Main Street Italian Eatery

We're excited to announce that this winter, we're giving Main Street Pizza Company a complete makeover! Going forward you can enjoy all of your favorite authentic Italian classics & pizza at "Main Street Italian Eatery". Get ready to indulge in your Italian favorites from our scratch kitchen. Everything from Main Street Italian Eatery is made completely from scratch and never frozen. Make your reservations now for a dinner experience that your taste buds will never forget. We are the home to the Farmingdale Pop Up events including Witchcraft, Christmas Club and The Wonder Pop Ups. Thanks to the support of our amazing customers and community we will be adding new and exciting venues in 2023!