• Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Hand Packed Pint

      You pick the flavor and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 16 oz.
      $11.10
    • Large Shake

      A McCools classic - unlimited flavors. Best Milkshake in New Jersey - 24 oz
      $10.40
    • Double Scoop

      Two ample scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1 or 2 flavors. 10 oz serving.
      $8.50
    • Single Scoop

      An ample scoop of Hersheys ice cream - 1 flavor. 5 oz serving.
      $5.55
    • Triple Scoop

      Three ample scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1, 2, or 3 flavors. 16 oz serving.
      $10.55
    • Medium Soft Serv

      A medium cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 10 oz serving.
      $7.85
    • Small Yogurt Recipe

      A McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available .6 oz.
      $6.60
    • Extreme Sundae

      2 scoops of Hersheys ice cream (1 or 2 flavors) plus 3 toppings. A huge treat! 10 oz plus toppings!
      $11.00
    • Junior Scoop

      One junior scoop of Hersheys ice cream - 1 flavor. 3.5 oz serving.
      $4.25
    • 6 Pk MiniCoolwhich

      6 of McCools famous MiniCoolwhichs in a take out pack - small chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
      $17.70
    • Hand Packed Quart

      You pick the flavor and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 32 oz.
      $16.75
    • Large Soft Serv

      A large cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 16 oz serving.
      $9.00
  • Shakes

    • Large Shake

      A McCools classic - unlimited flavors. Best Milkshake in New Jersey - 24 oz
      $10.40
    • Malted

      Hand-scooped vanilla ice cream blended with malt powder and milk. Hand-spun and made to order.
      $1.55
    • Small Shake

      A McCools classic - unlimited flavors. Best Milkshake in New Jersey - 16 oz
      $8.95
  • Frozen Yogurt

    • Small Yogurt Recipe

      A McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available .6 oz.
      $6.60
    • Medium Yogurt Recipe

      A McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available .10 oz.
      $9.45
    • Large Yogurt Blend-In

      A McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 16 oz.
      $11.50
    • Large Yogurt Recipe

      A McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available .16 oz.
      $11.50
    • Quart Yogurt Blend-In

      A McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 32 oz.
      $17.95
    • Quart Yogurt Recipe

      A McCools original - choose among 3 dozen favorite recipes based on Madison and Summit area culture! 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) available .32 oz.
      $17.95
    • Medium Yogurt Blend-In

      A McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 10 oz.
      $9.45
    • Small Yogurt Blend-In

      A McCools original - choose 3 lo-fat yogurt bases (vanilla, chocolate, coffee) and blend in your choice of fruit, toppings, and other blend-ins. 6 oz.
      $6.60
  • Hard Ice Cream

    • Triple Scoop

      Three ample scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1, 2, or 3 flavors. 16 oz serving.
      $10.55
    • Double Scoop

      Two ample scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1 or 2 flavors. 10 oz serving.
      $8.50
    • Single Scoop

      An ample scoop of Hersheys ice cream - 1 flavor. 5 oz serving.
      $5.55
    • Extreme Sundae

      2 scoops of Hersheys ice cream (1 or 2 flavors) plus 3 toppings. A huge treat! 10 oz plus toppings!
      $11.00
    • Hand Packed Quart

      You pick the flavor and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 32 oz.
      $16.75
    • Banana Split

      Classic combination of split banana, 3 scoops of ice cream of your choice, topped with your choice of toppings - an American classic!
      $11.55
    • Double Junior Scoop

      Two junior scoops of Hersheys ice cream - 1 or 2 flavors. 6 oz serving.
      $6.70
    • Ice Cream Float

      2 junior scoops of ice cream in your choice of seltzer or soft drink! An American classic! 16 oz serving
      $7.65
    • Sundae

      The ultimate American classic - an ample scoop of Hersheys ice cream (1 flavor) plus 2 toppings. A magical treat! 5 oz plus toppings!
      $8.75
    • Hand Packed Pint

      You pick the flavor and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 16 oz.
      $11.10
    • Junior Scoop

      One junior scoop of Hersheys ice cream - 1 flavor. 3.5 oz serving.
      $4.25
  • Non-Dairy

    • Double Junior Scoop Non-Dairy

      Two junior scoops of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 or 2 flavors. 6 oz serving.
      $7.80
    • Double Scoop Non-Dairy

      Two ample scoops of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 or 2 flavors. 10 oz serving.
      $10.20
    • Hand Packed Pint Non-Dairy

      You pick the non-dairy flavor (either oat-based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice) and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 16 oz.
      $12.60
    • Hand Packed Quart Non-Dairy

      You pick the non-dairy flavor (either oat-based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice) and we'll pack it! 1 or 2 flavors. 32 oz.
      $21.00
    • Large Shake Non-Dairy

      Choice of oat-based ice cream, sorbets, or Italian ice mixed with oat milk or seltzer for a refreshing non-dairy experience. 24 oz.
      $14.40
    • Small Shake Non-Dairy

      Choice of oat-based ice cream, sorbets, or Italian ice mixed with oat milk or seltzer for a refreshing non-dairy experience. 16 oz.
      $10.80
    • Triple Scoop Non-Dairy

      Three ample scoops of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1, 2 or 3 flavors. 16 oz serving.
      $12.60
    • Junior Scoop Non-Dairy

      A junior scoop of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 flavor. 3.5 oz serving.
      $4.80
    • Single Scoop Non-Dairy

      An ample scoop of Hersheys Non-Dairy Oat-Based ice cream or sorbet/Italian ice- 1 flavor. 5 oz serving.
      $6.60
  • Soft Serve Ice Cream

    • Large Soft Serv

      A large cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 16 oz serving.
      $9.00
    • Junior Soft Serv

      A junior cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 3.5 oz serving.
      $4.25
    • Medium Soft Serv

      A medium cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 10 oz serving.
      $7.85
    • Small Soft Serv

      A small cup of Soft Serv ice cream - Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist flavor. 5 oz serving.
      $5.55
  • Novelties

    • 6 Pk MiniCoolwhich

      6 of McCools famous MiniCoolwhichs in a take out pack - small chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
      $17.70
    • Frosty Bones

      Show your favorite family member love - 2 dog biscuits filled with vanilla soft serv. Ruff!!!
      $1.60
    • McCoolwhich

      McCools famous McCoolwich - huge chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
      $5.25
    • MiniCoolwhich

      McCools famous MiniCoolwhich - small chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
      $3.35
    • 4 Pk McCoolwhich

      4 of McCools famous Chipwhichs in a take out pack - huge chocolate chip cookie filled with vanilla soft serv and coated with chocolate chips or rainbow sprinkles.
      $19.20
    • Hersheys PrePacked Pints

      A ready to go take-out prepacked pint from Hersheys - available in a dozen popular flavors - 16 oz. Serves 3-5
      $9.85
  • Ice Cream Extras

    • Cones To Go

      Cones of your choice - will be packaged separately from your order.
      $0.45+
    • Toppings To Go

      Toppings of your choice - will be packaged in 4 oz cups separately from your order.
      $1.10+

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Poke Bowl
Poke Bowl
4.6
(55 Reviews)
Restaurant
Lee's Garden Chinese Restaurant
Lee's Garden Chinese Restaurant
4.3
(15 Reviews)
Chinese
O Sole Mio Pizzeria & Grill
O Sole Mio Pizzeria & Grill
4.6
(86 Reviews)
Pizza
Towne Delicatessen
Towne Delicatessen
4.7
(143 Reviews)
Deli, Sandwich shop
Old Glory Restaurant
Old Glory Restaurant
4.6
(273 Reviews)
American, Breakfast
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy
4.9
(186 Reviews)
Bakery
Subway
Subway
3.7
(49 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Dunkin'
Dunkin'
4.1
(168 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Bagel shop, Bakery
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Tropical Smoothie Cafe
4.5
(29 Reviews)
Juice shop, Breakfast, Cafe
Bellariva Trattoria & Pizzeria
Bellariva Trattoria & Pizzeria
4.3
(211 Reviews)
Pizza, Italian

(973) 301-0303

26 Main St, Madison, NJ 07940


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms