Nifty Fifty's (Newtown Square) Menu

4.3

(375+ Reviews)

+1 484-992-1950

Customer Favorites Shake Of The Month Party Trays Nifty Burgers Philly Steaks Specialty Sandwiches Coney Island Hot Dogs Chicken Nuggets and Chicken Fingers Fresh Cut Fries and Onion Rings Smothered Fries Salads & Chili Waffles Most Popular Milkshakes Blue Ribbon Milk Shakes®Classic Favorite Exotic Milk Shakes®Cake and Pie Exotic Milk Shakes®Cheesecake Exotic Milk Shakes®Cookie and Candy Bar Exotic Milk Shakes®Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Onion Rings
  Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.
  $6.49
- Cheeseburger
  Hand-pattied burger topped with cheese.
  $5.35+
- Fries
  Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes. Available in both regular and large sizes. Gluten Free
  $4.75+
- Cheese Fries
  Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes, topped with Whiz. Available in both regular and large sizes. Gluten Free
  $5.75+
- Bacon Cheeseburger
  Hand-pattied burger topped with cheese and crispy bacon.
  $6.39+
- Nuggets
  Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $6.15+
- Soda
  Soda served in a 24-ounce cup.
  $3.95
- Fingers
  Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $4.89+
- Texas Ringer
  Our #1 Selling Burger! Topped with cheese, bacon, an onion ring, lettuce and Texas Petal Sauce.
  $6.89+
- Black and White
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
Shake Of The Month
- Irish Potato
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
Party Trays
Perfect for family gatherings!
- 30 Nugget Tray
  Chicken Nugget Party Trays! Served with 1 dipping sauce of your choice. Chicken Nugget Styles - Original - Buffalo - Cheese - Garlic Parm - Honey BBQ - Spicy - Spicy Cheese - Spicy Thai Chili
  $25.49
- 60 Nugget Tray
  Chicken Nugget Party Trays! Served with 2 dipping sauces of your choice. Chicken Nugget Styles - Original - Buffalo - Cheese - Garlic Parm - Honey BBQ - Spicy - Spicy Cheese - Spicy Thai Chili
  $46.65
- Cheeseburger Tray
  Our Signature Party Cheeseburger Tray. Lettuce, fried or raw onions, pickles, relish, tomatoes, ketchup and mustard on the side available upon request.
  $45.99
Nifty Burgers
Freshly ground and hand-pattied on premises. All burger buns can be replaced with a lettuce wrap. *All burgers pictured are doubles. All toppings not listed in the description, fries/onion rings, and beverages/milkshakes are NOT INCLUDED in price.
- Bacon Cheeseburger
  Hand-pattied burger topped with cheese and crispy bacon.
  $6.39+
- Chili Cheeseburger
  Hand-pattied cheeseburger topped with our homemade Chili.
  $6.15+
- Royal Burger
  Cheeseburger crowned with a homemade onion ring.
  $6.15+
- Hamburger
  Freshly ground and hand-pattied burger.
  $4.89+
- Cheeseburger
  Hand-pattied burger topped with cheese.
  $5.35+
- Mushroom Swiss Burger
  Hand-pattied burger topped with Swiss cheese and Fresh Grilled Mushrooms.
  $6.15+
- Leo Special Burger
  Cheeseburger with tomato, onion and relish.
  $5.35+
- Texas Ringer
  Our #1 Selling Burger! Topped with cheese, bacon, an onion ring, lettuce and Texas Petal Sauce.
  $6.89+
- Turkey Cheeseburger
  4.5 oz fresh ground patty topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato. (Double Turkey Cheeseburger is served on a kaiser roll.)
  $7.29+
- The "Beyond" Burger
  Beyond Meat's™ Famous plant-based Veggie Burger served on a grilled roll with lettuce and tomato. (Double "Beyond" Burger is served on a kaiser roll.)
  $9.49+
Philly Steaks
The sandwich that "Philly" made famous, served on a grilled Italian roll. *All toppings not listed in the description, fries/onion rings, and beverages/milkshakes are NOT INCLUDED in price.
- Cheesesteak
  Served with your choice of cheese, served on a long roll.
  $12.25
- Mushroom Swiss Cheesesteak
  Served with mushrooms and Swiss cheese, served on a long roll.
  $12.85
- Bacon Cheddar Cheesesteak
  Served with crispy bacon and cheddar cheese, served on a long roll.
  $13.09
- Chicken Cheesesteak
  Tender, diced chicken served with your choice of cheese, on a long roll.
  $12.25
- Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
  Buffalo Chicken Steak served with lettuce and American cheese, topped with bleu cheese and grated Parmesan cheese.
  $12.95
- Mushroom Swiss Chicken Cheesesteak
  Tender, diced chicken served with mushrooms and Swiss cheese, served on a long roll.
  $12.85
- Chicken Caesar Steak
  Our #1 Selling Philly Steak! Our famous chicken steak served over a bed of Caesar salad, topped with fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese.
  $12.65
Specialty Sandwiches
Filet Mignon, Chicken, and Fish Sandwiches *All toppings not listed in the description, fries/onion rings, and beverages/milkshakes are NOT INCLUDED in price.
- Filet Mignon Sandwich
  Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, and American cheese. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.
  $14.29
- Filet Mignon Special
  Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and onion. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.
  $15.89
- Mushroom Filet Mignon Sandwich
  Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, and Swiss cheese and mushrooms. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.
  $14.95
- Royal Filet Mignon®
  Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, American cheese and crowned with two homemade onion rings. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.
  $14.95
- Chicken Cutlet
  "Hand breaded to order" and topped with whiz and pickles, served on a kaiser roll.
  $9.55
- Buffalo Chicken Cutlet
  With lettuce, bleu cheese and American cheese, served on a kaiser roll.
  $9.85
- Honey Grilled Chicken
  With lettuce and tomato.
  $8.89
- Honey Grilled Chicken Texas Ringer
  Served with cheese, bacon, two onions rings, lettuce and Texas Petal Sauce.
  $10.95
- Honey Grilled Mushroom Swiss Chicken
  With lettuce and tomato.
  $10.15
- Fish Filet
  Freshly breaded and golden fried cod fish, served with lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce and a lemon wedge on a grilled roll.
  $9.20
Coney Island Hot Dogs
Old fashioned "Boardwalk Style" All our hot dogs are split, grilled and served on a grilled potato roll. *All toppings not listed in the description, fries/onion rings, and beverages/milkshakes are NOT INCLUDED in price.
- Hot Dog
  Old fashioned “Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog. (Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)
  $4.49
- Cheese Hot Dog
  Old fashioned “Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog with Whiz. (Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)
  $5.49
- Chili Hot Dog
  Old fashioned “Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog topped with our homemade chili. (Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)
  $5.49
- Kraut Hot Dog
  Old fashioned “Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog topped with sauerkraut. (Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)
  $5.49
- Chili Cheese Hot Dog
  Old fashioned “Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog topped with our homemade chili and Whiz. (Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)
  $5.99
- Texas Tommy
  Hot Dog wrapped in bacon with Whiz (Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)
  $6.25
- Chili Texas Tommy
  Hot Dog wrapped in bacon topped with our homemade chili and Whiz (Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)
  $7.50
Chicken Nuggets and Chicken Fingers
Fresh, all white meat chicken, hand breaded on premises. *All chicken nuggets pictured are 9-pieces and all chicken fingers pictured are 5-pieces. All toppings not listed in the description, fries/onion rings, and beverages/milkshakes are NOT INCLUDED in price.
- Nuggets
  Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $6.15+
- Spicy Nuggets
  Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $6.75+
- Cheese Nuggets
  Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets topped with Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $7.19+
- Spicy Cheese Nuggets
  Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $7.75+
- Fingers
  Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $4.89+
- Spicy Fingers
  Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $5.55+
- Cheese Fingers
  Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers topped with Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $5.95+
- Spicy Cheese Fingers
  Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.
  $6.55+
Fresh Cut Fries and Onion Rings
Hand Cut Daily *All beverages/milkshakes are NOT INCLUDED in price.
- Fries
  Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes. Available in both regular and large sizes. Gluten Free
  $4.75+
- Spicy Fries
  Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning. Available in both regular and large sizes. Gluten Free
  $5.25+
- Cheese Fries
  Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes, topped with Whiz. Available in both regular and large sizes. Gluten Free
  $5.75+
- Spicy Cheese Fries
  Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz. Available in both regular and large sizes. Gluten Free
  $6.25+
- Onion Rings
  Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.
  $6.49
- Spicy Onion Rings
  Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning. Served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.
  $6.99
- Cheese Onion Rings
  Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, topped with Whiz. Served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.
  $7.69
- Spicy Cheese Onion Rings
  Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz. Served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.
  $8.29
Smothered Fries
The "SMOTHER" of all fries. *Sides not included
- Smothered Honey Barbecue Chicken Fries
  Fresh-cut fries topped with grilled honey barbecue chicken, Whiz and fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese. Gluten Free
  $10.49
- Smothered Cheezy Bacon Ranch Fries
  Fresh-cut fries topped with fresh cooked bacon, ranch dressing, Whiz and fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese.
  $10.49
- Smothered Philly Cheesesteak Fries
  Fresh-cut fries topped with our "Best of Philly" steak, Whiz and fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese. Gluten Free
  $10.49
- Smothered Buffalo Chicken Fries
  Fresh-cut fries topped grilled Buffalo chicken, served with bleu cheese dressing, Whiz and fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese. Gluten Free
  $10.49
- Smothered Chili Cheese Fries
  Fresh-cut fries topped with homemade chili, Whiz and fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese. Gluten Free
  $10.49
- Smothered Crab Meat Fries
  Fresh-cut fries topped with a blend of the highest quality lump and claw meats, our secret blend of seasonings, Whiz and fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese. Gluten Free
  $15.89
Salads & Chili
- Spicy Chicken Ranch Salad
  Crisp romaine drizzled with ranch dressing, topped with fresh, golden crispy chicken, perfected with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and topped with fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese.
  $12.59
- Nifty Caesar Salad
  Crisp romaine tossed with creamy Caesar dressing and croutons, topped with fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese.
  $8.75
- Bowl Chili
  Our homemade, award-winning recipe served with a roll and butter.
  $7.89
Waffles
Served ALL day!
- Whole Belgian Waffles
  Homemade Belgian Waffle.
  $8.15
- Chicken & Waffles
  Served with golden fried chicken cutlet over a Belgian waffle with a side of maple syrup.
  $11.49
Most Popular Milkshakes
- Birthday Cake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Black and White
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Butterscotch Krimpet
  Topped with Whipped Cream and a Krimpet
  $8.79
- Chocolate
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Chocolate Banana
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Chocolate Oreo
  Chocolate oreo
  $8.79
- Mint Chocolate Chip
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Mint Oreo
  Mint oreo
  $8.79
- Oreo Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Oreo Cookies and Cream
  $8.79
- Peanut Butter Kandy Kake
  Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Peanut Butter Oreo
  Contains Peanuts
  $8.79
- Reese Cup
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Strawberry
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Strawberry Banana Split
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Strawberry Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Strawberry Shortcake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Vanilla
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
Blue Ribbon Milk Shakes®
Nifty Fifty's is "The Milkshake Capital of the World®"
- Vanilla
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Chocolate
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Black & White
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Almond
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $7.75
- Banana
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Black Raspberry
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Black Cherry
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Blue Raspberry
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Cherry Bomb
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Chocolate Cherry
  Chocolate cherry
  $7.75
- Coconut
  Coconut
  $7.75
- Coffee
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Cotton Candy
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Bubble Gum
  Bubble gum
  $7.75
- Grape
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Green Apple
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Key Lime
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Lemon
  $7.75
- Mango
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Marshmallow
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Mint
  $7.75
- Mocha
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Passion Fruit
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Peach
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Pineapple
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Red Raspberry
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Root Beer
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Strawberry
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
- Watermelon
  Gluten Free
  $7.75
Classic Favorite Exotic Milk Shakes®
- Banana Coconut Custard
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Banana Fudge Dream
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Banana Nut
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Banana with Fresh Banana
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Bananas Foster
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Black Forest
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Butter Pecan
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Butterscotch Krimpet
  Topped with Whipped Cream and a Krimpet
  $8.79
- Candy Apple Walnut
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Caramel
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Caramel Apple
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Caramel Creme
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Chocolate Banana
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Chocolate Covered Strawberry
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Chocolate Marshmallow
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Chocolate Peanut Butter
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Chunky Monkey
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Coconut Creme
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Coconut Crunch
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Death By Chocolate
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- French Toast
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Fluffernutter
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Irish Potato
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Mint Chocolate Chip
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Moose Tracks
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Neopolitan
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Orange Creamsicle
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Peanut Butter
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Peanut Butter Jelly
  Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Peanut Butter Banana
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Peanut Butter Kandy Kake
  Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Pina Colada
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Rocky Road
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- S'mores
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Salted Caramel
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Strawberry Banana Split
  Topped with Whipped Cream Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Tiramisu
  Tiramisu
  $8.79
- Wholly Cannoli
  Wholly cannoli
  $8.79
Cake and Pie Exotic Milk Shakes®
- Apple Cobbler
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Banana Cream Pie
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Birthday Cake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Blueberry Cobbler
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Blueberry Shortcake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Boston Creme Pie
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Caramel Apple Pie
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Coconut Creme Pie
  Topped with Whipped Cream Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Dirt Cake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Funfetti
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Italian Rum Cake
  Topped with Whipped Cream Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Key Lime Pie
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Lemon Meringue Pie
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Peach Cobbler
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Strawberry Shortcake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
Cheesecake Exotic Milk Shakes®
- Black Forest Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Black Raspberry Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Blueberry Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Caramel Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Cherry Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Key Lime Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Oreo Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Pineapple Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Salted Caramel Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
- Strawberry Cheesecake
  Topped with Whipped Cream
  $8.79
Cookie and Candy Bar Exotic Milk Shakes®
- Chips Ahoy
  Chips ahoy
  $8.79
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
  $8.79
- Chocolate Oreo
  Chocolate oreo
  $8.79
- Mint Oreo
  Mint oreo
  $8.79
- Oreo Cookies and Cream
  $8.79
- Peanut Butter Oreo
  Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Strawberry Oreo
  Strawberry oreo
  $8.79
- Thin Mint
  Thin mint
  $8.79
- Almond Joy
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Baby Ruth
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Butterfinger
  Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Mounds
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Peanut Chew
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Reese Cup
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Snickers
  Gluten Free Contains Nuts
  $8.79
- Tootsie Roll
  Gluten Free
  $8.79
- Whoppers
  Whoppers
  $8.79
Beverages
- Sweet Iced Tea
  Fresh Brewed Sweet Iced Tea served in a 24-ounce cup.
  $3.99
- Unsweetened Iced Tea
  Fresh Brewed Unsweetened Iced Tea served in a 24-ounce cup.
  $4.05
- Lemonade
  Fresh Squeezed Lemonade served in a 24-ounce cup.
  $4.25
- Soda
  Soda served in a 24-ounce cup.
  $3.95