Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Michael's Frozen Custard Menu

4.1
(700+ Reviews)
$Dessert, Dessert shop, Ice cream shop
Order Online
Call
(608) 222-4110
Order Online

  • Burgers Chicken Dogs

    • Bacon Cheese

      1/3 lb of Fresh Local Ground Beef, American Cheese, Crisp Leaf Lettuce
      SINGLE
      $7.95
      DOUBLE
      $10.95
      Bacon Cheese

    • The Classic Burger

      $6.00
      The Classic Burger

    • Cowboy Burger

      1/3 lb fresh local beef, fried onions, apple wood smoked thick cut Bacon, Pickles and Pepper jack Cheese
      Single
      $7.95
      Double
      $10.95
      Cowboy Burger

    • California Burger

      SINGLE
      $7.95
      DOUBLE
      $10.95
      California Burger

    • Smoking Jalapeno

      SINGLE
      $7.95
      DOUBLE
      $10.95
      Smoking Jalapeno

    • Mushroom Swiss Glaze

      SINGLE
      $7.95
      DOUBLE
      $10.95
      Mushroom Swiss Glaze

    • Deluxe Cheeseburger

      1/3 lb local fresh beef, American Cheese, Pickles, Tomato, Crisp Leaf Lettuce, Ketchup and Mustard
      SINGLE
      $7.25
      DOUBLE
      $9.25
      Deluxe Cheeseburger

    • Hamburger Deluxe

      1/3 lb fresh local beef, Pickles, Tomato, Crisp Leaf Lettuce, Ketchup and Mustard
      SINGLE
      $7.25
      DOUBLE
      $9.25

    • The Basic Cheeseburger

      $5.00
      The Basic Cheeseburger

    • The Basic Hamburger

      $5.00

    • Chicken Deluxe Sandwich

      $6.75
      Chicken Deluxe Sandwich

    • Chicken Ranch Club

      $7.75
      Chicken Ranch Club

    • Spicy Deluxe Chicken

      $6.75
      Spicy Deluxe Chicken

    • Chicken Tenders

      5 PCS
      $7.75
      8 PCS
      $9.95
      2 PCS
      $4.25
      Chicken Tenders

    • Cheese Dog

      $6.29
      Cheese Dog

    • Chicago Dog

      $6.29
      Chicago Dog

    • Hot Dog PLAIN

      $4.99
      Hot Dog PLAIN

  • Sides

    • CHEESE CURDS

      Local hand battered Wisconsin Cheese Curds deep fried to perfection
      Regular
      $6.95
      Family
      $20.50
      CHEESE CURDS

    • Cheddar Cheese Fries

      Regular
      $5.95
      Family
      $15.10
      Cheddar Cheese Fries

    • French Fries

      Regular
      $4.95
      Family
      $12.42
      French Fries

    • Sweet Potato Fries

      Regular
      $4.95
      Family
      $12.42
      Sweet Potato Fries

    • Onion Rings

      Regular
      $5.50
      Family
      $15.26
      Onion Rings

  • Lemonade & Ice Tea

    • Lemonade

      Small 16 oz
      $3.59
      Medium 24 oz
      $4.25
      Large 32 oz
      $4.95
      Lemonade

    • Sweet Tea

      Small 16 oz
      $3.29
      Medium 24 oz
      $3.95
      Large 32 oz
      $4.49
      Sweet Tea

  • Drinks

    • Sprecher

      $3.95
      Sprecher

    • Water

      $1.00
      Water

    • Soda

      Medium - 24 oz
      $2.79
      Large - 32 oz
      $3.78
      Soda

    • Lemonade

      Small 16 oz
      $3.59
      Medium 24 oz
      $4.25
      Large 32 oz
      $4.95
      Lemonade

    • Sweet Tea

      Small 16 oz
      $3.29
      Medium 24 oz
      $3.95
      Large 32 oz
      $4.49
      Sweet Tea

  • Sundaes

    • Turtle Brownie

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Creamy Caramel, Majestic Hot Fudge and Salted Pecan Half's
      2 Scoop
      $9.95
      3 Scoop
      $10.95
      Turtle Brownie

    • Turtle

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Creamy Caramel, Majestic Hot Fudge and Salted Pecan Half's
      2 Scoop
      $9.47
      3 Scoop
      $10.50
      Turtle

    • Hot Fudge Decadent Brownie

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard Majestic Hot Fudge and homemade Rich Gooey Brownies
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Hot Fudge Decadent Brownie

    • Hot Fudge Brownie Pecan

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Creamy Caramel, Majestic Hot Fudge and Salted Pecan Half's
      2 Scoop
      $9.95
      3 Scoop
      $10.95
      Hot Fudge Brownie Pecan

    • Cookie Dough & Fudge

      The taste of fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, chunks of Cookie Dough and the perfect Hot Fudge makes this and all time best seller.
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Cookie Dough & Fudge

    • Cheesecake

      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Cheesecake

    • Strawberry Banana

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Generous amount of sliced Bananas and juicy sliced strawberries.
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Strawberry Banana

    • Strawberry Pecan

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Generous amount of sliced Bananas and juicy sliced strawberries.
      2 Scoop
      $9.95
      3 Scoop
      $10.95
      Strawberry Pecan

    • Chunky Monkey

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, generous amounts of sliced bananas, melted chocolate chips and salted Pecan Halfs
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Chunky Monkey

    • Bengal Tiger

      Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard Creamy Caramel and real Reese's Peanut Butter Cups
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Bengal Tiger

    • P. B. Cup

      The world's finest Vanilla Frozen Custard, melted chocolate chips, Creamy Reese's Peanut Butter, and Chunks of Crushed Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      P. B. Cup

    • Michael's Tree House

      Swing from the Tree and enjoy this Sundae from your own Tree House. Fresh Vanilla & Chocolate Frozen Custard, Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter, Sliced Banana's and Gooey Fudge Brownie Bites.
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Michael's Tree House

    • German Chocolate

      Fresh Chocolate Frozen Custard, Buttery Caramel, Shredded Coconut, Chocolate Cake pieces and Salted Pecan Halfs
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      German Chocolate

    • Tropical Paradise

      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Tropical Paradise

    • Mississippi Mud

      Award winning Vanilla Frozen Custard, a hint of real Coffee, Majestic Hot Fudge, Chunks of Oreo's and oh so good salted Pecan Halfs
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Mississippi Mud

    • Grizzly Bear

      Fresh Chocolate Frozen Custard Creamy Buttery Caramel and Salted Cashews
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Grizzly Bear

    • Muddy Banana

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Majestic Hot Fudge and sliced Bananas topped off with real chunks of Oreo's
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Muddy Banana

    • Death By Chocolate

      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Death By Chocolate

    • White Rabbit

      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      White Rabbit

    • P. B. Fudge Cake

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Rich Majestic Hot Fudge, Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter and Fudgy Cake pieces
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      P. B. Fudge Cake

    • Cookie Jar

      What better way to enjoy the Cookie Jar than to have your favorites together. Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Majestic Hot Fudge ,Homemade Peanut Butter Cookies and Cookie Dough Chunks. Yum!
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Cookie Jar

    • P. B. Fudge Cookie Jar

      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      P. B. Fudge Cookie Jar

    • Moonlight

      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Moonlight

    • Peanut Butter Cookie Jar

      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Peanut Butter Cookie Jar

    • Caramel Sundae

      2 Scoop
      $7.25
      3 Scoop
      $8.25
      Caramel Sundae

    • Hot Fudge Sundae

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Majestic Hot Fudge
      2 Scoop
      $7.25
      3 Scoop
      $8.25
      Hot Fudge Sundae

    • Marshmallow Sundae

      2 Scoop
      $6.95
      3 Scoop
      $7.95
      Marshmallow Sundae

    • Strawberry Sundae

      2 scoop
      $8.00
      3 Scoop
      $9.00
      Strawberry Sundae

    • Pineapple Sundae

      2 Scoop
      $7.25
      3 Scoop
      $8.25
      Pineapple Sundae

    • Hershey Choc Syrup

      2 Scoop
      $7.25
      3 Scoop
      $8.25
      Hershey Choc Syrup

    • Sprinkle Sundae

      2 Scoop
      $7.25
      3 Scoop
      $8.25
      Sprinkle Sundae

    • Butterscotch

      2 Scoop
      $7.25
      3 Scoop
      $8.25
      Butterscotch

    • Banana Split

      Four generous scoops of fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard with Strawberries, Pineapple and Hershey Chocolate Sauce sits on top of a fresh banana. You deserve the best and treat yourself today
      $14.95
      Banana Split

    • Caramel Cashew

      Fresh sweet cream Vanilla Frozen Custard creamy Caramel and loads of roasted Salted Cashews.
      2 Scoop
      $8.95
      3 Scoop
      $9.95
      Caramel Cashew

  • Twisters

    • Blue Sky

      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Blue Sky

    • Banana Cream Pie

      Fresh Award winning Vanilla Frozen Custard, fresh sliced bananas and crisp sweet pie crust pieces.
      16 ounce
      $10.95
      12 Ounce
      $9.95
      Banana Cream Pie

    • Birthday cake

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard Baked in house Birthday Cake and Rainbow sprinkles make this Twister a sure favorite on your Birthday or any day you wish to bring your birthday wishes come true.
      16 ounce
      $10.95
      12 ounce
      $9.95
      Birthday cake

    • Buttered Pecan

      Fresh Butter Pecan Frozen Custard twisted with roasted salted pecan half's. Take a ride of your life with this crowd pleaser.
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Buttered Pecan

    • CAMP smOREO's

      Fresh Vanilla and Chocolate Frozen Custard, creamy marshmallow and real Oreo's. Sit by the fire and enjoy this twist on a classic smores twister with the new Sm Oreo's Twister
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      CAMP smOREO's

    • Campfire Smores

      Sing around the camp fire and enjoy this Fresh Milk Chocolate Frozen Custard with creamy Marshmallow and Nabisco Graham Crackers
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Campfire Smores

    • Crazy For Cookie Dough

      It's raining Cookie Dough in this spectacular Twister, This Coyote thinks it's to good to be true. Michael's Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard twisted Chunks of Cookie Dough. You'll be crazy for cookie dough too!Beep Beep
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Crazy For Cookie Dough

    • Crazy P.B. Cookie Dough

      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Crazy P.B. Cookie Dough

    • Double Berry Twister

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, Strawberries and Raspberry Twisted into this refreshing Treat
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Double Berry Twister

    • Mint Chocolate Chip Twister

      Take me to your leader Earthling. Enjoy this great Twister cool Creamy Mint twisted with Melted Chocolate Chips
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Mint Chocolate Chip Twister

    • Oreo Twister

      The Original Round Edible Object. What do you get OREO
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Oreo Twister

    • Mint Oreo Twister

      Cool Creamy Mint Twisted with chunks of Oreo's
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Mint Oreo Twister

    • Key Lime Pie

      Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, real Key Lime and Honey Graham Crackers.
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Key Lime Pie

    • Flying Monkey

      Yes Toto Banana's do fly. Fresh Milk Chocolate Frozen Custard chunks of Bananas and Creamy Peanut Butter
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Flying Monkey

    • French Silk Twister

      Fresh Milk Chocolate Frozen Custard, Shaved Chocolate and Sweet Pie Crust twisted into the perfect French Silk Twister
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      French Silk Twister

    • Square Pants

      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Square Pants

    • Mad Hatter

      I believe in 6 possible things before breakfast. The Mad Hatter Twister is made with Michael's Fresh Vanilla Frozen Custard, melted Chocolate Chips, Chunks of Cookie Dough and colorful M & M's
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Mad Hatter

    • Mocha Cookie Crumble Twister

      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Mocha Cookie Crumble Twister

    • Espresso Chip Twister

      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Espresso Chip Twister

    • Reese's P. B. Cup Twister

      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Reese's P. B. Cup Twister

    • M & M Twister

      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      M & M Twister

    • Cookie Butter Twister

      16 oz
      $10.98
      12 oz
      $9.98
      Cookie Butter Twister

    • Heath Bar Twister

      Crushed Heath Bar twisted with cool creamy vanilla frozen custard
      16 oz
      $10.95
      12 oz
      $9.95
      Heath Bar Twister

  • Shakes, Malts & Floats

    • Hershey Chocolate Shake

      16 oz
      $8.50
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Hershey Chocolate Shake

    • Strawberry Shake

      16 oz
      $9.25
      12 oz
      $8.25
      Strawberry Shake

    • Pineapple Shake

      16 oz
      $8.50
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Pineapple Shake

    • Vanilla Shake

      16 oz
      $8.50
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Vanilla Shake

    • Bluemoon Shake

      16 oz
      $8.00
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Bluemoon Shake

    • Mint Shake

      16 oz
      $8.50
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Mint Shake

    • Coffee Shake

      16 oz
      $8.50
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Coffee Shake

    • Raspberry Shake

      16 oz
      $8.50
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Raspberry Shake

    • Pumpkin Shake

      16 oz
      $8.50
      12 oz
      $7.50
      Pumpkin Shake

    • ROOT BEER FLOAT

      $9.50
      ROOT BEER FLOAT

    • ORANGE DREAM FLOAT

      $9.50
      ORANGE DREAM FLOAT

    • CREAM SODA FLOAT

      $9.50
      CREAM SODA FLOAT

  • Cones

    • Dish

      2 Scoop
      $5.50
      3 Scoop
      $6.50
      1 Scoop
      $4.73
      Dish

    • Chocolate Dipped Waffle

      2 Scoop
      $7.00
      3 Scoop
      $7.95
      1 Scoop
      $6.25
      Chocolate Dipped Waffle

    • Sprinkle Waffle

      2 Scoop
      $7.00
      3 Scoop
      $7.95
      1 Scoop
      $6.25
      Sprinkle Waffle

    • Waffle Fresh Made

      2 Scoop
      $7.00
      3 Scoop
      $7.95
      1 Scoop
      $6.25
      Waffle Fresh Made

  • Take Home

    • 1 Pint

      $7.95
      1 Pint

    • 3 Pints

      $17.25
      3 Pints

    • 4 Pints

      $22.00
      4 Pints

    • 2 Pints

      $13.00
      2 Pints

    • 6 Pints

      $33.00

    • K-9

      $4.25

    • Layered Sundae

      $8.95
      Layered Sundae

  • Gift Certificate

    • Gift Certificate Sold

      $5.00
      Gift Certificate Sold

  • To Go Toppings

    • 12 oz Topping

      $8.25

    • 2 ounce topping

      $4.75

    • Empty Waffles

      Fresh made
      $3.15
      Sprinkle
      $3.49
      Choc Dipped
      $3.49
      Empty Waffles

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's
3.4
(156 Reviews)
Sandwich shop
Chipotle Mexican Grill
Chipotle Mexican Grill
3.4
(147 Reviews)
Mexican, American
Falbo Bros Pizzeria
Falbo Bros Pizzeria
4.0
(130 Reviews)
Pizza
Starbucks
Starbucks
4.0
(564 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Breakfast, Cafe
China Star
China Star
3.8
(233 Reviews)
Chinese
Noodles and Company
Noodles and Company
3.7
(536 Reviews)
Restaurant, Lunch, Pasta shop
Buffalo Wild Wings
Buffalo Wild Wings
3.6
(1,283 Reviews)
Chicken wings, Sports bar
PAPAs BBQ
PAPAs BBQ
4.6
(146 Reviews)
Barbecue
Tasting Room
Tasting Room
4.8
(543 Reviews)
Lounge, Cocktail bar
Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews
Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews
4.1
(1,614 Reviews)
Restaurant, Lunch
http://www.ilovemichaels.com/
(608) 222-4110

3826 Atwood Ave, Madison, WI 53714

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms