Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Menu

$Ice cream shop

19 McWilliams Pl, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Order Online

King Cake
- King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday January 25
  9 ring of soft Brioche dough filled with Cinnamon Sugar, lightly glazed and covered in purple, yellow and green sprinkles. A small feve comes with your cake and can be hidden in the cake after purchase. it's not edible so please be careful when eating your slice!King Cakes are baked fresh on Fridays and available for pre-order pickup every Saturday from 12pm to 4pm at R Bar in Asbury Park or at our shop in Jersey City.PLEASE SPECIFY IN ORDER NOTES WHERE YOU WANT TO PICK UP!The order cut off for Jan 25 pickup is Thursday Jan 23 at 10pm.We have a limited number of slots for March 1, so order early if you want to have King Cake for Mardi Gras Day.
  $39.00
- King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 1
  9 ring of soft Brioche dough filled with Cinnamon Sugar, lightly glazed and covered in purple, yellow and green sprinkles. A small feve comes with your cake and can be hidden in the cake after purchase. it's not edible so please be careful when eating your slice!King Cakes are baked fresh on Fridays and available for pre-order pickup every Saturday from 12pm to 4pm at R Bar in Asbury Park or at our shop in Jersey City.PLEASE SPECIFY IN ORDER NOTES WHERE YOU WANT TO PICK UP!The order cut off for Jan 25 pickup is Thursday Jan 30 at 10pm.
  $39.00
- King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 8
  9 ring of soft Brioche dough filled with Cinnamon Sugar, lightly glazed and covered in purple, yellow and green sprinkles. A small feve comes with your cake and can be hidden in the cake after purchase. it's not edible so please be careful when eating your slice!King Cakes are baked fresh on Fridays and available for pre-order pickup every Saturday from 12pm to 4pm at R Bar in Asbury Park or at our shop in Jersey City.PLEASE SPECIFY IN ORDER NOTES WHERE YOU WANT TO PICK UP!The order cut off for Feb 8 pickup is Thursday Feb 6 at 10pm.
  $39.00
- King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 15
  9 ring of soft Brioche dough filled with Cinnamon Sugar, lightly glazed and covered in purple, yellow and green sprinkles. A small feve comes with your cake and can be hidden in the cake after purchase. it's not edible so please be careful when eating your slice!King Cakes are baked fresh on Fridays and available for pre-order pickup every Saturday from 12pm to 4pm at R Bar in Asbury Park or at our shop in Jersey City.PLEASE SPECIFY IN ORDER NOTES WHERE YOU WANT TO PICK UP!The order cut off for Feb 15 pickup is Thursday Feb 13 at 10pm.
  $39.00
- King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 22
  9 ring of soft Brioche dough filled with Cinnamon Sugar, lightly glazed and covered in purple, yellow and green sprinkles. A small feve comes with your cake and can be hidden in the cake after purchase. it's not edible so please be careful when eating your slice!King Cakes are baked fresh on Fridays and available for pre-order pickup every Saturday from 12pm to 4pm at R Bar in Asbury Park or at our shop in Jersey City.PLEASE SPECIFY IN ORDER NOTES WHERE YOU WANT TO PICK UP!The order cut off for Feb 22 pickup is Thursday Feb 20 at 10pm.
  $39.00
- King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday March 1
  9 ring of soft Brioche dough filled with Cinnamon Sugar, lightly glazed and covered in purple, yellow and green sprinkles. A small feve comes with your cake and can be hidden in the cake after purchase. it's not edible so please be careful when eating your slice!King Cakes are baked fresh on Fridays and available for pre-order pickup every Saturday from 12pm to 4pm at R Bar in Asbury Park or at our shop in Jersey City.PLEASE SPECIFY IN ORDER NOTES WHERE YOU WANT TO PICK UP!The order cut off for March 1 pickup is Thursday Feb 27 at 10pm. Mardi Gras is March 4 and we have limited slots available for this date---place your order early!
  $39.00
Ice Cream Scoops
- 1 Scoop
  One 4oz scoop of ice cream (1 flavor only)
- 2 Scoops
  Two 4 oz scoops of ice cream (up to 2 flavors total)
  $8.25
- Handmade Cone On The Side
  Handmade in Brooklyn NY by the Konery (plus they are vegan and nut free!)
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Coffee Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two handmade Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with our Parlor Coffee Ice Cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
  $6.75
- Birthday Sprinkle Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two Confetti Sugar Cookies filled with Vanilla ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
  $6.75
- Red Velvet Dream Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two handmade Red Velvet White Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
  $6.75
- Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two Fruity Cereal French Macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs.
  $8.00
- Gingerbread Sandwich
  Two gingersbread cookies, hand decorated and filled with Peppermint Crunch ice cream (Mint ice cream, mellowed with a splash of Vanilla Extract and swirled with Candy Cane Crunch). Contains Milk, Soy, Wheat, Eggs
  $10.00
Frozen Treats
- Cold Brew Float
  One 4oz scoop of ice cream (1 flavor only) in our own Cold Brew Coffee (made with Brooklyn Roasting Company's Brazil Santana de Vargam Roast
  $9.75
- Make-Your-Own Ice Cream Sandwich
  One 4oz scoop of ice cream (1 flavor only) in between two fresh baked Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies, all rolled in Classic Rainbow Sprinkles
  $7.25
- Milkshake
  Two Scoops of your choice of ice cream (up to 2 flavors total) hand spun with Organic Whole Milk in a 16 ounce cup all topped with handmade Whipped Cream
  $12.75
- Puppy Froyo
  A small frozen treat for your furry friend made with Peanut Butter, Yogurt and Banana and topped with two crunchy treats
  $2.00
- Root Beer Float
  One 4oz scoop of ice cream (1 flavor only) in a 16oz cup of IBC Root Beer
  $9.75
- Sprinkles On The Side
  2 oz of our classic Rainbow Sprinkles, packaged to take home
  $2.50
- Sundae
  Your choice of 2 scoops of ice cream (up to 2 flavors total) and 2 toppings, whipped cream and a cherry
  $12.75
Bakeshop Treats
- 1 Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies
  Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt
  $19.50
- 1 French Macaron
  Choose from Pistachio, Raspberry, Coconut, Passion Fruit, Chocolate or Birthday Sprinkle
  $3.25
- 1 Fudge Brownie
  Made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together
  $4.50
- 1 Magic Bar
  A salted graham crust covered with layers of chocolate, coconut, dulce de leche, toffee, raisins and toasted almonds. Contains wheat, milk, tree nuts (coconut and almonds)
  $4.50
- 1 Raspberry Crumb Bar
  Brown sugar shortbread crust with layers of raspberry jam and brown sugar crumb topping
  $4.50
- 1 Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie
  Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
  $1.95
- Set Of 6 Assorted French Macarons
  Six assorted flavors of French Macarons boxed in a white gift box: *****Flavors may vary according to season so please call the shop to confirm before purchase*****
  $19.50
- Set Of 6 Cupcakes
  Two Vanilla, two Chocolate and two Red Velvet cupcakes packed in a plastic clamshell
  $22.50
Ice Cream Cakes
- The Classic 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Vanilla Bean ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch, Classic Chocolate ice cream and Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy. Serves up to 8 people.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $40.00
- The Midnight Cookie 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $40.00
- The Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy 6 Ice Cream Cake
  A 6 cake made with two giant French macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs, Soy.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- Super Sammie Ice Cream Cake
  Vanilla Bean ice cream rolled in rainbow sprinkles and sandwiched between 2 Giant chocolate chip cookies!Contains Milk, Eggs, Soy, WheatNEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- MatchaBerry 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Matcha Cookie ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Strawberry ice cream topped with our own Chocolate Cream filled cookie pieces. Contains Milk, Wheat, SoyNEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- Mini Celebration Ice Cream Cake: Vanilla Bean
  A 12oz mini cake made with Vanilla Bean ice cream, rolled in classic rainbow sprinkles and topped with frosting. Contains Milk.
  $12.50
- Sugar Paste Message Plaque
  A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your custom message in edible ink. Let us know your special message so we can inscribe it for you!*MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21*
  $5.00
- Box Of Candles
  $5.00
- Carrot Cake 6 Ice Cream Cake
  A thick wedge of our handmade Carrot Cake topped with a wedge of Cream Cheese ice cream, smothered with Salted Caramel Sauce and ringed with toasted, sweetened coconut. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Tree Nuts (Coconut)NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
Ice Cream Pints
- Alfajores 'N' Cream Ice Cream Pint
  Sweet Cream ice cream with Alfajores cookies---light buttery cookies filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut. Contains Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Coconut)
  $12.00
- Classic Chocolate Ice Cream Pint
  Chocolate ice cream made with melted 72% chocolate. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $14.00
- Earl Grey Fudge Ice Cream Pint
  Earl grey tea infused ice cream with a generous ripple of house made fudge. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $12.00
- Guava Cream Cheese Ice Cream Pint
  Cream Cheese ice cream with our own Guava ripple. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Honey Lavender Ice Cream Pint
  Honey ice cream made with local honey and gently infused with lavender. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint
  Creamy lemon olive oil ice cream made with lemon-infused Sicilian olive oil. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Malted Cookie Ice Cream Pint
  Our #1 seller from day 1! Malted milk ice cream swirled with our housemade sea salt chocolate chip cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy
  $12.00
- Matcha Cookie Ice Cream Pint
  Matcha ice cream chock full of our very own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.
  $12.00
- Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Pint
  Jet black ice cream made with activated charcoal and cocoa powder. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $12.00
- Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pint
  Caramel ice cream made with just enough sea salt to enhance its rich flavor. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Strawberry Ice Cream Pint
  A childhood favorite made only with pureed strawberries---never any artificial colors or flavors. Contains Milk;
  $12.00
- Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint
  America's favorite flavor, made with real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Sugar Cone On The Side
  $1.00
- Specialty Pint: Golfeados
  Based on the addictive Venezuelan pastry that is similar to (but BETTER!) than a Cinnamon Bun! Cotija Cheese ice cream (yes, that's the same cheese you often find atop your tacos) with Panela Caramel Sauce (a solid, unrefined cane sugar popular in Latin American countries) and pieces of anise spiced bunContains Milk, Eggs, Wheat
  $14.00
- Specialty Pint: Berg's Caraway Crunch
  This flavor is made in collaboration with Berg's Smoked Meat in Belmar, NJ which serves up Montreal Smoked Meat and Poutine. Bright Caraway ice cream sweetened with brown sugar and chock full of crunchy, all-butter Smoked Meat Toffee pieces. Contains Milk
  $14.00
- Specialty Pint: Carmen Rosa's Dominican Cake
  Almond ice cream with our own Guavea Jam, blue meringue crumble and pieces of fluffy, buttery Dominican Cake from Carmen Rosa's Bakery in Jersey City. Contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts (Almonds)
  $14.00
- Specialty Pint: Banana Bread
  Brown Sugar Banana ice cream chock full of the super famous Banana Bread from Dames Coffee Shop right here in Jersey City. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Mint Chip
  Pale green Mint ice cream with tiny dark chocolate flecks. Contains Milk, Soy
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Cafe Au Lait
  Made with the Commander's Palace blend from New Orlean's based coffee company, French Truck Coffee. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Cookies 'N' Cream
  Sweat Cream ice cream with our own chocolate cream-filled cookie pieces. Contains Wheat, Milk, Soy
  $12.00
Single Serve Non-Dairy
- Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy Mint Chip
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Mint Chip---a non-dairy ice cream made with Oatly Oat Milk, Mint and Vanilla extracts and dark chocolate flakes. Contains Soy.***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough---a non-dairy Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough pieces. Contains Soy, Peanuts. ***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Cookie Butter
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Cookie Butter---a non-dairy ice cream made with Cookie Butter (think crushed graham crackers and fall spices) and Soy Milk. Contains Soy, Wheat***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Pumpkin Spice
  A 6 ounce single cup made with local Pumpkin puree, fall spices and oat milk
  $8.25
Coffee Drinks
- Cold Brew
  Brewed for 16 hours in our kitchen using the Grind Shop's specialty Blend of beans
  $4.75
- Espresso
  Brewed with grinds from the Grind Shop right here in Jersey City.
  $3.75
- Latte
  1 shot of espresso with 5 ounces of steamed milk of your choice (don't forget to add a flavor!)
  $4.75
Hot Chocolate and More
- Hot Chocolate
  Your choice of milk blended with our own Hot Chocolate Syrup. Don't forget to add one of our handmade Vanilla Bean Marshmallows!
  $6.00
- Affagato Sundae: The Classic
  One 4oz scoop of ice cream (1 flavor only, your choice) drowned in a shot of espresso
  $6.75
Merchandise
- Milk Sugar Love Mug
  A 10oz ceramic pink mug with chocolate brown logo on the front ---- perfect for a cup of hot chocolate at home! Handwash recommended.
  $9.50
- Milk Sugar Love Cooler Bag
  A chocolate brown insulated tote that carries 4 pints PLUS a reusable cold brick!
  $10.00
- Milk Sugar Love Classic T-Shirt
  Available in Small only with a hand-drawn illustration by Nanu Studios in Hoboken!
  $20.00
Ice Cream Cakes
- The Classic 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Vanilla Bean ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch, Classic Chocolate ice cream and Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy. Serves up to 8 people.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $40.00
- The Midnight Cookie 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $40.00
- The Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy 6 Ice Cream Cake
  A 6 cake made with two giant French macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs, Soy.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- Super Sammie Ice Cream Cake
  Vanilla Bean ice cream rolled in rainbow sprinkles and sandwiched between 2 Giant chocolate chip cookies!Contains Milk, Eggs, Soy, WheatNEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- MatchaBerry 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Matcha Cookie ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Strawberry ice cream topped with our own Chocolate Cream filled cookie pieces. Contains Milk, Wheat, SoyNEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- Mini Celebration Ice Cream Cake: Vanilla Bean
  A 12oz mini cake made with Vanilla Bean ice cream, rolled in classic rainbow sprinkles and topped with frosting. Contains Milk.
  $12.50
- Sugar Paste Message Plaque
  A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your custom message in edible ink. Let us know your special message so we can inscribe it for you!*MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21*
  $5.00
- Box Of Candles
  $5.00
- Carrot Cake 6 Ice Cream Cake
  A thick wedge of our handmade Carrot Cake topped with a wedge of Cream Cheese ice cream, smothered with Salted Caramel Sauce and ringed with toasted, sweetened coconut. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Tree Nuts (Coconut)NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Coffee Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two handmade Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with our Parlor Coffee Ice Cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
  $6.75
- Birthday Sprinkle Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two Confetti Sugar Cookies filled with Vanilla ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
  $6.75
- Red Velvet Dream Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two handmade Red Velvet White Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
  $6.75
- Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two Fruity Cereal French Macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs.
  $8.00
- Gingerbread Sandwich
  Two gingersbread cookies, hand decorated and filled with Peppermint Crunch ice cream (Mint ice cream, mellowed with a splash of Vanilla Extract and swirled with Candy Cane Crunch). Contains Milk, Soy, Wheat, Eggs
  $10.00
Ice Cream Pints
- Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint
  America's favorite flavor, made with real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Sugar Cone On The Side
  $1.00
- Guava Cream Cheese Ice Cream Pint
  Cream Cheese ice cream with our own Guava ripple. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Classic Chocolate Ice Cream Pint
  Chocolate ice cream made with melted 72% chocolate. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $14.00
- Earl Grey Fudge Ice Cream Pint
  Earl grey tea infused ice cream with a generous ripple of house made fudge. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $12.00
- Honey Lavender Ice Cream Pint
  Honey ice cream made with local honey and gently infused with lavender. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pint
  Caramel ice cream made with just enough sea salt to enhance its rich flavor. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Matcha Cookie Ice Cream Pint
  Matcha ice cream chock full of our very own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.
  $12.00
- Strawberry Ice Cream Pint
  A childhood favorite made only with pureed strawberries---never any artificial colors or flavors. Contains Milk;
  $12.00
- Malted Cookie Ice Cream Pint
  Our #1 seller from day 1! Malted milk ice cream swirled with our housemade sea salt chocolate chip cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy
  $12.00
- Alfajores 'N' Cream Ice Cream Pint
  Sweet Cream ice cream with Alfajores cookies---light buttery cookies filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut. Contains Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Coconut)
  $12.00
- Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint
  Creamy lemon olive oil ice cream made with lemon-infused Sicilian olive oil. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Pint
  Jet black ice cream made with activated charcoal and cocoa powder. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Golfeados
  Based on the addictive Venezuelan pastry that is similar to (but BETTER!) than a Cinnamon Bun! Cotija Cheese ice cream (yes, that's the same cheese you often find atop your tacos) with Panela Caramel Sauce (a solid, unrefined cane sugar popular in Latin American countries) and pieces of anise spiced bunContains Milk, Eggs, Wheat
  $14.00
- Specialty Pint: Berg's Caraway Crunch
  This flavor is made in collaboration with Berg's Smoked Meat in Belmar, NJ which serves up Montreal Smoked Meat and Poutine. Bright Caraway ice cream sweetened with brown sugar and chock full of crunchy, all-butter Smoked Meat Toffee pieces. Contains Milk
  $14.00
- Specialty Pint: Cafe Au Lait
  Made with the Commander's Palace blend from New Orlean's based coffee company, French Truck Coffee. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Carmen Rosa's Dominican Cake
  Almond ice cream with our own Guavea Jam, blue meringue crumble and pieces of fluffy, buttery Dominican Cake from Carmen Rosa's Bakery in Jersey City. Contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Tree Nuts (Almonds)
  $14.00
- Specialty Pint: Mint Chip
  Pale green Mint ice cream with tiny dark chocolate flecks. Contains Milk, Soy
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Cookies 'N' Cream
  Sweat Cream ice cream with our own chocolate cream-filled cookie pieces. Contains Wheat, Milk, Soy
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Banana Bread
  Brown Sugar Banana ice cream chock full of the super famous Banana Bread from Dames Coffee Shop right here in Jersey City. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs
  $12.00
Single Serve Non-Dairy
- Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy Mint Chip
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Mint Chip---a non-dairy ice cream made with Oatly Oat Milk, Mint and Vanilla extracts and dark chocolate flakes. Contains Soy.***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough---a non-dairy Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough pieces. Contains Soy, Peanuts. ***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Cookie Butter
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Cookie Butter---a non-dairy ice cream made with Cookie Butter (think crushed graham crackers and fall spices) and Soy Milk. Contains Soy, Wheat***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Pumpkin Spice
  A 6 ounce single cup made with local Pumpkin puree, fall spices and oat milk
  $8.25
Bakeshop Treats
- 1 Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies
  Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt
  $19.50
- 1 French Macaron
  Choose from Pistachio, Raspberry, Coconut, Passion Fruit, Chocolate or Birthday Sprinkle
  $3.25
- 1 Fudge Brownie
  Made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together
  $4.50
- 1 Magic Bar
  A salted graham crust covered with layers of chocolate, coconut, dulce de leche, toffee, raisins and toasted almonds. Contains wheat, milk, tree nuts (coconut and almonds)
  $4.50
- 1 Raspberry Crumb Bar
  Brown sugar shortbread crust with layers of raspberry jam and brown sugar crumb topping
  $4.50
- 1 Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie
  Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
  $1.95
- Set Of 6 Assorted French Macarons
  Six assorted flavors of French Macarons boxed in a white gift box: *****Flavors may vary according to season so please call the shop to confirm before purchase*****
  $19.50
- Set Of 6 Cupcakes
  Two Vanilla, two Chocolate and two Red Velvet cupcakes packed in a plastic clamshell
  $22.50
Merchandise
- Milk Sugar Love Mug
  A 10oz ceramic pink mug with chocolate brown logo on the front ---- perfect for a cup of hot chocolate at home! Handwash recommended.
  $9.50
- Milk Sugar Love Cooler Bag
  A chocolate brown insulated tote that carries 4 pints PLUS a reusable cold brick!
  $10.00
- Milk Sugar Love Classic T-Shirt
  Available in Small only with a hand-drawn illustration by Nanu Studios in Hoboken!
  $20.00
Ice Cream Cakes
- The Classic 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Vanilla Bean ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch, Classic Chocolate ice cream and Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy. Serves up to 8 people.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $40.00
- The Midnight Cookie 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Cookies 'n' Cream ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Midnight Cookie ice cream with specialty sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $40.00
- The Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy 6 Ice Cream Cake
  A 6 cake made with two giant French macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs, Soy.NEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- Super Sammie Ice Cream Cake
  Vanilla Bean ice cream rolled in rainbow sprinkles and sandwiched between 2 Giant chocolate chip cookies!Contains Milk, Eggs, Soy, WheatNEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- MatchaBerry 6 Ice Cream Cake
  Layers of Matcha Cookie ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch and Strawberry ice cream topped with our own Chocolate Cream filled cookie pieces. Contains Milk, Wheat, SoyNEED AN INSCRIPTION? Please add on a sugar paste plaque so we can write on your cake!
  $45.00
- Sugar Paste Message Plaque
  A sugar paste plaque (it's completely edible!) inscribed with your custom message in edible ink. Let us know your special message so we can inscribe it for you!*MAX NUMBER OF CHARACTERS: 21*
  $5.00
- Box Of Candles
  $5.00
- Mini Celebration Ice Cream Cake: Vanilla Bean
  A 12oz mini cake made with Vanilla Bean ice cream, rolled in classic rainbow sprinkles and topped with frosting. Contains Milk.
  $12.50
Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Coffee Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two handmade Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with our Parlor Coffee Ice Cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
  $6.75
- Birthday Sprinkle Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two Confetti Sugar Cookies filled with Vanilla ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs.
  $6.75
- Red Velvet Dream Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two handmade Red Velvet White Chocolate cookies filled with Cream Cheese ice cream. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy.
  $6.75
- Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy Ice Cream Sandwich
  Two Fruity Cereal French Macarons filled with Fruity Cereal ice cream and rolled in Fruity Cereal. Contains Milk, Tree Nuts (Almonds), Eggs.
  $8.00
Ice Cream Pints
- Alfajores 'N' Cream Ice Cream Pint
  Sweet Cream ice cream with Alfajores cookies---light buttery cookies filled with dulce de leche and rolled in coconut. Contains Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Tree Nuts (Coconut)
  $12.00
- Classic Chocolate Ice Cream Pint
  Chocolate ice cream made with melted 72% chocolate. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $14.00
- Earl Grey Fudge Ice Cream Pint
  Earl grey tea infused ice cream with a generous ripple of house made fudge. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $12.00
- Guava Cream Cheese Ice Cream Pint
  Cream Cheese ice cream with our own Guava ripple. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Honey Lavender Ice Cream Pint
  Honey ice cream made with local honey and gently infused with lavender. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint
  Creamy lemon olive oil ice cream made with lemon-infused Sicilian olive oil. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Malted Cookie Ice Cream Pint
  Our #1 seller from day 1! Malted milk ice cream swirled with our housemade sea salt chocolate chip cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Eggs, Soy
  $12.00
- Matcha Cookie Ice Cream Pint
  Matcha ice cream chock full of our very own handmade chocolate cream-filled cookies. Contains Milk, Wheat, Soy.
  $12.00
- Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Pint
  Jet black ice cream made with activated charcoal and cocoa powder. Contains Milk, Soy.
  $12.00
- Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pint
  Caramel ice cream made with just enough sea salt to enhance its rich flavor. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Strawberry Ice Cream Pint
  A childhood favorite made only with pureed strawberries---never any artificial colors or flavors. Contains Milk;
  $12.00
- Specialty Pint: Cafe Au Lait
  Made with the Commander's Palace blend from New Orlean's based coffee company, French Truck Coffee. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
- Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint
  America's favorite flavor, made with real vanilla bean seeds and pure vanilla extract. Contains Milk.
  $12.00
Single Serve Non-Dairy
- Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy Mint Chip
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Mint Chip---a non-dairy ice cream made with Oatly Oat Milk, Mint and Vanilla extracts and dark chocolate flakes. Contains Soy.***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough---a non-dairy Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough pieces. Contains Soy, Peanuts. ***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Cookie Butter
  A 6 ounce pre-packed cup of Non-Dairy Cookie Butter---a non-dairy ice cream made with Cookie Butter (think crushed graham crackers and fall spices) and Soy Milk. Contains Soy, Wheat***Milk Sugar Love is not an allergen-free facility and cannot guarantee the absence of any of the 9 major allergens indicated by the FDA: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, sesame and soybeans.***
  $8.25
- Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Pumpkin Spice
  A 6 ounce single cup made with local Pumpkin puree, fall spices and oat milk
  $8.25
Bakeshop Treats
- 1 Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies
  Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt
  $19.50
- 1 French Macaron
  Choose from Pistachio, Raspberry, Coconut, Passion Fruit, Chocolate or Birthday Sprinkle
  $3.25
- 1 Fudge Brownie
  Made with Cocoa Powder and melted chocolate and just enough flour to hold it all together
  $4.50
- 1 Magic Bar
  A salted graham crust covered with layers of chocolate, coconut, dulce de leche, toffee, raisins and toasted almonds. Contains wheat, milk, tree nuts (coconut and almonds)
  $4.50
- 1 Raspberry Crumb Bar
  Brown sugar shortbread crust with layers of raspberry jam and brown sugar crumb topping
  $4.50
- 1 Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie
  Our #1 seller since day one, made with milk and dark chocolates and a sprinkling of sea salt. Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
  $1.95
- Set Of 6 Assorted French Macarons
  Six assorted flavors of French Macarons boxed in a white gift box: *****Flavors may vary according to season so please call the shop to confirm before purchase*****
  $19.50
- Set Of 6 Cupcakes
  Two Vanilla, two Chocolate and two Red Velvet cupcakes packed in a plastic clamshell
  $22.50
Hot Chocolate and More
- Hot Chocolate
  Your choice of milk blended with our own Hot Chocolate Syrup. Don't forget to add one of our handmade Vanilla Bean Marshmallows!
  $6.00
- Affagato Sundae: The Classic
  One 4oz scoop of ice cream (1 flavor only, your choice) drowned in a shot of espresso
  $6.75
- Affogato Sundae: The Frozen Irish
  One 4oz scoop of Vanilla Bean ice cream drowned in espresso and whiskey and coffee liqueur, topped with chocolate flakes and handmade whipped cream
  $8.75
- Affogato Sundae: The Salty Sweet
  One 4oz scoop of Salted Caramel ice cream drowned in espresso and Salted Caramel Sauce with candied almonds and handmade whipped cream
  $8.75

Menu Gallery

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Privacy

Terms

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop Menu

King Cake

King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday January 25

King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 1

King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 8

King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 15

King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday February 22

King Cake Pre-Order: Saturday March 1

Ice Cream Scoops

1 Scoop

2 Scoops

Handmade Cone On The Side

Ice Cream Sandwiches

Coffee Chip Ice Cream Sandwich

Birthday Sprinkle Ice Cream Sandwich

Red Velvet Dream Ice Cream Sandwich

Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy Ice Cream Sandwich

Gingerbread Sandwich

Frozen Treats

Cold Brew Float

Make-Your-Own Ice Cream Sandwich

Milkshake

Puppy Froyo

Root Beer Float

Sprinkles On The Side

Sundae

Bakeshop Treats

1 Dozen Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies

1 French Macaron

1 Fudge Brownie

1 Magic Bar

1 Raspberry Crumb Bar

1 Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookie

Set Of 6 Assorted French Macarons

Set Of 6 Cupcakes

Ice Cream Cakes

The Classic 6 Ice Cream Cake

The Midnight Cookie 6 Ice Cream Cake

The Fruity Cereal Mac Daddy 6 Ice Cream Cake

Super Sammie Ice Cream Cake

MatchaBerry 6 Ice Cream Cake

Mini Celebration Ice Cream Cake: Vanilla Bean

Sugar Paste Message Plaque

Box Of Candles

Carrot Cake 6 Ice Cream Cake

Ice Cream Pints

Alfajores 'N' Cream Ice Cream Pint

Classic Chocolate Ice Cream Pint

Earl Grey Fudge Ice Cream Pint

Guava Cream Cheese Ice Cream Pint

Honey Lavender Ice Cream Pint

Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream Pint

Malted Cookie Ice Cream Pint

Matcha Cookie Ice Cream Pint

Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Pint

Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pint

Strawberry Ice Cream Pint

Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint

Sugar Cone On The Side

Specialty Pint: Golfeados

Specialty Pint: Berg's Caraway Crunch

Specialty Pint: Carmen Rosa's Dominican Cake

Specialty Pint: Banana Bread

Specialty Pint: Mint Chip

Specialty Pint: Cafe Au Lait

Specialty Pint: Cookies 'N' Cream

Single Serve Non-Dairy

Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy Mint Chip

Single Serve Cup: Non Dairy PB Chocolate Cookie Dough

Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Cookie Butter

Single Serve Cup: Non-Dairy Pumpkin Spice

Coffee Drinks

Cold Brew

Espresso

Latte

Hot Chocolate and More

Hot Chocolate

Affagato Sundae: The Classic

Merchandise

Milk Sugar Love Mug