Mikey's Late Night Slice Menu

4.4
(2,600+ Reviews)
  • Slices!

    • Slice of Plain-Ass Pepperoni*

      A generous layer of Pepperoni, sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
      $5.90
      Slice of Plain-Ass Pepperoni*
    • Slice of Spicy-Ass Pepperoni*

      Pepperoni and Banana Peppers, laced with Sriracha Sauce and Red Pepper Flakes.
      $5.90
      Slice of Spicy-Ass Pepperoni*
    • Slice of Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic*

      Generous heapings of Mushrooms with a sprinkling of Roasted Garlic.
      $5.65
      Slice of Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic*
    • Slice of Cheese w/ Fresh Basil*

      Our classic cheese pizza. Subtly flavored with, you guessed it... fresh Basil Leaves.
      $5.65
      Slice of Cheese w/ Fresh Basil*
    • Slice POW Bada Bing BADA BOOM

      Pizza-of-the-Week: Bada Bing BADA BOOM! Our most decadent pizza yet! Italian Beef, Fresh Basil, and Creamy White Mac & Cheese atop our Classic Red Marinara Sauce. Be sure to wear something stretchy around the waist. Like maybe a track suit.
      $5.90
      Slice POW Bada Bing BADA BOOM
    • Slice of Vegan BBQ Chicken*

      Vegan BBQ Chick’n and Vegan Ranch, with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $5.90
      Slice of Vegan BBQ Chicken*
    • Slice of Vegan Pepperoni*

      (Somehow) Meatless Pepperoni with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $5.90
      Slice of Vegan Pepperoni*
  • Whole Pies!

    • Whole Plain-Ass Pepperoni

      A generous layer of Pepperoni, sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
      $29.90
      Whole Plain-Ass Pepperoni
    • Whole Spicy-Ass Pepperoni

      Pepperoni and Banana Peppers, laced with Sriracha Sauce and Red Pepper Flakes.
      $29.90
      Whole Spicy-Ass Pepperoni
    • Whole Cheese w/Fresh Basil

      Our Classic Cheese Pizza. Subtly flavored with fresh Basil leaves.
      $29.90
      Whole Cheese w/Fresh Basil
    • Whole Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic

      A healthy portion of mushroom with roasted garlic sprinkled throughout.
      $29.90
      Whole Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic
    • Whole POW Bada Bing BADA BOOM

      Pizza-of-the-Week: Bada Bing BADA BOOM! Our most decadent pizza yet! Italian Beef, Fresh Basil, and Creamy White Mac & Cheese atop our Classic Red Marinara Sauce. Be sure to wear something stretchy around the waist. Like maybe a track suit.
      $29.90
      Whole POW Bada Bing BADA BOOM
    • Whole Vegan Pepperoni

      (Somehow) Meatless Pepperoni with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $29.90
      Whole Vegan Pepperoni
    • Whole Vegan BBQ Chick'n

      Vegan Chick’n tossed in sweet BBQ sauce with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $29.90
      Whole Vegan BBQ Chick'n
    • Whole Build-Your-Own

      Sometimes, you want it your way. Let's make a pizza together!
      $28.65
      Whole Build-Your-Own
    • Whole THICC-Ass Pepperoni

      Sometimes, regular pepperoni just isn’t meaty enough to satisfy you. For those days we have this unbelievably meaty pizza, made with old world style “cup & char” pepperoni, that will MEAT all of your expectations.
      $31.84
      Whole THICC-Ass Pepperoni
    • Whole Mikey's Favorite

      Mikey likes Pepperoni, Banana Peppers, and Mushrooms on his pizza. That's what's up.
      $31.84
      Whole Mikey's Favorite
    • Whole P.M.S.

      Extra Strength Pepperoni, Mushrooms, and Sausage.
      $31.84
      Whole P.M.S.
    • Whole Weggie

      Grabs you by the Green Peppers, Red Onions, Mushrooms, and Tomatoes, and pulls.
      $31.84
      Whole Weggie
    • Whole Garbàge

      An absolute mess of everything we have in the kitchen: Pepperoni, Sausage, Fresh Basil, Cheese, Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, Red Onions, and MORE Cheese.
      $31.84
      Whole Garbàge
    • Whole Kowalski

      Pepperoni AND Sausage! MEAT on MEAT!
      $31.84
      Whole Kowalski
    • Whole Vegan Cheese w/ Fresh Basil

      Everything you love about our Cheese w/ Fresh Basil, except we sub Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese on it,
      $31.84
      Whole Vegan Cheese w/ Fresh Basil
    • Whole Vegan Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic

      Everything you love about our Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic except we sub in Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese on it.
      $31.84
      Whole Vegan Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic
  • Gluten Free Pies!

    • Gluten Free!*

      Our personal sized 10", DELICIOUS, Gluten-Free option gives you all the flavor of your choice of LNS pizza, without the tummyache!
      $12.99
      Gluten Free!*
    • GF BYO!*

      Our 10" Personal sized, DELICIOUS, Gluten-Free crust can be made however you would like! Let's make a pizza together!
      $11.99
      GF BYO!*
  • Extras*

    • Garlicky Breadsticks*

      The best part of our pizza is the garlicky bread stick crust.
      $5.61
      Garlicky Breadsticks*
    • Cheezy Breadsticks *

      Gooey melted cheese on our already delicious garlicky bread sticks.
      $6.71
      Cheezy Breadsticks *
    • Cinnamon Breadsticks

      Wash down all that savory pizza with our sweet Cinnamon Breadsticks, complete with a side of squeezable icing to frost it with!
      $5.61
      Cinnamon Breadsticks
    • Unicorn Bar***

      A Huge Colorful, Glittery, Gooey, Fruity, Krispy Treat.
      $5.25
      Unicorn Bar***

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Lupita’s Mexican Cuisine & Bar
Lupita’s Mexican Cuisine & Bar
4.8
(418 Reviews)
Mexican
Wanderlust Studio
Wanderlust Studio
5.0
(22 Reviews)
Live music venue
Shrimp Lips Seafood and Chicken
Shrimp Lips Seafood and Chicken
4.4
(638 Reviews)
Seafood, Restaurant
5 de mayo taqueria
5 de mayo taqueria
4.9
(71 Reviews)
Mexican
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza
3.1
(559 Reviews)
Pizza
Eight and Sand Tavern & Refuge
Eight and Sand Tavern & Refuge
4.8
(233 Reviews)
Bar & grill
Tara Hall
Tara Hall
4.6
(14 Reviews)
Bar
Hidden Leaf Cafe
Hidden Leaf Cafe
5.0
(43 Reviews)
Restaurant
Steel Mill Tavern
Steel Mill Tavern
3.9
(26 Reviews)
Bar
Mid-Ohio Kitchen at Reeb
Mid-Ohio Kitchen at Reeb
4.6
(81 Reviews)
Cafe

+1 614-737-3801

268 S 4th St, Columbus, OH 43215


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms