Nicky's Pizzeria Menu

4.5

(600+ Reviews)

$Pizza

Customer Favorites Apps & Sides Pizza Wraps & Subs Pasta Beverages Salads Kids Menu Desserts Lunch Menu

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Whole Pizza
  Toppings - Pepperoni, Jalapeno, Sausage, Banana Pepper, Meatball, Roasted Pepper, Ham, Artichoke Heart, Bacon, Sun Dried Tomato, Grilled Chicken, Basil, Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Garlic, Prosciutto, Feta Salami, Fresh Mozzarella, Anchovies, Extra Cheese, Mushrooms, Cold Cheese, Onion, Vegan Cheese, Black Olives, Vegan Pepperoni, Green Olives, Sliced Tomato, Pineapple
  $9.95+
- Garlic Knots
  Six pieces of our made from scratch dough tied into knots and tossed in garlic powder, garlic oil, parmesan and parsley.
  $5.95
- Garlic Cheese Bread
  Full size hoagie roll with garlic butter and melted mozzarella baked to perfection.
  $6.95
- Chicken Alfredo
  Grilled chicken and a fresh cream sauce with romano cheese tossed with penne noodles.
  $13.95
- Fried Ravioli
  Lightly breaded cheese ravioli served with house made marinara.
  $7.95
- Pepperoni Twists
  Four pieces of our made from scratch dough rolled with pepperoni and mozzarella, topped with garlic oil and served with house-made marinara.
  $6.95
- Supreme
  Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Pepper, Onions, House Sauce
  $13.95+
- Pizza By The Slice
  $3.45+
- Chicken Wings
  Fried chicken wings available in franks hot sauce, teriyaki, lemon pepper, garlic parmesan or tangy bbq.
  $8.95+
- Meatlovers
  Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Mozzarella
  $13.95+
Apps & Sides
- Pepperoni Twists
  Four pieces of our made from scratch dough rolled with pepperoni and mozzarella, topped with garlic oil and served with house-made marinara.
  $6.95
- Garlic Bread
  Toasted bread topped with garlic butter and herb seasoning.
  $3.25
- Garlic Cheese Bread (Vegan)
  Toasted bread topped with vegan cheese, garlic, and herbs.
  $6.95
- Garlic Knots (Vegan)
  Strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and tossed in garlic oil and parsley.
  $5.95
- Tofu Bites
  Plain, hot, teriyaki, lemon pepper, garlic parmesan, or BBQ. Drizzle of ranch or blue cheese.
  $7.95
- Brussel Sprouts
  Golden-roasted Brussels sprouts, perfectly seasoned and bursting with flavor.
  $7.95
- Extra Marinara
  $0.75
- Extra Dressing
  $0.75
- Chicken Wings
  Fried chicken wings available in franks hot sauce, teriyaki, lemon pepper, garlic parmesan or tangy bbq.
  $8.95+
- Fried Mac & Cheese Bites
  Macaroni pasta enveloped in a rich cheese sauce, then formed into bites and fried until golden.
  $6.95
- Garlic Cheese Bread
  Full size hoagie roll with garlic butter and melted mozzarella baked to perfection.
  $6.95
- Meatballs
  Ground meatballs, typically includes bread crumbs, minced onion, and a blend of seasonings, served with marinara sauce.
  $8.95
- French Fries
  Generous portion of battered, seasoned french fries served with a side of ketchup.
  $6.95
- Bruschetta
  Fresh tomato, fresh basil, garlic and olive oil over baked crostini topped with balsamic glaze.
  $7.95
- Chicken Fingers
  Five lightly breaded fried chicken tenders served with a side of honey mustard dipping sauce.
  $9.95
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Six pieces of lightly breaded mozzarella cheese served with house-made marinara.
  $8.95
- Fried Calamari
  Hearty portion of italian breaded, lightly fried, squid rings served with house-made marinara dipping sauce.
  $12.95
- Fried Ravioli
  Lightly breaded cheese ravioli served with house made marinara.
  $7.95
- Garlic Knots
  Six pieces of our made from scratch dough tied into knots and tossed in garlic powder, garlic oil, parmesan and parsley.
  $5.95
- Soup
  Cup or bowl. Classic American soup.
  $3.99+
Pizza
- Pizza By The Slice
  $3.45+
- Take & Bake
  Two 10 inch freshly rolled in house dough balls, 2 house made pizza sauce, in house shredded grande cheese, and high gluten flour to roll out your dough. Comes with instructions.
  $12.00+
- Monday Special
  Cheese or pepperoni on a classic pizza crust.
  $10.00
- Pickle Pizza
  Red pepper flakes, pickles, parmesan cheese, parsley, ranch drizzle.
  $10.95+
- Whole Pizza
  Toppings - Pepperoni, Jalapeno, Sausage, Banana Pepper, Meatball, Roasted Pepper, Ham, Artichoke Heart, Bacon, Sun Dried Tomato, Grilled Chicken, Basil, Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Garlic, Prosciutto, Feta Salami, Fresh Mozzarella, Anchovies, Extra Cheese, Mushrooms, Cold Cheese, Onion, Vegan Cheese, Black Olives, Vegan Pepperoni, Green Olives, Sliced Tomato, Pineapple
  $9.95+
- Supreme
  Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Pepper, Onions, House Sauce
  $13.95+
- Italian Stallion
  Choice of personal or large, featuring traditional American toppings with an Italian twist.
  $13.95+
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
  Chicken bacon ranch pizza with a choice of personal or large size. Topped with seasoned chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch dressing.
  $11.95+
- Spring Break
  Spring Break Pizza: Available in personal or large sizes, topped with a vibrant mix of seasonal ingredients.
  $11.95+
- Barbecue Chicken
  Barbecue chicken pizza with two size options: personal or large.
  $11.95+
- Buffalo Chicken
  Spicy Buffalo chicken, mozzarella cheese, and a drizzle of ranch dressing, available in personal or large sizes.
  $11.95+
- Bacon Fetaroni
  Pepperoni pizza topped with bacon, available in personal and large sizes.
  $13.95+
- Chicken alla Vodka
  Grilled chicken, prosciutto, and shallots in a made to order vodka sauce on a fresh, hand stretched pizza dough topped with fresh mozzarella, parmesan and basil
  $15.95+
- Veggie
  Veggie pizza with various sizes available: personal or large.
  $13.95+
- White
  Garlic Oil Base, Ricotta, Romano, Mozzarella
  $10.95+
- BBQ Chicken Luau
  BBQ sauce base, grilled chicken, bacon. pineapple, jalapenos
  $13.95+
- Classic Margherita
  Red Base, Mozzarella, Parm, Basil
  $10.95+
- White Margherita
  Garlic Oil Base, Tomato, Basil, Mozzarella, Balsamic Drizzle
  $10.95+
- Meatlovers
  Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Mozzarella
  $13.95+
- Cheese Calzone
  Additional Toppings $1.25
  $11.95
- Stromboli
  Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Bacon, Mozzarella Cannot be made as vegan
  $11.95
- Wednesday Special
  Pepperoni or Cheese Pizza House or Caesar Salad Garlic Knots
  $29.99
- 2 Slice Lunch
  Two slices of pizza, toppings and cheese blend typically included, served as a lunch portion.
  $9.95
- Slice & Salad Lunch
  Slice of American-style pizza paired with choice of house salad or Caesar salad.
  $9.95
Wraps & Subs
- Fried Chicken Wrap
  Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Mozz, Ranch
  $11.95
- Grilled Chicken Wrap
  Gr Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Balsamic Vinaigrette
  $11.95
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  Gr Chicken, Lettuce, Romano, Caesar
  $12.95
- Buffalo Solider Wrap
  Buffalo Soldier Wrap: Succulent chicken coated in spicy Buffalo sauce, wrapped snugly. Choice of fries, Caesar, or house salad. Option for no side available.
  $12.95
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
  Chicken, Bacon, American, Lettuce, Tomato, Ranch
  $7.95+
- Chicken Parmigiana Sub
  Chicken, Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce
  $7.95+
- Meatball Parmigiana
  Meatball, Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce
  $7.95+
- Vegan Meatball Parmigiana
  A choice of half or whole sandwich with vegan meatballs and parmigiana cheese.
  $7.95+
- Italian Combo
  Ham, Pep, Salami, Capicola, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Mustard, Oil, Vinegar
  $7.95+
Pasta
- Penne Alla Vodka
  Savory tomato cream sauce simmered with shallots, imported prosciutto and vodka.
  $15.95
- Spaghetti W/ Meatballs
  Spaghetti served with meatballs. Option of house salad or Caesar salad on the side.
  $13.95
- Chicken Alfredo
  Grilled chicken and a fresh cream sauce with romano cheese tossed with penne noodles.
  $13.95
- Chicken Parmigiana
  Breaded chicken cutlet with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella over a bed of spaghetti.
  $13.95
- Baked Spaghetti
  Baked spaghetti with a meat sauce and melted cheese.
  $11.95
- Vegan Ravioli
  Stuffed vegan ravioli, choice of house or Caesar salad.
  $11.95
- Lasagna
  Layers of pasta, rich meat sauce, creamy cheese. Choice of House or Caesar Salad.
  $11.95
Beverages
- Coke
  The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
  $2.05
- Diet Coke
  A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
  $2.05
- Cherry Coke
  Enjoy the crisp and refreshing taste with sweet, smooth cherry flavor.
  $2.05
- Coke Zero
  The same great taste but with zero calories.
  $2.05
- Dr. Pepper
  Unique blend of 23 flavors, carbonated soft drink.
  $2.05
- Sprite
  The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
  $2.05
- Minute Maid Lemonade
  100% Pure squeezed pasteurized orange juice. A delicious orange juice with a taste that’s the next best thing to fresh squeezed.
  $2.05
- Pink Lemonade
  Refreshing, slightly tangy pink lemonade with a sweet, colorful twist.
  $2.05
- Unsweet Tea
  Refreshing, chilled classic tea with no added sweetness.
  $2.05
- Orange Fanta
  Zesty and refreshing citrus beverage with a vibrant orange fizz.
  $2.05
- Sweet Tea
  Refreshing sweet tea brewed to perfection.
  $2.05
- Red Bull
  Invigorating Energy Surge: The Classic Red Bull Experience
  $3.00
- Ginger Beer
  Refreshing, Sparkling Beverage with a Zesty Ginger Kick
  $3.00
- Coffee
  Freshly brewed, aromatic blend to kick-start your day.
  $4.00
- Espresso
  Rich, flavorful cup of espresso brewed to perfection.
  $4.00
Salads
- House Salad
  Tomato, Cucumber, Carrots, Black Olives, Green Olives
  $7.95+
- Caesar Salad
  Romano Cheese, Croutons, Caesar Dressing
  $7.95+
- Mediterranean Salad
  Artichoke Hearts, Sundried Tomato, Onions, Olives, Feta
  $9.95+
- Main Street Salad
  Tomato, Cucumber, Green Pepper, Bacon, Mozz, Croutons
  $9.95+
- Lexington Salad
  Tomato, Cranberries, Walnuts, Bacon, Feta
  $9.95+
- Side Salad
  House or Caesar side salad. Mixed greens for the House; Romaine, Parmesan, croutons for the Caesar.
  $4.95
- Caprese Salad
  Fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, basil. Choice of small or large size.
  $7.95+
- Salad Sampler Box
  Choose from three of our salads. This is prepared in one of our large 16 inch pizza boxes and is great to share!
  $18.00+
Kids Menu
- Kid's Slice
  Includes Drink
  $5.50
- Toasted Cheese Sandwich W/FF
  Half of a hoagie roll with melted american cheese.
  $7.50
- Buttered Noodles
  Spaghetti noodles tossed in butter.
  $7.50
- Kid's Spaghetti
  House-made marinara sauce over spaghetti noodles.
  $7.50
- Chicken Fingers W/FF
  Hand-breaded chicken tenders accompanied by french fries, typically served with a side of ketchup.
  $7.50
Desserts
- Cannoli
  A deep-fried pastry shell stuffed with a sweet cream filling topped with chocolate chips and powdered sugar.
  $3.45
- Coke Float
  Scoops of vanilla ice cream floating in bubbly coke.
  $5.00
- Cheesecake
  New york style cheesecake drizzled with your choice of chocolate or caramel sauce.
  $6.99
- Ice Cream
  Your choice of chocolate or vanilla ice cream with a chocolate or caramel drizzle.
  $3.00
- Cannoli (Catering)
  A deep-fried pastry shell stuffed with a sweet cream filling topped with chocolate chips and powered sugar. Min 20
  $3.00
- Dining Kit
  Leave the dishes to us! Our dining kits come with disposable plates, napkins and cutlery. Each dining kit serves 10 people.
  $10.00
- Seasonal Dessert
  House-made dessert crafted with chef's choice of seasonal ingredients. Please ask your server for today's selection.
  $4.00
- Brownie
  Decadent Chocolate Brownie, Perfectly Moist and Rich in Flavor
  $4.00
- Brownie Sundae
  Warm brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, caramel drizzle, and whipped cream.
  $6.50
- Caramel Apple Crumb Cake
  Moist apple cake topped with a buttery brown sugar crumble and drizzled with rich caramel sauce.
  $4.00
- Zeppoli
  Fried dough dusted with powdered sugar, typically served with chocolate or raspberry sauce.
  $7.50
Lunch Menu
- Pick Two
  Choice of two items. Options include pizza slices, salads, bread, and sides such as French fries or meatballs.
  $11.95
- NY Slice Lunch
  NY slice with choice of house salad, Caesar salad, or 2 NY slices.
  $9.95
- House Salad (Lunch)
  Tomato, Cucumber, Carrots, Black Olives, Green Olives
  $7.95+
- Caesar Salad (Lunch)
  Romano Cheese, Croutons, Caesar Dressing
  $7.95+
- Mediterranean Salad (Lunch)
  Artichoke Hearts, Sundried Tomato, Onions, Olives, Feta
  $9.95+
- Lexington Salad (Lunch)
  Tomato, Cranberries, Walnuts, Bacon, Feta
  $9.95+
- Main Street Salad (Lunch)
  Tomato, Cucumber, Green Pepper, Bacon, Mozz, Croutons
  $9.95+
- Buffalo Solider Wrap
  Choice of sides include fries, Caesar salad, house salad, or no side.
  $12.95
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  Gr Chicken, Lettuce, Romano, Caesar
  $12.95
- Fried Chicken Wrap
  Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Mozz, Ranch
  $11.95
- Grilled Chicken Wrap
  Gr Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato, Balsamic Vinaigrette
  $11.95
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
  Chicken, Bacon, American, Lettuce, Tomato, Ranch
  $7.95+
- Chicken Parmigiana Sub
  Chicken, Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce
  $7.95+
- Chicken Parmigiana
  Crispy breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce, mozzarella, and Parmesan. Choice of House or Caesar Salad.
  $13.95
- Meatball Parmigiana
  Meatball, Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce
  $7.95+
- Vegan Meatball Parmigiana
  Vegan meatballs topped with marinara, melted cheese. Available in half or whole sizes.
  $7.95+
- Italian Combo
  Ham, Pep, Salami, Capicola, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Mustard, Oil, Vinegar
  $7.95+
- Soup
  $3.99+