Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
I95 Intersteak Hot Sandwich
Seasoned and chopped, tender ribeye, sautéed peppers and onions, topped with cheese of choice.
$15.60
Mama Mia Hot Sandwich
Homemade meatballs & marinara, melted Mozzarella, served on a garlic toasted roll.
$15.60
Lower East Side Hot Sandwich
Thinly sliced steamed corned beef, melted Swiss, sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing served on rye.
$18.00
ITALIAN PASTA
A selection of deli salad, available in medium, large, or x-large sizes.
$4.55
CANNOLI
Crispy pastry tubes filled with sweetened ricotta cheese and dotted with chocolate chips, dusted with powdered sugar.
$4.99
Chicago Beef Hot Sandwich
Thinly sliced, seasoned Italian beef dipped in au jus with a choice of mild or hot giardiniera.
$15.60
HOMEMADE PEACH COBBLER
A homemade peach cobbler with a golden-brown crust and tender peach filling.
$4.99
Coney Dog
Homemade Coney island chili sauce with minced onion.
$3.25
AMAZING BREAD PUDDING
Mrs. Collins own recipe of a bread pudding unlike any you have ever enjoyed! Sold solely at mikes other place!
$6.99
Arthur Avenue Cold Sandwich
Mortadella, hot cappy, sopressata, Genoa salami, prosciutto, Provolone, fresh Mozzarella, marinated roast red peppers, extra virgin olive oil.
$17.00
ALL NEW!!!!! JUST FOR KIDS!
Smaller sized sandwiches for Kids under 12!
6” Mini Cold Sub Combo for Kids
Mini sub just for the kids! Choice of Meat, Cheese and Toppings for $5.00
Adding chips and a drink to make it a combo!!!
$10.63
6” Mini Cold Sub for Kids
Mini sub just for the kids! Choice of Meat, Cheese and Toppings for $5.00
$6.25
SOUPS
MINESTRONE SOUP
A GREAT Vegetarian Option!
$3.90
SHRIMP & SAUSAGE GUMBOLAYA
Chicken and Sausage
$5.85
LEPRECHAUN IRISH SOUP
Cabbage, Carrots, Potatoes, and Corned Beef in a broth
$5.85
DAILY SPECIALS- APPETIZERS AND SIDES
NY KNISH
Golden-brown pastry filled with seasoned mashed potatoes, offering a savory and satisfying bite.
$5.20
ARANCINI BALLS
With Beef and Peas
$6.50
MIKE'S HOT HONEY BUFFALO WINGS
Hot honey buffalo wings. Choice of Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing. Available in quantities of 6 or 12.
$11.70
DAILY SPECIALS
Items we have listed as a special only.
THE SPRING CHICKEN
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Marinated Roasted Red Peppers, Shredded Lettuce, and Italian Dressing, served on our Toasted Kaiser Roll
$15.60
TERIYAKI CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK
Our Original Chicken Cheesesteak with Sauteed Peppers and Onions, Teriyaki Sauce, and your Choice of Cheese. Served on an 8" Garlic Toasted Amoroso Roll
$15.60
HOUSE SALADS
Chef Salad
Ham, salami, turkey, provolone, romaine mix, cucumber, tomatoes.
$16.25
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine mix, grilled chicken, black olives, croutons, shredded Parmesan.
$16.25
Garden Salad
Romaine mix, cucumbers, red onions, tomatoes.
$10.38
COLD SANDWICHES
Comes with your choice of bread and toppings.
Arthur Avenue Cold Sandwich
Mortadella, hot cappy, sopressata, Genoa salami, prosciutto, Provolone, fresh Mozzarella, marinated roast red peppers, extra virgin olive oil.
$17.00
Arthur Avenue Cold Sandwich Combo
Mortadella, hot cappy, soppressata, Genoa salami, prosciutto, Provolone, fresh Mozzarella, marinated roast red peppers, extra virgin olive oil.
$22.00
Rockefeller Cold Sandwich
Virginia ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, Provolone.
$16.25
Rockefeller Cold Sandwich Combo
Virginia ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, Provolone.
$18.00
Jersey Classic Cold Sandwich
Boiled ham, Genoa salami, provolone.
$13.65
Jersey Classic Cold Sandwich Combo
Boiled ham, Genoa salami, Provolone.
$18.00
American Classic
Turkey, roast beef, cheddar cheese, and crispy bacon, with choice of toppings
$17.00
American Classic Sandwich Combo
Turkey, roast beef, cheddar cheese, and crispy bacon, with choice of toppings
$22.00
Pocono Cold Sandwich
Turkey breast with choice of cheese.
$13.65
Pocono Cold Sandwich Combo
Turkey breast with choice of cheese.
$18.00
The Ocala
Medium rare roast beef and choice of cheese and toppings
$18.85
The Ocala Sandwich Combo
Medium rare roast beef and choice of cheese and toppings
$23.40
BLT Sandwich
Crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato with mayonnaise on choice of toast
$12.35
BLT Sandwich Combo
Crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato with mayonnaise on choice of toast
$16.90
Jersey Club Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast, crispy bacon, choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$15.58
Jersey Club Sandwich Combo
Grilled chicken breast, crispy bacon, lettuce, choice of cheese, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$20.00
Long Branch Cold Sandwich
Chicken salad.
$12.98
Long Branch Cold Sandwich Combo
Chicken salad.
$17.50
Atlantic Cold Sandwich
Tuna salad.
$12.98
Atlantic Cold Sandwich Combo
Tuna salad.
$17.50
HOT SANDWICHES
I95 Intersteak Hot Sandwich
Seasoned and chopped, tender ribeye, sautéed peppers and onions, topped with cheese of choice.
$15.60
I95 Intersteak Hot Sandwich Combo
Seasoned and chopped, tender ribeye, sautéed peppers & onions, topped with cheese of choice.
$20.15
Betsy Ross Hot Sandwich
Seasoned and chopped chicken breast, sautéed peppers, and onions, topped with cheese of choice. Served on a garlic toasted roll
$15.60
Betsy Ross Hot Sandwich Combo
Seasoned and chopped chicken breast, sautéed peppers & onions, topped with cheese of choice.Served on a garlic toasted roll
$20.15
Chicago Beef Hot Sandwich
Thinly sliced, seasoned Italian beef dipped in au jus with a choice of mild or hot giardiniera.
$15.60
Chicago Beef Hot Sandwich Combo
Thinly sliced, seasoned Italian beef dipped in au jus with choice of mild or hot giardiniera.
$20.15
Al Capone Hot Sandwich
A Chicago beef sandwich adding grilled Italian sausage, sautéed green peppers, and Provolone.
$18.00
Al Capone Hot Sandwich Combo
A Chicago beef sandwich adding grilled Italian sausage, sautéed green peppers, and Provolone.
$22.75
Turnpike Hot Sandwich
Mild Italian sausage, sautéed peppers, and onions, on a garlic toasted roll.
$14.95
Turnpike Hot Sandwich Combo
Mild Italian sausage, sautéed peppers, and onions, on a garlic toasted roll.
$19.50
Mama Mia Hot Sandwich
Homemade meatballs & marinara, melted Mozzarella, served on a garlic toasted roll.
$15.60
Mama Mia Hot Sandwich Combo
Homemade meatballs & marinara, melted Mozzarella, served on a garlic toasted roll.
$20.15
Lower East Side Hot Sandwich
Thinly sliced steamed corned beef, melted Swiss, sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing served on rye.
$18.00
Lower East Side Hot Sandwich Combo
Thinly sliced steamed corned beef, melted Swiss, sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing served on rye.
$22.75
Midtown Hot Sandwich
Thinly sliced, steamed corned beef, Swiss cheese, and spicy mustard on rye.
$18.00
Midtown Hot Sandwich Combo
Thinly sliced, steamed corned beef, Swiss cheese, and spicy mustard on rye.
$22.75
5th Avenue
Thinly sliced, steamed Pastrami. Swiss Cheese, and Spicy Mustard on thick cut Rye bread
$18.00
5th Avenue Sandwich Combo
Thinly sliced, steamed Pastrami, Swiss cheese, and Spicy Mustard on thick cut rye bread
$22.75
Upper East Side
A combination of thinly sliced and steamed Corned Beef and Pastrami, with Sauerkraut and melted Swiss, then topped with 1000 Island dressing, served on toasted thick cut Rye bread.
$18.00
Upper East Side Sandwich combo
A combination of thinly sliced and steamed Corned Beef and Pastrami, with Sauerkraut and melted Swiss, then topped with 1000 Island dressing, served on toasted thick cut Rye bread.
$22.75
Parkway Sandwich
Griddle cooked Taylor ham, Fried Egg, & Yellow American Cheese. Served on a Buttered and Toasted Kaiser (Hard) Roll. You may add salt, pepper, ketchup, etc.
$14.28
Parkway Sandwich Combo
Griddle cooked Taylor ham, Fried Egg, & Yellow American Cheese. Served on a Buttered and Toasted Kaiser (Hard) Roll. You may add salt, pepper, ketchup, etc.
$18.83
SPECIALTY HOT DOGS
Natural casing sabrett or 1/4 lb beefdogs.
Jersey Dog
Plain ‘ole dog.
$2.60
NY Dog
Kraut.
$3.25
Coney Dog
Homemade Coney island chili sauce with minced onion.
$3.25
Rest Stop Dog
Coney chili, and cheese sauce.
$4.55
Pushcart Dog
Sabrett red onion sauce.
$3.25
All American Dog
Cheese sauce and bacon.
$4.55
Carolina Dog
Slaw and bacon.
$4.55
Ohio Dog
Slaw and Coney chili sauce.
$4.55
Spicy Garden Dog
Spicy. Hot giardiniera and sport peppers.
$3.25
Chicago Dog
Pickle, tomato, green relish, raw onion, sport peppers, celery salt on a poppy roll.
$4.55
Italian Stallion Dog
1/4 lb dog only. Sautéed peppers, onions, and Italian potatoes served on a garlic toasted roll.
$9.00
South Amboy Dog
1/4 lb dog only. Griddle cooked Taylor ham and cheese sauce.
$10.38
Weezie Weenie
1/4 lb dog only. Griddle cooked Taylor ham, cheese sauce, Coney chili sauce, and minced onion.
$11.68
DELI SALADS & STUFF
STUFFED GRAPE LEAVES
Greek grape leaves stuffed with a seasoned rice. (Dolmades)
$0.95
PEPPER SHOOTERS
Cored out hot cherry pepper, stuffed with imported Provolone and prosciutto, in an olive oil mixture.
$2.60
NAPOLI STUFFED PEPPERS
Stuffed with an Anchovy and Eggplant Mixture
$2.60
MARINATED MUSHROOMS
Marinated button mushrooms, seasoned with herbs and immersed in a light vinegar-based marinade.
$5.85
OLIVE SALAD
A medley of marinated green and black olives, seasoned with herbs and spices.
$5.85
COLESLAW
Crisp cabbage mix, medium (1/2 lb), large (1 lb), x-large (2 lb) options available.
$4.55
GRANDMAS CUCUMBER DILL SALAD
Crisp cucumbers, fresh dill in a light dressing. Options: medium, large, x large.
$4.55
SEAFOOD SALAD
A delicious mixture of crab and shrimp.
$6.48
CHICKEN SALAD
Chicken salad with choice of medium, large, or x-large portions.
$6.48
CRANBERRY WALNUT CHICKEN SALAD
Our homemade chicken salad with cranberries and walnuts! Ahhhhh-mazing!
$6.48
TUNA SALAD
Tuna mixed with creamy mayo. Options for medium, large, or x-large servings.
$6.48
MAFIA SALAD
Italian sausage, roasted red potatoes, sliced cherry tomatoes, red onion, freshly chopped parsley, roasted garlic, olive oil and some Italian seasonings!
$6.48
CAPRESE SALAD
Fresh mozzarella and cherry tomatoes seasoned with herbs.
$5.85
ARTICHOKE SALAD
Crisp cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, black olives, red onions, and tender artichoke hearts tossed in a light dressing.
$5.85
ANTIPASTA
Mixed deli meats, cheese, olives, and vegetables. Size options: medium, large, x large.
$4.55
ITALIAN PASTA
A selection of deli salad, available in medium, large, or x-large sizes.
Red potato egg salad. Available in medium, large, or x-large sizes.
$4.55
GERMAN POTATO SALAD
Potato salad with a German twist: vinegar-based, seasoned with bacon. Available in medium, large, or x-large sizes.
$4.55
CHEDDAR MAC SALAD
Macaroni salad mixed with cheddar. Available in medium (1/2 lb), large (1 lb), and x large (2 lb).
$4.55
HEAT & EATS
Meals that are freshly cooked and cooled, then packed in microwaveable containers for you to "heat and eat" at your leisure! ALL HOMEMADE!!!! REMINDER: THESE ITEMS ARE SERVED COLD FOR YOU TO HEAT
Stuffed Shells
Meals that are freshly cooked and cooled, then packed in microwaveable containers for you to "heat and eat" at your leisure! ALL HOMEMADE!!!!
$11.68
Swedish Meatball Stroganoff Over Egg Noodles
Meals that are freshly cooked and cooled, then packed in microwaveable containers for you to "heat and eat" at your leisure! ALL HOMEMADE!!!!
$11.68
CORNED BEEF DINNER
Meals that are freshly cooked and cooled, then packed in microwaveable containers for you to "heat and eat" at your leisure! ALL HOMEMADE!!!!
Slow cooked, seasoned Corned Beef in a True Irish manner, over cabbage, potatoes, and carrots
$15.60
FETTUCINI ALFREDO WITH CHICKEN
Meals that are freshly cooked and cooled, then packed in microwaveable containers for you to "heat and eat" at your leisure! ALL HOMEMADE!!!!
$15.60
EXTRAS
BEVERAGES
Choose Your Choice of Beverage
$2.50
Monster
A power-packed energy drink to keep you energized and focused.
$3.50
Chips
Assorted flavors.
$2.00
Soda and Potato Salad Combo
Add to your sandwich!
$5.00
Soda and Italian Pasta Salad Combo
Add to your sandwich!
$5.00
Soda and Greek Pasta Salad Combo
Add to your sandwich!
$5.00
Soda and Macaroni Salad Combo
Add to your sandwich!
$5.00
CONDIMENT PACKAGES
Assorted condiment packets typically include ketchup, mustard, mayonnaise, and other common sauces to enhance your meal.
DESSERTS
AMAZING BREAD PUDDING
Mrs. Collins own recipe of a bread pudding unlike any you have ever enjoyed! Sold solely at mikes other place!
$6.99
HOMEMADE PEACH COBBLER
A homemade peach cobbler with a golden-brown crust and tender peach filling.
$4.99
TUXEDO BOMBS
Chocolate-coated spheres with alternating white and dark stripes, resembling a tuxedo pattern.
$7.99
LEMON DROPS
White chocolate shavings top a zesty lemon cream, garnished with a vibrant berry compote.
$7.99
CARROT CAKE
Sweet and moist spice cake.
$9.99
CHOCOLATE LAYER CAKE
Multiple layers of rich chocolate cake, typically filled and topped with smooth chocolate frosting.
$5.99
PEANUT BUTTER EXPLOSION CAKE
Layers of chocolate cake and peanut butter mousse, topped with brownie pieces and peanut butter chips.
$7.99
RUM CAKE
Layers of moist cake infused with rum, topped with whipped cream and garnished with almond slices.
$7.99
NY STYLE CHEESECAKE
Rich creamy cake.
$5.99
CHERRY CHEESECAKE
Creamy cheesecake with a tart cherry topping on a graham cracker base.
$6.50
CARAMEL PECAN CHEESECAKE
New York-style cheesecake topped with pecans and caramel drizzle.
$6.50
OREO CHEESECAKE
Creamy cheesecake infused with crushed Oreo cookies, topped with whole Oreo pieces.
$6.50
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE CRUNCH CHEESECAKE
$6.50
CANNOLI
Crispy pastry tubes filled with sweetened ricotta cheese and dotted with chocolate chips, dusted with powdered sugar.
$4.99
CHOCOLATE CANNOLI
Crisp pastry shell filled with sweet, creamy chocolate-infused ricotta, dusted with powdered sugar.
$5.99
TIRAMISU
Layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers with mascarpone cheese, dusted with cocoa powder.
$5.99
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
Know a great happy hour or special for this location?