Legal Sea Foods - Short Hills Menu

4.0

(1,000+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Starters Salads & Bowls Sandwiches From the Sea Butcher's Table Legal Classics Pasta Lobster Crispy Fried Sides Desserts Saratoga Spring Water Kids' Menu Soup by the Quart and Gallon

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Legal Lobster Roll
  warm butter-poached or traditional with lemon mayo, french fries, coleslaw
  $46.00
- Crab Cake, A Legal Signature
  lump crab, mustard sauce, greens, corn, onions, tomatoes, Dijon vinaigrette
  $25.00
- New England Clam Chowder
  Our classic recipe.
  $9.00
- Kids' Grilled Salmon
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $12.00
- Salmon*, grilled
  HELGELAND COAST, NORWAY; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $35.00
- Lobster Bisque
  cream sherry
  $10.50
- Crispy Calamari
  GULF OF MAINE, regular with tartar sauce or Rhode Island style (hot peppers & garlic)
  $18.50
- Classic Caesar Salad
  romaine hearts, garlic croutons, shaved romano, creamy dressing
  $12.50
- Fish & Chips
  NORTH ATLANTIC wild caught, french fries and coleslaw
  $29.00
- Greek Salad
  tomato, cucumber, feta, chickpeas, Kalamata olives, lemon-oregano vinaigrette
  $14.00
Starters
*Served raw or undercooked, or contains (or may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
- Shrimp Cocktail, Colossal Naked
  with cocktail sauce
  $21.00
- Tuna Tartare*
  gochujang marinated cucumbers, avocado crema, rice paper crisps
  $22.00
- Shrimp Ceviche
  citrus marinated shrimp, tomato, red onion, cilantro, blue corn tortilla, salsa roja
  $18.00
- Tuna Tataki*
  blackened, citrus soy sauce, kelp salad, wasabi cream
  $20.00
- New England Clam Chowder
  Our classic recipe.
  $9.00
- Lobster Bisque
  cream sherry
  $10.50
- Chowder Fries
  New England clam chowder, french fries, sharp cheddar cheese, bacon, scallions
  $17.00
- Crispy Calamari
  GULF OF MAINE, regular with tartar sauce or Rhode Island style (hot peppers & garlic)
  $18.50
- Fish Tacos
  NORTH ATLANTIC whitefish, pickled red cabbage, chipotle aioli, pico de gallo
  $17.00
- Crab Cake, A Legal Signature
  lump crab, mustard sauce, greens, corn, onions, tomatoes, Dijon vinaigrette
  $25.00
- Mussels, Organic PEI
  garlic-butter broth, white wine, grilled crusty bread
  $19.00
- Popcorn Shrimp
  chili lime aioli
  $17.00
- Bang Bang Cauliflower
  tempura fried, kung pao sauce (contains peanut oil)
  $17.00
- Edamame
  with sea salt or sticky soy sauce
  $8.00
- Kelp Salad
  MAINE, sesame chili vinaigrette
  $8.00
Salads & Bowls
*Served raw or undercooked, or contains (or may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
- Greek Salad
  tomato, cucumber, feta, chickpeas, Kalamata olives, lemon-oregano vinaigrette
  $14.00
- House Salad
  local organic leaf lettuce, tomato, roasted corn, hard boiled egg, red onion, croutons, apple Dijon vinaigrette
  $12.00
- Classic Caesar Salad
  romaine hearts, garlic croutons, shaved romano, creamy dressing
  $12.50
- Winter Chopped Salad
  romaine, radicchio, candied walnuts, blue cheese, pepitas, pomegranate, maple cider dressing
  $13.00
- Thai Peanut Salad
  napa cabbage, red cabbage, edamame, scallion, red pepper, peanut dressing, crispy rice noodles
  $14.00
- Grain Bowl
  farro, kimchi, pickled cabbage, avocado, kelp salad, pineapple, spicy mayo
  $13.00
Sandwiches
*Served raw or undercooked, or contains (or may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
- Crispy Fish Sandwich
  NORTH ATLANTIC wild caught whitefish, lettuce, tomato, pickle, tartar sauce, french fries, coleslaw
  $19.00
- Legal Lobster Roll
  warm butter-poached or traditional with lemon mayo, french fries, coleslaw
  $46.00
- Tuna Burger
  chili-garlic seasoned ground tuna, roasted red pepper sauce, french fries, coleslaw
  $20.00
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich
  applewood smoked bacon, Vermont cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo, french fries, coleslaw
  $19.00
- Bacon Cheddar Burger*
  DOUBLE R RANCH, WASHINGTON STATE, applewood smoked bacon, Vermont cheddar, lettuce, tomato, french fries, coleslaw
  $20.00
From the Sea
Choose a Protein From the Sea or Butcher's Table, a Flavor Style, and 2 Sides (Looking for today's fish origins? Please see click the red Freshly Sourced button on the menu page of legalseafoods.com) *Served raw or undercooked, or contains (or may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
- Cod Loin, seared
  ICELAND, MSC Certified Sustainable; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $33.00
- Rainbow Trout, grilled
  COLOMBIA, BAP 4-Star Certified Sustainable; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $29.00
- Arctic Char, grilled
  ICELAND; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $30.00
- Salmon*, grilled
  HELGELAND COAST, NORWAY; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $35.00
- Swordfish Steak, grilled
  WILD CAUGHT; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $41.00
- Yellowfin Tuna*, seared
  WILD CAUGHT; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $41.00
- Shrimp, grilled
  BAY OF BENGLA, All Natural BAP 4-Star Certified Sustainable; simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $35.00
Butcher's Table
simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
- Filet Mignon* 8oz, grilled
  simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $49.00
- Boneless Ribeye* 16oz, grilled
  simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $49.00
- Sirloin Steak Tips* 12oz, grilled
  simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $32.00
- Half Chicken, roasted
  simply prepared with lemon & olive oil, or enhance with one of our chef-curated flavor combinations. served with a choice of two sides
  $26.00
Legal Classics
- Cod , Salt & Vinegar Crusted
  ICELAND, crispy potato wedges, napa cabbage and bacon slaw, remoulade
  $33.00
- Haddock, Baked Anna's Way
  NORTH ATLANTIC, wild caught, buttered crumbs, roasted tomato, herbed rice pilaf, broccoli
  $29.50
- Crab Cake & Shrimp
  lump crab cake, grilled shrimp, mustard sauce, herbed rice pilaf, greens, corn, onion, tomato, Dijon vinaigrette
  $45.00
- Cioppino
  clams, mussels, scallops, shrimp, calamari, whitefish, lobster tail, tomato broth
  $46.00
Pasta
- Clams and Linguini
  clams, garlic-shallot confit, white wine, pancetta, chili flakes
  $30.00
- Shrimp Scampi
  linguini, tomato, sofrito, white wine, garlic butter
  $28.00
- Rigatoni Bolognese
  slow braised beef and pork ragù, marinara, ricotta, mascarpone
  $28.00
- Orecchiette Salsiccia
  sweet Italian sausage, mushrooms, leeks, tomatoes
  $26.00
Lobster
Gulf of Maine
- Stuffed Lobster Tails
  shrimp, scallops, peppers, onions, buttery crackers, choice of two sides
  $47.00
Crispy Fried
TRADITIONAL NEW ENGLAND OR ANGRY STYLE served with french fries and coleslaw
- Crispy Fried Shrimp, Jumbo Naked
  served with french fries and coleslaw
  $29.50
- Crispy Fried Scallops
  GULF OF MAINE, french fries and coleslaw
  $39.00
- New England Fried Clams
  NEW ENGLAND, sweet & petite, served with french fries and coleslaw
  $43.00
- Clam Strips
  NEW ENGLAND, french fries and coleslaw
  $29.00
- Fisherman's Platter
  jumbo naked shrimp, sea scallops, local whitefish, calamari, clam strips, served with french fries and coleslaw
  $48.00
- Fish & Chips
  NORTH ATLANTIC wild caught, french fries and coleslaw
  $29.00
Sides
- Coleslaw
  
  $4.00
- Herbed Rice Plilaf
  $9.00
- Steamed Jasmine Rice
  
  $9.00
- Roasted Mushrooms
  $9.00
- Steamed Broccoli
  Gluten-free.
  $9.00
- Brussels Sprouts with Bacon
  $9.00
- Crispy Potato Wedges
  $9.00
- Whipped Potatoes
  $9.00
- French Fries
  
  $9.00
Desserts
- New York Cheesecake
  seasonal topping
  $11.00
- Boston Cream Pie
  (contains nuts) sponge cake, custard, chocolate sauce, creme anglaise, almonds, toffee bits
  $11.00
- Espresso Torte
  strawberries, whipped cream
  $12.00
- Key Lime Pie
  lime custard, raspberry sauce, whipped cream
  $11.00
Saratoga Spring Water
- Saratoga Spring Water 28oz
  $8.00
- Saratoga Sparkling Water 28oz
  $8.00
Kids' Menu
ages 12 and under
- Kids' Burger/Cheeseburger
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Grilled Chicken Sandwich
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Grilled Cheese Sandwich
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Pasta
  with butter or red sauce, choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Mac & Cheese
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Grilled Salmon
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $12.00
- Kids' Grilled Chicken Breast
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Grilled Sirloin Tips
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $13.00
- Kids' Fish Fingers
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Popcorn Shrimp
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
- Kids' Chicken Fingers
  choice of kids' starter and two kids' sides
  $10.00
Soup by the Quart and Gallon
- Packaged Cold - Clam Chowder Quart
  packaged cold, ready to heat
  $24.00
- Packaged Cold - Clam Chowder Gallon
  packaged cold, ready to heat
  $90.00
- Packaged Cold - Lobster Bisque Quart
  packaged cold, ready to heat
  $30.00
- Packaged Hot - Clam Chowder Quart
  $24.00
- Packaged Hot - Clam Chowder Gallon
  $90.00
- Packaged Hot - Lobster Bisque Quart
  Packaged by the quart
  $30.00