New York City Pizza Menu

3.8

(375+ Reviews)

$Pizza, Bar, Restaurant

Appetizers
- Fried Calamari
  Served with our tomato sauce
  $11.95
- Italian Fries
  Our fabulous fries topped with special seasonings
  $6.95
- Small Fries
  $2.50
- Large Fries
  $5.00
- Chicken Fingers
  Lightly breaded breast strips. Plain, mild, hot, garlic parmesan, calypso or Jack Daniels BBQ sauce
  $13.95
- Mamma's Housemade Meatballs
  2 meatballs in our tomato sauce
  $8.95
- Buffalo Wings
  Plain, mild, hot, garlic parmesan, calypso or Jack Daniels BBQ sauce
  $15.95
- (6) Garlic Bread Sticks
  Freshly baked bread sticks, smothered in fresh garlic and parmesan, served with our tomato sauce
  $6.50
- (12) Garlic Bread Sticks
  Freshly baked bread sticks, smothered in fresh garlic and parmesan, served with our tomato sauce
  $9.50
- Insalata Caprese
  Our fresh mozzarella roasted tomato and basil, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil
  $12.95
- Classic Antipasto
  Sliced Prosciutto di Parma, fresh mozzarella, genoa salami, kalamata olives and seasoned artichoke hearts Serves Two
  $19.95
- Fresh Zucchini Sticks (5)
  Fried fresh local zucchini, served with our tomato sauce
  $8.50
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Served with our tomato sauce
  $9.50
- Garlic Bread
  Italian bread with fresh garlic and Romano cheese
  $7.50
House Specialties
- Fresh Zucchini Sticks (5)
  Fried fresh local zucchini, served with our tomato sauce
  $8.50
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Served with our tomato sauce
  $9.50
- Garlic Bread
  Italian bread with fresh garlic and Romano cheese
  $7.50
Soups
- Pasta Fagioli
  Classic Italian cannelloni bean stew with ditalini pasta
  $6.95
- NYCP's Wedding Soup
  Chicken, meatball and escarole soup with ditalini pasta
  $5.95
Salads
- House Salad
  Mixed greens, bell pepper, crouton, sliced mushroom, onion, diced tomato, tossed with your choice of dressing
  $9.45
- Side Salad
  Mixed lettuce greens and tomato
  $5.45
- Chopped Salad
  Mixed greens, kalamata olives, onion, tomato and bell pepper chopped and tossed in ranch dressing, topped with our croutons
  $10.45
- Caesar Salad
  Romaine lettuce, grated Romano croutons and our classic Caesar dressing
  $9.45
- Greek Salad
  Iceberg with feta cheese, diced tomato, bell pepper, kalamata olives, artichoke, drizzled with our Mediterranean dressing
  $10.45
- Side Caesar
  $5.45
Heroes
- The Italian Sub
  Ham, salami, pepperoni and provolone, with shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
  $14.95
- Ham & Provolone Sub
  With shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
  $13.95
- Turkey & Provolone Sub
  With shaved lettuce, sliced onion, and tomato, oil and vinegar
  $12.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
  Slices of fried and breaded eggplant with our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven
  $13.95
- Chicken Parmigiana Sub
  Breaded chicken cutlet covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven
  $13.95
- Meatball Parmigiana Sub
  Meatballs covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, baked in the oven
  $13.95
- Philly Cheesesteak Sub
  Shaved top sirloin sautéed with onion, bell pepper, and mushroom, topped with white American cheese
  $13.95
- Buffalo Chicken Sub
  Boneless breaded chicken breast fried and dipped in Buffalo wing sauce, with romaine lettuce and our blue cheese dressing
  $13.95
Pastas & Entrees
- Spaghetti With Meatballs
  Meatballs in our tomato sauce and tossed with spaghetti
  $15.50
- Penne Bolognese
  Meat sauce of beef stewed in tomato sauce with a touch of cream
  $15.95
- Fettuccine Alfredo
  Cream sauce with parmesan and romano cheese tossed with fettuccine
  $16.95
- Penne Alla Vodka
  Minced prosciutto, onions, peas, sautéed and finished with vodka in tomato sauce with a touch of cream
  $16.95
- Housemade Baked Ziti
  Ricotta and mozzarella cheese with ziti pasta, topped with our tomato sauce and mozzarella
  $12.50
- Linguine And Red Clam Sauce
  Sautéed baby clams, garlic and marinara, tossed with linguine
  $18.95
- Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
  Covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, served with penne pasta
  $17.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana Pasta
  Covered in our tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, served with penne pasta
  $15.95
- Chicken Marsala
  Tender breaded chicken cutlet sautéed with mushrooms in our Sicilian Marsala sauce, served with penne pasta
  $18.95
- Spaghetti With Marinara
  $11.95
- Meatball Refill
Extra Sauces & Dressings
- House Vinaigrette
  $1.00
- Caesar
  $1.00
- Ranch
  $1.00
- Blue Cheese
  $1.00
- Peppery Parmesan
  $1.00
- Honey Mustard
  $1.00
- Mediterranean
  $1.00
- Oil and Vinegar
  $1.00
- Sugo
  $1.00
- Wing Sauce
  $1.00
Smash Burger
- NYCP Smash Burger
  Two patties smashed to order served with shredded lettuce, Roma tomato, sliced onion with House Seasoning and Sauce, Topped with White Cheddar Cheese
  $11.95
Calzone & Stromboli
- Small Calzone
  Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
  $17.00
- Large Calzone
  Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
  $19.00
- Small Stromboli
  Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
  $17.00
- Large Stromboli
  Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
  $19.00
Kid's Menu
- Kids Spaghetti w/ Tomato Sauce
  $6.95
- Kids Spaghetti & Meatball
  $8.45
- Kids Penne Pasta w/ Butter Sauce
  $6.95
- Kids Chicken Fingers (4)
  $6.95
- Kids Buffalo Wings (5)
  $6.95
- Kids Hamburger
  $6.95
- Kids Chicken Alfredo
  $6.95
Desserts
- Housemade Cannoli
  $5.95
- Housemade Plain Cheesecake
  $5.95
BYO Pizza
- 14" New York
  $19.00
- 16" New York
  $21.00
- 14" Deep Dish Pan
  $21.00
- 16" Deep Dish Pan
  $23.00
- Sicilian
  $26.00
By The Slice
- By the Slice
  $3.50
Medium 14" Specialty
- 14" NYCP Special
  Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, onion and mushroom
  $27.50
- 14" Vegetarian
  Mushroom, bell pepper, onion, tomato and artichoke
  $24.50
- 14" Meat Lovers
  Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham and bacon
  $29.00
- 14" BBQ Chicken Pizza
  Our BBQ fried chicken, bacon, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses
  $27.00
- 14" White Pizza
  Ricotta white sauce, mozzarella and romano cheese
  $23.00
- 14" Hawaiian
  Tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham and pineapple
  $23.00
- 14" Margherita
  Our fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil and garlic
  $24.00
- 14" Buffalo Chicken Pizza
  Ranch sauce, fried chicken, mozzarella and cheddar cheese with buffalo wing sauce
  $26.00
Large 16" Specialty
- 16" NYCP Special
  Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, onion and mushroom
  $30.50
- 16" Vegetarian
  Mushroom, bell pepper, onion, tomato and artichoke
  $27.50
- 16" Meat Lovers
  Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, ham and bacon
  $32.00
- 16" BBQ Chicken Pizza
  Our BBQ fried chicken, bacon, mozzarella and cheddar cheeses
  $30.00
- 16" White Pizza
  Ricotta white sauce, mozzarella and romano cheese
  $26.00
- 16" Hawaiian
  Tomato sauce, mozzarella, ham and pineapple
  $26.00
- 16" Margherita
  Our fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil and garlic
  $27.00
- 16" Buffalo Chicken Pizza
  Ranch sauce, fried chicken, mozzarella and cheddar cheese with buffalo wing sauce
  $29.00
10" Gluten Free Cauli Crust
- 10" Cauli Crust (Gluten Free)
  $15.95
Dough Balls
- Med Dough Ball
  $5.00
- Large Dough Ball
  $6.00
Calzone & Stromboli
- Small Calzone
  Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
  $17.00
- Large Calzone
  Pizza turnover filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese
  $19.00
- Small Stromboli
  Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
  $17.00
- Large Stromboli
  Stuffed bread with mozzarella cheese
  $19.00
20oz Bottled Soda
- 20oz Pepsi
  $3.00
- 20oz Diet Pepsi
  $3.00
- 20oz Sierra Mist
  $3.00
- 20oz Mt.Dew
  $3.00
- 20oz Dr. Pepper
  $3.00
2 Liter Bottled Soda
- 2L Pepsi
  $3.00
- 2L Diet Pepsi
  $3.00
- 2L Sierra Mist
  $3.00
- 2L Mt Dew
  $3.00
- 2L Dr. Pepper
  $3.00