Search
New York Bagel Menu
4.3
(150+ Reviews)
Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.- Plain Cream Cheese$2.03+
- 1/2 Dozen$9.00
- Baker's DozenChoose 13 bagels$15.59
- Bagel with Cream Cheese$3.59
- Chive Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Lox SandwichPicture shown on an onion bagel with chive cream cheese, cucumbers, tomato, red onion, capers and lox.$7.79
- Natalie's Gourmet Orange JuiceNatalie's juice co. 16oz$5.99
- Vegetable Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Egg, Cheese & Breakfast Meat Sandwich$7.19
- Strawberry Cream Cheese$2.99+
Bagels
- One Bagel$1.50
- 1/2 Dozen$9.00
- Baker's DozenChoose 13 bagels$15.59
Cream Cheese & Spreads
- Plain Cream Cheese$2.03+
- Plain Lite Cream Cheese$2.03+
- Chive Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Vegetable Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Herb & Garlic Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Olive Hot Pepper Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Strawberry Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Salted Caramel Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese$2.99+
- Dairy-free Vegan Spread$2.99+
- Philadelphia 1oz$1.19
- Philadelphia 8oz$5.99
- Butter Side$0.30
- Butter Stick$1.55
- Butter 1lb$5.99
- Peanut Butter Individual$2.03
- Jelly Individual$0.95
Fish
- Ma Cohen's Nova Lox 4oz$10.19
- Ma Cohen's Herring in Cream Sauce$6.59
- Ma Cohen's Herring in Wine Sauce$6.59
- Acme Nova LoxThinly sliced Acme Nova Lox packaged to order.$10.20+
- Please Call to Order Sable, Whitefish or Kippered Salmon
Deli By The Pound
- Muenster Cheese$2.40+
- American Cheese$2.40+
- Swiss Cheese$2.70+
- Hot Pepper Cheese$2.40+
- Cheddar Cheese$2.70+
- Tuna Salad$4.50+
- Egg Salad$2.70+
- Chicken Salad$3.00+
- Smoked Whitefish Salad$9.00+
- Tomato Slices$0.60
- Onion Slices$0.60
- Cucumber Slices$0.60
Breakfast Sandwiches
- Bagel with Cream Cheese$3.59
- Bagel with Butter$2.99
- Lox SandwichPicture shown on an onion bagel with chive cream cheese, cucumbers, tomato, red onion, capers and lox.$7.79
- Peanut Butter$3.83
- One Slice of Cheese$2.99
- Egg & Cheese Sandwich$5.39
- Egg, Cheese & Breakfast Meat Sandwich$7.19
- Egg, Cheese & Deli Meat Sandwich$7.79
- Breakfast Meat on a Bagel$5.39
Deli Sandwiches
- Build-Your-Own Mini$5.99
- Build-Your-Own RegularIncludes a Double Portion of Meat, Dill Pickle Spear, and Your Choice of Cole Slaw or Potato Salad$8.39
- The ManhattanHot Corned Beef and Pastrami, Swiss, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing$9.59
- The BronxHot Corned Beef, Swiss, Russian Dressing$9.59
- The DetroiterHot Turkey and Ham, Muenster, Roasted Red Pepper, Honey Mustard$9.59
- Eastside VeggieCheddar, Muenster, Vegetable Cream Cheese, Honey Mustard, Lettuce, Tomato$9.59
- The Slow JoeHot Ham, Your Choice of Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Russian Dressing$9.59
- The GobblerTurkey, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayonnaise$9.59
- The YankeeHot Turkey, Your Choice of Cheese, Russian Dressing$9.59
- The ReubenHot Corned Beef, Swiss, Sauerkraut, Russian Dressing$9.59
- The RachelHot Turkey, Swiss, Sauerkraut, Russian Dressing$9.59
- Vegan SpecialVegan Cream Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Red Pepper, Cucumber, Onion$8.39
- Turkey ClubTurkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayonnaise$9.59
- BLTBacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayonnaise$9.59
- Salad SammieYour Choice of Tuna Salad, Egg Salad, Chicken Salad or Whitefish Salad (extra charge), Lettuce, Tomato$9.59
Miscellaneous
- Dogels$11.99
- Bagel Chips$5.39
- Teething Bagel$1.19
- Halvah$8.39
- Vanilla Yogurt Parfait$4.19
- Potato Chips$1.19
- Fresh Fruit Cup$4.79
- Dill Pickle Spear$0.30
- Everything Spice$7.19
- Eggs - Dozen$8.39
- Side Capers$1.19
- Cookie$3.59
Hot Drinks
- Small Coffee$2.75
- Large Coffee$3.11
- Hot Tea$2.75
- Hot Chocolate$3.11
- Coffee Box$22.80
Cold Drinks
- Juice$2.99
- Just Iced Tea$3.59
- Arizona$2.39
- Pop$2.03
- Ice Mountain Water$1.67
- Milk - Pint$2.99
- Cold Brew$4.79
- Natalie's Gourmet Orange JuiceNatalie's juice co. 16oz$5.99
- Natalie's Specialty Juice$7.19
- 1/2 Gal OJ$5.99
