Nervous Nellie's Menu

1131 First St, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
  • Apps 'n Shareables

    • NEW! Nellie's Mega-Loaded Nachos

      A heaping mountain of multi-colored corn tortilla chips with black beans, pico de gallo, queso, mixed cheeses, jalapenos, sour cream drizzle, and your choice of chicken, steak, or pulled pork
      $15.99
    • Buffalo Chicken Dip

      A creamy blend of blue and cream cheese, shredded chicken, and our spicy Buffalo sauce, baked to perfection and served with crispy corn chips
      $13.99
    • Coconut Onion Rings

      A large basket of coconut breaded rings and our famous tropical dipping sauce. Plenty to share
      $13.99
    • Nellie's Mega-Pretzel

      A delicious soft pretzel with Sea Salt. Served with Nellies spicy queso sauce
      $13.99
    • Nellie's Signature Shrimp Cocktail

      Six jumbo shrimp, served with our "South of the Border" cocktail sauce, lime, and tortilla chips
      $14.99
    • Tavern Bread

      A house favorite! A mix of bleu, cheddar, and jack cheeses, roasted garlic, fresh tomatoes. Served with zesty marinara sauce
      $13.99
    • Coconut Fried Shrimp

      Golden fried with our coconut breading. Served with a tropical dipping sauce
      $15.99
    • Fried Shrimp And Grouper Bites

      Lightly fried gulf shrimp and black grouper served with our creamy lobster sherry sauce
      $15.99
    • Shrimp And Scallop Bruschetta

      Jumbo Shrimp and sea scallops, sautéed with fresh basil, and tomato in white wine garlic butter. Served with garlic crostini
      $16.99
    • Florida Gator Bites

      Chunks of marinated gator tail fried golden brown drizzled with our spicy creamy boom boom sauce and topped with our sweet and tangy mango salsa
      $15.99
    • Homemade Mozzarella Planks

      Huge planks of gooey mozzarella breaded in house and lightly fried served with zesty marinara sauce for dipping
      $13.99
    • Drunken Wings

      A helping of luscious crispy fried wings - Tossed in our home brewed pepper sauce. Hot, mild, or garlic teriyaki
      $14.99
    • Crazy Calamari 'N Shrimp

      A blend of lightly breaded and fried calamari, shrimp, banana peppers, pickled jalapeños and red cherry peppers drizzled with a balsamic glaze and topped with pico de gallo
      $15.99
    • Devilish Mussels

      Fresh mussels simmered in our spicy marinara sauce. Served with freshly toasted garlic bread
      $14.99
    • Seafood Quesadilla

      Plump shrimp scallops and our fresh catch rolled in a tomato basil tortilla stuffed with melted Monterey jack cheese sautéed mushrooms, onions, spinach and poblano peppers
      $19.99
    • Citrus-Mango Ceviche

      shrimp, scallops and our fresh catch marinated in lime juice with fresh mangoes onions peppers and cilantro chilled and refreshing served with corn tortilla chips and garnish with avocados
      $15.99
    • Oven Roasted Crab And Artichoke Dip

      our twist on a classic combination of artichoke spinach and cream cheese with fresh lump crab meat served with crispy corn tortilla chips
      $14.99
  • Shucked 'n Chilled*

    • Nellie's Colossal Seafood Tower

      An assortment of snow and King Crab, steamed shrimp, oysters, Shrimp Cocktail, and Island Mango Ceviche
    • World's Largest Shrimp And Lobster Cocktail

      a full pound of chilled plump shrimp and a quarter pound of Maine lobster served with lemon wedges cocktail sauce, fresh horseradish and melted drawn butter
      $37.99
    • Oysters On The Half Shell

      Freshly shucked
    • Peel & Eat Chilled Shrimp

      Served up with cocktail sauce and lemon
      $13.99
  • Soups

    • New England Clam Chowder

      A generous crock of our tasty chowdahhh filled with tender clams, russet potatoes, and bacon. A family tradition
      $8.99
    • Bahamian Style Black Bean And Rice

      This traditional favorite topped with cilantro crema and pico de gallo
      $7.99
    • Soup And Salad To-Boot

      The best of both! A crisp field greens or tasty caesar salad along with our soup or chowder of the moment
      $15.99
  • Greens 'n Stuff

    • Nellie's Inspired Chef Salad

      A blend of crisp romaine and spring mix lettuce topped with bacon, turkey breast, roast beef, blue cheese crumbles, cheddar jack cheese, hard-boiled egg, cukes, cherry tomato, carrots, onions and croutons
      $17.99
    • Crazy Cobb Salad

      Tender all natural grilled chicken breast over spring mix and crisp romaine topped with cherry tomato cukes shredded carrots red onions with blue cheese crumbles cheddar jack cheese crispy bacon and a hard boiled egg
      $16.99
    • Latin Chimichurri Steak Salad

      Grilled skirt steak, served over micro greens, avocado slices, grape tomatoes, pickled red onions, black beans, and cilantro rich Chimichurri vinaigrette
      $17.99
    • Double Wide Wedge Salad

      A double wedge of chilled iceberg lettuce drizzled with a balsamic glaze then topped with cherry tomatoes cukes red onion and finished with blue cheese crumbles crispy bacon and croutons
      $15.99
    • Ultimate Lobster Salad

      Our award winning signature lobster salad on a bed of crisp romaine and spring mix greens with cherry tomatoes cukes onions and croutons. Taste of the Beach award winner
    • Jumbo Shrimp And Scallop Salad

      Bronzed jumbo shrimp and scallops served over a bed of spring mix greens and crisp romaine cherry tomatoes cukes onions and croutons best paired with our House citrus vinaigrette
      $20.99
    • Pineapple-Mango Chicken Salad

      Our all natural chicken salad served over spring mix greens crispy romaine topped with home made praline pecans red onion fresh mango salsa and finished with juicy chunks of pineapple
      $15.99
    • Strawberry Summer Salad

      Crisp romaine and spring mix greens topped with our homemade praline pecans craisins fresh vine ripened strawberries and fruit salad
      $14.99
  • Nellie's World Famous Sandwiches

    • New! The "Lobstah" Grilled Cheese

      A mix of succulent chuncks of lobster in a creamy herb sauce with melted white and yellow cheddar and Monterey Jack cheeses on Texas toast. Drizzled with our chipotle aioli
      $22.99
    • Nellie's Famous Grouper Sandwich

      Ocean fresh grouper cooked fried, bronzed or blackened on a bakery roll. Comes with crisp lettuce, tomato, red onion and homemade tartar sauce
      $22.99
    • Fresh Haddock Sandwich

      Have it your way! Fried, bronzed, or blackened on a bakery roll. Served with hand sliced tomato crisp lettuce, red onion and our homemade tartar sauce
      $16.99
    • Oh Mahi Mahi Sandwich

      Florida's fresh catch prepared just the way you like it! Nellie recommends Blackened, bronzed, or pan seared. Served with crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, red onion and tartar Sauce
      $17.99
    • Frenchy's Dip

      Sliced roast beef, piled high on a baked hoagie. Smothered with melted provolone cheese, and if that wasn't enough, our own Au Jus for dipping
      $16.99
    • Nellie's Philly Cheese Steak

      Baked hoagie overstuffed with shaved ribeye steak, sweet onions, mushrooms, and green bell peppers. Topped with Nellie's savory queso sauce
      $16.99
    • The Cuban

      Loaded with roasted pork, smoked ham, melted Swiss cheese, and of course pickle. Topped with our house mustard. Served with black beans & rice and golden French fries
      $16.99
    • Award Winning Lobster Roll

      A butter grilled split top bun, loaded with our award winning Lobster Salad. Served with lettuce and cucumber, golden French fries and a side of mixed fruit
    • Avocado BLT

      Crisp Applewood smoked bacon, fresh avocado, vine ripened tomatoes, crisp romaine lettuce, and mayo. Served on toasted bread
      $16.99
    • The "Big" Sandwich

      Dagwood's two fisted triple decker with roast beef, turkey breast, Applewood smoked bacon, American and Swiss cheeses, tomato, cukes, lettuce and mayo
      $16.99
    • Old Fashioned Chicken Salad Sandwich

      Homemade chicken salad seasoned to perfection topped with vine ripened tomato and lettuce on freshly toasted white bread
      $14.99
    • Beach Chicken Sandwich

      Lightly Fried chicken breast smothered in mozzarella cheese pico de gallo jalapeño peppers and Smokey bacon
      $16.99
    • Whiskey Chicken Sandwich

      Whiskey Glazed chicken breast flame seared to perfection topped with Smokey bacon grilled pineapple and Swiss cheese
      $16.99
    • Boom Boom Chicken Sandwich

      Beach fried chicken breast tossed in our Boom Boom sauce then piled high with provolone cheese and crispy bacon
      $16.99
    • Ugly's BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich

      Island style BBQ Pulled pork piled high on Texas toast served with Coleslaw on the side Plank Fries and fresh fruit
      $16.99
  • Tacos & More!

    • Crunchy Fried Fish Tacos

      Crunchy deep fried haddock topped with fresh cole slaw, pico de gallo and drizzled with creamy chipotle aioli served with our island black beans and rice.
      $16.99
    • Blackened Mahi Tacos

      Fresh Mahi lightly blackened and topped with fresh cole slaw, pico de gallo and drizzled with our creamy chipotle aioli served with island black beans and rice
      $16.99
    • Boom Boom Shrimp Tacos

      Lightly fried shrimp tossed in our spicy creamy buffalo sauce topped with fresh cole slaw, pico de gallo and served island black beans and rice
      $16.99
    • Grouper Tacos

      Lightly fried fresh grouper topped with crunchy fresh cole slaw, pico de gallo and drizzled with our creamy chipotle aioli served with island black beans and rice
      $19.99
    • Nellie's Grande Quesadilla

      Fajita Steak or all natural chicken. melted cheddar and jack cheeses, onions, peppers, & chipotle aioli, in a large tortilla. Island black beans & rice
      $18.99
  • Everybody Loves Reubens

    • Two-Fisted Reuben

      Slow roasted corn beef brisket smothered in sauerkraut tangy 1000 island dressing and melted Swiss cheese on home baked rye bread
      $16.99
    • Reuben's Sister Rache

      Sliced turkey breast piled high with creamy cole slaw, 1000 Is. dressing, and Swiss cheese on grilled rye
      $15.99
    • H'angry Haddock Reuben

      Crunchy fried haddock topped with savory Cole slaw melted provolone cheese smothered with 1000 island dressing on grilled rye bread
      $16.99
    • Fried Lobster Reuben

      Freddy's favorite! A tender crispy fried Maine Lobster meat topped with savory coleslaw melted Swiss cheese finished with 1000 island dressing. "Make it Happen"
    • Bronzed Grouper Reuben

      Gulf grouper topped with grilled pineapple Swiss cheese coleslaw 1000 island dressing on grilled rye bread
      $21.99
    • Ridiculous Reuben

      Slow roasted corned beef, seasoned pork, savory swiss, thousand island dressing and cole slaw - on grilled home baked rye
      $16.99
  • *Burgers With Attitude

    • NEW! Surf And Turf Burger

      Choice cut charbroiled burger smothered in fresh Maine Lobster and our creamy cheese sauce
      $23.99
    • The San Carlos Slammer

      The House Specialty. A generous half pound burger with American cheese, crispy smoked bacon, golden onion strings, tomatoes, and our Special, (If we gave you the recipe, we'd have to kill you) Sauce
      $16.99
    • Prime Steakhouse Burger

      Char-grilled half pound of ground beef, layered with sauteed mushrooms, provolone, crisp onion strings, and our special horseradish remolaude
      $16.99
    • Whiskey Creek BBQ Cheeseburger

      A big half pound burger with our hickory BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, smokey bacon, & golden onion strings
      $16.99
    • Ultimate Patty Melt

      A full half pound burger with grilled onions, American and Swiss cheese, 1000 Island Dressing, nestled between our famous home - baked grilled rye . Wow!
      $16.99
    • Dreamful Cheeseburger

      A full half pound, fresh ground beef. Your choice of American, Swiss or Provolone
      $16.49
  • Seafood.... and Lot's of It!

    • Sesame Crusted Tuna

      Fresh tuna, seared rare with sesame seeds, teriyaki glaze, oriental noodles and stir fry vegetables
      $27.99
    • Fried Grouper (Seasonally Available)

      A full half pound of Black Grouper, golden and fried to perfection. With Plank Fries and sautéed vegetable
      $31.99
    • Fried Grouper (Seasonally Available)

      Golden deep fried grouper, served with French Fries and sautéed vegetable and tartar sauce
      $29.99
    • Lobster Mac & Cheese

      Chunks of lobster served with our three cheese macaroni, baked golden with bread crumbs
      $29.99
    • Sailor's Delight

      Jumbo shrimp, gigantic sea scallops and our incredible Maine lobster sauce over pan seared Atlantic Haddock. Served with Calypso Rice and sautéed vegetables
      $27.99
    • Beachbake

      Baked haddock overstuffed with crab meat and crowned with jumbo shrimp, seasoned bread crumbs, roasted garlic butter and White Zinfandel - Baked to perfection!!! Served with Calypso Rice and sautéed vegetables
      $27.99
    • Island Style Coconut Shrimp

      Coconut milk dipped, coconut breaded shrimp, golden fried with mango salsa, golden French fries, Chef's vegetable, and tropical dipping sauce
      $26.99
    • Nellie's Famous Fried Shrimp

      Eight hand breaded jumbo shrimp, fried golden brown, served with Plank fries and sautéed vegetable, lemon and cocktail sauce
      $24.99
    • Baked Twin Lobster Tails

      Two sweet 6oz tails, baked to perfection. Served with fresh asparagus, mashed potatoes, and sautéed vegetables
    • Ginger-Teriyaki Glazed Atlantic Salmon

      Grilled Salmon with our own teriyaki glaze, stir-fry vegetables and oriental noodles
      $27.99
    • Captain's Feast

      Golden fried fresh catch, jumbo shrimp, clam strips, golden fried crab cake served with plank fries and cole slaw
      $31.99
    • Blue Crab Stuffed Shrimp

      1/2 pound of jumbo shrimp stuffed with blue crab and baked to perfection served with mashed potatoes and sautéed vegetables
      $28.99
    • Bimini Scallop Boat

      1/2 pound of fresh sea scallops broiled in Nellie's garlic scampi butter topped with golden bread crumbs served mashed potatoes and sautéed vegetables
      $34.99
    • Ultimate Crab Cakes

      made with lump blue crab meat then fried golden brown topped with remoulade sauce and served with mashed potatoes and sautéed vegetables
      $27.99
    • Stuffed Scallops

      Broiled sea scallops topped with our lump blue crab meat stuffing served with mashed potatoes and sautéed vegetables
      $35.99
    • Florida Broiled Platter

      Black grouper, jumbo shrimp and large sea scallops broiled in garlic butter and served with Calypso rice and sautéed vegetables
      $33.99
    • Alaskan King Crab

      1 ½ pounds of steamed King Crab. Served with mashed potatoes, steamed asparagus, drawn butter, lemon, cornbread and butter
  • Nellie's Fresh Catch

    • Black Grouper

      $29.00
    • Atlantic Salmon

      $25.00
    • Mahi Mahi

      $25.00
    • Swordfish

      $26.00
    • Yellowtail Snapper

      $26.00
    • Tuna

      $25.00
  • Signature Sauces

    • Lobster Sauce

      Butter, cream, sherry, lobster
      $10.00
    • Oscar Sauce

      Lump blue crab, asparagus, and lobster sauce.
      $12.00
    • Chimichurri Sauce

      South American cilantro, garlic, and parsley olive oil pesto.
      $4.00
    • Tropical Pineapple-Mango Salsa

      Fresh mango, onion, red pepper, and tropical spices.
      $4.00
  • USDA Choice Steaks!

    • USDA Choice 16oz Ribeye

      Our 16oz. Ribeye is marbled for great flavor, and perfectly seasoned. Served with crispy onion strings
      $43.99
    • Chargrilled New York Strip

      Our fire-grilled 14oz. strip loin is seasoned to perfection and broiled to your specifications. Served with crispy onion strings
      $39.99
    • Filet Mignon

      8oz of the most tender cut of Midwestern beef. Perfectly done, with all the extras and crispy onion straws
      $41.99
    • Mile High Baked Meat Loaf

      Home baked meat loaf piled high with mashed potatoes, rich brown gravy, sautéed vegetables, crispy onion strings, cornbread and butter
      $19.99
    • Traditional Surf And Turf

      An 8 oz. Filet Mignon paired with a 5oz. Lobster Tail and drawn butter. The best of Midwestern beef and Great Atlantic fisheries! Served with mashed potatoes and steamed asparagus
    • Famous Tavern Baby Back Ribs

      These ribs are so good, they're bad! Baked low and slow! Served with our famous hickory smoked sauce, Russet mashed potatoes and Chef's vegetable
      $18.99
  • Nellie's Famous Seafood Pots

    • Nellie's Ultimate Steam Pot

      A motherload of crab clusters, shrimp, mussels, and oysters served up shore style with steamed potatoes, carrots, andouille sausage, and corn on the cob
      $45.99
    • Island Steamed Crab Legs And Clusters

      a full pound and a half of Alaskan snow crab steamed with island spices served shore style with steamed potatoes, carrots, andouille sausage and corn on the cob
      $43.99
    • Old Bay Shrimp Boil

      A full pound of Old Bay steamed shrimp. Served with steamed russet potatoes, carrots, Andouille sausage, corn on the cob, lemon, melted butter, cocktail sauce, cornbread
      $29.99
  • Nellie's Island Bowls, Pasta, Etc.

    • Cajun Fried Fish Gumbo

      A tasty Cajun Gumbo made with "The Trinity", Andouille sausage, plump Gulf shrimp, with a fried filet of fresh catch, Served over fluffy rice
      $19.99
    • Famous Seafood Pasta

      A wonderful recipe featuring lobster, scallops, shrimp, and fresh catch, sautéed with fresh vegetables in a rich cream sauce. Enjoy this tantalizing treat!
      $26.99
    • Nervous Nellie's Incredible Island Jambalaya

      A ransom of gulf shrimp, jerk seasoned all natural chicken breast, and spicy Andouille sausage in a rich tomato sauce over steaming rice
      $19.99
    • Fettuccine Alfredo

      Imported Parmesan, dairy fresh cream, garlic, sun-dried tomatoes, and fresh parsley, served over fettuccine pasta.
      $19.99
    • Chicken Parmesan!

      Lightly fried tender all natural chicken breast – Topped with fresh mozzarella and savory tomato sauce
      $19.99
    • Tropical Chicken Pasta

      Tender chunks of chicken, asparagus, mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes, in a Parmesan cream sauce and Cavatappi pasta
      $19.99
    • Golden Macaroni And Cheese

      We add crisp smoked Applewood bacon and grilled all natural chicken - Fresh parsley look-out!
      $16.99
    • Sizzling Steak And Chicken Fajitas

      Fire charred skirt steak or chicken breast, served over sauted onions and peppers, with black beans and rice, Pico de gallo, sour cream, guacamole, and flour tortillas.
      $22.99
    • Chipotle Shrimp And Pineapple Fajitas

      Jumbo shrimp and chunks of pineapple sautéed in chipotle butter over onions and green peppers. Served with sour cream, pico, cheddar cheese, and flour tortillas
      $28.99
    • Jumbo Shrimp And Scallop Stir-Fry

      Pan sizzled jumbo shrimp and scallops, with teriyaki glazed oriental vegetables over Calypso rice
      $26.99
    • Thai Chicken Stir-Fry

      Soy, coconut milk, garlic–chili, tender all natural chicken and stir-fry vegetables are the stars of this show – Fluffy rice – Yeah
      $21.99
  • Please!!! Be A 'Basket Case'!!!

    • Fried Jumbo Shrimp

      We pick 'um big - Lightly battered and tastefully fried - Sit back and enjoy
      $20.99
    • Ale Battered Grouper

      A heap'in help'in of Nellie's original recipe...Wow! This is the real deal.
      $26.99
    • Oh! Chicken Fingers

      "No bones about it" !! Tender and tasty! Plain, Hot saucey, Boom Boom or Teriyaki garlic
      $16.99
    • Fried Clam Strips

      Hand dipped in our special recipe! A loaded basket with cocktail & Tartar for the Dipper
      $18.99
    • Ale Battered Jumbo Shrimp And Fish

      This Ole time favorite, lightly fried in a special recipe!! Ole malt vinegar to boot!.
      $21.99
    • Olde Fashioned Ale Battered Fish And Chips

      This tavern favorite will carry on the tradition - We call it heaven right here!
      $19.99
    • Crispy Jumbo Scallops

      Did you hear about these yet? Oh boy!! Always brag'in! Large and succulent - "A House Specialty"
      $27.99
    • Golden Fried Shrimp And Scallops

      Our most popular "daily double" Golden brown and delish!
      $28.99
  • Premium Sides

    • Steamed Asparagus

      $7.00
    • Baked Macaroni & Cheese

      $7.00
    • Black Beans & Rice

      $6.00
    • Garlic Mashed Potatoes

      $6.00
    • Basket Of Cornbread And Orange Butter

      $6.00
    • Coconut Onion Rings (5)

      $7.00
    • Signature House Salad

      $6.00
    • Signature Caesar Salad

      $6.00
    • 6 Oz Baked Lobster Tail

    • 8 Oz Alaskan Snow Crab

    • 4 Oz Crab Cake

      $8.00
  • Nervous Nellie's Signature Desserts

    • Pinå Colada Bread Pudding

      Made with a rich coconut, pineapple custard, drizzled with rum sauce and served with vanilla ice cream
      $8.99
    • Barrier Island Key Lime Pie

      Our take on a Florida tradition. A sweet tart dessert our guests travel thousands of miles to enjoy!
      $8.99
    • Nellie's Colossal Chocolate Cake

      Our mile high chocolate cake is layers of rich cake, topped with a creamy semi-sweet chocolate frosting
      $8.99
    • Frozen Fruit Smoothie

      $6.99
  • Apps 'N Good Old Stuff

    • Nellie's Incredible Chowder Fries

      Our crispy plank fries covered in our creamy Clam Chowder, covered with smoky bacon bits
      $12.99
    • Nellie's Mega-Loaded Nachos

      A heaping tray of our multi-color nachos with black beans, pico de gallo, queso, mixed cheeses, jalapenos, and sour cream with your choice of chicken, steak or pulled pork
      $14.99
    • Nellie's Signature Shrimp Cocktail

      Six plump, chilled pearls of the deep. Served with our cocktail sauce and lemon
      $12.99
    • Homemade Mozzarella Planks

      Lightly fried - Amazing! Zesty marinara for the dipper
      $9.99
    • Coconut Fried Shrimp

      Our lightly fried "famous recipe" . Sweet Thai sauce for the dipper
      $13.99
    • Oven Roasted Crab And Artichoke Dip

      This classic combination of artichokes, spinach, and cream cheese with a seafood twist. Crispy tortilla chips
      $12.99
    • Fried Shrimp And Grouper Bites

      Spiced and seared. Served with our fabulous lobster sherry sauce
      $14.99
  • Soups 'n' Greens 'n' Stuff

    • New England Clam Chowder

      A generous crock of our tasty brew filled with tender clams, russet potatoes, and bacon. A family tradition
      $7.99
    • Steam'in Onion Soup Au Gratin

      This Ole time favorite crowned with savory garlic toast and melted cheese! Oh yeah
      $6.99
    • Nellies Special Holiday Dinner Salad

      Crisp field greens tossed with sun-dried cranberries and sweet praline pecans. Dressing of your choice
      $4.99
    • Holiday Chef Salad

      A holiday masterpiece - Sliced turkey breast over baby greens, diced sweet potato, craisins, bacon, praline pecans, bacon, boiled egg, and tomato
      $16.99
    • World's Ultimate Lobster Roll

      This is the real deal!! The largest you have ever seen - home-baked hoagie roll overloaded with the tastiest, most succulent lobster you can imagine - Sided with plank fries and fresh seasonal fruit
      $23.99
  • Some Wild 'N Crazy Sandwiches

    • Grab Your Grouper Sandwich

      "Claimed to be the World's largest." On a home-baked roll - Your way...Fried, bronzed or skillet seared
      $18.99
    • Mahi Mahi Soft Tacos

      Topped with tropical salsa! Sided with island black beans and rice
      $15.99
    • Fried Fish Tacos

      Crunchy, deep fried haddock, topped with crunchy cabbage, pico de gallo, and chipolte aioli. Served with Island black beans and rice
      $15.99
    • Two-Fisted Corned Beef Reuben

      Slow roasted corned beef smothered with tangy sauerkraut, dressing and melted Swiss - Sail on!
      $13.99
    • The "Clobstah" Grilled Cheese

      A melted mixture of lobster and crab in a creamy herb sauce and three melted cheeses on Texas Toast
      $18.99
    • Dreamful Cheeseburger

      A full half pound, fresh ground beef. Your choice of American, Swiss, Provolone, or Pepper Jack
      $13.49
    • The "Finest Kind" Cheese Steak

      Home-baked hoagie over-stuffed with sliced ribeye, sweet onion, mushrooms and bell peppers. Topped with savory melted cheese! Wow
      $13.99
    • Fire-Seared Whiskey Chicken Sandwich

      Oh yeah! Basted, then open flame-seared to perfection, this plump chicken breast, Applewood smoked bacon, grilled pineapple and cheese will bring you back for more - Enjoy
      $12.99
  • Traditional Holiday Dinner

    • Roast Tom Turkey

      Young turkey, with traditional dressing, mashed potatoes, pan gravy, green bean casserole, pecan sweet potatoes, cranberries, Pumpkin Praline Pie
      $22.99
    • Holiday Glazed Ham

      Apple smoked gourmet ham, raisin sauce, traditional dressing, mashed potatoes, pan gravy, pecan sweet potatoes, cranberries, Pumpkin Praline Pie
      $25.99
    • Roast Turkey & Ham Feast

      Roast Turkey with dressing, Applewood smoked ham, mashed potatoes, green bean casserole, pecan sweet potatoes, cranberries, and Pumkin Praline Pie
      $28.99
  • From the Sea

    • Baked Twin Lobster Tails

      Two sweet 5oz tails, baked to perfection. Served with fresh asparagus, drawn butter, lemon, and a Chef side of your choice
      $35.99
    • Our Famous Seafood Pasta

      Our wonderful recipe sporting fresh lobster, scallops, succulent shrimp, fresh catch and more is the talk of many a review!! Blessed in a marvelous lobster cream sauce. Enjoy this tantalizing treat
      $22.99
    • Island Crab Pot

      Tasty Alaskan King & Alaskan Snow Crab steamed, with Island spices. Served shore-style with steamed russet potatoes, carrots, Andouille sausage and corn on the cob, home baked cornbread
      $37.99
    • Olde Fashioned Ale Battered Fish And Chips

      This tavern favorite will carry on the tradition - We call it heaven right here!
      $15.99
    • Beachbake

      Baked haddock overstuffed with crab meat and crowned with jumbo shrimp, seasoned bread crumbs, roasted garlic butter and White Zinfandel - Baked to perfection!!! Plus two sides of your choice
      $22.99
    • Our Sailor's Delight

      Jumbo shrimp, gigantic sea scallops and our incredible Maine lobster sauce over pan seared Atlantic Haddock. Dance on Sailor! Plus two sides of your choice
      $22.99
    • Florida Broiled Seafood Platter

      Enjoy! Red grouper, Jumbo shrimp and large sea scallops have the star role! Supporting cast of seasonal vegetable and smashed red potato!
      $27.99
    • Captain's Feast

      Lightly fried, You provide the style!!! Then we'll provide this tasty combo of fresh catch, large shrimp, large scallops and fried clams - Served up with plank fries and coleslaw. Better be hungry!
      $26.99
    • Alaskan King Crab

      1 ½ pounds of steamed King Crab. Served with Smashed Potatoes, steamed asparagus, drawn butter, lemon, cornbread and butter
  • From Fields and Farms

    • Chargrilled Choice 16oz Ribeye

      Our 16oz. Ribeye, marbled for great flavor, and perfectly seasoned. Served with Smashed Potatoes, Chef's Vegetable, crispy onion straws
      $31.99
    • Chargrilled New York Strip

      Our fire grilled 12oz.strip loin, seasoned to perfection, broiled to your specifications
      $27.99
    • Our 8oz Filet Mignon

      The most tender cut of Midwestern corn fed beef. Perfectly done, melt in your mouth tender
      $29.99
    • Famous Tavern Baby Back Ribs

      These ribs are so good, they're bad! Baked low and slow! Served with our famous hickory smoked sauce, Home baked beans, and our famous Plank French Fries. Try Nellie's Slab for twice the fun!
      $17.99
    • Our Traditional Surf And Turf

      An 8oz Filet Mignon paired with a 5oz Lobster Tail and drawn butter. The best of Midwestern beef and Great Atlantic fisheries! Served with Smashed Potatoes and Chef's Vegetable
      $39.99
  • Main

    • Cheeseburger

      Char-grilled 1/4 lb fresh ground beef with melted American cheese. Served with fries
    • Chicken Fingers

      Hand-cut chicken breast, prepared with our special recipe. Then lightly fried to a golden brown. Served with fries
    • Creamy Mac And Cheese

      Mama's favorite recipe! Our famous Hot Dog - On a home baked bun. With golden fries
    • Roni's & Butter

      Rigatoni pasta with tasty butter – Oh! Lightly Fried Chicken
    • Sandwich

      A great experience!! Grilled Cheese Sandwich- Old reliable grilled on artisan bread with American cheese
  • Appetizers

    • Nellie's Signature Shrimp Cocktail

      Six jumbo shrimp served with our "South of the Border" cocktail sauce, lime, and corn tortilla chips
      $12.99
    • Shrimp & Scallop Bruschetta

      Jumbo shrimp and sea scallops, fresh basil, garlic and ripe tomato in our tasty recipe! Corn tortilla chips on the side
      $13.99
    • Citrus Mango Ceviche

      Shrimp, scallops, and fresh catch marinated in lime juice with red onions, peppers, olives and cilantro. Served with corn tortilla chips
      $12.99
    • Devilish Mussels

      Fresh mussels simmered in our spicy marinara sauce
      $12.99
    • Naked Drunken Wings

      Choice of sauce Hot, mild, or garlic teriyaki
      $10.99
    • World's Largest Shrimp & Lobster Cocktail

      Most folks share this one! A full pound of lightly steamed and chilled plump shrimp and a quarter pound of Maine lobster meat; lemon wedges, cocktail sauce and melted butter accompany
      $28.99
    • Crabmeat Stuffed Artichoke Dip

      This classic combination of artichokes, spinach, and cream cheese with a seafood twist, served with crispy corn tortilla chips
      $12.99
    • Oysters On The Half Shell

      $9.99
    • Peel & Eat Shrimp

      $13.99
  • Salads

    • Ultimate Chilled Lobster Salad

      Our signature lobster salad set on a bed of baby greens, with grape tomatoes, and cucumbers
      $19.99
    • Nellie's Inspired Chef Salad

      Imagine crisp lettuce, smokehouse bacon, turkey breast, and roast beef with select cheeses, hard boiled eggs, cucumbers, and bleu cheese crumbles
      $14.99
    • Latin Chimichurri Steak Salad

      Grilled fajita steak and cilantro rich chimichurri sauce, served over baby greens, grape tomatoes, sweet pickled red onions, black beans, and queso fresco
      $14.99
  • Entrees

    • Baked Twin Lobster Tails

      Two sweet 6oz tails, baked to perfection, served with fresh asparagus, smashed red potatoes, and sautéed vegetables
    • Florida Broiled Seafood Platter

      Enjoy! Black grouper, jumbo shrimp, and large sea scallops have the star role! Supporting cast of seasonal vegetable and Calypso rice
      $27.99
    • Chargrilled 16 Oz. Steak

      Our 16oz. marbled Ribeye, perfectly seasoned, served with smashed potatoes, chef's vegetable & rich Au Jus
      $31.99
    • Chargrilled New York Strip

      Our fire grilled 12oz strip loin seasoned to perfection, broiled to your specifications. Served with smashed potatoes, chef's vegetable & rich Au Jus
      $27.99
    • Island Steamed Crab Legs & Clusters

      Tasty Alaskan King & Alaskan Snow Crab legs steamed with island spices. Served shore-style with steamed russet potatoes, carrots, and corn on the cob
      $37.99
    • Nellie's Fresh Catch

      Grilled with olive oil, blackened, or bronzed, served with Calypso rice & sautéed vegetables
      $22.00
    • Nellie's Tropical Burrito Bowls

      Sautéed chicken, steak, or carnitas with corn, Pico de Gallo, queso, mixed cheeses, sour cream & chipotle aioli
      $16.99
    • Sizzling Steak & Chicken Fajitas

      Tender marinated flank steak and plump chicken breast create this memorable dish with seared bell peppers, sweet onions and corn tortillas
      $18.99
    • Chipotle Shrimp Pineapple Fajitas

      Everything you could imagine! Jumbo Shrimp chunks of pineapple, onions and peppers. & corn tortillas. Teriyaki glazed stir fry vegetables
      $21.99
    • Alaskan King Crab

      1½ pound of steamed King Crab served with smashed potatoes, steamed asparagus drawn butter, & lemon
  • Nervous Nellies Signature Desserts

    • Pina Colada Bread Pudding

      Our famous bread pudding. Made with our home baked bread, a rich custard with cream of coconut and fresh pineapple. Drizzled with a rich rum sauce. Served with vanilla bean ice cream
      $8.99
    • Barrier Island Key Lime Pie

      A Florida tradition. A sweet and tart dessert, our guests travel thousands of miles from the around the World just to enjoy!
      $8.99
    • Nellie's Colossal Chocolate Cake

      Baked in house our mile high chocolate cake is layersof unbelievably rich cake topped with a creamy semi-sweet chocolate frosting
      $8.99
    • Brownie Sunday

      A warm Triple fudge brownie topped with vanilla bean ice cream, rich chocolate sauce candied pecans and whipped cream
      $8.99
    • Seasonal Cheesecake

      Check with your server for current selection
      $8.99
    • Frozen Smoothies

      Strawberry, Banana, Raspberry, Peach, Pina Colada, Mango, Strawberry-Banana, and Mighty Chocolate
      $6.99
  • Sparkling & Blush

    • Cupcake, Prosecco, Italy

      $9.49
    • Osyster Bay Rose

      $8.49
    • Mimosa

      $8.99
  • Red Wine

    • Rodney Strong, Merlot, Sonoma, CA

      $9.49
    • Rodney Strong, Cabernet, Sonoma, CA

      $11.49
    • Alamos, Malbec, Mendoza Argentina

      $7.49
    • Robert Mondavi, Cabernet, California

      $8.49
    • Meiomi, Pinot Noir, California

      $9.49
  • White Wine

    • Mezzacorona, Pinot Grigio, Trentino, Italy

      $9.49
    • Seven Daughters, Moscato, Italy

      $8.49
    • Oyster Bay, Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough, New Zealand

      $8.49
    • Oyster Bay, Rose, Marlborough, New Zealand

      $8.49
    • Kim Crawford, Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough, New Zealand

      $10.49
    • Chateau St Michele, Riesling, Columbia Valley, WA

      $7.49
    • Josh, Chardonnay, Mendocino, CA

      $8.49
    • Kendall Jackson, Chardonnay, Santa Rosa, CA

      $10.49
  • Ugly's "Photo Op" Drinks

    • Shark Attack

      Take a dive into the water with this dangerously good cocktail! Featuring Tito's Vodka, blue curaco, lemonade and sprite and a little blood in the water. Don't forget about our finned friends lurking in your bowl. Enjoy! 60oz Jumbo Glass To Share? Only one 60oz drink per table
      $10.99
    • Cadillac Margarita

      A perfect blend of Corazón Silver Tequila, Naranja Orange Liquor and our margarita mix served on the rocks with a salted rim 60oz Jumbo Glass To Share? Only one 60oz drink per table
      $11.99
  • Beach Frozen Classics

    • Jamaican Me Crazy Pina Colada

      An Island Favorite! A blend of Jamaican rums, rich cream of coconut, and pineapple juice. Chilled and blended, smooth and delicious
    • Barrier Island Rum Runner

      Light and dark rum, banana and blackberry liquor blended to frozen perfection
    • The Miami Vice

      The best of two Island favorites! 50% Pina Colada, and 50% Fresh Strawberry Daiquiri. 100% delicious!
    • Acapulco Frozen Margarita

      Made with 100% Agave Siler Tequila, Triple Sec, our very own margarita mix served frozen!
    • Abaco Island Strawberry Daquiri

      A sweet frozen cocktail of blended light rums and fresh strawberry puree
  • Island Margaritas

    • Coco Loco Margarita

      A blend Lunazul, fresh Cream of Coconut, splash of Naranja Orange Liqueur and our margarita mix, served on the rocks with a toasted coconut rim
      $10.99
    • Perfect Patrón Margarita

      A delicious blend of Patrón Silver Tequilla Naranja Orange Liqueur our very own margarita mix made with real key limes topped with a floater of Gran Galla
      $12.99
    • Lunazul Infused Tequila Margarita

      Lunazul 100% Blue Agave Tequila Infused with Fresh Pineapple, Strawberries, and Oranges. Blended with out own Sweet and Sour Mix this is one Fresh Margarita!
      $10.49
    • Cadillac Margarita

      A perfect blend of Corazón Silver Tequila, Naranja Orange Liquor and our margarita mix served on the rocks with a salted rim
      $11.99
  • Mojitos

    • Classic Mojito

      Bacardi Silver Rum, fresh muddled limes and mint. Shaken to perfection, enjoy with a fresh sugar cane
      $10.99
    • Wild Berry Mojito

      Bacardi Dragon Berry rum muddled with fresh lime mint and simple syrup
      $10.99
  • Marvelous Martinis

    • Nellies Cosmo

      360 Citrus Vodka and Gran Galla, Splash of Cranberry, Fresh Squeezed Lime Juice
      $9.49
    • Lemon Drop Martini

      360 Citrus Vodka , Naranja Orange Liquor a sweet and sour martini served with a sugar rim
      $9.99
    • Key Lime Martini

      The perfect after dinner cocktail 360 Vanilla Vodka, splash of cream of coco, pineapple and fresh squeezed lime juice served straight up with a graham cracker rimmed glass
      $9.99
  • Signature Cocktails

    • Pain Killer

      Pussers Rum, Fresh Cream of Coconut, pineapple juice, orange juice with a toasted coconut rim and garnished with a sprinkle of nutmeg
      $12.49
    • Spiked Blueberry Lemonade

      A blend of 360 Blueberry Vodka refreshing lemonade with a splash of sprite and topped with fresh blueberries
      $10.49
    • Top Shelf Estero Ice Tea

      Tito's Vodka, Tanqueray Gin, Bacardi Rum, Cuervo to Lunazul Tequila, sweet & sour and a splash of Coke
      $10.99
    • Nellies Bloody Mary

      Titos Vodka & Nellies homemade potion, garnished our special way
      $9.49
    • Tipsy Mermaid

      A blend of Bacardi Silver rum, Bacardi Limon rum, Midori Melon Liquor, Blue Curaçao, pineapple juice and sprite served in a 32 oz Bacardi Beach bucket
      $14.99
    • Top Shelf Mai Tai

      Captain, Rum Haven Coconut Rum, blended with OJ and Pineapple Juices with a splash of Grenadine
      $10.49
  • Happy Hour And Daily Drink Special

    • Monday – Miami Vice

    • Tuesday – Nervous Nellie Rum Punch

    • Wednesday – Mojito

    • Thursday – Pina Colada

    • Friday – Mai Tai

    • Saturday – Shark Attack

    • Sunday – Bloody Mary

  • Happy Hour

    • Beach Frozen Classics

      $8.00
  • Premium Cocktails

    • Titos

    • Bacardi

    • Lunazul

    • Jim Beam

    • JW Red

    • Tanqueray

  • House Wines

    • Cab

    • Merlot

    • Pinot Grigio

    • Chardonnay

    • White Zin

  • Import / Craft Local Beers

    • Doxx Especial Lager

    • Corona

    • Corona Premier

    • Heineken

    • Heinekin 0.0

    • Red Stripe

    • Stella

    • Cigar City Jai Lai IPA

    • Fort Myers High Five IPA

    • Big Storm Bromossa Tangerine IPA

  • Domestic

    • Blue Moon

    • Coors Light

    • Miller Light

    • Budweisser

    • Bud Light

    • Yuengling

    • Landshark

    • White Claw

      Mango, Black Cherry, Ruby Grapefruit

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Ugly's Waterside Bar
Ugly's Waterside Bar
4.4
(35 Reviews)
Bar, Bar & grill
Wahoo Willie's
Wahoo Willie's
4.7
(415 Reviews)
Bar & grill, Bar
Matanzas on the Bay
Matanzas on the Bay
4.5
(1,651 Reviews)
Seafood
Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant
Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant
4.6
(803 Reviews)
Seafood
Petey's Upper Deck Bar
Petey's Upper Deck Bar
4.5
(177 Reviews)
Bar, Bar & grill
Smokin Oyster Brewery
Smokin Oyster Brewery
4.5
(2,297 Reviews)
Seafood, Bar
The Yucatan Beach Stand
The Yucatan Beach Stand
4.4
(3,993 Reviews)
Restaurant, Bar, Lunch
Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe
Bonita Bills Waterfront Cafe
4.3
(2,418 Reviews)
Seafood, Bar, Cafe
Lighthouse Tiki Bar & Grill
Lighthouse Tiki Bar & Grill
4.5
(1,128 Reviews)
Bar & grill, Bar, Restaurant
Dixie Fish Company
Dixie Fish Company
4.6
(3,302 Reviews)
Seafood

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms