Mama Nancy's Pizza Menu

$$Pizza
3495 E Broad St, Columbus, OH 43213
  • 12" Nancy's Deep Dish Pizza (2 to 3 Person)

    • 12" Oak Park Chicago Classic Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, Italian sausage, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust.
      $19.98
    • 12" Just Cheese Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust.
      $17.99
    • 12" Willis Tower Veggies Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, red onion, mushroom, green pepper, green olive, black olive, garlic, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust.
      $22.99
    • 12" Wrigley Field Pepperoni Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, chunky red sauce, old world pepperoni on top, jumbo pepperoni inside, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust.
      $19.98
    • 12" Windy City Way Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, Italian sausage, red onion, green pepper, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust.
      $21.99
    • 12" Millennium Park Meat Lovers Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, old world pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, bacon, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust.
      $22.99
    • 12" Lincoln Park Veggies Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, ricotta cheese, black olive, mushroom, garlic, olive oil, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust. (NO RED SAUCE)
      $21.99
    • 12" Grant Park Chicken Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, chicken, red onion, mushroom, green pepper, BBQ sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust. (NO RED SAUCE)
      $21.99
  • 7" Nancy's Deep Dish Pizza (1 Person)

    • 7" Oak Park Chicago Classic Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, Italian sausage, , chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, and Nancy's butter crust.
      $11.99
    • 7" Just Cheese Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, and Nancy's butter crust.
      $10.99
    • 7" Willis Tower Veggies Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, red onion, mushroom, green pepper, green olive, black olive, garlic, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, and Nancy's butter crust.
      $13.99
    • 7" Wrigley Field Pepperoni Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, chunky red sauce, old world pepperoni on top, jumbo pepperoni inside, parmesan cheese, seasoning, and Nancy's butter crust.
      $11.99
    • 7" Windy City Way Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, Italian sausage, red onion, green pepper, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, and Nancy's butter crust.
      $12.99
    • 7" Millennium Park Meat Lovers Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, bacon, chunky red sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, and Nancy's butter crust.
      $13.99
    • 7" Lincoln Park Veggies Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, ricotta cheese, black olive, mushroom, garlic, olive oil, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust (NO RED SAUCE).
      $12.99
    • 7" Grant Park Chicken Deep Dish

      Wisconsin mozzarella, chicken, red onion, mushroom, green pepper, BBQ sauce, parmesan cheese, seasoning, Nancy’s butter crust. (NO RED SAUCE)
      $12.99
  • 14" New York Style Pizza (1 to 2 Person)

    • 14" New York Classic Cheese

      New York style thin crust, homemade sauce, cheese and your choice of toppings.
      $15.49
    • 14" New York Manhattan Pepperoni

      New York style thin crust, homemade sauce, cheese, Ezzo old world pepperoni.
      $17.48
    • 14" New York Buffalo Chicken

      New York style thin crust, buffalo sauce, chicken, cheese, ranch on top.
      $17.48
    • 14" New York BBQ Chicken

      New York style thin crust, BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, red onion cheese.
      $19.47
    • 14" New York Statue Of Liberty Veggies

      New York style thin crust, homemade sauce, Ezzo old world pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, ham cheese. Only meat, no veggies here.
      $19.99
    • 14" New York Time Squares Supreme Pizza

      New York style crust, homemade red sauce, red onion, green pepper, mushroom, old world pepperoni, Italian sausage, cheese.
      $20.99
    • 14" New York Wall Street Meat Lovers

      New York style crust, homemade sauce, old world pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, ham, cheese.
      $20.99
  • 10" x 8" Detroit Style Pizza (1 to 2 Person)

    • Detroit's Classic Cheese

      Detroit style caramelized crust, homemade red sauce, oregano, cheese, parmesan cheese.
      $13.49
    • Detroit's Chevy Corvette Pepperoni

      Detroit style caramelized crust, homemade red sauce, cheese, oregano, parmesan cheese, old world pepperoni.
      $15.48
    • Detroit's Ford GT

      Detroit style caramelized crust, homemade red sauce, old world pepperoni, Italian sausage, oregano, cheese, parmesan cheese.
      $16.95
    • Detroit's Spicy Ferrari

      Detroit style caramelized crust, buffalo sauce, BBQ sauce, old world pepperoni, jalapeno, banana pepper, crushed red pepper, cheese, parmesan cheese. (NO RED SAUCE)
      $16.95
    • Detroit's Motor City Special

      Detroit style caramelized crust, homemade red sauce, Italian sausage, red onion, green pepper, mushroom, oregano, cheese, parmesan cheese.
      $17.95
    • Detroit's FIAT Hero

      Detroit style caramelized crust, Italian dressing, old world pepperoni, salami, ham, red onion, banana pepper, cheese, parmesan cheese. (NO RED SAUCE)
      $17.95
    • Detroit's Central Chicken

      Detroit style caramelized crust, homemade red sauce, chicken, green pepper, red onion, cheese, parmesan cheese.
      $16.95
    • Detroit's Motown Veggies

      Detroit style caramelized crust, roma tomato, black olive, red onion, green pepper, olive oil, garlic, cheese, parmesan cheese. (NO RED SAUCE)
      $16.95
  • Yummy Crispy Wings

    • 6 Pieces - Cajun Dry Rub Wings

      6 traditional wings tossed in Cajun dry rub (mild heat).
      $7.99
    • 6 Pieces - Classic BBQ Wings

      6 traditional wings tossed in BBQ sauce.
      $7.99
    • 6 Pieces - Garlic Parmesan Wings

      6 traditional wings tossed in garlic parmesan sauce.
      $7.99
    • 6 Pieces - Classic Buffalo Wings

      6 traditional wings tossed in classic buffalo sauce (medium heat).
      $7.99
    • 6 Pieces - Hot Honey Wings

      6 traditional wings tossed in hot honey glaze (medium heat).
      $7.99
    • 12 Pieces - Cajun Dry Rub Wings

      12 traditional wings tossed in Cajun dry rub (mild heat).
      $15.98
    • 12 Pieces - Classic BBQ Wings

      12 traditional wings tossed in BBQ sauce.
      $15.98
    • 12 Pieces - Garlic Parmesan Wings

      12 traditional wings tossed in garlic parmesan sauce.
      $15.98
    • 12 Pieces - Classic Buffalo Wings

      12 traditional wings tossed in classic buffalo sauce (medium heat).
      $15.98
    • 12 Pieces - Hot Honey Wings

      12 traditional wings tossed in hot honey glaze (medium heat).
      $15.98
    • 18 Pieces - Cajun Dry Rub Wings

      18 traditional wings tossed in Cajun dry rub (mild heat).
      $23.97
    • 18 Pieces - Classic BBQ Wings

      18 traditional wings tossed in BBQ sauce.
      $23.97
    • 18 Pieces - Garlic Parmesan Wings

      18 traditional wings tossed in garlic parmesan sauce.
      $23.97
    • 18 Pieces - Classic Buffalo Wings

      18 traditional wings tossed in classic buffalo sauce (medium heat).
      $23.97
    • 18 Pieces - Hot Honey Wings

      18 traditional wings tossed in hot honey glaze (medium heat).
      $23.97
  • Nancy's Amazing Stromboli (1 to 2 Person)

    • Nancy's Amazing Stromboli

      Half-moon shape, cheese, olive oil, oregano, parmesan. Choose your toppings to put inside the Stromboli. Mariana sauce on the side. It's amazing! Our hidden gems!
      $13.49
  • Oven Baked Subs (9")

    • 9" Cheesy Garlic Bread

      Cheese, garlic oil, oregano, and a side of pizza sauce.
      $7.99
    • 9" Italian Sub

      Salami, pepperoni, cheese, roma tomato, romain lettuce, banana pepper, red onion, and Italian dressing.
      $9.99
    • 9" Ham Bacon Club

      Ham, bacon, cheese, roma tomato, romain lettuce, and mayonnaise on the side.
      $9.99
    • 9" Veggies Sub

      Cheese, romain lettuce, roma tomato, mushroom, red onion, green pepper, black olive, green olive, banana pepper, and Italian dressing.
      $9.99
    • 9" Meatball And Cheese

      Meatball, cheese, and homemade marinara sauce.
      $9.99
  • Salad

    • House Salad

      Romaine lettuce, tomato, cheese, pepperoni, and red onion. Choose your sauce (ranch or Italian).
      $8.99
    • Veggie Salad

      Romaine lettuce, tomato, cheese, red onion, banana pepper, and green olive. Choose your sauce (ranch or Italian).
      $8.99
    • Club Salad

      Romaine lettuce, ham, bacon, tomato, cheese, and red onion. Choose your sauce (ranch or Italian).
      $8.99
  • Homemade Dessert - Cake Cup Creamery

    • Strawberries & Cream Cake Cup

      Layers of vanilla cake crumble, vanilla ice cream, diced strawberries, and whipped frosting served in a cup and topped with diced strawberry pieces.
      $5.99
    • Cookies & Cream Cake Cup

      Layers of chocolate cake crumble, vanilla ice cream, crushed Oreo pieces, and whipped frosting served in a cup and topped with crushed Oreo pieces.
      $5.99
    • Peanut Butter Cup

      Layers of chocolate cake crumble, vanilla ice cream, peanut butter cup pieces, and whipped frosting served in a cup and topped with peanut butter cup pieces.
      $5.99

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms