Lefty's Bagels Menu

Indulge in our delectable oatmeal raisin blueberry cookie, where hearty oats, plump raisins, and bursts of juicy blueberries combine for a delightful treat. Each bite offers a satisfying crunch from the oats, balanced by chewy pockets of caramel-like raisins and tangy bursts of blueberry sweetness.

Satiny soft dough made with butter, and cream cheese wrapped around a filling. Rugelach, which in Yiddish means "little twists." Beloved in many Jewish communities, these cookies flake like a Danish or croissant with its buttery flavor the perfect foil for the sweet filling within.

Our Babka, meticulously crafted by skilled artisans, boasts a swirl of heavenly dough entwined with layers of premium fillings. Each bite offers a symphony of textures—soft, buttery layers melding with luscious chocolate, cinnamon, or fruit.

One of our traditional NYC style kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily topped with schmear of your choice. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flour in our bagels!

Six of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!\r\n\r\nPlease select 6 bagels from the selections before adding to cart.

A dozen (12) of our Traditional NYC hand made, kettle-boiled bagels, sweetened with malt and baked daily right here in our store. We only use unbromated, unbleached, natural flours in our bagels!\r\n\r\nPlease select 12 bagels from the selections before adding to cart

Unlike a bagel, it does not have a hole in the middle, but a depression and is only baked. Filled with classic sauteed onion.

Freshly baked bagel with farm fresh locally raised egg

Freshly baked bagel with sauage patty, egg, and cheese.

Bagel with nova lox, farm fresh egg, and sautéed onion

Your choice of corned beef or pastrami, farm fresh egg, potato latke, and sautéed onion on a fresh bagel

Western style bagel sandwich, eggs, ham, bell peppers, sauteed onion and jack cheese

Freshly baked bagel with black forest ham, scrambled egg, and cheese.

Freshly baked bagel with fried salami, scrambled egg, and cheese.

Freshly baked bagel with Pastrami Smoked Salmon and plain cream cheese

Freshly baked bagel with whole Smoked Whitefish and Plain Cream Cheese

Freshly baked bagel with Smoked Sable and Plain Cream Cheese

Freshly baked bagel with Smoked Trout and Plain Cream Cheese

Locally Cured Applewood Smoked Thick Cut Bacon

Maple sausage formed into handmade patties

Thinly sliced and roasted to perfection

100% all Beef Salami

Hot New York style corned beef with a strong flavor profile, no mild cure here! A classic corned beef with an unforgettable garlic flavor.

New York top round roast beef slow roasted at extremely low temperatures to maintain integrity and keep natural juices intact. The result is a roast beef that is never dry, red throughout with a natural flavor, taste, and texture.

A savory perfection of our Oven Roasted Turkey, meticulously prepared to satisfy your culinary desires. Crafted from premium, hand-selected turkeys, each succulent slice offers a symphony of flavors and textures, promising a delightful dining experience.

Experience the rich, smoky essence of our Hardwood Smoked Turkey, a testament to craftsmanship and flavor. Hand-selected for quality and taste, each slice embodies a perfect blend of tradition and culinary innovation.

Delight in the bold and savory flavors of our Turkey Pastrami, a contemporary twist on a classic favorite. Expertly crafted with premium turkey breast, each slice embodies a perfect balance of robust spices and tender texture, promising a gourmet experience like no other.

Indulge in the rich and savory flavors of our All Beef Salami, a testament to artisanal craftsmanship and timeless taste. Made exclusively from premium beef, each slice offers a robust blend of spices and a satisfying texture that captivates the palate.

An exceptional taste of our Black Forest Ham, a premium delicacy that embodies the essence of tradition and craftsmanship. Carefully prepared from select pork, each slice offers a harmonious balance of smokiness and savory sweetness, perfect for discerning palates.

Freshly baked bagel with roast beef, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, horseradish cheese or provolone

You know - Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, on a freshly baked bagel

Freshly baked bagel with hot pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and deli mustard

Freshly baked bagel with beef salami, Swiss cheese and deli mustard

Freshly baked bagel with ham, pickles, Swiss cheese, and mayonnaise

Freshly baked bagel with turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, Provolone cheese and mayonnaise

Fresh avocado, diced tomato, lemon, salt & pepper on a fresh bagel

Sliced cucumber and dill cream cheese on a bagel of your choice

New York Pizza meets Lefty's Bagel! Four Cheese blend, and choice of toppings

Home-made whitefish salad using chunks of smoked whitefish with lettuce and tomato on freshly baked bagel

Home-made using farm fresh eggs with lettuce and tomato on a freshly baked bagel

Home-made chicken salad with lettuce and tomato on a freshly baked bagel

Elevate your snacking experience with our Bagel Chips, a delightful fusion of robust flavors and crunchy texture. Crafted from our authentic bagels, each chip is infused with the savory essence of garlic and a medley of herbs, creating a gourmet treat that's perfect for any occasion

Kosher Dill or Half Sour

Indulge in our delectable oatmeal raisin blueberry cookie, where hearty oats, plump raisins, and bursts of juicy blueberries combine for a delightful treat. Each bite offers a satisfying crunch from the oats, balanced by chewy pockets of caramel-like raisins and tangy bursts of blueberry sweetness.

Satiny soft dough made with butter, and cream cheese wrapped around a filling. Rugelach, which in Yiddish means "little twists." Beloved in many Jewish communities, these cookies flake like a Danish or croissant with its buttery flavor the perfect foil for the sweet filling within.

Our Babka, meticulously crafted by skilled artisans, boasts a swirl of heavenly dough entwined with layers of premium fillings. Each bite offers a symphony of textures—soft, buttery layers melding with luscious chocolate, cinnamon, or fruit.

Comes with: - 96 oz of coffee - Quart of Half & Half - 10 - 12 oz cups, lids, sleeves - Sugar in the Raw/Stevia in the Raw - Coffee stirrers

Firepot Breakfast Organic Black Tea (16oz) - Notes of dried cherry and fresh oak.

Iced Classic Black Tea from Firepot Tea (16oz) - Notes of dried cherry and malt.

Classic New York Deli Soda

Fresh, cold, and creamy whole milk, perfectly refreshing and nutritious.

Rich, creamy milk flavored with velvety smooth chocolate.

A perfect complement to lunch on the road, Martinelli's 10 fl. oz. glass bottle contains 100% juice from U.S. grown fresh apples. It contains no chemical additives and is not from concentrate. Just premium apple juice.

Natalies Orange Juice

Every drop tastes pure and will leave you feeling refreshed.

8oz container of garlic and herb cream cheese

8oz container of veggie cream cheese

8oz container of nova lox cream cheese

8oz container of scallion cream cheese

8oz container of jalapeño cream cheese

8oz container of strawberry cream cheese

8oz container of blueberry cream cheese

Light and airy whipped butter, ideal for spreading on your favorite breakfast items.

A creamy blend of chickpeas, tahini, lemon juice, and fresh garlic.

Choice of two-ounce spreads. Options include savory, sweet, and classic varieties such as Plain, Nova Lox, and Blueberry.

Fresh salmon, salt, sugar and a smoldering fire is all we use to make all of our cold smoked salmon.\r\n4oz or 8oz pre-packaged

Our buttery whitefish hails from the great lakes. Order by the pound.\n\n*whole fish is available by request and weigh between 2.5 and 3.5 pounds

Our Sable is caught in the icy waters off of Alaska. Buttery, rich and a must on any appetizing platter.\r\nAvailable by the pound

A delightful medley of tender, diced chicken breast blended with crisp, colorful vegetables and a creamy dressing, creating a harmonious balance of flavors and textures.

Tuna salad combines flaky albacore tuna with a creamy mayonnaise and chopped celery.

Our Egg Salad presents a classic blend of finely chopped hard-boiled eggs, mixed with creamy mayonnaise and diced celery.

Kippered salmon salad features tender flakes of smoked salmon mixed with a creamy mayonnaise.

Cured beef available in various sizes, from 1/4 pound to 1 pound.

Thinly sliced beef salami, available in various sizes from a quarter-pound to a full pound.

Succulent oven roasted turkey slices. Options range from 1/4 to 1 pound.

Hardwood smoked turkey by the pound. Select your preferred size from a quarter-pound to a full pound.

Slices of turkey pastrami sold by weight. Choose from various size options ranging from 1/4 pound to 1 pound.

Tender sliced roast beef. Available in sizes from 1/4 pound to 1 pound.