Search
Maggies Original Cookie Co Menu
4.8
(75+ Reviews)
Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.- Cream Cheese BrownieFor chocolate addicts only$3.50
- 3.5 Dozen TraySmall tray with 42 favorites$44.00
- 4.5 Dozen TraySmall tray with 54 favorites$58.00
- Gourmet Delights Big CookiesBig Cookies need a minimum of 1 1/2 hours for order to be baked and decorated for delivery!$24.00
- 6.5 Dozen TrayLarge tray with 78 favorites$82.00
- 8.0 Dozen TrayLarge tray with 96 favorites$98.00
- 7.5 Dozen TrayLarge tray with 90 favorites$92.00
- Traditional Treats Big CookiesBig Cookies need a minimum of 1 1/2 hours for order to be baked and decorated for delivery.$24.00
Big Cookies
Let us help make birthdays, holidays, anniversaries, or any other special occasion extra special with a big, decorated cookie! 12” in diameter to feed between 8-12 people. Big Cookies order time is 1 hour to allow for baking and decorating- Traditional Treats Big CookiesBig Cookies need a minimum of 1 1/2 hours for order to be baked and decorated for delivery.$24.00
- Gourmet Delights Big CookiesBig Cookies need a minimum of 1 1/2 hours for order to be baked and decorated for delivery!$24.00
Celebration Trays
Let us help your party get started and be a part of the special occasion!- 3.5 Dozen TraySmall tray with 42 favorites$44.00
- 4.5 Dozen TraySmall tray with 54 favorites$58.00
- 6.5 Dozen TrayLarge tray with 78 favorites$82.00
- 7.5 Dozen TrayLarge tray with 90 favorites$92.00
- 8.0 Dozen TrayLarge tray with 96 favorites$98.00
Bars & Brownies
- Cream Cheese BrownieFor chocolate addicts only$3.50
- Fudge BrownieNothin plain about this brownie$3.00
- German ChocolateYummy combo of chocolate and caramel$3.00
- Lemon BarLuscious lemon with cream cheese$3.00
- Magic Cookie BarAn incredible disappearing act$3.00
- Rocky RoadThese will make the journey smoother$3.00
Gourmet Delights
- ButterfingerDon't lose a finger on the butterfinger cookie$1.00
- Candy BarTwo desserts in one$1.00
- Gourmet Chocolate ChipThe ultimate chocolate chip cookie$1.00
- No BakesYou’ll never no-bake them again$1.00
- Nutty Chocolate ChipSometimes you just feel like a nut$1.00
- Peanut Butter ChunkBig chunks of heaven$1.00
- Peanut Butter No BakesMaggie’s original recipe$1.00
- Smiley Face CookieGuaranteed to brighten anyone’s day$1.00
- Triple Chocolate SinA rich chocolate cookie studded with white and dark chocolate chunks.$1.00
Traditional Treats
- Chocolate ChipJust like your momma’s... Only better$1.00
- Coconut MacaroonsBetter than the classic!$1.00
- Kiss CookieUp for peanut butter and chocolate$1.00
- M&m CookieMelts in your mouth not in your hands$1.00
- Maggie’s MistakesOne of maggie’s best mistakes by far$1.00
- Mexican WeddingPecan sandie dusted with powdered sugar$1.00
- Oatmeal Chewie$1.00
- Oatmeal RaisinThis classic needs no introduction$1.00
- Peanut ButterPeter pan never had it so good$1.00
- Raspberry ThumbprintPersonalized shortbread$1.00
- Sand TartThe beach isn't any better$1.00
- SnickerdoodleYummy name, better to eat$1.00
- Sugar CookieMelts in your mouth not in your hands$1.00
Bars and Brownies
- Cream Cheese BrownieFor chocolate addicts only$3.50
- Fudge BrownieNothin plain about this brownie$3.00
- German Chocolate Brownie$3.00
- Lemon BarLuscious lemon with cream cheese$3.00
- Magic Cookie BarAn incredible disappearing act$3.00
- Rocky Road Brownie$3.00
