Mikey's Late Night Slice Menu

4.4
(1,100+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Whole Plain-Ass Pepperoni

      A generous layer of Pepperoni, sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
      $37.64
    • Slice of Plain-Ass Pepperoni*

      A generous layer of Pepperoni, sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
      $7.40
    • Cheezy Breadsticks *

      Gooey melted cheese on our already delicious garlicky bread sticks.
      $8.42
    • Slice of Cheese w/ Fresh Basil*

      Our classic cheese pizza. Subtly flavored with, you guessed it... fresh Basil Leaves.
      $7.08
    • Slice of Spicy-Ass Pepperoni*

      Pepperoni and Banana Peppers, laced with Sriracha Sauce and Red Pepper Flakes.
      $7.40
    • Whole Cheese w/Fresh Basil

      Our Classic Cheese Pizza. Subtly flavored with fresh Basil leaves.
      $37.64
    • Unicorn Bar***

      A Huge Colorful, Glittery, Gooey, Fruity, Krispy Treat.
      $5.51
    • Slice of Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic*

      Generous heapings of Mushrooms with a sprinkling of Roasted Garlic.
      $7.08
    • Whole Spicy-Ass Pepperoni

      Pepperoni and Banana Peppers, laced with Sriracha Sauce and Red Pepper Flakes.
      $37.64
    • Whole Build-Your-Own

      Sometimes, you want it your way. Let's make a pizza together!
      $36.06
    • Garlicky Breadsticks*

      The best part of our pizza is the garlicky bread stick crust.
      $7.03
    • Slice of Vegan Pepperoni*

      (Somehow) Meatless Pepperoni with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $7.40
  • Slices!*

    • Slice of Cheese w/ Fresh Basil*

      Our classic cheese pizza. Subtly flavored with, you guessed it... fresh Basil Leaves.
      $7.08
    • Slice of Vegan BBQ Chicken*

      Vegan BBQ Chick’n and Vegan Ranch, with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $7.40
    • Slice of Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic*

      Generous heapings of Mushrooms with a sprinkling of Roasted Garlic.
      $7.08
    • Slice of Vegan Pepperoni*

      (Somehow) Meatless Pepperoni with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $7.40
    • Slice POW Bada Bing BADA BOOM

      Pizza-of-the-Week: Bada Bing BADA BOOM!Our most decadent pizza yet! Italian Beef, Fresh Basil, and Creamy White Mac & Cheese atop our Classic Red Marinara Sauce. Be sure to wear something stretchy around the waist. Like maybe a track suit.
      $7.40
    • Slice of Plain-Ass Pepperoni*

      A generous layer of Pepperoni, sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
      $7.40
    • Slice of Spicy-Ass Pepperoni*

      Pepperoni and Banana Peppers, laced with Sriracha Sauce and Red Pepper Flakes.
      $7.40
  • Wholes!*

    • Whole Cheese w/Fresh Basil

      Our Classic Cheese Pizza. Subtly flavored with fresh Basil leaves.
      $37.64
    • Whole Build-Your-Own

      Sometimes, you want it your way. Let's make a pizza together!
      $36.06
    • Whole Kowalski

      Pepperoni AND Sausage! MEAT on MEAT!
      $40.08
    • Whole Vegan Pepperoni

      (Somehow) Meatless Pepperoni with Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $37.64
    • Whole Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic

      A healthy portion of mushroom with roasted garlic sprinkled throughout.
      $37.64
    • Whole THICC-Ass Pepperoni

      Sometimes, regular pepperoni just isn’t meaty enough to satisfy you. For those days we have this unbelievably meaty pizza, made with old world style “cup & char” pepperoni, that will MEAT all of your expectations.
      $40.08
    • Whole Vegan Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic

      Everything you love about our Mushroom w/ Roasted Garlic except we sub in Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese on it.
      $37.64
    • Whole Garbàge

      An absolute mess of everything we have in the kitchen: Pepperoni, Sausage, Fresh Basil, Cheese, Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, Red Onions, and MORE Cheese.
      $40.08
    • Whole POW Bada Bing BADA BOOM

      Pizza-of-the-Week: Bada Bing BADA BOOM!Our most decadent pizza yet! Italian Beef, Fresh Basil, and Creamy White Mac & Cheese atop our Classic Red Marinara Sauce. Be sure to wear something stretchy around the waist. Like maybe a track suit.
      $37.64
    • Whole Vegan Cheese w/ Fresh Basil

      Everything you love about our Cheese w/ Fresh Basil, except we sub Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese on it,
      $37.64
    • Whole Vegan BBQ Chick'n

      Vegan Chick’n tossed in sweet BBQ saucewith Selfish Cow Vegan Cheese.
      $37.64
    • Whole Mikey's Favorite

      Mikey likes Pepperoni, Banana Peppers, and Mushrooms on his pizza.
      $40.08
    • Whole P.M.S.

      Extra strength Pepperoni, Mushrooms, and Sausage.
      $40.08
    • Whole Weggie

      Grabs you by the Green Peppers, Red Onions, Mushrooms, and Tomatoes, and pulls.
      $40.08
    • Whole POW Hot Mikey's Mac

      HOT MIKEY'S UNPLUGGED: THE MAC SESSIONSEverything you love about the Hot Mikey's pizza: Nashville Hot Chicken, Ranch, and Pickles... with creamy Mac & Cheese solo!
      $37.64
    • Whole Plain-Ass Pepperoni

      A generous layer of Pepperoni, sprinkled with Parmesan Cheese.
      $37.64
    • Whole Spicy-Ass Pepperoni

      Pepperoni and Banana Peppers, laced with Sriracha Sauce and Red Pepper Flakes.
      $37.64
  • Extras!*

    • Cheezy Breadsticks *

      Gooey melted cheese on our already delicious garlicky bread sticks.
      $8.42
    • Garlicky Breadsticks*

      The best part of our pizza is the garlicky bread stick crust.
      $7.03
    • Unicorn Bar***

      A Huge Colorful, Glittery, Gooey, Fruity, Krispy Treat.
      $5.51
    • Side Unicorn Sauce!*

      Unicorn Sauce, formerly known by a more infamous name, is the same delicious tangy, smokey, and now SPICY AF, too!
      $0.50
    • Side Spicy Unicorn Sauce!*

      Straight from the 'Corn's Horn, and SPICY AF! Our latest and greatest sauce bottle is everything you love about the original Unicorn Sauce, but with a serious kick!
      $0.50
    • Side Vegan Ranch!*

      Creamy, flavorful, and tastes just like classic homemade ranch.
      $0.50
    • Bottle of Garlic Sauce!*

      Rich and creamy garlic sauce, perfect for enhancing the flavor of your pizza or dipping your crust.
      $9.49
    • Bottle of Unicorn Sauce!*

      A tangy and slightly spicy sauce, perfect for adding an extra kick to your pizza.
      $9.49
    • Side Garlic Sauce!*

      Late Night Slice's original bomb-ass buttery garlic sauce of delicious garlicky goodness that great for dipping.
      $0.50
    • Side Ranch!*

      Our magical Ranch blend of buttermilk, garlic and onion flavors mixed with mild heat of aged chiles and red peppers that adds a Bold twist to the classic ranch seasoning.
      $0.50
  • Beverages!*

    • Red Bull*

      $6.00

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Starbucks
Starbucks
3.9
(319 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Breakfast, Cafe
Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's
3.4
(275 Reviews)
Sandwich shop
White Castle
White Castle
3.8
(2,462 Reviews)
American, Hamburger, Restaurant
Fox In The Snow Cafe
Fox In The Snow Cafe
4.6
(1,085 Reviews)
Bakery, Cafe, Coffee shop
Ciao Cafe -German Village
Ciao Cafe -German Village
4.5
(44 Reviews)
Ice cream shop, Cafe, Sandwich shop
The Thurman Cafe
The Thurman Cafe
4.6
(6,370 Reviews)
Hamburger, American, Bar
German Village Coffee Shop
German Village Coffee Shop
4.7
(1,125 Reviews)
American, Breakfast, Coffee shop
South Village Grille
South Village Grille
4.6
(944 Reviews)
American, Bar
jony's sushi
jony's sushi
4.1
(61 Reviews)
Japanese
Mid City Garage
Mid City Garage
4.5
(183 Reviews)
Bar

(614) 869-0249

457 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms