Midtown Creamery Menu

4.8

(600+ Reviews)

Ice cream shop, Dessert, Dessert shop

Mains
- Hand Packed Quart Gourmet Ice Cream
  Choose an ice cream: V for Vanilla (Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla), She Got All That Cake (Cake Batter with Sprinkles), Ave Maria (Guava, Cream Cheese and Maria Cookies), Dark Necessities (Nutella with Oreo), Cookie Palooza (Tons of Cookies and a Bit of Chocolate Fudge).
  $15.00
- Hand Packed Pint Gourmet Ice Cream
  Choose an ice cream: V for Vanilla (Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla), She Got All That Cake (Cake Batter with Sprinkles), Ave Maria (Guava, Cream Cheese and Maria Cookies), Dark Necessities (Nutella with Oreo), Cookie Palooza (Tons of Cookies and a Bit of Chocolate Fudge).
  $11.00
- Giant Ice Cream Sandwich
  Pick 3 ice creams between 2 chocolate chip cookies from Cindy Lou's cookies. Choose first ice cream: V for Vanilla (Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla), She Got All That Cake (Cake Batter with Sprinkles), Ave Maria (Guava, Cream Cheese and Maria Cookies), Dark Necessities (Nutella with Oreo), Cookie Palooza (Tons of Cookies and a Bit of Chocolate Fudge). Choose second ice cream: V for Vanilla (Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla), She Got All That Cake (Cake Batter with Sprinkles), Ave Maria (Guava, Cream Cheese and Maria Cookies), Dark Necessities (Nutella with Oreo), Cookie Palooza (Tons of Cookies and a Bit of Chocolate Fudge). Choose third ice cream: V for Vanilla (Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla), She Got All That Cake (Cake Batter with Sprinkles), Ave Maria (Guava, Cream Cheese and Maria Cookies), Dark Necessities (Nutella with Oreo), Cookie Palooza (Tons of Cookies and a Bit of Chocolate Fudge).
  $10.99
- Maria Cookie Trio
  3 mini ice cream sandwiches. Ave Maria ice cream and Maria cookies drizzled with guava sauce and condensed milk.
  $7.49
- Brownie Sundae
  1 scoop over a brownie served with chocolate sauce, dulce de leche and mixed nuts.
  $7.49
Beverages
- Cereal Shake
  Choose vanilla or cake batter milkshake blended with your choice of cereal. Choose a flavor: Vanilla Milkshake, Cake Batter Milkshake. Choose a cereal: Apple Jacks, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Cocoa Pebbles, Lucky Charms, Fruity Pebbles.
  $9.35
- Double Espresso Shake
  Your choice of ice cream. Choose an ice cream: V for Vanilla (Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla), She Got All That Cake (Cake Batter with Sprinkles), Ave Maria (Guava, Cream Cheese and Maria Cookies), Dark Necessities (Nutella with Oreo), Cookie Palooza (Tons of Cookies and a Bit of Chocolate Fudge).
  $8.49
- Milkshake
  Choose any flavor ice cream. Choose an ice cream: V for Vanilla (Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla), She Got All That Cake (Cake Batter with Sprinkles), Ave Maria (Guava, Cream Cheese and Maria Cookies), Dark Necessities (Nutella with Oreo), Cookie Palooza (Tons of Cookies and a Bit of Chocolate Fudge).
  $7.99