L'Antica Pizzeria Da Michele Belmont Shore

We stopped in early afternoon kn a random tuesday. Margherita pizza with prosciutto and arugula was fam5astic. Good dough, decent sauce and thin. Pretty good for italian pizza in america. Servers and staff were super ni e amd inviting. The price seemed good too! Grazie per tutto.

We arrived early and sat at the bar. Lovely service staff. Food was out of this world, everything we ate was delicious! Actually felt like we were dinning in someone’s private home! We will return!!!

Delightful evening with friends, the appetizers (arancini, stuffed pizza dough) were perfect for sharing.

Extremely Disappointing Experience at L'Antica Pizzeria Da Michele Belmont Shore I recently visited L'Antica Pizzeria Da Michele Belmont Shore, and I must say that my experience was extremely disappointing. Despite the restaurant being almost empty, with only two other customers, the service and quality of food were far from satisfactory. I arrived at the restaurant around 5:15 pm and ordered the authentic traditional margherita pizza and a Caesar salad. However, the food took an unbelievably long time to arrive at my table. It wasn't until 6:20 pm that I finally received my order, and to make matters worse, the food was already cold. Waiting for over an hour for a single pizza is simply ridiculous and unacceptable. I will give credit to the initial server who attended to me. He was knowledgeable and provided good service. However, after he left, the service deteriorated significantly. The lack of attention and care was evident, as I was left waiting for an extended period without any explanation or updates on my order. In an attempt to rectify the delay, the staff offered me a complimentary dessert as I was leaving. While the gesture was appreciated, it did little to make up for the overall poor experience. The inconvenience and disappointment I faced throughout my visit make it clear that I will not be returning to L'Antica Pizzeria Da Michele Belmont Shore again. I expected better from a restaurant with such a reputation, but unfortunately, this experience fell far below my expectations. I would caution anyone considering dining at this establishment to be prepared for long waits and subpar service. There are plenty of other options in the area that offer better quality food and more efficient service.

I ordered 2 margarita pizzas to go , both were raw and had holes in the center with a long brown hair on one. Absolutely disgusting. And pizzas are gummy. Cook the dough 1 more minute