Montalbano's Menu

4.6

(200+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Beverages Today's Lunch Specials Hot Soups Lunch Menu - Hot Sandwiches Lunch Menu - Cold Sandwiches Lunch Menu - Specialty Sandwiches Lunch Menu - Fresh Salads Lunch Menu - Soups

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- 14. The Gladiator
  Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, portobello mushrooms, & creamy Caesar dressing.
  $13.00
- 3. The 122 Special
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, broccoli rabe, & balsamic vinegar.
  $13.00
- Rib Eye Cheese Steak
  Rib eye steak with melted cheese; choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- A Picnic in Rome
  Artichoke hearts, roasted peppers, pesto marinated in grilled chicken served with Italian dressing.
  $12.95
- Pastrami and Cheese
  Pastrami, cheese. Choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Sausage and Peppers
  Sausage and peppers sandwich served on your choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- 19. The Godfather
  Prosciuttini, salami, mortadella, capicolla, soppressata, provolone, & roasted peppers.
  $13.00
- 16. Pollo Alla Vincenzo
  Fried chicken cutlet, prosciutto, asiago cheese, & olive oil.
  $13.00
- Turkey and Cheese
  Turkey slices and cheese in your choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $11.00
- Ham and Cheese
  Ham and cheese combined in your choice of hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $11.00
Beverages
- 20 oz. Soda
  Please specify coke, diet coke, sprite, diet sprite, seltzer, ginger ale, or fanta
  $3.49
- 12 oz. can of soda
  Please specify coke, diet coke, sprite, diet sprite, ginger ale, seltzer, or fanta
  $2.00
- 16.9 oz Poland Spring Water
  Sourced from natural springs in Maine, Poland Spring 16.9 oz water offers pure and refreshing hydration in a convenient bottle.
  $2.00
- 16 oz. Snapple
  Please specify lemon, diet lemon, peach, diet peach
  $4.00
- 12 oz. Manhattan Special
  Please specify regular or diet
  $4.00
- 16 oz. Hanks
  Please specify root beer, orange cream, vanilla cream, or black cherry
  $4.00
Today's Lunch Specials
Lunch specials come with a 12 oz. can of soda or bottle of water.
- #1. STUFFED SHELLS SERVED WITH CHICKEN PARMIGIANA
  Manicotti with chicken parmigiana. Choice of rice ball or potato croquet. Drink choices include various sodas or water.
  $12.95
- #2. CAVATELLI WITH HOT SAUSAGE MEAT & BROCCOLI RABE
  Marinated London broil over mesclun salad. Choice of soda or water. Side options: rice ball or potato croquet.
  $12.95
- #3. PASTA SALAD SERVED WITH GRILLED CHICKEN
  Chicken pasta salad. Choose drink: soda (cola, diet cola, lemon-lime) or water. Choice of side: rice ball or potato croquet.
  $12.95
- #4. THE LUNCH BOX SPECIAL: TURKEY AND MUNSTER CHEESE ON A ROLL WITH LETTUCE AND TOMATOES SERVED WITH A BAG OF CHIPS
  Turkey and Munster cheese on a roll with lettuce and tomatoes, served with chips. Choose a soda or water and a side: rice ball or potato croquet.
  $12.95
- #5. THE MONTALBANO’S SPECIAL SALAD OF THE DAY: THE I.S. 49 SPECIAL: THE BLAZING BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD LARGE TOSSED SALAD TOPPED WITH FRIED CHICKEN CUTLET IN SPICY BUFFALO WING SAUCE, SHREDDED CHEDDER CHEESE, & BLEU CHEESE CRUMBLES SERVED WITH BLEU CHEESE DRESSING
  Large tossed salad with fried chicken cutlet in spicy buffalo wing sauce, shredded cheddar cheese, and bleu cheese crumbles. Choice of soda or water, and rice ball or potato croquet.
  $12.95
- #6. THE MONTALBANO’S SPECIAL WRAP OF THE DAY: THE STATEN ISLANDER: FRIED CHICKEN CUTLET, SWISS CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, BACON, & HONEY MUSTARD DRESSING
  Boar's Head chicken breast, provolone, baby greens, sundried tomatoes, pesto. Drink: Soda or water. Side: Rice ball or potato croquet.
  $12.95
- #7. THE MONTALBANO’S SPECIAL PANINI OF THE DAY: THE MEDITERRANEO ON A CIABATTA BREAD: GRILLED CHICKEN, FRESH MOZZARELLA, GRILLED EGGPLANT, SAUTEED ONIONS & PEPPERS, LEAF LETTUCE, TOMATOES, & PESTO MAYO
  Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, grilled eggplant, sautéed onions & peppers, leaf lettuce, tomatoes, pesto mayo on ciabatta. Side: choice of rice ball or potato croquet. Drink: soda or water.
  $12.95
Hot Soups
- Hot Soups
  Hot and sour soup. Choose from Pasta & Bean, Lentil, Escarole & Bean, Chicken, or Minestrone. Available in Small or Large sizes.
  $5.99
Lunch Menu - Hot Sandwiches
We use the highest quality Boar's head cold cuts, imported meats, cheeses, produce, & spreads.
- Chicken Parmigiana
  Tender chicken with parmesan, available as Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Veal Parmigiana
  Tender veal parmigiana served on your choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $13.00
- Meatball Parmigiana
  Meatballs with marinara sauce and melted parmigiana cheese. Choice of hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $12.00
- Eggplant Parmigiana
  Eggplant parmesan served as a Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Rib Eye Cheese Steak
  Rib eye steak with melted cheese; choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Potato and Egg
  Potato and egg with a choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $10.00
- Pepper and Egg
  Egg sandwich with peppers. Choose from hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $10.00
- Sausage and Peppers
  Sausage and peppers sandwich served on your choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Sausage, Peppers and Potatoes
  Sausage with peppers and potatoes sandwich. Choose from hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $13.00
- Grilled Chicken
  Warm grilled chicken sandwich. Choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
Lunch Menu - Cold Sandwiches
No charge for lettuce, tomatoes or onions. We use the highest quality Boar's head cold cuts, imported meats, cheeses, produce, & spreads.
- Ham and Cheese
  Ham and cheese combined in your choice of hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $11.00
- Salami and Cheese
  Salami with cheese on choice of hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $11.00
- Turkey and Cheese
  Turkey slices and cheese in your choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $11.00
- Soppressata and Cheese
  Soppressata and cheese with your choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Italian Capicolla and Cheese
  Capicolla and cheese on your choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Mortadella and Cheese
  $11.00
- Prosciutto and Cheese
  Prosciutto with cheese. Choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Roast Beef and Cheese
  Roast beef and cheese with choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Pastrami and Cheese
  Pastrami, cheese. Choice of Hero, Roll, Wrap, or Panini.
  $12.00
- Tuna or Chicken Salad
  Tuna or Chicken Salad Choice of tuna or chicken. Served as hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $11.00
Lunch Menu - Specialty Sandwiches
We use the highest quality Boar's head cold cuts, imported meats, cheeses, produce, & spreads.
- 1. The Monte Special
  Soppressata, capicolla, mortadella, salami, provolone, prosciuttini, & roasted peppers.
  $13.00
- 2. The 120 Special
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, & balsamic vinegar.
  $13.00
- 3. The 122 Special
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, broccoli rabe, & balsamic vinegar.
  $13.00
- 4. The Paper Boy Special
  Ham, hot soppressatta, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers, olive oil, & balsamic vinegar.
  $13.00
- 5. The Steve Special
  Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, sundried tomatoes, broccoli rabe, & pesto.
  $13.00
- 6. The Reuben
  Pastrami, swiss, cole slaw, & mustard.
  $13.00
- 7. The Borough Hall Special
  Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, sundried tomatoes, & roasted peppers.
  $13.00
- 8. The D.A. Special
  Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, & balsamic vinegar.
  $13.00
- 9. The Tony Soprano Special
  Hot capicolla, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, & marinated eggplant.
  $13.00
- 10. Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
  Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, shredded Romano cheese, croutons, & Caesar dressing.
  $12.00
- 11. The Staten Islander
  Fried chicken cutlet, swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, & honey mustard dressing.
  $12.00
- 12. The Turkey Blast
  Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers & thousand island dressing.
  $12.00
- 13. Fried Chicken Cutlet B.L.T
  Crispy fried chicken cutlet, bacon, lettuce, tomato on your choice of hero, roll, wrap, or panini.
  $12.00
- 14. The Gladiator
  Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, portobello mushrooms, & creamy Caesar dressing.
  $13.00
- 15. The Don Vito
  Grilled chicken, smoked mozzarella, sundried tomatoes & pesto.
  $13.00
- 16. Pollo Alla Vincenzo
  Fried chicken cutlet, prosciutto, asiago cheese, & olive oil.
  $13.00
- 17. The Chicken Sorrento
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, fried eggplant, & prosciutto.
  $13.00
- 18. The Goodfella
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, prosciutto, sundried tomatoes, pesto, & olive oil.
  $13.00
- 19. The Godfather
  Prosciuttini, salami, mortadella, capicolla, soppressata, provolone, & roasted peppers.
  $13.00
- 20. The All-American
  Ham, salami, roast beef, turkey, swiss cheese, lettuce, & tomatoes.
  $13.00
- 21. The Low-carb Special
  Low sodium ham, alpine lace cheese, lettuce, & tomatoes.
  $11.00
- 22. The Lucchese
  Sliced chicken breast, sundried tomato, pesto, provolone, baby greens, & olive oil.
  $12.00
- 23. Genovese
  Honey roasted turkey breast, pesto, baby greens, tomatoes, & olive oil.
  $12.00
- 24. Calabrese
  Hot soppressata, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, & olive oil.
  $12.00
- 25. Siciliano
  Grilled eggplant, roasted red peppers, ricotta salata, baby greens, & balsamic vinegar.
  $12.00
- 26. The Hot Tuscany
  Hot capicolla, genoa salami, mortadella, provolone, roasted peppers, marinated eggplant & pesto.
  $13.00
- 27. Portofino
  Homemade tuna salad, olive tapenade, leaf lettuce, tomatoes, & olive oil.
  $11.00
- 28. Toscano
  Salami, provolone, olive tapenade, leaf lettuce, & balsamic vinegar.
  $11.00
- 29. Palermo
  Homemade tuna salad, fresh mozzarella, & tomatoes.
  $11.00
- 30. Vegetariano
  Vegetarian. Mixed grilled vegetables, fresh mozzarella, & balsamic vinegar.
  $12.00
- 31. Prosciutto E Pomodoro
  Imported prosciutto, leaf lettuce, tomatoes, & olive oil.
  $12.00
- 32. Salame E Carciofe
  Salami, provolone, & artichoke spread.
  $12.00
- 33. Capri
  Fresh mozzarella, olive tapenade & tomatoes.
  $11.00
- 34. Bistecca Toscano
  Sliced roast beef, leaf lettuce, tomatoes, oregano, & olive oil.
  $12.00
- 35. Prosciutto E Mozzarella
  Imported prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, & olive oil.
  $12.00
- 36. Toast Italiano
  Parma cotto ham, fontina cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, & olive oil.
  $12.00
- 37. Alpino
  Virginia ham, fontina cheese, leaf lettuce, tomatoes, onions, olive oil, & balsamic vinegar.
  $11.00
- 38. The Calabrese Cubano
  Hot soppressata, provolone, dijon mustard & sliced pickles.
  $12.00
- 39. The Cuban
  Virginia ham, swiss cheese, mustard & sliced pickles.
  $12.00
- 40. The Cowboy
  Grilled chicken, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, bacon & BBQ sauce.
  $13.00
Lunch Menu - Fresh Salads
We use the highest quality Boar's head cold cuts, imported meats, cheeses, produce, & spreads.
- Tossed Salad
  Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, & black olives.
  $7.95
- The 120 Special
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, & roasted peppers.
  $11.95
- The 120 with Grilled Chicken
  Grilled chicken salad with choice of small or large size. Dressing options include oil & vinegar, creamy Italian, ranch, Russian, Italian, and more.
  $12.95
- The Blazing Buffalo
  Fried chicken cutlet in a spicy buffalo wing sauce, shredded cheddar cheese, bleu cheese crumbles, & tortilla chips served with ranch dressing.
  $12.95
- The Fama
  Mushrooms, artichokes, mixed olives, roasted peppers, & fresh mozzarella.
  $12.95
- The Correction Officer's Wife
  Roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, & mushrooms.
  $11.95
- The Motel Salad
  Tossed salad with fried chicken cutlet.
  $9.95
- The Don't Worry About It!
  If you have to ask, don't order it!!
  $12.95
- My Big Fat Greek
  Red bell peppers, feta cheese, grape leaves, kalamata olives, & a 1/4 of pita bread served with lemon & olive oil dressing.
  $11.95
- The Grilled Chicken Caesar
  Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, shredded Romano cheese, & croutons.
  $11.95
- Italy Meets Greece
  Salami, provolone, red bell peppers, kalamata olives, feta cheese, & cici beans served with Italian dressing.
  $12.95
- The Chef Salad
  Turkey, ham, swiss, roast beef, & hard boiled egg.
  $11.95
- The Pauley Salad
  Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, antipasto, & mushrooms.
  $15.95
- A Picnic in Rome
  Artichoke hearts, roasted peppers, pesto marinated in grilled chicken served with Italian dressing.
  $12.95
Lunch Menu - Soups
Includes bread. Add grated cheese for an additional cost. We use the highest quality Boar's head cold cuts, imported meats, cheeses, produce, & spreads.
- Lentil
  Hearty lentil soup. Available in small or large sizes.
  $5.99
- Minestrone
  Italian vegetable soup. Available in small or large size.
  $5.99
- Pasta and Beans
  Pasta with beans in a savory broth. Small or large size available.
  $5.99
- Chicken
  Chicken soup available in small or large size.
  $5.99

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Montalbano's Menu

Customer Favorites

14. The Gladiator

3. The 122 Special

Rib Eye Cheese Steak

A Picnic in Rome

Pastrami and Cheese

Sausage and Peppers

19. The Godfather

16. Pollo Alla Vincenzo

Turkey and Cheese

Ham and Cheese

Beverages

20 oz. Soda

12 oz. can of soda

16.9 oz Poland Spring Water

16 oz. Snapple

12 oz. Manhattan Special

16 oz. Hanks

Today's Lunch Specials

#1. STUFFED SHELLS SERVED WITH CHICKEN PARMIGIANA

#2. CAVATELLI WITH HOT SAUSAGE MEAT & BROCCOLI RABE

#3. PASTA SALAD SERVED WITH GRILLED CHICKEN

#4. THE LUNCH BOX SPECIAL: TURKEY AND MUNSTER CHEESE ON A ROLL WITH LETTUCE AND TOMATOES SERVED WITH A BAG OF CHIPS

#5. THE MONTALBANO’S SPECIAL SALAD OF THE DAY: THE I.S. 49 SPECIAL: THE BLAZING BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD LARGE TOSSED SALAD TOPPED WITH FRIED CHICKEN CUTLET IN SPICY BUFFALO WING SAUCE, SHREDDED CHEDDER CHEESE, & BLEU CHEESE CRUMBLES SERVED WITH BLEU CHEESE DRESSING

#6. THE MONTALBANO’S SPECIAL WRAP OF THE DAY: THE STATEN ISLANDER: FRIED CHICKEN CUTLET, SWISS CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, BACON, & HONEY MUSTARD DRESSING

#7. THE MONTALBANO’S SPECIAL PANINI OF THE DAY: THE MEDITERRANEO ON A CIABATTA BREAD: GRILLED CHICKEN, FRESH MOZZARELLA, GRILLED EGGPLANT, SAUTEED ONIONS & PEPPERS, LEAF LETTUCE, TOMATOES, & PESTO MAYO

Hot Soups

Hot Soups

Lunch Menu - Hot Sandwiches

Chicken Parmigiana

Veal Parmigiana

Meatball Parmigiana

Eggplant Parmigiana

Rib Eye Cheese Steak

Potato and Egg

Pepper and Egg

Sausage and Peppers

Sausage, Peppers and Potatoes

Grilled Chicken

Lunch Menu - Cold Sandwiches

Ham and Cheese

Salami and Cheese

Turkey and Cheese

Soppressata and Cheese

Italian Capicolla and Cheese

Mortadella and Cheese

Prosciutto and Cheese

Roast Beef and Cheese

Pastrami and Cheese

Tuna or Chicken Salad

Lunch Menu - Specialty Sandwiches

1. The Monte Special

2. The 120 Special

3. The 122 Special

4. The Paper Boy Special

5. The Steve Special

6. The Reuben

7. The Borough Hall Special

8. The D.A. Special

9. The Tony Soprano Special

10. Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

11. The Staten Islander

12. The Turkey Blast

13. Fried Chicken Cutlet B.L.T

14. The Gladiator

15. The Don Vito

16. Pollo Alla Vincenzo

17. The Chicken Sorrento

18. The Goodfella

19. The Godfather

20. The All-American

21. The Low-carb Special

22. The Lucchese

23. Genovese

24. Calabrese

25. Siciliano

26. The Hot Tuscany

27. Portofino

28. Toscano