Milky Way Cleveland Menu

4.6

(375+ Reviews)

$Kosher

Pizza
- Slices
  Choose from our freshly baked every day Milky way slices. Always changing always fresh!!
  $3.50
- 10" Pizza
  Our personal style Milky Way pie. Fresh and delicious every time
  $14.95
- 14" Pizza
  Hand Crafted. All in House! Milky way Build it your way! Serves 3
  $18.95
- 18" Pizza
  Our Largest pizza! Feeds 4-6. Delicious every time
  $23.95
- Vegan Pizza
  Our all Vegan pizza. Handcrafted vegan dough. Freshly grated vegan cheese. Fresh vegan sauce. Customize your pizza with our delicious vegan toppings!
  $18.95
- Gluten Free 10" Personal Pie
  Our Gluten free thin crust pizza.
  $14.95
Calzones
- Mushroom Calzone
  Our signature dough. Filled with mushrooms, cheese and sauce. Baked to perfection.
  $13.95
- Vegetable Calzone
  Our in house signature dough stuffed with tomatoes, green peppers, onions, and of course our house blended cheese.
  $13.95
- Cheese Calzone
  Our in house made dough stuffed with cheese! Oh so delicious.
  $13.95
- Create Your Own Calzone
  Got to have it your way. That's the Milky Way! Create your own calzone. Choose up to 4 toppings
  $15.95
- Spinach and Feta Calzone
  $14.50
Pretzels
- Plain Pretzel
  A great Vegan option. Hand braided vegan pretzels. Don't forget to dip it into our in house marinara.
  $6.95
- Cheese Pretzel
  A Milky Way must try! Cheese, Dough, dipping sauce!!!!
  $9.25
- Spinach and Feta Pretzel
  In house blend of spinach garlic and feta cheese.
  $9.95
- Garlic and Pepper Jack Pretzel
  In house blend of garlic and pepper jack cheese. Our one of a kind pretzel!
  $9.95
- Jalapeño and Schug Pretzel
  Hand twisted pretzels filled with jalapeño and schug
  $9.95
Salad and Soups
- Salad Bar
  $16.50
- Side Of Tuna
  2 Scoops of Tuna served with Lettuce and Tomato
  $7.95
- Side Of Egg Salad
  2 scoops of Egg salad, served with lettuce and toamto
  $6.95
- Side of Israeli Salad
  Our in house, hand chopped Israeli salad. (Cucumber, tomato, oil, seasoning)
  $5.95
- Side of Purple Cabbage Salad
  Milky Way original recipe, made from scratch.
  $5.95
- Soup
  All made in house. Handcrafted recipes! We rotate so make sure to try them all!
  $5.95
Fries
- Plain French Fries
  Shoe string fries. The Milky Way! Fried to a crispy finish, salted to perfection.
  $5.95
- Spicy Fries
  Can't be kosher pizza without Spicy fries.
  $6.95
- Sweet Potato
  $7.95
- Mixed Fries
  $6.95
Sides & Breads
- Mozzarella Sticks
  In house breaded mozzarella sticks.
  $10.95
- Jalapeno Poppers
  Cool cream cheese with spicy jalapeno. Breaded and fried! Garlic dipping sauce.
  $10.95
- Nachos
  In house made tortilla chips. Smothered in cheddar sauce finished with mozzarella cheese.,
  $6.95
- Nachos Deluxe
  In house made tortilla chips. Smothered in cheddar sauce, tomato, red onion, Jalapenos, avocado, with a side of sour cream. Topped with mozzarella cheese
  $9.95
- Onion Rings
  Crispy on the outside, soft and oniony on the inside.
  $8.95
- Potato Cigars (10)
  A great Vegan option. Crispy on the outside, soft delicious mashed potato on the inside.
  $9.25
- Pizza Rolls
  Pizza in a roll! so Soft, cheesy, saucy!
  $3.95
- Bread Sticks
  Milky Way, the only way. Fresh bread sticks made to order. Also vegetarian!
  $8.95
- Cheese Bread Sticks
  Fresh cheese bread sticks anyone?
  $12.95
- Garlic Knots
  You gotta have a garlic knot.
  $0.95
- Vegetarian Chicken Nuggets
  Chicken nuggets, plain fries. A great kid meal option, and Vegetarian!
  $9.95
- Side of Hummus with(6) Falafel Balls
  In house made Hummus & in house made falafel balls.
  $8.95
- Falafel Ball (single)
  Try one, you're going to want another!
  $1.25
- Bread
  Try one of our in house made breads or pita.
  $2.50
- Side Secret Sauce
  $0.50
Paninis
- The "Battleship"
  In house made sub, filled with breaded eggplant, pesto, sundried tomatoes, and cheese. Panini'd.
  $14.95
- The "Olympus"
  In House baked sub filled with, Black and Green Olives, feta cheese, roasted red peppers, red onion, topped with a balsamic glaze. Panini'd
  $14.95
- "Holy Guacamole"
  Calling all Avocado Lovers! In house fresh sub filled with FRESH avocado, garlic mayo, tomato and cheese. Panini'd
  $14.95
- The "Fire Bird"
  Wait, spicy chicken and cheese! Yup. In house sub filled with vegetarian chicken, red onion, tomato, Buffalo sauce, ranch drizzle, and cheese. Panini'd
  $14.95
- The "Easy Caprese"
  In house made sub, marinated fresh mozz, sliced tomato, pesto, and fresh basil leaf. Panini'd. We present, the Easy Caprese
  $14.95
- "Pop-Eye"
  In house made sub, spinach, feta, garlic mayo, red onion, and balsamic drizzle. Panini'd
  $14.95
- "Oh My Cod"
  In House sub, freshly fried breaded fish, tartar sauce, tiger sauce, sliced onions, tomato, and American cheese. Panini'd
  $14.95
- The "Pazzini"
  Fresh sub, in house pizza sauce, cheese, tomato, onion, green pepper. Panini'd
  $14.95
- "Tunariffic"
  In house sub, filled with tuna, avocado, tomato, and cheese. Panin'd
  $14.95
- Terri Yummy
  In house sub. Filled with portabella mushrooms, onions, green peppers, teriyaki sauce, tomatoes, and cheese
  $14.95
Sandwiches and Wraps
- Tuna Salad Sandwich
  Our creamy in house made tuna topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles.
  $11.25
- Egg Salad Sandwich
  Egg salad topped with lettuce, tomato, onions, pickle.
  $10.25
- Vegetarian Chicken Sandwich
  Vegetarian chicken cutlet, topped with lettuce tomato pickle
  $11.50
- Tuna Melt
  Our creamy tuna topped with isreali salad and cheese. Melted to perfection. Served IN a sandwich or ON a pita
  $12.95
- Portabella Mushroom Sandwich
  Sautéed portabella mushrooms, caramelized onions and peppers. Seasoned with soy sauce.Topped with lettuce and tomato.
  $11.95
- Greek Wrap
  Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, black olives, feta cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette served in a wrap of your choice.
  $10.95
- ALT Wrap
  Avocado, lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo and cheese
  $11.25
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich
  An American classic! made with American and mozzarella cheese
  $9.95
- Fried Fish
  Perfectly fried breaded cod. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles, oh and Tartar sauce!
  $12.95
- Whole Falafel
  Our signature homemade falafel balls, stuffed inside a large pita bread. Accompanied by Israeli salad, purple cabbage, pickles, hummus and tehina.
  $10.95
- Vegetarian Chicken Avocado Pesto Wrap
  $12.25
Hoagies
- Tuna Salad Hoagie
  Our creamy in house made tuna, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle
  $12.95
- Eggplant Parmesan Hoagie
  Our signature breaded eggplant. Layered with marinara sauce and cheese. Melted!
  $13.95
- ALT Hoagie
  Avocado, lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo and cheese
  $12.95
- Vegetarian Meatball Hoagie
  Its all Vegan! Our all vegan bread, homemade vegan meatballs topped with caramelized onions and peppers. Glazed with marinara sauce
  $12.95
- Portabella Hoagie
  Its Vegan! Sautéed portabella mushrooms, onions, peppers. Seasoned with soy sauce. Topped with fresh lettuce and tomato
  $12.95
- Fried Fish Hoagie
  Breaded Cod fried to perfection. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle. Served with a side of tartar sauce.
  $13.50
- Vegetarian Chicken Hoagie
  Vegan Chicken Cutlet topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle
  $12.95
- Vegetarian Chicken Parmesan Hoagie
  Vegetarian chicken cutlet topped with marinara sauce and cheese
  $13.95
- Vegetarian Chicken Avocado Pesto Hoagie
  Its Vegan! Vegetarian chicken cutlet topped with avocado, lettuce, tomato and pesto
  $13.95
Burgers
- The Impossible Burger
  An amazing plant based burger served on a toasted pretzel bun. Melted american cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle. Secret sauce finishes it off!
  $16.95
- The "Cowboy"
  Ranch dressing, onion rings, lettuce, tomato and American cheese
  $14.95
- The "Fun-Guy"
  Caramelized mushrooms and onions, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and BBQ Sauce
  $14.95
- The "Dynamite"
  Sliced Jalapenos, crispy onions, pepper jack cheese, Asian ginger hot sauce, and sliced tomato's
  $14.95
- The "Sweet-Pete"
  Caramelized Onions, sweet potato fries, mozz cheese and Cesar dressing
  $14.95
Entrees
- Baked Ziti
  Ziti pasta baked with sauce and cheese
  $12.95
- Eggplant and Ziti
  A hybrid. Delicious breaded eggplant crossed with ziti noodles. Sauced and cheese'd
  $13.95
- Vegetarian Chicken Parmesan
  Vegetarian Chicken mixed with ziti noodles sauce and cheese
  $13.95
- Noodles and Cheese
  Ziti noodles mixed with our homemade cheddar sauce, covered in cheese and baked to perfection
  $12.95
- Tuna Melt in a TIN(no bread)
  Creamy tuna, topped with Israeli salad, and cheese. Melted to perfection
  $14.95
- Vegetarian Meatball Parmesean
  Vegetarian meatballs served with caramelized onions and peppers, finished with marinara sauce and cheese!
  $14.95
- Fried Fish Plate
  Breaded cod fried. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, and a side of tartar.
  $15.95
- Falafel Plate
  Its Vegan! Israeli salad, purple cabbage salad, pickles, hummus, tahina, falafel balls and a side of pita bread.
  $13.95
- Eggplant Parmesan (in a tin)
  Breaded eggplant layered with sauce and cheese!
  $13.95
- Portabella Melt
  Sautéed portabella mushrooms with onions, peppers, seasoned soy sauce, topped with cheese.
  $13.95
- Plain Noodles
  $8.95
- Fish and Chips
  $16.95
Combos
- Combo 1 - 2 Slices FF
  2 Slices of pizza. Your choice of plain, spicy or mixed fries. Also a fountain drink
  $14.95
- Combo 2 - Fish FF Hoagie
  Fried fish hoagie with fries of your choice, and a fountain drink.
  $19.95
- Combo 3 - Burger FF
  Vegy Burger with your choice of fries and a drink
  $18.95
- Combo 4 - Soup & Roll
  Soup of your choice and a roll. Also a fountain drink
  $9.95
- Combo 5 - Veg Ckn FF
  Vegy chicken sandwich your choice of fries and a drink
  $18.95
- Combo 6 - Falafel FF
  Whole falafel, your choice of fries and a fountain drink
  $17.95
- Combo 7 - Pie Family FF
  1-18" plain cheese pizza. Choice of a family fries.
  $33.95
- Combo 8 - 2 Pies Family plain/spicy FF
  2-18" Plain cheese pizza, 1 family fries plain, 1 spicy family fries.
  $66.95
- Wednesday Combo 1 -Any 2 Slices FF
  $9.99
Desserts
- Ice Cream
  $3.95
- Milkshake
  Its a Milky way Classic!
  $9.95
For Limited Time Only
- Mac N' Cheese Bombs
  Its all from scratch. Mac n' cheese breaded and fried.
  $9.95
- Knishes
  $3.95
Bagels To Go
- Half Dozen Bagels
  $9.00
- Bakers Dozen (13) Bagels
  $18.00
- Single Bagel.
  $1.50
Combos
- Cream Cheese on Bagel/ Coffee
  $4.50
- Eggs on a Bagel/Small Coffee
  $4.95
- Danish With Coffee
  Danish of your choice and a small coffee
  $3.95
Sandwiches
- Lox & Cream Cheese
  $9.95
- Whitefish
  $8.95
- Eggs
  $5.95
- PB & Jelly
  $3.95
- Butter
  $2.95
- Cream Cheese
  $4.25
- Tuna
  In house made tuna fresh daily. Served on freshly boiled and baked bagels. Build the sandwich how you like it!
  $7.95
- Egg Salad
  $6.95
- Cheese Melt
  $6.95
- Beyond Sausage
  $9.95
- Toasted Bagel
  $1.50
- Muensterella
  $12.95
Omelettes
- Cheese Omelette
  A classic Cheese Omelette
  $12.95
- Vegetable Omelette
  Sautéed mushroom, green peppers, onions, tomatoes
  $12.95
- Leo Omelette
  Sauteed onions and lox
  $16.95
- Spinach Omelette
  Sauteed spinach, garlic and onions
  $15.95
- Greek Omelette
  Black olives, red onions, Feta cheese
  $12.95
- Broccoli Cheddar Omelette
  Broccoli, garlic, onions and cheddar cheese
  $15.95
- Create Your Own Omelette
  Build your Omelette how you want it
  $10.95
- The "Hangry Hippo" Plate
  Bread of your choice, eggs, sausage, home fries
  $17.95
- Scrambled Eggs
  $9.95
- Sunny-Side Up Eggs
  $9.95
- Plain Omelette (NO cheese)
  $11.95
Sourdough Toast
- Avocado Toast
  Toasted sourdough, avocado seasoned, diced red onion, feta cheese, diced tomato, kosher salt, drizzle of olive oil. Topped with a sunny side up
  $14.95
- Sabich Toast
  Freshly toasted in house sourdough bread. Lightly schmear of hummus and schug. Topped with eggplant, Israeli salad.. Drizzled with tahini. Topped with a sunny side up.
  $14.95
- Tuna Avocado Toast
  Our fresh Sourdough bread, creamy tuna fish, fresh avocado, cucumbers and pickles
  $14.95
Pancakes & French Toast & Waffles
- Pancakes
  $6.95
- French Toast
  $7.95
- Waffles (powder sugar, , syrup)
  $7.95
- Belgium Waffle (ice cream of choice, caramel sauce or choc sauce, whip cream)
  Our in house made FRESH waffle. Ice cream of your choice, caramel sauce and choc sauce topped with whip cream.
  $10.95
Side Dishes
- Home Fries
  $5.95
- Cheesey Home Fries
  $7.95
- Israeli Salad
  Cucumbers, onions, tomatoes, oil, seasoning
  $4.95
- Side of Butter
  $0.95
- Side of Cream Cheese
  $1.95
- Beyond sausage
  $5.00
- Side Of Salad
  Romaine, tomato, red onion, cucumber
  $4.95
Quiche of the Day
- 4" Quiche
  Try our delicious, filling, in house made quiches. Fresh every day!
  $9.95
1/2 LB Containers
- 8 oz Plain Cream Cheese
  $5.00
- 8 oz Tuna
  $6.50
- 8 oz Egg Salad
  $6.00
- 8 oz Flavored Cream Cheese
  $6.00
- 8 oz Lox Cream Cheese
  $7.00
- 8 oz White Fish
  $8.00
- 4 oz Lox
  $6.95
Bagels
- Single
  $1.50
- Half Dozen
  $9.00
- Baker's Dozen
  $18.00
Bagel Sandwiches
- Bagel W/ Lox & Cream Cheese
  $9.95
- Cream Cheese Bagel
  $4.25
- Egg Salad Bagel
  $6.95
- Eggs on a Bagel
  $6.95
- Tuna Salad Bagel
  $7.95
- Bagel And Butter
  $2.95
Sourdough Toasts
- Avocado Toast
  Our in house baked sourdough. Toasted to perfection. Topped with freshly diced avocado, tomato, red onion and feta cheese. Seasoned with olive oil salt and pepper. Topped with a sunny side up
  $14.95
- Sabich Toast
  Our in house baked sourdough bread. Toasted to perfection. A light schmear of our in house hummus, schug. Topped with fried eggplant, Israeli salad, and a fried egg. Drizzled with Tahini
  $14.95
- Tuna Avocado
  $14.95
Cold Drinks
- Fountain Soda
  $2.95
- 20 Oz Bottle
  $2.95
- Gatorade
  $2.95
- Snapple
  $2.95
- Seltzer Can
  $1.95
- Orange Juice (small)
  $3.50
- 2-Liter
  $4.95
- Milkshake
  $9.95
- Coffee Shake
  $11.50
- Small Slushy 12 Oz
  $4.95
Coffee Drinks
- Hot Coffee
  $3.50
- Iced coffee
  $3.95
- Hot Tea
  $2.95
- Hot Chocolate
  $5.95
Calzones
- Mushroom Calzone
  Our signature dough. Filled with mushrooms, cheese and sauce. Baked to perfection.
  $13.95
- Vegetable Calzone
  Our in house signature dough stuffed with tomatoes, green peppers, onions, and of course our house blended cheese.
  $13.95
- Cheese Calzone
  Our in house made dough stuffed with cheese! Oh so delicious.
  $13.95
- Create Your Own Calzone
  Got to have it your way. That's the Milky Way! Create your own calzone. Choose up to 4 toppings
  $15.95
Combos
- Combo 1 ( 2 Slices)
  2 SLICES OF REGULAR CHEESE PIZZA plain, spicy or mixed fries & fountain drink
  $14.95
- Combo 7
  1 LARGE PLAIN PIE 1 regular, spicy or mixed family fries
  $33.95
- Combo 8
  2 LARGE PLAIN PIES, 1 FAMILY PLAIN FRIES & 1 FAMILY SPICY FRIES
  $66.95
Desserts
- Ice Cream
  $3.95
- Milkshake
  Its a Milky way Classic!
  $9.95
Fries
- Plain French Fries
  Shoe string fries. The Milky Way! Fried to a crispy finish, salted to perfection.
  $5.95
- Spicy Fries
  Can't be kosher pizza without Spicy fries.
  $6.95
- Sweet Potato
  $7.95
- Mixed Fries
  $6.95
Pizza
- Slices
  Choose from our freshly baked every day Milky way slices. Always changing always fresh!!
  $3.50
- 10" Pizza
  Our personal style Milky Way pie. Fresh and delicious every time
  $14.95
- 14" Pizza
  Hand Crafted. All in House! Milky way Build it your way! Serves 3
  $18.95
- 18" Pizza
  Our Largest pizza! Feeds 4-6. Delicious every time
  $23.95
- Vegan Pizza
  Our all Vegan pizza. Handcrafted vegan dough. Freshly grated vegan cheese. Fresh vegan sauce. Customize your pizza with our delicious vegan toppings!
  $18.95
- Gluten Free 10" Personal Pie
  Our Gluten free thin crust pizza.
  $14.95
Pretzels
- Plain Pretzel
  A great Vegan option. Hand braided vegan pretzels. Don't forget to dip it into our in house marinara.
  $6.95
- Cheese Pretzel
  A Milky Way must try! Cheese, Dough, dipping sauce!!!!
  $9.25
- Spinach and Feta Pretzel
  In house blend of spinach garlic and feta cheese.
  $9.95
- Garlic and Pepper Jack Pretzel
  In house blend of garlic and pepper jack cheese. Our one of a kind pretzel!
  $9.95
- Jalapeño and Schug Pretzel
  Hand twisted pretzels filled with jalapeño and schug
  $9.95
Side Dishes
- Bread Sticks
  Milky Way, the only way. Fresh bread sticks made to order. Also vegetarian!
  $8.95
- Cheese Bread Sticks
  Fresh cheese bread sticks anyone?
  $12.95
- Garlic Knots
  You gotta have a garlic knot.
  $0.95
- Jalapeno Poppers
  Cool cream cheese with spicy jalapeno. Breaded and fried! Garlic dipping sauce.
  $10.95
- Mozzarella Sticks
  In house breaded mozzarella sticks.
  $10.95
- Nachos
  In house made tortilla chips. Smothered in cheddar sauce finished with mozzarella cheese.,
  $6.95
- Onion Rings
  Crispy on the outside, soft and oniony on the inside.
  $8.95
- Pizza Rolls
  Pizza in a roll! so Soft, cheesy, saucy!
  $3.95
- Potato Cigars (10)
  A great Vegan option. Crispy on the outside, soft delicious mashed potato on the inside.
  $9.25