Mama Mia’s Pizza and Pasta - Oyster Bay Menu

4.5

(200+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Pizzettes (12" Pie)Round Specialty Pies Salads / Insalate - Dinner Square Specialty Pies Calzones, Rolls & Knots Appetizers Soups / Zuppe Pasta Specialties - Dinner Baked Entrées / Pasta Al Forno - Dinner Chicken Entrées / Specialita Di Pollo Veal Entrées / Specialita Di Vitello Seafood Entrées / Specialita Di Pesce Eggplant Entrées / Specialita Di Melanzane Vegetables / Verdura Heroes Beverages Desserts

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Cheese (18")
  A classic 18-inch pizza topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and rich tomato sauce.
  $23.95
- Cheese (Slice)
  Generous layers of melted mozzarella cheese atop a classic tomato sauce and a crispy, thin crust.
  $4.00
- Alla Vodka
  Vodka sauce-coated pasta, options include capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $20.95
- Mozzarella Sticks (6)
  Served with marinara.
  $16.00
- Garlic Knots (6)
  Six golden knots, infused with garlic butter and a hint of parsley.
  $3.50
- Chicken Roll
  Tender chicken pieces wrapped in golden-brown dough with melted cheese and a hint of marinara sauce.
  $10.25
- Pepperoni Bites
  Bite-sized pizza dough parcels filled with pepperoni, lightly seasoned with herbs and sesame seeds.
  $6.50
- Vodka (Slice) Square
  Square slice topped with a smooth blend of tomato, vodka, and cream sauce, along with a mix of cheeses.
  $4.25
- Buffalo Chicken (Slice)
  Tender chicken pieces, tangy buffalo sauce, and a creamy drizzle on a classic pizza slice.
  $5.75
- 20 Oz Bottle
  20 oz bottled beverages. Options include cola, diet cola, and lemon-lime.
  $3.50
Pizzettes (12" Pie)
Featuring Traditional Italian thin-crust personal pizzas. Each personal is prepared with only the finest ingredients and then baked to perfection in our brick oven. Gluten-free option is available for an additional cost.
- Regular Cheese Pizzetta
  Thin crust, plum tomatoes, sprinkled lightly with marinara sauce.
  $15.95
- Vodka Pizza
  Homemade vodka sauce and a blend of cheeses, baked on a 12" brick oven pizzette.
  $17.95
- Pizza Margherita
  San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, garlic & basil drizzled with virgin olive oil.
  $17.95
- Campagnola
  Crumbled sausage, sun-dried tomatoes, broccoli rabe, a touch of fresh mozzarella & a whisper of garlic & oil.
  $17.95
- Rustico
  Crumbled sausage, diced tomato & mozzarella drizzled with virgin olive oil.
  $17.95
- Vegetable
  Green peppers, onions, broccoli & mushrooms.
  $17.95
- Melanzana Parmigiana Pizzetta
  Eggplant cutlets grande mozzarella tomato sauce
  $16.95
- BBQ, Buffalo or Chicken Bacon Ranch
  Brick oven 12" pizzettes with choice of BBQ, Buffalo, or Chicken Bacon Ranch toppings.
  $17.95
Round Specialty Pies
Deep dish any pie at an extra cost.
- Cheese (Slice)
  Generous layers of melted mozzarella cheese atop a classic tomato sauce and a crispy, thin crust.
  $4.00
- Cheese (18")
  A classic 18-inch pizza topped with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and rich tomato sauce.
  $23.95
- Baked Ziti (Slice)
  Penne pasta baked with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a pizza slice.
  $5.75
- Baked Ziti (18")
  Creamy ricotta and mozzarella cheese, ziti pasta, and marinara sauce on a round 18" pizza crust, garnished with parsley.
  $30.00
- BBQ Chicken (Slice)
  Tender chicken pieces, rich barbecue sauce, and melted cheese on a classic pizza crust.
  $5.75
- BBQ Chicken (18")
  House-made BBQ sauce and tender chicken top this 18" pizza, garnished with red onions and a blend of cheeses, finished with a BBQ sauce drizzle.
  $32.50
- Broccoli Pie (Ricotta) (18")
  An 18" pie generously topped with fresh broccoli and dollops of creamy ricotta on a classic crust.
  $27.50
- Buffalo Chicken (Slice)
  Tender chicken pieces, tangy buffalo sauce, and a creamy drizzle on a classic pizza slice.
  $5.75
- Buffalo Chicken (18")
  Buffalo sauce and ranch dressing generously topped with chicken, often accompanied by a blend of cheeses, on a hand-stretched 18" dough.
  $32.50
- Chicken Bacon Ranch (Slice)
  Tender chicken pieces, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch dressing atop a classic pizza slice.
  $5.50
- Chicken Bacon Ranch (18")
  Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch dressing atop a cheesy, 18-inch pizza.
  $32.50
- Chicken & Broccoli (Slice)
  Grilled chicken and fresh broccoli topped with shredded lettuce and drizzled with creamy dressing on a classic pizza slice.
  $5.50
- Chicken & Broccoli (18")
  Diced chicken and fresh broccoli atop a classic crust, typically includes a blend of cheeses and a garlic-infused sauce.
  $32.50
- Chicken Parmigiana with Ricotta (18")
  Tender chicken pieces topped with marinara, ricotta, and mozzarella, garnished with fresh basil on an 18" pizza crust.
  $32.50
- Eggplant (Ricotta) (Slice)
  Breaded eggplant and creamy ricotta cheese on a classic pizza crust with our signature sauce.
  $5.75
- Eggplant (Ricotta) (18")
  Topped with roasted eggplant, dollops of creamy ricotta cheese, and tomato sauce, this 18" pizza combines savory and rich flavors for a satisfying bite.
  $27.50
- Francese (Slice)
  Sliced chicken in a light, lemon and white wine sauce, typically served on a classic pizza crust.
  $5.75
- Francese (18")
  Tender chicken in a buttery lemon and white wine sauce, generously layered atop our hand-tossed 18" dough.
  $32.50
- Hawaiian (Slice)
  Topped with sweet pineapple and ham, complemented by a rich tomato sauce and melted cheese on a classic crust.
  $5.75
- Hawaiian (18")
  Generously topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil leaves.
  $32.50
- Margherita (Slice)
  Fresh mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and basil leaves on a thin, crisp crust.
  $5.75
- Margherita (18")
  Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and basil on a traditional 18-inch pizza crust.
  $29.50
- Meat Lover's (Slice)
  A slice of pizza generously topped with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, and meatball, layered over a classic tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese base.
  $5.75
- Meat Lover's (18")
  Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham, topped with melted mozzarella cheese on a classic pizza crust.
  $32.50
- Special Pie (Everything) (18")
  Topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and mozzarella cheese.
  $32.50
- Special Pie (Ricotta) (18")
  Hand-tossed dough topped with a generous layer of ricotta, crafted into an 18" pie.
  $29.50
- Vegetable (Slice)
  Topped with mushrooms, broccoli, bell peppers, black olives, and a sprinkle of grated cheese.
  $5.75
- Vegetable (18")
  A colorful blend of broccoli, mushrooms, red onions, bell peppers, tomatoes, and spinach atop a cheese pizza with a rich tomato sauce.
  $30.50
- White (Slice)
  White pizza slice typically includes a blend of ricotta cheese, garlic, and a mix of other cheeses, served on a light, crispy crust without tomato sauce.
  $5.75
- White (18")
  A white pizza with a garlic butter base, typically includes a blend of cheeses, often featuring ricotta.
  $28.50
Salads / Insalate - Dinner
Salad dressings: ranch, olive oil & lemon, Italian, balsamic, honey mustard, French. Salads served with focaccia.
- Antipasto
  Iceberg, ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, roasted peppers & giardiniera.
  $20.00
- Caesar
  Romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons & homemade Caesar dressing.
  $17.00
- Caprese
  Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes & basil served with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette.
  $18.50
- House
  Mixed green salad, choice of ranch, olive oil & lemon, Italian, balsamic, honey mustard, or French dressing.
  $15.50
- Cobb Salad
  Mixed greens, chicken, tomato, bacon, hard-boiled egg, and red onion.
  $18.50
- Lg Italian Salad
  Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives mushrooms, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and creamy Italian dressing.
  $17.50
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  iceberg lettuce, romaine, Cherry tomato, Red Onions, Shredded carrots, Spicy Buffalo chicken. creamy blue cheese dressing on the side.
  $18.50
Square Specialty Pies
- Brooklyn Sicilian (Slice)
  Thick crust topped with crumbled sausage.
  $4.75
- Brooklyn Sicilian (Pie)
  Thick crust topped with crumbled sausage.
  $35.50
- Crispino (Slice)
  Thin crust topped with sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & basil.
  $5.50
- Crispino (Pie)
  Thin crust topped with sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & basil.
  $35.00
- Crispino Mushroom (Slice)
  Thin crust topped with fresh mozzarella and sautéed mushrooms.
  $5.50
- Crispino Mushroom (Pie)
  Thin crust topped with fresh mozzarella and sautéed mushrooms.
  $35.00
- Grandma (Slice)
  Thin crust covered with mozzarella & san marzano splashed with imported tomatoes & basil.
  $5.00
- Grandma (Pie)
  Thin crust covered with mozzarella & san marzano splashed with imported tomatoes & basil.
  $27.50
- Upside Down Siciliana (Slice)
  "The way it's done in the old neighborhood".
  $5.00
- Upside Down Siciliana (Pie)
  "The way it's done in the old neighborhood".
  $26.50
- Regular Sicilian (Slice)
  Square pie with a thick crust, traditionally topped with a robust tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
  $4.50
- Regular Sicilian (Pie)
  Generously topped with melted mozzarella, rich tomato sauce, and a sprinkle of herbs on a thick, airy crust.
  $28.50
- Grandma Rustico (Pie)
  Grilled chicken or crumbled sausage. Thin crust with crumbled sausage or grilled chicken & broccoli rabe.
  $32.00
- Vodka (Slice) Square
  Square slice topped with a smooth blend of tomato, vodka, and cream sauce, along with a mix of cheeses.
  $4.25
- Vodka (Pie)
  Creamy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil leaves on a square-cut pizza.
  $29.95
- Grandma Tuscana (Slice)
  Thin crust with crumbled sausage and vodka sauce topped with a sprinkle of pecorino Romano.
  $5.00
- Grandma Tuscana (Pie)
  Thin crust with crumbled sausage and vodka sauce topped with a sprinkle of pecorino Romano.
  $32.00
Calzones, Rolls & Knots
- Broccoli Roll
  Golden-brown dough filled with melted cheese and tender broccoli florets.
  $10.00
- Cheese Calzone
  Golden-brown calzone filled with melted cheese, served with a side of marinara sauce and a fresh green salad.
  $10.00
- Chicken Roll
  Tender chicken pieces wrapped in golden-brown dough with melted cheese and a hint of marinara sauce.
  $10.25
- Eggplant Roll
  Pizza dough rolled and filled with tender slices of eggplant, typically includes a blend of cheeses and a savory sauce.
  $10.00
- Ham & Cheese Calzone
  A folded pizza dough pocket filled with savory ham and melted cheese, often accompanied by a blend of spices.
  $11.75
- Sausage Roll
  Savory pastry filled with seasoned, minced pork.
  $10.25
- Spinach Roll
  Filled with fresh spinach and melted cheese, wrapped in a golden, baked dough.
  $10.00
- Peperoni Pinwheel
  Savory pinwheels filled with pepperoni and melted cheese, rolled in a soft, golden dough.
  $5.00
- Spinach Pinwheel
  Homemade pizza dough rolled with fresh spinach, then sliced into pinwheel shapes and baked until golden.
  $5.00
- Buffalo Roll
  Stuffed with spicy buffalo chicken and drizzled with tangy hot sauce and creamy ranch dressing.
  $11.00
Appetizers
Quick bites that satisfy.
- Buffalo Calamari
  Tossed in hot sauce, served with blue cheese dressing.
  $18.95
- Chicken Bites
  Buffalo or BBQ served with blue cheese dressing.
  $15.95
- Fried Calamari
  Buffalo style add an extra cost.
  $19.00
- French Fries
  Crispy golden strips of deliciousness served hot and seasoned to perfection.
  $6.95
- Garlic Bread
  With mozzarella add at an extra cost.
  $8.00
- Mozzarella Sticks (6)
  Served with marinara.
  $16.00
- Stuffed Mushrooms
  Mushroom caps filled with creamy cheese, topped with crispy bacon bits and fresh green onions.
  $16.00
- Zucchini Sticks
  Crispy breaded zucchini sticks served with a tangy marinara dipping sauce.
  $16.00
- Pepperoni Bites
  Bite-sized pizza dough parcels filled with pepperoni, lightly seasoned with herbs and sesame seeds.
  $6.50
- Chicken Fingers
  With fries.
  $16.50
- Garlic Knots (6)
  Six golden knots, infused with garlic butter and a hint of parsley.
  $3.50
- Buffalo Chicken Wings (10)
  Tender chicken wings coated in spicy buffalo sauce, served with celery, carrot sticks, and a side of creamy dipping sauce.
  $18.00
- Fried Cheese Ravioli (6)
  Served with tomato sauce on the side.
  $16.00
Soups / Zuppe
Fresh & made to order, never frozen or out of a can.
- Chicken Noodle
  Tender chicken, wide egg noodles, and sliced carrots in a savory broth with fresh herbs.
  $8.50
- Lentil
  A hearty blend of lentils, carrots, and spinach in a savory broth.
  $8.50
- Minestrone
  A hearty vegetable soup with pasta, beans, and diced tomatoes, garnished with grated cheese and fresh parsley.
  $8.50
- Pasta Fagioli
  Tender ditalini pasta, cannellini beans, tomatoes, green beans, and carrots in a savory broth with fresh herbs.
  $8.50
Pasta Specialties - Dinner
Choice of pasta: capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
- Alfredo
  Fettuccine Alfredo with choice of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $20.95
- Alla Vodka
  Vodka sauce-coated pasta, options include capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $20.95
- Bolognese
  Rich meat sauce, choice of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $20.95
- Broccoli
  Broccoli sautéed with your choice of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $18.95
- Garlic & Oil
  Garlic & oil pasta, choice of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $17.95
- Marinara
  Marinara pasta available with your choice of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $17.95
- Meatballs or Sausage
  Choice of meatballs or sausage served with capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne options.
  $20.95
- Meat Sauce
  Rich, slow-cooked meat sauce served with a choice of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $20.95
- Red or White Clam Sauce
  Clam sauce, choice of red tomato or white garlic. Options of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $23.95
- Tomato Sauce
  Classic tomato sauce over your choice of capellini, spaghetti, linguini, penne, or whole wheat penne.
  $17.95
- Pasta With Chicken & Broccoli
  Grilled chicken, Chopped tomatoes, broccoli Garlic oil.
  $22.00
- Rigatoni Fiorentina
  Grilled chicken, Fresh Spinach in a creamy vodka sauce topped with melted mozzarella. Side salad on the side.
  $22.00
- Linguini With Shrimp & Broccoli
  Shrimp, broccoli, Chopped Tomatoes, Garlic Oil
  $23.00
- Pasta Ala Carbonara
  Pancetta, peas, and shallots in a cream sauce.
  $20.95
Baked Entrées / Pasta Al Forno - Dinner
Served with salad & bread.
- Baked Ziti
  Tender Ziti Pasta in a Rich Tomato Sauce, Baked with Mozzarella Cheese
  $18.50
- Baked Ravioli
  Cheese-filled ravioli baked in marinara sauce, topped with melted mozzarella and sprinkled with fresh herbs.
  $18.50
- Lasagna
  Layers of pasta, rich meat sauce, and creamy ricotta cheese, topped with melted mozzarella and fresh basil.
  $18.50
- Manicotti
  Stuffed pasta tubes filled with seasoned ricotta cheese, topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, garnished with fresh parsley.
  $18.75
- Stuffed Shells
  Large pasta shells filled with creamy ricotta, spinach, and herbs, baked in a rich tomato sauce and topped with grated Parmesan.
  $18.50
Chicken Entrées / Specialita Di Pollo
Served with choice of pasta with tomato sauce, salad & bread.
- Chicken Cutlet Milanese
  Breaded chicken cutlet.
  $26.50
- Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
  Breaded chicken cutlet topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella.
  $26.95
- Chicken Marsala
  Boneless chicken breast sautéed with mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.
  $28.50
- Chicken Francese
  Boneless chicken breast sautéed in a lemon, butter & white wine sauce.
  $28.50
- Chicken Piccata
  Boneless chicken breast sautéed in a lemon white wine caper sauce.
  $28.50
- Chicken Sorrentino
  Boneless chicken breast with eggplant, prosciutto & mozzarella in a red sauce.
  $28.50
- Chicken Verdi
  Egg battered chicken, white wine lemon butter sauce, broccoli, and mozzarella cheese.
  $28.50
- Chicken Alla Vodka
  Breaded chicken, melted mozzarella, and creamy vodka sauce.
  $28.95
- Breaded Chicken Bruschetta
  Topped with fresh mozzarella, fresh chopped tomatoes, onions & topped with balsamic glazed.
  $28.50
- Grilled Chicken Bruschetta
  Topped with fresh mozzarella, fresh chopped tomatoes, onions & Topped with balsamic glazed.
  $28.50
- Grilled Chicken And Broccoli Rabe Dinner
  Served with your choice of pasta and a side salad. Bread on the side.
  $29.50
Veal Entrées / Specialita Di Vitello
- Veal Cutlet Milanese
  Breaded veal cutlet served on a bed of romaine lettuce.
  $30.50
- Veal Cutlet Parmigiana
  Breaded veal cutlet topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella.
  $30.95
- Veal Marsala
  Veal sautéed with mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.
  $30.95
- Veal Francese
  Veal sautéed in a lemon, butter & white wine sauce.
  $30.95
- Veal Piccata
  Veal sautéed in a lemon white wine and caper sauce.
  $30.95
- Veal Sorrentino
  Veal, eggplant, prosciutto & mozzarella in a red sauce.
  $31.95
Seafood Entrées / Specialita Di Pesce
- Shrimp Marinara or Fra Diavolo
  Shrimp sautéed in marinara sauce (mild or hot).
  $30.95
- Shrimp Francese
  Sautéed shrimp in a lemon, butter & white wine sauce.
  $30.95
- Shrimp Scampi
  Delicately seasoned shrimp sautéed in a light butter, garlic & white wine sauce.
  $30.50
- Shrimp Oreganata
  Breaded shrimp in a garlic, white wine sauce topped with seasoned bread crumbs.
  $30.50
- Seafood Platter
  Clams, mussels, shrimp, and calamari served with a mild or spicy marinara sauce.
  $32.50
Eggplant Entrées / Specialita Di Melanzane
- Eggplant Parmigiana
  Baked eggplant in tomato sauce topped with mozzarella.
  $23.95
- Eggplant Rollatini
  Baked eggplant stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella.
  $24.95
- Eggplant Rollatini with Spinach
  Baked eggplant stuffed with ricotta, sautéed spinach & mozzarella.
  $25.95
Vegetables / Verdura
- Sautéed Broccoli Florets
  Broccoli florets sautéed with garlic, roasted tomatoes, capers, and extra virgin olive oil, finished with parmesan cheese and a squeeze of lemon.
  $13.75
- Sautéed Broccoli Rabe
  Tender sautéed broccoli rabe with garlic and olive oil.
  $14.00
- Sautéed Spinach
  Tender sautéed spinach with garlic, chili flakes, and a hint of lemon zest.
  $13.75
- Sautéed Mushrooms
  Mushrooms sautéed in garlic and olive oil, typically includes a blend of herbs for added flavor.
  $13.75
- Mixed Veggie Plate
  A medley of seasonal vegetables, typically sautéed, offering a variety of textures and flavors.
  $14.25
Heroes
- Chicken Parmigiana Hero
  Tender breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, served on a toasted hero roll.
  $16.00
- Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
  Baked eggplant in tomato sauce topped with mozzarella.
  $16.00
- Grilled Chicken Cutlet Hero
  Iceberg lettuce, tomato, mayo.
  $16.00
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero
  Marinara sauce, meatballs, and parmesan cheese on a hero bread.
  $16.00
- Cold Italian Hero
  Ham, salami, provolone, mozzarella, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes & our signature house dressing.
  $16.00
- Sausage Parmigiana
  Smothered in marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, this hero features savory sausage nestled in a toasted roll.
  $15.00
- Sausage, Peppers & Onions
  Italian sausage with sautéed peppers and onions, served on a hero bread.
  $16.00
- Shrimp Parmigiana
  Breaded shrimp topped with marinara sauce, melted mozzarella, and fresh basil in a sandwich.
  $16.95
- Veal Parmigiana
  Tender veal cutlet, with rich tomato sauce, and melted Parmesan – classic Italian comfort.
  $16.95
Beverages
- Bottled Water
  Pure and refreshing bottled water.
  $3.25
- 20 Oz Bottle
  20 oz bottled beverages. Options include cola, diet cola, and lemon-lime.
  $3.50
Desserts
- Fresh Filled Cannoli
  Crisp pastry shell traditionally filled with sweetened ricotta cheese and chocolate chips, often garnished with powdered sugar.
  $5.50
- NY Style Cheesecake
  $7.50