in season. zest of lemon
  $15.00
- Will You Marry Me Cherry
  I made this pie for my husband, Tom. He proposed to me after his first bite. Made with both sweet and tart cherries. Be careful who you serve it to! Recently chosen to be the pie on all billboard and playbill ads for the Waitress!
  $15.00
- Hudson Valley Apple Crumb
  Warwick Apple fest Winner. Variety of apples from Ochs Orchard. Crumb topping: oats, brown sugar, butter.
  $15.00
- Hudson Valley Apple Pie
  Warwick Apple fest Winner. Variety of apples from small farms in the Hudson Valley.
  $15.00
- Mixed Berry Pie
  Strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, and raspberries. Perfect with vanilla ice cream!
  $15.00
Savory Pies
- Shepherds Pie with beef
  Bottom crust, grass fed ground beef slow cooked with carrots, onion, and celery combined own special spice blend. Your top crust is our homemade mashed potato recipe. Fully endorsed by our British customers.
  $16.00
- Vegetable Curry Pie
  Sweet potatoes, cauliflower, zucchini, onions, celery, garlic and spices simmered in a mild curry sauce and baked in our handmade butter crust
  $16.00
Cream Pies
- Leslie's Lime Pie
  Our own superior version of a key lime pie. Also, the only pie with my name on it so it must be special. Tart, creamed lime filling made with fresh Turkish limes, topped with lime zest. Always leaves me feeling refreshed.
  $15.00
- Black Dirt Chocolate Cream
  Flaky bottom crust, house made chocolate pudding, house made whipped cream, rich dark chocolate shavings representing the black dirt farming region of the Hudson Valley.
  $15.00
Quiches
- Vegetable Quiche
  Zucchini, Broccoli, Goat Cheese, Onion, Sundried Tomato, Swiss, pastured eggs, local cream
  $15.00
Slices
- Savory Slices
  Creamy chicken pie with tender carrots, celery, and a flaky crust.
  $9.25
- Sweet Pie Slices
  Fresh slice of pie made with the highest quality ingredients
  $7.00