Mileto's Sub Shop and pizza in Newberry Menu

4.6
(500+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Famous Pounder Cheesesteak

      An entire pound of chipped sirloin, seasoned to perfection on a whole! And a half pound on a half sub!
      $8.75
    • Funnel Cake Fries

      Funnel Cake Fries topped with powdered sugar
      $6.50
    • Turkey Breast

      Sliced turkey breast with options for 7" or 14", bun or no bun, cold or cosmo. Cheese selections include mozzarella to cooper sharp.
      $7.25
    • French Fries

      Crispy golden strips of deliciousness served hot and seasoned to perfection.
      $5.83
    • Italian

      Capicola, Baked Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese
      $7.25
    • Bacon Cheddar Ranch Fries or Tots

      A pile of french fries or tater tots topped with hot golden cheese, real bacon and ranch dressing! It's a whole meal!
      $8.95
    • 4 Mozzarella Sticks

      Crispy breaded mozzarella sticks with a golden exterior and a gooey cheese center. Four pieces per serving.
      $5.83
    • Three Cheese Steak

      Our Famous Cheesesteak with American, Provolone and Aged Cheddar Sauce! Any toppings you would like! So cheesy and delicious! Garden will be on top of this and cheese on the very bottom. It is very juicy so please know this ahead, since the cheese is on the bottom!
      $11.75
    • Chicken Cheesesteak

      Half pound of seasoned white meat chicken on a half. Whole pound of meat on a whole.
      $8.75
    • Middleswarth

      We reserve the right to substitute if choice is unavailable.
      $1.19+
  • Pretzel roll sandwich

    • Pretzel roll cheesesteak

      Tender slices of beef, melted cheese, and savory seasonings nestled in a soft pretzel roll.
      $9.65
    • Pretzel roll breakfast sandwich

      Sausage egg and cheese on a pretzel roll. Sausage
      $7.95
    • Pretzel ham sandwich

      Ham and cheese on a pretzel roll.
      $9.25
    • Pretzel roll cheeseburger

      Cheeseburger on a pretzel roll
      $9.85
  • Gluten free subs

    Get any sub on a gluten free sub roll.
    • Cheesesteak - gluten free

      Sliced beef with melted cheese and onions, served in a gluten-free sub roll.
      $19.00
    • Ham sub - gluten free

      $17.00
    • Turkey - gluten free

      $17.00
    • Regular -gluten free

      Thinly sliced deli meat, crisp lettuce, fresh tomato slices, and onions on a gluten-free sub roll.
      $17.00
    • Italian -gluten free

      $17.00
  • Footlong hot dogs

    • Chili cheese footlong hot dog

      Chili cheese footlong hot dog. Home made chili and yellow shredded cheese.
      $7.50
    • Footlong hot dog

      A footlong hot dog topped with mustard and ketchup on a soft bun.
      $5.75
  • Sandwiches

    • Buffalo chicken sandwich

      Chicken filet with mild sauce, ranch and American cheese.
      $9.50
    • Chicken cordon bleu

      Chicken filet with Swiss cheese melted over ham.
      $9.50
    • Reuben

      Savory corned beef layered with melted Swiss cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and creamy Russian dressing, all sandwiched between slices of marbled rye bread.
      $9.50
  • Cheeseburgers

    • Bacon cheeseburger

      Juicy beef patty topped with crispy bacon, melted cheese, shredded lettuce, and a dollop of ketchup and mayo.
      $8.50
    • Toasted cheeseburger

      2 toasted cheese sandwiches with burger in the middle.
      $9.25
    • Cheeseburger

      Juicy beef patty topped with melted cheese, fresh lettuce, and a hint of ketchup, all nestled in a soft bun.
      $8.00
    • Jacked up burger

      Burger with fried onions and peppers topped with pepper jack cheese.
      $9.50
    • Swiss burger

      Burger with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, and fried onions.
      $9.25
    • Pizza burger

      Burger with sauce, pepperoni, and provolone cheese.
      $9.25
    • Western burger

      Burger with yellow cheddar cheese with an onion ring with barbecue sauce over the top.
      $9.00
  • With a Fork

    Salads
    • Chef Salad

      Ham, Turkey, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Hard Boiled Egg. Your choice of dressing. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.
      $10.50
    • Tuna Salad

      Tuna on a bed of lettuce, tomato and onion with provolone cheese. Your choice of dressing. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.
      $7.50
    • Chicken Cheesesteak Salad

      Lettuce, Tomato and fried onion topped with 8oz of seasoned chicken and american cheese. Your choice of dressing. Served with or without french fries on top. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.
      $9.00
    • Cheesesteak Salad

      Lettuce, Tomato and fried onion topped with 8oz of seasoned sirloin and american cheese. Your choice of dressing. Served with or without french fries on top. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.
      $8.75
    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      8oz of Delicious Grilled Chicken Breast Strips atop Lettuce, Tomato and Onion topped with a Shredded Mozzarella and Provolone Cheese blend and your choice of dressing!
      $8.75
    • Tossed Salad

      Lettuce, tomato and onion with provolone cheese and your choice of dressing. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette,Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.
      $6.95
  • Finger Foods

    Fryer Food
    • Kid's Nugget Basket

      6 piece chicken nuggets and tater tots or fries meal.
      $7.88
    • Chicken Tenders Basket

      3 Large white meat chicken tenders and a large order of french fries.
      $11.60
    • Beer Battered Haddock Basket

      8oz Beer Battered Haddock served with a pile of French Fries and a side of Tarter Sauce.
      $12.66
    • French Fries

      Crispy golden strips of deliciousness served hot and seasoned to perfection.
      $5.83
    • French Fries with Cheese

      Crispy French fries lavishly topped with melted cheese.
      $6.36
    • Bacon Cheddar Ranch Fries or Tots

      A pile of french fries or tater tots topped with hot golden cheese, real bacon and ranch dressing! It's a whole meal!
      $8.95
    • Tater Tots

      Crispy golden tots, perfect for dipping. A comforting classic side dish.
      $5.83
    • Tater Tots with Cheese

      $6.36
    • Chicken Nuggets (6)

      $4.25
    • Chicken Tenders (4)

      large breaded tenders!
      $6.75
    • Plain or Hot Wing Dings/ 4 or 8 piece

      Breaded drums and flats, hot or plain.
      $5.50
    • 4 Mozzarella Sticks

      Crispy breaded mozzarella sticks with a golden exterior and a gooey cheese center. Four pieces per serving.
      $5.83
    • Fried Mushrooms

      Crispy Golden-Battered Mushrooms
      $5.50
    • Fried Cauliflower

      Crisp and delicious cauliflower florets
      $5.83
    • Fried Pickle Chips

      $5.50
    • Mac & Cheese Bites

      Crispy bites filled with creamy macaroni and cheese, a perfect appetizer or snack.
      $5.83
    • Corn Nuggets

      Golden fried bites of cornmeal filled with hot, creamy corn goodness.
      $5.50
    • Onion Rings

      Crispy golden-fried onion rings, perfectly seasoned for a savory crunch.
      $5.50
    • Cheese curds

      Golden, crispy cheese curds with a crunchy exterior and gooey melted cheese inside.
      $5.83
    • Pizza logs

      Crispy rolls filled with melted cheese and pepperoni, served with marinara sauce.
      $6.95
    • 6 Deep Fried Pierogies

      6 deep fried Mrs. T's Cheddar and Potato Pierogies.
      $5.83
    • Broccoli & Cheddar Bites

      Breaded & Deep Fried
      $5.83
    • Curly Fries

      Seasoned Curly Fries
      $6.36
    • Curly Fries With Cheese

      Seasoned Curly Fries with a side of Cheese Whiz
      $6.79
    • Deep Fried Oreos

      4 Gooey Pancake Battered Deep Fried Oreos topped with powdered sugar
      $7.50
    • Dozen Hot Wings

      12 hot wings, choice of flavors including mild to extra hot, garlic parm, bourbon, BBQ, tangy, mango habanero.
      $15.37
    • Funnel Cake Fries

      Funnel Cake Fries topped with powdered sugar
      $6.50
    • Shrimp basket

      Fried shrimp with fries
      $12.60
  • Kids meals

    • Chicken tenders and fries

      Crispy Chicken Strips & Golden Fries Combo
      $8.47
    • Grilled cheese and fries

      Melty grilled cheese sandwich with crispy golden fries.
      $7.47
    • Chicken nuggets and fries

      Crispy, tender chicken nuggets served with a side of golden fries.
      $7.88
  • Breakfast sandwiches

    • Bacon egg and cheese english muffin

      $6.00
    • Steak egg and cheese bagel

      Juicy steak, fried egg, and melted cheese layered inside a soft bagel.
      $6.50
    • Steak egg and cheese English muffin

      $6.25
    • Sausage egg and cheese

      Savory sausage patty, fried egg, and melted cheese nestled between a toasted English muffin.
      $6.00
    • Sausage burrito

      Soft tortilla filled with scrambled eggs, seasoned sausage, and melted cheese.
      $7.00
  • Mileto’s Staff Tip

    We appreciate all of you very much! Feel free to leave a tip that our Mileto’s staff will receive directly.
    • Kitchen Love

      $3.00
  • New and Special Menu Items!

    • Bacon Steak N' Chicken Hoagie

      A GIANT Portion of Real Bacon, Our Famous Steak and Chicken made with whiz. Any toppings you like. If you would like a different cheese please indicate.
      $12.19+
    • Pounder Cheesesteak Pizza

      A pound of our famous seasoned sirloin steak atop of a fresh baked Lycoming Bakery pizza shell! Choose any toppings you desire, whether it be in the garden with mayo, or with sauce, green peppers, fried onions and mushrooms! Or whatever you dream up! If you don't see it in the options here, put it in the notes!
      $17.95
    • Deep Fried Oreos

      4 cream filled chocolate cookies deep fried in a gooey pancake batter.
      $7.50
    • Funnel Cake Fries

      An order of a funnel cake fries topped with powdered sugar!
      $5.83
  • Cold/Cosmo Hoagies/Wraps

    All cold subs and grilled subs available in wraps: white, wheat, spinach, tomato. Half or whole. Please specify in the notes if you would like a wrap and what flavor. Some exceptions apply and if so we will send on a hoagie roll.
    • Veggie

      All vegetables any way you want it! Add options below!
      $6.25
    • Cheese

      Provolone Cheese only.
      $7.25
    • Regular

      Dutch Loaf, Chopped Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese
      $7.25
    • Italian

      Capicola, Baked Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese
      $7.25
    • Turkey Breast

      Sliced turkey breast with options for 7" or 14", bun or no bun, cold or cosmo. Cheese selections include mozzarella to cooper sharp.
      $7.25
    • Ham

      Ham wrap available in 7" half or 14" whole sizes, with or without bun. Choose cosmo (toasted) or cold. Select one cheese: mozzarella, provolone, American, Swiss, pepper jack, whiz, cooper sharp.
      $7.25
    • Tuna

      Our Tuna is made with mayo only. No onions, celery or spices added.
      $7.25
    • Meatball

      Made with Thompsons beef meatballs, Ma Mileto's original recipe homemade sauce topped with Parmesan cheese. If made as a cosmo, topped with provolone cheese. If you would like a different kind of cheese please indicate in the notes.
      $7.25
    • Canadian Bacon

      Canadian bacon wrap with options for 7" or 14", bun-less version available. Cold or toasted. Choice of mozzarella, provolone, American, Swiss, pepper jack, whiz, or cooper sharp cheese.
      $7.25
    • BLT

      Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato with all the fillings you like!
      $7.25
    • Ham & Turkey Combo

      Ham and turkey with your choice of cheese, available in 7" or 14", whole or bun-less. Opt for cold or cosmo toasted. Choose from 8 cheese options.
      $8.50
    • Roast Beef

      Roast beef wrap with cheese options including mozzarella, Swiss, and pepper jack. Served cold or toasted. Available in 7" half or 14" whole, with or without the bun.
      $8.50
    • The "Big R"

      It's HUGE! 24 oz of meat! A pile of ham, turkey and roast beef, PLUS the cheese.
      $13.25
    • Pizza Rolla

      Just like the name....Pizza on a roll!
      $7.68
    • Beer Battered Haddock Sub

      8oz on a half. 16oz on a whole.
      $9.00
    • Grinder

      A regular sub with all the fillings and more provolone cheese on top toasted to perfection.
      $7.75
    • Half Size Chicken Parm Sub

      PLEASE ADD IN NOTES IF YOU WANT BREADED OF GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST! OTHERWISE YOU WILL RECEIVE GRILLED. 8oz of chicken on a half and 16oz of chicken on a whole. On a toasted garlic hoagie roll with mozzarella cheese, homemade sauce and pesto. If you do not want pesto, please add that in the notes.
      $8.50
    • Mixed Cheese

      Perfect blend of provolone, swiss and american cheeses! Tastes amazing as a cosmo!
      $8.21
    • Whole Size Chicken Parm Sub

      PLEASE ADD IN NOTES IF YOU WANT BREADED OF GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST! OTHERWISE YOU WILL RECEIVE GRILLED. 8oz of chicken on a half and 16oz of chicken on a whole. On a toasted garlic hoagie roll with mozzarella cheese, homemade sauce and pesto. If you do not want pesto, please add that in the notes.
      $16.50
    • Don father

      Italian sub cosmo with pepper jack cheese
      $8.50
  • From the Grill

    All cold subs and grilled subs available in wraps: white, wheat, spinach, tomato. Half or whole. Please specify in the notes if you would like a wrap and what flavor. Some exceptions apply and if so we will send on a hoagie roll.
    • Famous Pounder Cheesesteak

      An entire pound of chipped sirloin, seasoned to perfection on a whole! And a half pound on a half sub!
      $8.75
    • Three Cheese Steak

      Our Famous Cheesesteak with American, Provolone and Aged Cheddar Sauce! Any toppings you would like! So cheesy and delicious! Garden will be on top of this and cheese on the very bottom. It is very juicy so please know this ahead, since the cheese is on the bottom!
      $11.75
    • Chicken Cheesesteak

      Half pound of seasoned white meat chicken on a half. Whole pound of meat on a whole.
      $8.75
    • Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

      8 oz. on a half. 16oz on a whole. We use franks red hot!
      $8.75
    • Cheeseburger

      8oz on a half. 16oz on a whole. We chop our burger meat to fit the hoagie roll.
      $8.75
    • Canadian Bacon Cheesesteak

      Our famous pounder cheesesteak mixed with canadian bacon! Flavor bursting!!!
      $11.75
    • Half Size Boss Burger

      All beef burger on a toasted bun. You get 8oz on a half and 16oz on a whole plus bacon! Includes 3 cheeses! Cooper cheese, american cheese and whiz! Topped with onion rings, mayo and bbq sauce. Its HUGE and absolutely delicious!
      $12.95
    • Canadian Bacon Cheeseburger

      Delicious Thompsons Cheeseburger mixed with canadian bacon! It's SO GOOD!
      $11.75
    • Whole Size Boss Burger

      All beef burger on a toasted bun. You get 8oz on a half and 16oz on a whole plus bacon! Includes 3 cheeses! Cooper cheese, american cheese and whiz! Topped with onion rings, mayo and bbq sauce. Its HUGE and absolutely delicious!
      $24.95
    • Bacon Burger

      Juicy beef patty topped with crispy bacon and melted cheese, served with a side of golden fries.
      $9.95
    • Hot Sausage

      Spicy Italian Sausage, chopped to perfection! 10oz on a half. 20oz on a whole.
      $8.75
    • Bacon Cheeseburger

      On a hoagie roll! Half or whole!
      $12.19
    • Cheeseburger

      8oz on a half. 16oz on a whole. we chop our burger meat to fit the hoagie roll.
      $8.75
    • The tango (chicken & beef cheesesteaks)

      $9.26
    • Taco cheesesteak

      Seasoned ground beef, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, and melted cheese wrapped in a soft tortilla.
      $9.00
  • Wraps

    Choose from White, Wheat, Tomato and Spinach. Cold and grill options available, choose from list. Prices vary.
    • Famous Cheesesteak

      A half pound of chipped sirloin steak seasoned to perfection.
      $8.49
    • Chicken Cheesesteak

      Half Pound of delicious seasoned white meat chicken. (Grilled Breast Strips or Traditional Chicken Cheesesteak Option)
      $8.49
    • Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

      Half Pound of seasoned white meat chicken grilled in Frank's Red Hot Sauce.
      $8.49
    • Cheeseburger Sub

      10oz of seasoned ground beef.
      $11.75
    • Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

      Ground seasoned burger mixed with real bacon pieces, so juicy!
      $14.75
    • Canadian Bacon Cheesesteak

      Our Famous Cheesesteak grilled with canadian bacon.....flavor bursting.
      $14.75
    • Canadian Bacon Cheeseburger

      Ground burger grilled with canadian bacon. It's SOOOOO good!
      $14.75
    • Hot Sausage Sub

      10oz Hot Italian Sausage Patties Chopped to fit a hoagie roll or wrap.
      $9.39
    • Veggie Wrap

      Fresh vegetables in a choice of white, wheat, tomato, or spinach wrap. Select from eight cheese options, including mozzarella, provolone, and Swiss.
      $5.89
    • Ham

      Ham wrapped in choice of white, wheat, tomato, or spinach wrap. Available cheeses: mozzarella, provolone, American, Swiss, pepper jack, whiz, cooper sharp.
      $7.09
    • Turkey Breast

      Turkey breast wrap with choices of white, wheat, tomato, or spinach wrap. Select one cheese: mozzarella, provolone, American, Swiss, pepper jack, whiz, or cooper sharp.
      $7.09
    • Tuna

      Our Tuna is made with mayo only. No onions, celery or added spices.
      $7.09
    • Italian

      Capicola, Baked Ham, Salami and Provolone Cheese.
      $7.09
    • Regular

      Dutch Loaf, Chopped Ham, Salami and Provolone Cheese
      $7.09
    • Ham & Turkey Combo

      Ham and turkey slices with choice of cheese, encased in a flavored wrap selected from white, wheat, tomato, or spinach options.
      $11.75
    • BLT

      Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato and whatever other toppings you would like!
      $7.09
    • Roast Beef

      Roast beef in choice of white, wheat, tomato, or spinach wrap. Option of mozzarella, provolone, American, Swiss, pepper jack, whiz, or cooper sharp cheese.
      $11.75
    • The 'Big R'

      It's HUGE! 24 oz of ham, turkey and roast beef PLUS the cheese.
      $16.75
    • Mixed Cheese

      Swiss, American and Provolone Cheese
      $7.39
    • Cheese

      Provolone Cheese Only
      $7.09
    • Canadian Bacon

      Cold
      $14.75
  • Pizza

    Pizza dough from Lycoming Bakery. Don Pepino Pizza Sauce. Blend of Mozzarella and Provolone Cheeses.
    • 12" Large Pizza

      A 12-inch large pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a thin crust.
      $10.95
    • Mini 6" Personal Pizza

      $5.95
    • Large Italian Hoagie Pizza

      An amazing creation! Italian hoagie meat (capicola, ham, salami and provolone) on a pizza. Simple and so delicious! Top it with all the hoagie toppings you want, it's great with sauce, mayo, hot peppers, whatever you like!
      $17.95
  • Chips/Soda/Chocolate Milk

    We carry a variety of Lays, Middleswarth, Pepsi and Gallikers Chocolate Milk.
    • Middleswarth

      We reserve the right to substitute if choice is unavailable.
      $1.19+
    • Valley farms chocolate milk

      Pints and Quarts Available
      $3.00

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Finish Line Cafe
Finish Line Cafe
4.0
(87 Reviews)
Bar
Good Grace African Restaurant
Good Grace African Restaurant
4.8
(27 Reviews)
Restaurant
Riepstine's Pub
Riepstine's Pub
4.6
(212 Reviews)
Brewpub, Brewery
Dunkin'
Dunkin'
4.0
(744 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Bagel shop, Breakfast
Newberry Hotel
Newberry Hotel
4.0
(124 Reviews)
Bar
Subway
Subway
4.0
(153 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Newberry Sub Shop
Newberry Sub Shop
4.5
(627 Reviews)
Cheesesteak, Hoagie, Pizza
Hotel Kast
Hotel Kast
4.3
(353 Reviews)
Gastropub, Bar & grill
UpTop Cafe
UpTop Cafe
4.6
(39 Reviews)
Restaurant

(570) 323-0103

2127 W 4th St, Williamsport, PA 17701


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms