New York Pizza Company Menu

4.8
(125+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • XL LARGE 20" NY Style Thin Crust Cheese Pizza - Create Your Own Pizza

      Premium Mozzarella Cheese, Top Tier Ingredients Always.. Fresh Dough made in House Daily. Add Any of Our Premium Toppings !
      $23.99
    • Meat Pie (Meat Lovers) (20" XL LARGE NY Style Thin Crust)

      Topped with Premium Mozzarella Cheese, House made Bacon, Italian Sausage, Premium Pepperonis and Fresh Sliced Ham ! Loaded Down with Meat... Add any other Toppings you like !
      $35.99
    • MEDIUM 14" NY Style Thin Crust Cheese Pizza - Create Your Own Pizza

      Premium Mozzarella Cheese, Top Tier Ingredients Always.. Fresh Dough made in House Daily. Add Any of Our Premium Toppings !
      $14.99
    • HOT HONEY PEPPERONI XL Large 20" Inch NY Style Thin Crust Pizza

      Authentic Taste ! CUP N CRISP PEPPERONIS! This pizza comes loaded with Pepperoni included in the Price !! Hot Honey Infused with Chilies .... Ezzo Cup N Char Pepperoni's .... The Best ! .... We use only Fresh Dough made daily... All of Our Pies are Handcrafted and baked in a Traditional style Deck Oven ... Each Pizza is Handcrafted to order for You .. Add any other Toppings You'd like !
      $32.99
    • Huge Slice of Cheese 1/4 of 20" Pie

      HUGE 1/4th of a 20 inch Pizza From Our Slice Counter - Authentic New York Thin Crust Slice of Traditional Cheese Pizza . Fresh Dough , Fresh Tomato Sauce, Premium Italian Mozzarella Reheated in our Deck oven and Delivered to your Door.
      $6.99
    • New Item - Creamy New York Cheesecake

      Try Our New Delicious Creamy New York Cheesecake !! Delicious, Rich and Creamy with Thick Graham Cracker Crust!
      $8.99
    • Huge Slice of Pepperoni 1/4 of 20" Pie

      HUGE 1/4th of a 20 inch Pizza From Our Slice Counter - Authentic New York Thin Crust Slice of Traditional Pizza . Fresh Dough , Fresh Tomato Sauce, Premium Italian Mozzarella , Cup n Char Pepperonis - Reheated in our Deck oven and Delivered to your Door.
      $7.99
    • White Pie with Romas NY Style ! Thin Crust - XL LARGE 20" inch

      Traditional New York style White Pie .. A sauceless pie topped with Mozzarella ,Parmesan, Pecorino Romano, First Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Premium Italian Ricotta Cheese and Fresh Basil !
      $37.99
    • Pizza Margherita XL LARGE 20" NY Style Thin Crust Pizza

      Traditional Style Thin Crust Margherita .. Premium Extra Virgin Pressed Olive Oil, Fresh Fior Di Latte Italian Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano , Fresh Tomatoes and Topped with Fresh Basil ! .. Add Any Top Notch Topping You like ...
      $35.99
    • HOT HONEY PEPPERONI $3 OFF MEDIUM 14" Pizza $3 OFF

      Authentic Taste ! CUP N CRISP PEPPERONIS! This pizza comes loaded with Pepperoni included in the Price !! Hot Honey Infused with Chilies .... Ezzo Cup N Char Pepperoni's .... The Best ! .... We use only Fresh Dough made daily... All of Our Pies are Handcrafted and baked in a Traditional style Deck Oven ... Each Pizza is Handcrafted to order for You .. Add any other Toppings You'd like !
      $19.99
  • VIRTUAL SLICE COUNTER

    HUGE SLICES.. 1/4th of a 20" Pizza .. New York Thin Crust . Authentic New York Taste and Quality
    • Huge Slice of Cheese 1/4 of 20" Pie

      HUGE 1/4th of a 20 inch Pizza From Our Slice Counter - Authentic New York Thin Crust Slice of Traditional Cheese Pizza . Fresh Dough , Fresh Tomato Sauce, Premium Italian Mozzarella Reheated in our Deck oven and Delivered to your Door.
      $6.99
    • Huge Slice of Pepperoni 1/4 of 20" Pie

      HUGE 1/4th of a 20 inch Pizza From Our Slice Counter - Authentic New York Thin Crust Slice of Traditional Pizza . Fresh Dough , Fresh Tomato Sauce, Premium Italian Mozzarella , Cup n Char Pepperonis - Reheated in our Deck oven and Delivered to your Door.
      $7.99
    • Huge Slice of Meat-Lovers 1/4 of 20" Pie

      HUGE 1/4th of a 20 inch Pizza From Our Slice Counter - Authentic New York Thin Crust Slice of Traditional Cheese Pizza . Fresh Dough , Fresh Tomato Sauce, Premium Italian Mozzarella, Cup n Char Pepperonis, Ham, Bacon, Sweet Italian Sausage- Reheated in our Deck oven and Delivered to your Door. n
      $9.99
    • Huge Slice of Italian Sweet Sausage 1/4 of 20" Pie

      HUGE 1/4th of a 20 inch Pizza From Our Slice Counter - Authentic New York Thin Crust Slice of Traditional Pizza . Fresh Dough , Fresh Tomato Sauce, Premium Italian Mozzarella , Premium Sweet Italian Sausage - Reheated in our Deck oven and Delivered to your Door.
      $7.99
    • Huge Slice of Hot Honey Pepperoni 1/4 of 20" Pie

      HUGE 1/4th of a 20 inch Pizza From Our Slice Counter - Authentic New York Thin Crust Slice of Traditional Pizza . Fresh Dough , Fresh Tomato Sauce, Premium Italian Mozzarella , Cup n Char Pepperonis - Reheated in our Deck oven and Delivered to your Door.
      $8.99
  • PASTA - WEEKLY SPECIALS - DEALS

    Limited Time Offer While Supplies Last !
    • THE BEST Italian Meatballs with Marinara, Cheese, Basil Appetizer

      Shareable Portion of Italian meatballs made with beef and pork, seared in Extra Virgin Olive oil Fresh Seasoned Tomato Sauce, a blend of Premium Italian Cheeses, Fresh Basil
      $12.99
    • Chicken Alfredo Pasta Appetizer

      Creamy Alfredo, Penne Pasta, Premium Chicken Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Fresh Basil
      $9.99
    • 14" HOT HONEY PEPPERONI MEDIUM PIZZA

      DELICIOUS !!!!
      $20.99
    • Sausage & Mushroom 14" Pizza NY Thin Crust Medium 14"

      Premium Ingredients Always ... Portobellos , Italian Mozz, Fresh Dough, Hand Pinched Sausage Fresh Tomato Sauce ... Pepperonis in pic not included
      $19.99
    • $5 OFF 20” XL Buffalo Chicken LARGE 20” Pizza

      Authentic Buffalo Sauce topped with Premium Italian Mozzarella Cheese and Buffalo Chicken ... Add a side of Ranch for $2
      $31.99
    • $5 OFF 20” XL LARGE Jamaican Jerk Chicken Pizza 20” Pizza

      Authentic Jamaican Jerk Sauce topped with Premium Italian Mozzarella Cheese and Jamaican Jerk Chicken ... Add Romas Tomatoes for $4
      $31.99
    • HOT HONEY 4 CHEESE + 4 MEAT XL LARGE 20" NY THIN CRUST PIZZA

      Fresh Tomato Sauce with Our Famous 4 Cheese Blend ... 4 Meats include Pepperoni, Ham, Italian Sausage and Bacon then Topped with Mozzarella and a drizzle of Chilies Infused Hot Honey....
      $36.99
    • HOT HONEY 4 CHEESE + 4 MEAT MEDIUM 14" NY THIN CRUST PIZZA

      Fresh Tomato Sauce with Our Famous 4 Cheese ... 4 Meats include Pepperoni, Ham, Italian Sausage and Bacon then Topped with Mozzarella and a drizzle of Chilies Infused Hot Honey....
      $26.99
    • 12" Meatball Stromboli Wrapped in Fresh Made NY Pizza Dough

      Get Your Meatball Fix on with this Generous Portion of THE BEST Meatball Stromboli ...with THE BEST Italian Meatballs made with Beef and Pork, simmered in olive oil, Charred/Seared and topped with Parmesan, Pecorino Romano, Mozzarella Cheese and our Fresh seasoned Tomato Sauce. Wrapped in Our Fresh In-House Made Pizza Dough and Baked to Perfection. Deliciousness Guaranteed !
      $16.99
  • Authentic Specialty Pies

    • Pizza Margherita XL LARGE 20" NY Style Thin Crust Pizza

      Traditional Style Thin Crust Margherita .. Premium Extra Virgin Pressed Olive Oil, Fresh Fior Di Latte Italian Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano , Fresh Tomatoes and Topped with Fresh Basil ! .. Add Any Top Notch Topping You like ...
      $35.99
    • Pizza Margherita MEDIUM 14" INCH NY Style Thin Crust Pizza

      Traditional Style Thin Crust Margherita .. Premium Extra Virgin Pressed Olive Oil, Fresh Fior Di Latte Italian Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano , Fresh Tomatoes and Topped with Fresh Basil ! .. Add Any Top Notch Topping You like ...
      $25.99
    • White Pie with Romas, Prosciutto XL Large 20" Pizza

      Traditional New York style White Pie .. A sauceless pie topped with Mozzarella ,Parmesan, Pecorino Romano, First Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Premium Italian Ricotta Cheese , Prosciutto, Sliced Romas and Fresh Basil!.. (you can substitute the Romas for any other topping, simply add special instructions at check out) Add any other Premium Toppings
      $45.99
    • White Pie with Romas, Prosciutto MEDIUM 14" INCH Pizza

      Traditional New York style White Pie .. A sauceless pie topped with Mozzarella ,Parmesan, Pecorino Romano, First Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Premium Italian Ricotta Cheese , Prosciutto, Sliced Romas and Fresh Basil!.. (you can substitute the Romas for any other topping, simply add special instructions at check out) Add any other Premium Toppings
      $35.99
    • 4 Cheese Quattro Formaggi XL Large 20" Pizza

      Premium 4 Cheese Blend. Parmesan, Romano, Mozzarella and Provolone This is The Best 4 Cheese Pizza Ever! Add any of Our Top Notch Toppings you like !
      $29.99
    • 4 Cheese Quattro Formaggi Medium 14" inch Pizza

      Premium 4 Cheese Blend. Parmesan, Romano, Mozzarella and Provolone This is The Best 4 Cheese Pizza Ever! Add any of Our Top Notch Toppings you like !
      $19.99
    • Grandma Meatball Pie XL Large NY Thin Crust 20" inch

      Grandma Pie Meatball Pie - Garlic, Olive oil and Parm Romano Covered with Premium Mozzarella, Marinara and Loaded with Italian Beef and Pork Meatballs and Topped after the bake with Fresh Basil leaves. New York Thin Crust Dough made daily in house.
      $39.99
    • Grandma Meatball Pie MEDIUM NY Thin Crust 14" inch

      Grandma Pie Meatball Pie - Garlic, Olive oil and Parm Romano Covered with Premium Mozzarella, Marinara and Loaded with Italian Beef and Pork Meatballs and Topped after the bake with Fresh Basil leaves. New York Thin Crust Dough made daily in house.
      $29.99
    • White Pie with Romas MEDIUM 14" inch NY Style ! Thin Crust

      Traditional New York style White Pie .. A sauceless pie topped with Mozzarella ,Parmesan, Pecorino Romano, First Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Premium Italian Ricotta Cheese and Fresh Basil !
      $26.99
    • White Pie with Romas NY Style ! Thin Crust - XL LARGE 20" inch

      Traditional New York style White Pie .. A sauceless pie topped with Mozzarella ,Parmesan, Pecorino Romano, First Pressed Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Premium Italian Ricotta Cheese and Fresh Basil !
      $37.99
  • Specialty Pizzas

    • 20" Spicy Italian Spicy Sausage x Hot Honey

      Spicy Sausage and Hot Honey Infused with Chilies, Topped with Fresh Basil .. We use only Fresh Dough made daily... All of Our Pies are Handcrafted and baked in a Traditional style Deck Oven ... Each Pizza is Handcrafted to order for You
      $32.99
    • MEDIUM 14" Spicy Italian - Spicy Sausage & Hot Honey

      Spicy Sausage and Hot Honey Infused with Chilies, Topped with Fresh Basil .. We use only Fresh Dough made daily... All of Our Pies are Handcrafted and baked in a Traditional style Deck Oven ... Each Pizza is Handcrafted to order for You
      $19.99
    • HOT HONEY PEPPERONI XL Large 20" Inch NY Style Thin Crust Pizza

      Authentic Taste ! CUP N CRISP PEPPERONIS! This pizza comes loaded with Pepperoni included in the Price !! Hot Honey Infused with Chilies .... Ezzo Cup N Char Pepperoni's .... The Best ! .... We use only Fresh Dough made daily... All of Our Pies are Handcrafted and baked in a Traditional style Deck Oven ... Each Pizza is Handcrafted to order for You .. Add any other Toppings You'd like !
      $32.99
    • HOT HONEY PEPPERONI $3 OFF MEDIUM 14" Pizza $3 OFF

      Authentic Taste ! CUP N CRISP PEPPERONIS! This pizza comes loaded with Pepperoni included in the Price !! Hot Honey Infused with Chilies .... Ezzo Cup N Char Pepperoni's .... The Best ! .... We use only Fresh Dough made daily... All of Our Pies are Handcrafted and baked in a Traditional style Deck Oven ... Each Pizza is Handcrafted to order for You .. Add any other Toppings You'd like !
      $19.99
    • Sausage-Mushrooms-Onions XL Large 20" Inch NY Style Thin Crust

      Portobello Mushrooms, Onions, and Loaded Down with Sweet Italian Sausage 20" XL Large NY Style Thin Crust ....Premium Mozzarella . Fresh New York Dough made Daily
      $30.99
    • Sausage-Mushrooms-Onions MEDIUM 14" Inch NY Style Thin Crust

      Portobello Mushrooms, Onions, and Loaded Down with Sweet Italian Sausage 20" XL Large NY Style Thin Crust ....Premium Mozzarella . Fresh New York Dough made Daily
      $24.99
    • Meat Pie (Meat Lovers) (20" XL LARGE NY Style Thin Crust)

      Topped with Premium Mozzarella Cheese, House made Bacon, Italian Sausage, Premium Pepperonis and Fresh Sliced Ham ! Loaded Down with Meat... Add any other Toppings you like !
      $35.99
    • Hawaiian Lovers Pizza XL large 20"

      Loaded down with premium ham, bacon & pineapple, Italian mozzarella cheese, Fresh Dough !! add any other toppings you want !
      $35.99
    • Hawaiian Lovers Pizza MEDIUM 14" Inch

      Loaded down with premium ham, bacon & pineapple, Italian mozzarella cheese, Fresh Dough !! add any other toppings you want !
      $24.99
    • Grandma Pie NY Style !! XL LARGE 20" Pizza

      Garlic, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Premium Italian Mozzarella Topped with Rows of Fresh Tomato Sauce and Fresh Basil. Just like Grandma used to make! Yummy
      $33.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza with Ranch 20" XL Large NY Style Pizza

      Premium chicken tossed in our House buffalo sauce and then drizzled with Ranch.
      $36.99
    • Grandma Pie NY Style !! MEDIUM 14" inch Pizza

      Garlic, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Premium Italian Mozzarella Topped with Rows of Fresh Tomato Sauce and Fresh Basil. Just like Grandma used to make! Yummy
      $24.99
    • XL Jamaican Jerk Chicken Pizza 20" Xl Large NY Thin Crust Delicious !

      Tender jerk chicken, mozzarella cheese, and a tangy barbecue sauce on a 20" New York-style thin crust pizza.
      $36.99
    • MEDIUM Jamaican Jerk Chicken Pizza 14" NY Thin Crust

      Tender jerk chicken pieces on a thin, crispy 14" New York-style crust, topped with mozzarella cheese and drizzled with a savory sauce.
      $25.99
    • NO RANCH Buffalo Chicken Pizza with NO Ranch 20" XL Large NY Style Pizza

      Premium chicken tossed in Buffalo sauce and Premium Mozzarella
      $36.99
  • Create Your Own Pizza

    • MEDIUM 14" NY Style Thin Crust Cheese Pizza - Create Your Own Pizza

      Premium Mozzarella Cheese, Top Tier Ingredients Always.. Fresh Dough made in House Daily. Add Any of Our Premium Toppings !
      $14.99
    • XL LARGE 20" NY Style Thin Crust Cheese Pizza - Create Your Own Pizza

      Premium Mozzarella Cheese, Top Tier Ingredients Always.. Fresh Dough made in House Daily. Add Any of Our Premium Toppings !
      $23.99
  • SIDES

    • SIDE OF MARINARA

      Our House Marinara 3oz
      $2.00
    • SIDE OF RANCH

      Ranch Dipping Sauce Great with Pizza
      $2.00
    • SIDE OF BUFFALO

      Buffalo Sauce 3oz ....
      $2.00
    • FRESH AND CRISP BANANA PEPPERS (NEW ITEM)

      Imported Banana Peppers
      $2.00
    • Garlic Powder

      Ground garlic typically used to enhance the flavor of various dishes.
      $1.29
  • Dessert

    • New Item - Creamy New York Cheesecake

      Try Our New Delicious Creamy New York Cheesecake !! Delicious, Rich and Creamy with Thick Graham Cracker Crust!
      $8.99
  • Beverages

    • 16.9oz Coca Cola

      The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
      $2.99
    • 16.9oz Sprite

      The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
      $2.99
    • 16.9oz Diet Coke

      A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
      $2.99
    • Bottled Water

      Pure and refreshing bottled water.
      $1.99
    • Fanta Orange

      Change up your routine with the bright, bubbly, fruity orange flavor.
      $2.99
  • BEER GARDEN

    • Miller Lite 12oz Bottle

      A 12oz bottle of Miller Lite, a light American lager typically brewed with a blend of malted barley and hops, offering a clean, crisp taste. 4.2% alcohol by volume.
      $4.45
    • MODELO ESPECIAL 12OZ BOTTLE

      Modelo Especial is a rich, full-flavored pilsner-style lager with smooth notes of orange blossom honey, light hop character, and a crisp, clean finish. Imported from Mexico.
      $4.45
    • YUENGLING 12OZ BOTTLE

      A classic American lager with a rich amber color and a balanced blend of sweet caramel malt and subtle hop bitterness.
      $4.45
    • COORS BANQUET 12OZ BOTTLE

      Coors Banquet typically includes a classic American light lager profile with a smooth, refreshing taste.
      $4.45

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Scooter's Coffee
Scooter's Coffee
4.2
(164 Reviews)
Coffee shop
Marma Dukes
Marma Dukes
4.3
(112 Reviews)
Bar
Pizza Hut Express
Pizza Hut Express
3.0
(2 Reviews)
Pizza
KFC Headquarters
KFC Headquarters
1.5
(515 Reviews)
Chicken
Louie's Hot Chicken & Barbecue
Louie's Hot Chicken & Barbecue
4.6
(1,007 Reviews)
Barbecue
Waffle House
Waffle House
3.9
(1,625 Reviews)
Breakfast, American, Diner
Frisch's Big Boy
Frisch's Big Boy
3.8
(2,354 Reviews)
Diner, Breakfast, Buffet
Tastee Treats Louisville
Tastee Treats Louisville
4.9
(17 Reviews)
Bakery
Subway
Subway
3.7
(69 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Thorntons
Thorntons
3.2
(73 Reviews)
Breakfast, Coffee shop, Donut shop

+1 502-963-5756

2354 Frankfort Ave, Louisville, KY 40206


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms