Made in New York Pizza Menu

4.4
(200+ Reviews)
$Pizza
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Cheese Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
      $24.00
    • Spicy Pepperoni Pie

      Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
      $35.00
    • 5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce

      $4.00
    • Pepperoni Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
      $29.00
    • Vodka Pie

      Homemade vodka sauce, pecorino, fresh mozzarella, topped with basil and e.v.o.o
      $29.00
    • Margherita Pie

      Tomato sauce, fior di latte cheese, and fresh basil on a classic round pie, finished with a drizzle of olive oil.
      $29.00
    • Grandma Pie

      Aged & fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, hand-crushed seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh chopped garlic, sicilian oregano, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil.
      $29.00
    • Sausage Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
      $29.00
    • Pinwheel

      Homemade dough envelops a generous layer of pepperoni and a rich blend of cheeses, all baked to achieve a golden crust.
      $5.00
    • Coca Cola

      The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
      $3.00
  • Round Pies

    • Cheese Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano.
      $24.00
    • Pepperoni Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school large pepperoni.
      $29.00
    • Sausage Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with old-school sliced, sweet Italian sausage.
      $29.00
    • Vodka Pie

      Homemade vodka sauce, pecorino, fresh mozzarella, topped with basil and e.v.o.o
      $29.00
    • Mushroom Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino Romano, and Sicilian oregano topped with fresh mushrooms.
      $29.00
    • Margherita Pie

      Tomato sauce, fior di latte cheese, and fresh basil on a classic round pie, finished with a drizzle of olive oil.
      $29.00
    • White Spinach Pie

      A blend of cheeses, fresh spinach and garlic.
      $34.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Pie

      Mozzarella cheese and breaded chicken marinated in frank's red hot sauce, topped with a ranch drizzle
      $34.00
    • BBQ Chicken Pie

      Mozzarella cheese and breaded chicken marinated in classic sweet baby rays bbq sauce.
      $34.00
    • Spinach Mushroom Pie

      Spinach and mushrooms atop a light, savory sauce, finished with a generous blend of cheeses on a classic round pie crust.
      $34.00
    • Sausage Pepperoni Pie

      Tomato sauce and a blend of cheeses topped with sausage and pepperoni on a hand-stretched dough.
      $35.00
    • Pepperoni Mushroom Pie

      Tomato sauce and a blend of cheeses topped with pepperoni and fresh mushrooms.
      $35.00
    • Sausage Jalapeno Pie

      Hand-stretched dough topped with a robust pizza sauce, a blend of cheeses, savory sausage pieces, and slices of jalapeño for a spicy kick.
      $35.00
    • Sausage Mushroom Pie

      Hand-stretched dough, tomato sauce, a blend of cheeses, Italian sausage, and garlic roasted mushrooms.
      $35.00
    • Gluten Free Pie

      Gluten-free crust pizza, offering a base for various toppings.
      $18.00
    • Yo Paulie Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino romano, and sicilian oregano tipped with pepperoni, hot cherry peppers and honey drizzle.
      $32.00
    • Street Fair Pie

      California tomatoes, aged whole milk mozzarella, pecorino romano, and sicilian oregano, sweet italian sausage, white onion and hot cherry peppers.
      $32.00
  • Square Pies

    • Classic Sicilian Pie

      Homemade marinara sauce, sicilian oregano, pecorino and mozzarella.
      $29.00
    • Veggie Pie

      Tomato sauce, broccoli, mushrooms, peppers, onions, and fresh tomatoes typically included in this square pie.
      $34.00
    • Upside Down Pie

      Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano.
      $29.00
    • Spicy Pepperoni Pie

      Slow-cooked tomato sauce, aged whole milk mozzarella, and a dusting of pecorino Romano topped with spicy cupping pepperoni.
      $35.00
    • Eggplant Pie

      Thick, square pizza slice topped with roasted eggplant, rich tomato sauce, fresh basil, and a sprinkle of grated cheese.
      $34.00
    • White Pie

      A four cheese blend, topped with basil and e.v.o.o
      $34.00
    • Grandma Pie

      Aged & fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, hand-crushed seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh chopped garlic, sicilian oregano, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil.
      $29.00
    • Vodka Square Pie

      A square pie featuring a creamy blend of tomato vodka sauce and assorted cheeses.
      $29.00
  • Sides

    • 5 Garlic Knots w/ Sauce

      $4.00
    • Pinwheel

      Homemade dough envelops a generous layer of pepperoni and a rich blend of cheeses, all baked to achieve a golden crust.
      $5.00
    • Chicken Roll

      Pizza dough filled with chicken, sauce, and cheese, then rolled and baked until golden.
      $9.00
    • Cheese Calzone

      Stuffed italian calzone filled with a rich blend of cheeses
      $8.50
  • Sodas

    • Coca Cola

      The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
      $3.00
    • Coke Zero

      The same great taste but with zero calories.
      $3.00
    • Diet Coke

      A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
      $3.00
    • Sprite

      The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
      $3.00
    • Sprite Zero

      The same iconic great taste with zero sugar.
      $3.00
    • Dr. Pepper

      Unique blend of 23 flavors, carbonated soft drink.
      $3.25
    • Root Beer

      Smooth, classic root beer with a rich, frothy head. Perfectly sweet and endlessly refreshing.
      $3.25
    • Fanta

      Refreshing carbonated beverage with a fruity twist, ideal for quenching your thirst.
      $3.25
    • Ginger Ale

      Refreshing, crisp ginger-flavored carbonated soft drink.
      $3.25
    • Seltzer Water

      Effervescent, crisp seltzer, perfect for refreshing hydration.
      $3.25
    • Lemonade

      Refreshing citrus beverage.
      $3.25
    • Fuze Tea

      A combination of tea and vitamins to offer consumers a healthy, great-tasting beverage with beneficial nutrients.
      $3.00
    • Gold Peak Tea

      A high quality ready-to-drink iced tea with an authentic home brewed taste.
      $3.25
    • Vitamin Water

      Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
      $3.25
    • Glass Bottles

      Glass bottled sodas, offering a selection of classic and specialty flavors.
      $3.75
  • Water

    • Bottled Water

      Sourced from natural springs, this water is known for its purity and refreshing taste.
      $2.50
    • Smart Water

      Every drop tastes pure and will leave you feeling refreshed.
      $3.00
    • Big Smart Water

      $5.00
  • Side Sauces

    • Ranch

      A tangy and creamy sauce, our ranch is a house-made blend of herbs and buttermilk, perfect for dipping your favorite pizza slices.
      $1.00
    • Balsamic

      A rich and tangy sauce, our balsamic is crafted to complement any pizza with its deep, complex flavors.
      $1.00
    • Golden Italian

      A zesty blend of olive oil, vinegar, herbs, and spices, creating a golden, tangy dressing ideal for complementing pizza.
      $1.00
    • Marinara

      A traditional sauce crafted with tomatoes, garlic, and a selection of herbs, simmered to enhance its natural flavors.
      $1.00
    • Mike's Hot Honey

      Mike's Hot Honey is honey infused with chili peppers, offering a unique blend of sweetness and heat.
      $1.00
    • BBQ

      A smoky and savory sauce, typically simmered with a blend of spices, tomatoes, and a hint of sweetness, ideal for enhancing pizzas and sides.
      $1.00
  • Desserts

    • NY Cheesecake

      Classic new york cheesecake: rich, creamy, with a silky smooth texture.
      $7.50
    • Tiramisu

      Classic Italian dessert made with ladyfingers soaked in coffee, layered with mascarpone cheese and dusted with cocoa.
      $7.50
    • Cannolis

      Crisp pastry shells filled with sweetened ricotta, often accompanied by chocolate chips or pistachios, and dusted with powdered sugar.
      $7.50

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?


(646) 449-8556

271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms