Newberry Sub Shop Menu

2002 Newberry St, Williamsport, PA 17701
  • Sherry's Red Hot Peppers

    • Sherry's Red Hot Peppers

      16 oz. Portion
      $8.50
    • Sherry's Red Hot Peppers

      8 oz. Portion
      $5.75
  • Middleswarth Potato Chips

    • Plain Weekender Bag

      Weekender Bag - Plain - 10 oz.
      $7.15
    • BBQ Weekender Bag

      Weekender Bag - BBQ - 10 oz
      $7.15
  • Chicken Cheese Steaks

    • Half Chicken Cheese Steak

      $9.30
    • Whole Chicken Cheese Steak

      $19.90
  • Drinks

    • 20 Oz Pepsi Products

      Looking for a refreshing drink to pair with your meal? Select a drink below from our wide variety of Pepsi products.
      $3.60
    • 2-Liter Bottled Drinks

      $5.00
    • Pint Chocolate Milk

      Valley Farms Pint Chocolate Milk
      $2.75
  • Miscellaneous

    • Half Hot Sausage Sub

      Pork based… includes fried onions, bell peppers, cheese, and light meatball sauce.
      $13.10
    • Half 7” CheeseBurger Sub - Fresh Ground Beef

      Half 7” CheeseBurger Sub with fresh ground beef. Includes Cheese, Fried or Raw Onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayonnaise, & Sherry’s Red Hot Peppers.
      $13.10
    • Whole Hot Sausage Sub

      Pork Based Sausage - Includes fried onion, fried bell pepper, american cheese, and light meatball sauce.
      $26.20
    • Whole 14” Cheese Burger Sub - Fresh Ground Beef

      Whole 14” CheeseBurger Sub with fresh ground beef. Includes Cheese, Fried or Raw Onions, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayonnaise, and Sherry's Red Hot Peppers
      $26.20
  • Extras

    • Side Of Meatball Sauce - 2 Oz

    • 2 Oz Ketchup Side

    • 2 Oz Mustard Side

    • Oil And Pepper Sides

    • Mayonnaise Side - 2 Oz

    • Side Of Meatball Sauce - 8 Oz

      $3.60
  • Pizza

    • Pizza With Everything

      Includes Pepperoni, Extra Cheese, Onions, Mushrooms, Bell Peppers, and Sausage.
      $16.45
    • Large 12" Cheese Pizza

      $18.55
    • Small 9" Cheese Pizza

      Small 9" Pizza
      $10.70
  • Cold Subs - 7“ Half - 14” Whole Sub Rolls

    • Whole Veggie N Cheese Sub

      Whole Veggie n Cheese Sub with Alfalfa Sprouts.
      $21.40
    • Half Veggie N Cheese Sub

      Half Veggie n Cheese Sub - Includes alfalfa bean sprouts.
      $10.70
    • Half Cold Canadian Bacon & Cheese Sub

      Half Cold Canadian Bacon n Cheese Sub.
      $11.10
    • Half Veggie N Cheese Sub W/ Mushrooms

      Half Veggie n Cheese Sub with Alfalfa Bean Sprouts,, Cucumbers, Fresh Mushrooms , and Fresh Bell Peppers.
      $11.10
    • Whole Roast Beef N Cheese Sub

      Whole Roast Beef n Cheese Sub.
      $24.30
    • Whole Cold Canadian Bacon N Cheese Sub

      Whole Cold Canadian Bacon n Cheese Sub.
      $22.20
    • Half Roast Beef N Cheese Sub

      Half Roast Beef n Cheese Sub.
      $12.15
    • Half Regular Sub

      Half Regular Sub - Our Version Of Italian Sub - Choice of Cheese, Hard Salami, Sweet Chopped Ham, and Dutch Loaf.
      $11.10
    • Half Salami & Ch Sub

      Half Hard Salami n Cheese Sub.
      $12.15
    • Whole Regular Sub

      Whole Regular Sub - Our Version Of Italian Sub - Choice of Cheese, Hard Salami, Sweet Chopped Ham, and Dutch Loaf.
      $22.20
    • Half BLT Sub

      $11.10
    • Whole BLT Sub

      $22.20
    • Half Ham N Cheese Sub

      Half Smithfield VA Baked Ham n Cheese Sub.
      $12.15
    • Whole Combo Sub

      Whole Smithfield VA Baked Ham, Turkey Breast n Cheese Sub.
      $24.30
    • Whole Salami N Cheese Sub

      Whole Hard Salami n Cheese Sub
      $24.30
    • Half Combo Sub (Ham,Turkey & Cheese)

      Half Smithfield VA Baked Ham, Turkey Breast n Cheese Sub.
      $12.15
    • Whole Veggie N Cheese Sub W/ Mushrooms

      Whole Veggie n Cheese Sub with Alfalfa Bean Sprouts, Cucumbers, Fresh Mushrooms and Fresh Bell Peppers.
      $22.20
    • Whole Tuna N Cheese Sub

      Whole Tuna n Cheese Sub.
      $22.20
    • Whole Ham N Cheese Sub

      Whole Smithfield VA Baked Ham n Cheese.
      $24.30
    • Whole Cold Cheese Sub

      $21.40
    • Half Turkey N Cheese Sub

      Half Turkey Breast n Cheese.
      $11.10
    • Whole Turkey N Cheese Sub

      Whole Turkey Breast n Cheese.
      $22.20
    • Half Cold Cheese Sub

      $10.70
    • Half Tuna & Cheese Sub

      Half Tuna n Cheese Sub.
      $11.10
  • CheeseSteaks (Sirloin - 20 Oz Per Whole 14” Sub)

    • Half Cheese Steak (10 Oz Sirloin)

      10 OZ SIRLOIN CHEESESTEAK
      $13.10
    • Whole Cheese Steak (20 Oz Sirloin)

      20 OZ SIRLOIN CHEESESTEAK
      $26.20
  • Cosmos (Oven Toasted) - 7” Half Cosmos - 14” Whole Cosmos

    • Half BLT Sub Cosmo (Oven Toasted)

      BLT On Sub Roll - Oven Toasted.
      $11.10
    • Half Cheese Cosmo

      Choice of Provolone or American Cheese - Toasted
      $10.70
    • Whole Turkey & Cheese Cosmo

      Turkey Breast and Cheese - Toasted
      $22.20
    • Half Roast Beef Cosmo

      Roast Beef and Cheese - Toasted
      $12.15
    • Whole BLT Sub Cosmo (Oven Toasted)

      Whole BLT On Sub Roll - Oven Toasted.
      $22.20
    • Whole Canadian Bacon Cosmo

      Canadian Bacon and Cheese - Toasted
      $22.20
    • Whole Tuna Cosmo

      Tuna and Cheese. - Toasted
      $22.20
    • Half Tuna Cosmo

      Tuna and Cheese. - Toasted
      $11.10
    • Half Combo Cosmo (Ham, Turkey & Cheese)

      Smithfield VA Baked Ham, Turkey Breast & Cheese - Toasted
      $12.15
    • Half Veggie And Cheese Cosmo

      Includes alfalfa bean sprouts.
      $10.70
    • Half Grinder

      Regular sub - Oven-Toasted
      $11.10
    • Half Veggie, Cheese & Mushroom Cosmo

      Includes alfalfa bean sprouts, cucumbers, fresh mushrooms, and fresh bell peppers.
      $11.10
    • Whole Grinder (Regular Toasted)

      Regular sub - Oven-Toasted
      $22.20
    • Whole Ham Cosmo

      Smithfield VA Baked Ham and Cheese - Toasted
      $24.30
    • Whole Cheese Cosmo

      Choice of Provolone or American Cheese - Toasted
      $21.40
    • Whole Meatball Sub

      Homemade Meatball - No Cheese - NOT Toasted - Topped With Grated Parmesan Cheese.
      $23.70
    • Half Turkey Cosmo

      Turkey Breast and Cheese - Toasted
      $11.10
    • Half Salami Cosmo

      Hard Salami and Cheese - Toasted
      $12.15
    • Whole Veggie & Cheese Cosmo

      Includes alfalfa bean sprouts.
      $21.40
    • Whole Meatball Cosmo

      Homemade Meatballs and Cheese - Toasted
      $24.30
    • Half Ham Cosmo

      Smithfield VA Baked Ham and Cheese - Toasted
      $12.15
    • Whole Roast Beef Cosmo

      Roast Beef and Cheese - Toasted
      $24.30
    • Half Meatball Sub

      Homemade Meatball - No Cheese - NOT Toasted - Topped With Grated Parmesan Cheese.
      $11.85
    • Whole Veggie, Cheese & Mushroom Cosmo

      Includes alfalfa bean sprouts, cucumbers, fresh mushrooms, and fresh bell peppers.
      $22.20
    • Half Meatball Cosmo

      Homemade Meatballs and Cheese - Toasted
      $12.15
    • Whole Combo Cosmo (Ham, Turkey & Cheese)

      Smithfield VA Baked Ham, Turkey Breast, and Cheese - Toasted
      $24.30
    • Whole Salami Cosmo

      Hard Salami and Cheese - Toasted
      $24.30
    • Half Canadian Bacon Cosmo

      Canadian Bacon and Cheese - Toasted
      $11.10
  • Salads

    • Deluxe Cheese Steak Salad

      Fried mushrooms, fried bell peppers and fried onions.
      $17.85
    • Tossed Salad

      $12.15
    • Tossed Salad With Tuna & Cheese

      $14.30
    • Chef Salad

      Ham, turkey, and cheese.
      $15.70
    • Chef Salad With Salami

      $17.15
    • Chicken Cheese Steak Salad

      Dark meat and cooked with light fried onions.
      $12.35
    • Tossed Salad With Tuna

      $13.60
    • Chef Salad With Tuna

      $17.15
    • Cheese Steak Salad

      $17.15
    • Tossed Salad With Cheese

      $12.85
  • Burgers

    • Bacon Cheese Burger

      1/3# Bacon Cheese Burger
      $12.25
    • Cheese Burger

      1/3# Cheese Burger
      $10.75
  • Pizza Rolla

    • Whole Pizza Rolla 14"

      Cheese and sauce toasted on an open-faced sub roll.
      $21.40
    • Half Pizza Rolla 7"

      Cheese and sauce toasted on an open-faced sub roll.
      $11.10
  • 12” Wraps

    • Regular (Italian) Wrap

      $11.10
    • BLT Wrap

      $11.10
    • Hot Sausage Wrap

      $13.10
    • Turkey & Cheese Wrap

      $11.10
    • Veggie & Cheese Wrap

      $11.10
    • Tuna & Cheese Wrap

      $11.10
    • Cheese Steak Wrap - 10 Oz. Sirloin

      $13.10
    • Cold Cheese Wrap

      $10.70
    • Salami & Cheese Wrap

      $12.15
    • Roast Beef & Cheese Wrap

      $12.15
    • CheeseBurger Sub Wrap - Fresh Ground Beef

      $13.10
    • Canadian Bacon & Cheese Wrap

      $11.10
    • Ham & Cheese Wrap

      $12.15
    • Combo (Ham-Turkey-Cheese) Wrap

      $12.15
  • Tacos

    • Taco - 8 " Soft Shell

      Home Made Taco Meat on an 8" Soft Shell Taco
      $7.85

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Newberry Hotel
Newberry Hotel
4.0
(124 Reviews)
Bar
Riepstine's Pub
Riepstine's Pub
4.6
(210 Reviews)
Brewpub, Brewery
Good Grace African Restaurant
Good Grace African Restaurant
4.8
(20 Reviews)
Restaurant
Finish Line Cafe
Finish Line Cafe
4.0
(87 Reviews)
Bar
Dunkin'
Dunkin'
4.0
(740 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Bagel shop, Bakery
Subway
Subway
4.0
(152 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Mileto's Sub Shop and pizza in Newberry
Mileto's Sub Shop and pizza in Newberry
4.6
(511 Reviews)
Sandwich shop
Hotel Kast
Hotel Kast
4.3
(351 Reviews)
Gastropub, Bar & grill
UpTop Cafe
UpTop Cafe
4.6
(39 Reviews)
Restaurant

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms