Search
New York Bagel Menu
4.6
(1,275+ Reviews)
Include Plasticware, Knives, Etc.
- Include Plasticware, Napkins, Etc.
Bagels
- One Bagel$1.25
- ½ Dozen BagelsChoose 6 Bagels$7.50
- Baker's DozenChoose 13 Bagels$12.99
- 1.5 DozenChoose 18 Bagels$17.99
Cream Cheese
- 8oz Plain Whipped$4.49
- 8oz Plain Lite$4.49
- 8oz Lox$6.49
- 8oz Herb & Garlic$6.49
- 8oz Strawberry$6.49
- 8oz Vegetable$6.49
- 8oz Sundried Tomato$6.49
- 8oz Olive & Hot Pepper$6.49
- 8oz Chive$6.49
- 8oz Salted Caramel$6.49
- 8oz Philadelphia$4.99
- 8oz Tofutti$6.49
- 1 oz Philadelphia$0.99
- Individual Plain$1.69
- Individual Plain Lite$1.69
- Individual Lox$2.49
- Individual Herb & Garlic$2.49
- Individual Strawberry$2.49
- Individual Vegetable$2.49
- Individual Sundried Tomato$2.49
- Individual Olive & Hot Pepper$2.49
- Individual Chive$2.49
- Individual Salted Caramel$2.49
- Individual Vegan Spread$2.49
Spread It On Bagel
- Cream Cheese Sandwich$2.99
- Hummus Sandwich$2.99
- Peanut Butter Sandwich$3.19
- Butter Sandwich$2.49
- One Slice of Cheese$2.49
- Avocado Toast$4.99
Breakfast on a Bagel
- Egg Sandwich$3.99
- Lox SandwichChoose a topping if desired.$6.49
- Sausage Sandwich$4.49
- Bacon Sandwich$4.49
Deli Favorites
Served With Cole Slaw and a Dill Spear; Potato Salad Available- The ManhattanCorned Beef, Pastrami, Swiss, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing$7.99
- The BronxCorned Beef, Swiss, Russian Dressing$7.99
- The DetroiterHam, Turkey, Muenster, Roasted Red Pepper, Honey Mustard$7.99
- East Side VeggieCheddar, Muenster, Lettuce, Tomato, Vegetable Cream Cheese, Honey Mustard$6.99
- Howard’s Hot TunaTuna, Muenster, Cheddar Spread$7.99
- The Slow JoeHam, Your Choice of Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Russian Dressing$7.99
- The GobblerTurkey, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayonnaise$7.99
- The YankeeTurkey, Your Choice of Cheese, Russian Dressing$7.99
- The ReubenCorned Beef, Swiss, Sauerkraut, Russian Dressing$7.99
- The RachelTurkey, Swiss, Sauerkraut, Russian Dressing$7.99
- Vegan SpecialPlain Vegan Spread, Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Red Pepper, Cucumber, Onion Served With Two Pickle Spears$6.99
- Turkey ClubBacon, Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo$7.99
- BLTBacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo$7.99
- Salad SammieYour choice of tuna, chicken or egg salad, lettuce and tomato.$7.99
Build-Your-Own Sandwiches
- RegularIncludes a Double Portion of Meat and 2 Sides$6.99
- MiniIncludes a Single Portion of Meat$4.99
Melts
- Tuna Melt$7.99
- Turkey Melt$7.99
- Corned Beef Melt$7.99
- Pastrami Melt$7.99
- Ham Melt$7.99
Pizza Bagels
- Cheese Pizza BagelServed cold - heat up at home for now or save for later$2.99
- Pepperoni Pizza BagelServed cold - heat up at home for now or save for later$3.49
Fish
- Ma Cohen's Nova Lox4oz Package$8.49
- Ma Cohen's Herring in Cream Sauce8oz$7.99
- Ma Cohen's Herring in Wine Sauce8oz$5.49
- Nova Lox - Quarter Pound$8.49
Deli - By The Pound
- Onion Slices$0.50
- Tomato Slices$0.50
- Cucumber Slices$0.50
- Tuna SaladAvailable by the quarter pound and half pound.$3.75
- Egg SaladAvailable by the quarter pound and half pound.$2.25
- Chicken SaladAvailable by the quarter pound and half pound.$2.50
- Smoked Whitefish SaladAvailable by the quarter pound.$7.50
Miscellaneous
- Halvah$6.99
- Fruit Cup$3.99
- Cheese Cubes$10.99
- Vanilla Yogurt$3.49
- Butter Stick$1.29
- Butter Box$4.99
- Butter Side$0.25
- Chips$0.99
- Bagel Chips$4.49
- Teething Bagels$0.99
- Dogels$9.99
- Cookie$2.99
- Marshmallow Square$2.99
- Dill Pickle Spear$0.25
- Side Capers$0.99
- Dozen Eggs$5.99
- Everything Spice$5.99
Coffee & Hot Beverages
- Sm Coffee$2.29
- Lg Coffee$2.59
- Coffee Box96 ounces - equivalent of 8 small cups$19.00
- Hot Chocolate$2.29
- Hot Tea$2.29
Cold Drinks
- Natalie's Fresh Juices$5.99
- Natalie's Gourmet Orange JuiceNatalie's Juice Co. 16oz$4.99
- Juice - BottleSimply, Tropicana, Everfresh, Welch's - brand may vary$2.49
- Lemonade - Bottle$2.49
- Pop$1.69
- Naked Juice$4.99
- Ice Mountain$1.39
- La Croix$1.99
- Milk - Pint$2.49
- San Pellegrino$1.99
- Vitamin Water$1.99
- Kombucha$3.99
- Iced Tea$2.49
- 1/2 Gallon OJ$6.99
- Cold Brew Coffee$4.99
- Arizona Arnold Palmer$1.99
- V8$1.99
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
