Starters
- Turtle Wings
- South Village Chislic
- Circle City Onion Rings To Share
- Dillinger Fries To Share
- Teepee Cheese And Sausage
- Garfield Park-Chos
- Manual Sticks
- Indy 500 Fingers
- Southport Pepper Jack Balls
- State Fair Spiral Cut Chips
Salads
- Unser Caesar Salad
- Aj Salad
- 1879 Salad
- Al Capone Salad
Sandwiches
- Hoosier Sandwich
- Parkway Dog
- Last Chance Dog
- Georgetown Sandwich
- Key West Fish & Chips
- Prohibition Pork
- Smith Valley Grilled Ham & Cheese
- Southie Cheese
Side
- Coleslaw
- Cottage Ch
Specialty Pies
- The 1879
- Death By Scorpion Sauce Pie
- Katie Bug Pie
- Cutie Pie
- The Duke
- Last Chance Pie
- Garlic Cheese Bread
- Breadsticks
Desserts
- Dessert Pizza 10 Inch
- Dessert Of The Moment
Last Chance Pizza
- Cheese
- 1 Topping
- 2 Topping
Appetizer/Desserts
- Cheese Bread With Smoked Provolone
- Cannoli's
