Molly's Cupcakes Menu

Assortment of our classic Molly cupcakes with sprinkles

An assortment of our classic mini molly flavors with sprinkles.

Assortment of our mini Molly cupcakes with sprinkles

An assortment of our classic mini molly flavors with sprinkles.

A box of our four most popular cupcakes and a personalized notecard! Includes the Ron Bennington, Cookie Monster, Cake Batter, and a Red Velvet with Buttercream frosting and sprinkles, plus a notecard. Please write in the special instructions your message - a friendly reminder we will write UP TO 15 WORDS ONLY. Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.

An assortment of some of our best chocolate-based centerfilled cupcakes including Chocolate Decadence, Molten Flourless Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, and Ron Bennington.

An assortment of some of our best-selling centerfilled cupcakes: half Cake Batter with plastic Happy Birthday! toothpicks and half of our Cookie Monster cupcakes. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.

Classic cupcakes of your choice with pastel confetti sprinkles, half of them adorned with plastic Happy Birthday! toothpicks. Comes with our most popular frostings - does not include cream cheese* (*temperature sensitive*) unless specified in special instructions. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.

Includes our centerfilled Cake Batter (sky blue frosting!), centerfilled White Chocolate Raspberry (raspberry buttercream is pink!), and classic cupcakes of your choice topped with multicolored pastel confetti sprinkles. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.

Half of our centerfilled White Chocolate Raspberry (raspberry buttercream is pink!) and half classic cupcakes of your choice. Includes personalized notecard - leave message in the special instructions. Up to 15 words (these are small and handwritten! Thank you!). Notecards will not be sent if message isn't included in special instructions.

An assortment of 6 classic Molly cupcakes and 6 Centerfilled cupcakes

Vanilla-raspberry cake, filled with white chocolate mousse, topped with raspberry buttercream, and sprinkled with white chocolate curls

Chocolate cake filled with cookies-'n-cream mousse, topped with vanilla buttercream and a mini Oreo cookie

Vanilla caramel cake filled with butterscotch pudding, topped with a salted vanilla buttercream and drizzled with housemade caramel sauce

Peanut butter cake filled with Nutella, topped with Nutella buttercream and dusted with cocoa powder

Vanilla chocolate-chip cake, filled with safe cookie dough, topped with vanilla buttercream, and garnished with a mini chocolate chip cookie

Vanilla funfetti cake, filled with safe cake batter, frosted with colorful buttercream and topped with rainbow sprinkles! NOTE: Most often this frosting is sky blue--occasionally we switch it up. If you need this cupcake to be blue, write it in the special instructions. No other color requests will be fulfilled.

Flourless chocolate cake filled with dulce de leche ganache, topped with a French vanilla buttercream, and drizzled with chocolate sauce. NOTE: This is "gluten-friendly:" not made with gluten, but prepared in a shared kitchen.

Chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse, topped with chocolate ganache and chocolate curls

Vanilla cake with a caramel filling; topped with buttercream, chocolate and caramel drizzle, and a homemade shortbread cookie

Vanilla cake filled with classic creme brulee custard, topped with flambeed sugar and fresh berries. NOTE: *requires refrigeration

A Cupcake Wars Winner! Vanilla brown sugar streusel cake filled with a cinnamon peach puree; topped with homemade whipped cream, cinnamon, and a sliced peach. NOTE: *requires refrigeration

Vanilla blueberry cake topped with cream cheese pastry cream mix, homemade graham cracker, and fresh blueberries *requires refrigeration

Vanilla cake filled with strawberry filling, topped with buttercream and a strawberry shortcake crumble.

*KEEP COLD!* Cinnamon cake with an apple pie filling topped with whipped cream, caramel drizzle, and cinnamon streusel. Last day available: October 31st!

*KEEP COLD!* Pumpkin cake filled with a creamy mascarpone filling and topped with a cinnamon buttercream swirl.

Select the frosting - comes with sprinkles

Select the frosting - comes with sprinkles

Select the frosting - comes with sprinkles

Select the frosting - comes with sprinkles

Frosting contains coconut. Please note: these are made in a shared kitchen with all of our other products. If you have an allergy/intolerance, there is a chance for cross-contact! For same day orders: we do not bake many of these - please call us at 773-883-7220 before placing an order for 3+ does not come with sprinkles unless requested - no dairy/eggs but may contain gelatin.

Frosting contains coconut. Please note: these are made in a shared kitchen with all of our other products. If you have an allergy/intolerance, there is a chance for cross-contact! For same day orders: we do not bake many of these - please call us at 773-883-7220 before placing an order for 3+ does not come with sprinkles unless requested - no dairy/eggs but may contain gelatin.

Fruity Pebble Rice Krispie Treat made with gooey marshmallows.

Standard small wax candle of varying colors

Include a festive note card! UP TO 15 WORDS (these are SMALL and handwritten! Thank you!)