New York Bagel Co Menu

4.2

(625+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Bulk Bagels & Cream Cheese Bagels with Toppings Bagel Breakfast Sandwiches Fresh Garden Salads Lunch Sandwiches & More Lunch Specials Chips & Sides Fresh Baked Goodies Coffee, Tea & More Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Bacon, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
  Bagel sandwich with bacon, egg, and cheese. Choose from various bagel flavors such as Plain, Spinach, Blueberry, Onion, and many more.
  $7.69
- Bagels (1/2 Dozen)
  Choice of six bagels from our large variety of bagels. This does not include cream cheese.
  $10.80
- Gourmet Muffins
  Cranberry and walnut, blueberry, banana nut, pistachio, morning glory, bran, chocolate chip.
  $3.99
- Iced Coffee
  Chilled coffee with choice of (Decaf, French Vanilla, Hazelnut, Regular), dairy (Cream, Whole, Skim), and flavors like Almond, Toasted Marshmallow, and more. Available in Small, Medium, Large. Sweetened swirls optional.
  $3.15
- Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
  Not toasted to toasted dark. Cream cheese: less, regular, or extra. Spread: on bagel or on the side.
  $4.85
- Half Pound of Cream Cheese
  A half pound is typically the perfect amount for a half dozen bagels
  $6.00
- Bagel With Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese
  Bagel topped with garlic & herb cream cheese. Choice of 20 flavors. Adjustable toasting levels. Cream cheese can be less, regular, or extra. Spread on bagel or on the side.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese
  Strawberry, blueberry, olive, garlic & herb, horseradish & scallion, sundried tomato.
  $7.10
- Iced Java
  Refreshing iced coffee. Choose from a variety of flavors like vanilla, hazelnut, or fruit. Available in small, medium, or large. Optional caramel, mocha, or white chocolate swirls.
  $4.85
- Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
  $6.69
- Bagel with Butter
  $3.49
- Coffee Milk
  $3.59
Bulk Bagels & Cream Cheese
Our bagels are freshly baked and are the best in town!
- Bagels (Dozen)
  Various bagel flavors in a dozen. This does not include cream cheese.
  $18.05
- Half Pound of Cream Cheese
  A half pound is typically the perfect amount for a half dozen bagels
  $6.00
- Bagel - as is, no spreads or toppings
  A variety of bagel flavors including Plain, Spinach, Egg, Cinnamon Raisin, Asiago Cheese, and more. No spreads or toppings.
  $2.05
- Bagels (1/2 Dozen)
  Choice of six bagels from our large variety of bagels. This does not include cream cheese.
  $10.80
- One Pound of Cream Cheese
  A pound is typically the perfect amount for a dozen bagels
  $11.50
Bagels with Toppings
**Please do not alter the cream cheese choice in the notes after choosing a bagel with a certain cream cheese variety. If you do not see the cream cheese you are looking for in this list, we cannot guarantee that it is available and you will receive the cream cheese as it is labeled here.** Thank you!
- Bagel With Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese
  Bagel topped with garlic & herb cream cheese. Choice of 20 flavors. Adjustable toasting levels. Cream cheese can be less, regular, or extra. Spread on bagel or on the side.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
  Not toasted to toasted dark. Cream cheese: less, regular, or extra. Spread: on bagel or on the side.
  $4.85
- Bagel with Strawberry Cream Cheese
  Strawberry, blueberry, olive, garlic & herb, horseradish & scallion, sundried tomato.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Blueberry Cream Cheese
  Strawberry, blueberry, olive, garlic & herb, horseradish & scallion, sundried tomato.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Cream Cheese & Lox Slices
  Bagel with cream cheese & lox slices. Choice of bagel flavors and toasting preferences.
  $19.75
- Bagel with Butter
  $3.49
- Bagel with Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese
  Sundried tomato cream cheese with choice of spread and bagel flavor. Optional toasting levels and spread placement.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese
  Bagel with lox cream cheese. Choose from spreads like Strawberry, Blueberry, or Scallion, and bagel flavors like Plain, Spinach, or Cinnamon Raisin. Toasting options and spread preference available.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
  Variety of bagel flavors with walnut raisin cream cheese. Choice of bagel temperature, cream cheese amount, and spread preference.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Peanut Butter
  Bagel with your choice of flavor - plain, savory, or sweet. Optionally toasted to your preference with peanut butter spread on or on the side.
  $3.49
- Bagel With 3 Pepper Diablo Cream Cheese
  $7.10
- Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese
  Variety of bagel flavors including savory, sweet, and hearty options. Vegetable spread with choices of no toast to dark, and light to extra spread amount. Spread on bagel or side.
  $7.10
- Bagel with Jelly
  Assorted bagel flavors like plain, spinach, cinnamon raisin, and poppy with jelly. Choose your preferred bagel temperature and spread preference.
  $3.49
Bagel Breakfast Sandwiches
Our bagels are freshly baked and are the best in town!
- Bacon, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
  Bagel sandwich with bacon, egg, and cheese. Choose from various bagel flavors such as Plain, Spinach, Blueberry, Onion, and many more.
  $7.69
- Chourico, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
  Chourico, egg, and cheese on your choice of bagel flavor, including options like plain, asiago cheese, cinnamon raisin, blueberry, and more.
  $8.29
- Ham, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
  Ham, egg, and cheese on choice of bagel flavors like Plain, Sesame, Blueberry, and more.
  $7.69
- Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
  $6.69
Fresh Garden Salads
Salads come with your choice of dressing: fat-free Italian, creamy Italian, Thousand island, fat-free ranch, Caesar or Greek.
- Garden Salad with Tuna Salad
  Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and onions topped with a generous scoop of tuna salad.
  $10.35
- Garden Salad with Chicken Salad
  Chicken salad served over a bed of mixed greens, typically includes tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and a hard-boiled egg.
  $10.35
- Garden Salad with Sliced Turkey
  Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and onions, typically includes sliced turkey breast.
  $10.35
- Greek Salad
  Fresh mixed greens, olives, feta, cucumber, and tomato in homemade dressing.
  $9.49
- Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken
  Grilled chicken breast served over a mix of lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, and carrots, typically includes a variety of mixed vegetables.
  $10.35
- Garden Salad
  Fresh mixed greens with seasonal vegetables
  $8.35
Lunch Sandwiches & More
All sandwiches are available on our fresh baked bagels, bread, rolls, or wraps and come with a slice of our half-sour kosher pickle. Lettuce, tomato, onions, hot peppers, chopped pickles, mayo, mustard (yellow, deli or honey) and ketchup are available at no additional charge.
- BLT (Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato)
  Crisp bacon, fresh lettuce, ripe tomato. Choice of bagels, rolls, wheat or white bread, or wraps.
  $8.49
- Chicken Salad
  Chicken Salad On your choice of bagels, rolls, wheat bread, white bread, or wraps.
  $15.85
- Pan Roasted Turkey
  Turkey with choice of bagels, rolls, wheat bread, white bread, or wraps.
  $12.49
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  Bagels, Rolls, Wheat or White Bread, Wraps.
  $10.85
- Egg Salad
  Creamy egg salad. Served on your choice of bagels, rolls, wheat bread, white bread, or wraps.
  $12.10
- Roast Beef
  Warm roast beef, choice of bagels, rolls, wheat or white bread, wraps.
  $13.35
- CLT (Cheese, Lettuce and Tomato)
  Cheese, lettuce, and tomato sandwich. Choose from bagels, rolls, wheat bread, white bread, or wraps.
  $6.25
- Smoked Virgina Ham
  Smoked Virginia ham with choice of Bagels, Rolls, Wheat Bread, White Bread, or Wraps.
  $8.99
- Tuna Salad
  Choice of bagels, rolls, wheat bread, white bread, or wraps.
  $14.35
- Hot Pastrami
  Pastrami on your choice of bagels, rolls, wheat or white bread, or wraps.
  $14.85
Lunch Specials
- Pizza Bagel Special
  2 Bagel Pizzas, Bottled Beverage and Chips
  $11.25
- Bagel Dog Special
  1 Bagel Dog, Bottled Beverage and Chips
  $11.25
Chips & Sides
- Bag of Chips
  Variety of Deep River chips including sea salt, salt & vinegar, mesquite BBQ, spicy dill pickle, zesty jalapeño, and sweet Maui onion.
  $3.19
- Whole Pickle
  A whole pickle, traditionally cured in a brine or vinegar solution, offering a tangy and crisp taste.
  $2.35
- Side Potato Salad
  Creamy potato salad, seasoned with fresh herbs
  $5.15
- Pickle Spear
  A single spear of pickle, typically served as a tangy and crisp accompaniment.
  $1.50
- Side Cole Slaw
  Crisp Cabbage Salad in Creamy Dressing
  $4.80
Fresh Baked Goodies
- Bagel Pizza
  Half a bagel topped with marinara sauce, melted cheese, and Italian seasonings, baked to a golden finish.
  $3.10
- Bagel Pizza with Pepperoni
  Half a plain bagel topped with pizza sauce, cheese, and slices of pepperoni, baked until golden.
  $3.75
- Gourmet Muffins
  Cranberry and walnut, blueberry, banana nut, pistachio, morning glory, bran, chocolate chip.
  $3.99
- Bagel Dog
  A savory hot dog wrapped in a freshly baked bagel, topped with poppy seeds.
  $4.99
Coffee, Tea & More
Coffee offered in regular, decaf, French vanilla, hazelnut, hazelnut decaf, San Francisco (our dark roast). Iced coffee offered in regular, decaf, French vanilla, and hazelnut.
- Iced Coffee
  Chilled coffee with choice of (Decaf, French Vanilla, Hazelnut, Regular), dairy (Cream, Whole, Skim), and flavors like Almond, Toasted Marshmallow, and more. Available in Small, Medium, Large. Sweetened swirls optional.
  $3.15
- Iced Java
  Refreshing iced coffee. Choose from a variety of flavors like vanilla, hazelnut, or fruit. Available in small, medium, or large. Optional caramel, mocha, or white chocolate swirls.
  $4.85
- Cold Brew
  Cold brew coffee. Choose size, dairy (no dairy, cream, whole or skim milk), flavors (vanilla, hazelnut, almond, etc.), and sweeteners (caramel, mocha, white chocolate).
  $4.60
- Hot Tea
  A selection of hot teas available in various sizes, with dairy and sweetener options. Choose from a variety of flavors such as vanilla, hazelnut, peach, and more.
  $2.80
- Hot Coffee
  Decaf, Hazelnut, Regular, and more. Dairy options: Cream, Skim, and others. Flavors: French Vanilla, Toasted Marshmallow, and more. Sizes: Small, Medium, Large. Sweetened swirls available.
  $2.80
- Iced Tea
  Refreshing iced tea with your choice of dairy—none, cream, whole, or skim milk. Available in small, medium, or large sizes.
  $2.95
Beverages
- Soda (20 oz. bottle)
  Coke, Diet Coke, caffeine free Diet Coke, Sprite, orange soda, ginger ale, dasani.
  $3.99
- Chocolate Milk
  Chocolate or strawberry.
  $3.59
- Snapple Lemon Tea
  Lemon iced tea, diet lemon iced tea, peach iced tea, diet peach iced tea, kiwi strawberry, mango madness, raspberry iced tea, diet raspberry ice tea, diet cranberry apple.
  $3.89
- Bottled Water
  Pure and refreshing bottled water.
  $2.39
- Orange Juice
  Classic citrus refreshment.
  $3.89
- Coffee Milk
  $3.59