Nikki's Custard® Menu

4.9

(150+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites SIZE

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Pint
  Creativity is a must! If you need more than (4) pints of any one flavor, please call the shop to order. 717-517-8439
  $6.99
- Double Cup
  Delight in two scoops of creamy Chocolate or Vanilla custard, refreshing sorbet, or non-dairy options.
  $5.79
- Single Cup
  Enjoy 1 scoop of creamy custard, non-dairy, sorbet or low sugar soft-serve options. Jazz it up with choices of sauces and toppings.
  $3.89
- Rocksolid - 16oz. REG
  16oz. Our version of a concrete, blended with toppings (milkshake without the milk). Have fun with it!
  $6.59
- Kids Cup
  1/2 scoop in a cup. Jazz it up with choices of sauces and toppings.
  $1.89
- Rocksolid - 12oz. MINI
  12oz. Our version of a concrete, blended with toppings (milkshake without the milk). Have fun with it!
  $5.79
- Milkshake - 16oz. REG
  16oz. We use whole milk. We do offer oat milk for a 'plant milk' alternative. Create to your heart's content!
  $6.79
- Milkshake - 12oz. MINI
  12oz. We use whole milk. We do offer oat milk for a 'plant milk' alternative. Create to your heart's content!
  $5.99
SIZE
- 12oz Macchiato Shake - MINI
  12oz. Salted Caramel Macchiato Milkshake! Vanilla custard, salted caramel sauce, decaf cold brew, whipped cream, and sprinkles. April's refreshingly sweet coffee milkshake goodness!
  $7.75
- 16oz. Macchiato Shake - REG
  16oz. Salted Caramel Macchiato Milkshake! Vanilla custard, salted caramel sauce, decaf cold brew, whipped cream, and sprinkles. April's refreshingly sweet coffee milkshake goodness!
  $8.57
- Cold Brew Float - 12oz. MINI
  12oz. Think coffee custard float, not your traditional 'root beer' float, but adding our decaf cold brew coffee and whipped cream - Mmmm, tastes just right!
  $6.75
- Kids Cup
  1/2 scoop in a cup. Jazz it up with choices of sauces and toppings.
  $1.89
- Single Cup
  Enjoy 1 scoop of creamy custard, non-dairy, sorbet or low sugar soft-serve options. Jazz it up with choices of sauces and toppings.
  $3.89
- Double Cup
  Delight in two scoops of creamy Chocolate or Vanilla custard, refreshing sorbet, or non-dairy options.
  $5.79
- Milkshake - 12oz. MINI
  12oz. We use whole milk. We do offer oat milk for a 'plant milk' alternative. Create to your heart's content!
  $5.99
- Milkshake - 16oz. REG
  16oz. We use whole milk. We do offer oat milk for a 'plant milk' alternative. Create to your heart's content!
  $6.79
- Rocksolid - 12oz. MINI
  12oz. Our version of a concrete, blended with toppings (milkshake without the milk). Have fun with it!
  $5.79
- Rocksolid - 16oz. REG
  16oz. Our version of a concrete, blended with toppings (milkshake without the milk). Have fun with it!
  $6.59
- Pint
  Creativity is a must! If you need more than (4) pints of any one flavor, please call the shop to order. 717-517-8439
  $6.99
- Cold Brew Float - 16oz. REG
  16oz. Think coffee custard float, not your traditional 'root beer' float, but adding our decaf cold brew coffee and whipped cream - Mmmm, tastes just right!
  $7.57
- Add On - Sides
  Side of sauces, nuts or toppings - provided in a separate container