Lake Effect Ice Cream Menu

Our award-winning salty caramel ice cream drizzled with hot caramel sauce, covered by locally made chenez caramel corn, and then finished with real whipped cream.

Big wayne's cake batter ice cream, brownie chunks, chocolate sauce, real whipped cream, rainbow sprinkles, and a candle pssssst... It can be your birthday every day!

Coconut ice cream drizzled with local vanilla honey and paired with two small scoops of black sesame ice cream topped off with toasted black sesame seeds, real whipped cream, and an amazing lotus blossom cookie made for us by our friends at west side bazaar

Our red velvet paula's donut and silver cloud vanilla ice creams drizzled with white and dark chocolate sauces, then finished with real whipped cream, and brightly colored rock candy to pay homage to the north park theatre's iconic neon sign.

A big ball of frozen hot chocolate ice cream covered in flame-toasted mini marshmallows and topped with chocolate sauce, real whipped cream, and graham crackers

House chocolate ice cream, covered with extra hot fudge topped with dicamillo's chocolate biscotti di prato, real whipped cream, and even more chocolate sauce

El guapo vanilla ice cream rolled in chrusciki bakery cinnamon crumbles, topped with fiegel apiaries honey, cinnamon chocolate, real whipped cream and a tater cakes bakery cinnamon crisp

A scoop each of our salty caramel, peanut butter epiphany, and revolution coffee ice cream is paired with a complimentary sauce, real whipped cream, and a locally-made, super decadent, blue table chocolate truffle

Revolution coffee and silver cloud vanilla ice creams separated by forno bonomi ladyfingers, topped with espresso and rum sauces then finished with real whipped cream, dark chocolate flakes, and dusted with confectioners sugar

Unique, hand-crafted sundaes using locally sourced ingredients

Ask for selections

Includes ice cream - 1 topping and real whipped cream

Ask for selections

Homemade freeze pop

Simplicity at its best. A rich and creamy meyer lemon ice cream with just a hint of tartness. A summer favorite.

Our rich glazed donut ice cream blended with big chunks of paulas glazed frycakes

Our award winning salty-sweet masterpiece just one taste and you will be hooked! Gf

Decadent brownie batter ice cream dirtied up with sem sweet chocolate and lots of soft chocolate. Cookies

Gf without a doubt the best peanut butter ice cream you will ever eat. Blended with milk chocolate +peanuts

Our newest paula's donut creation. Rich red velvet ice cream packed with paula's red velvet donuts

Gf we swirl fresh strawbery puree together with our silver cloud vanilla. A perfect summer treat!

Slightly sweet and nutty. This exotic flavor is unlike any ice cream you have tried gf

It's like you get to lick the bowl after making a cake. Decadently rich!

Our famous hot chocolate ice cream. Super creamy and it really does taste like hot chocolate

Gf just like the iconic wny drink. You will be dreaming of riding the comet at crystal beach

Gf tennessee sour mash whiskey blended with sweet cream + browar sugar

Gf a unique earl grey tea ice cream mixed with chocolate covered toffee pieces

Gf a bright blue ice cream that tastes a lot like fruity pebbles!

We created a new cocoa blend just for our new chocolate ice cream. It's a deep, rich milk chocolate gf

Gf from the blue mountain's of southern india we bring you the best vanilla ice cream ever

A classic flavor taken to a whole new level! Packed with chocolate chips and cookie dough pieces

Our vanilla ice cream packed full of crushed oreos and swirls of ghiradelli white chocolate sauce

A new kind of coffee ice cream made with turkish ground revolution coffee from our friends at public espresso gf

We tricked out this classic flavor by adding semi sweet dark chocolate flakes

We tricked out this classic flavor by adding semi sweet dark chocoate flakes

For the coconut purist. Simple and rich coconut ice cream blended with sweet coconut flakes. Gf

We tricked out this classic flavor by adding semi sweet dark chocoate flakes

Our silver cloud vanilla with peanut butter and caramel swirls. We then pack it with chocolate covered potato chips

Totally unique and amazing! Date and coconut ice cream with dark chocolate and brazil nuts

Our tribute to cheektowaga caramel infused mascarpone ice cream with prince polo candy bars+ mixed nuts

The infamous hogsmeade drink now as a creamy, buttery ice cream. Mischief managed!

Traditional green peppermint ice cream packed with chocolate mint grasshopper cookies

Our 2021 mother's day flavor! A sweet, tart, orange sherbet spiked with champagne

Simple, fluffy and rich, tastes like vanilla cake batter, and frosting in one!"

Yep, you read it correctly sponge candy ice cream stuffed with chunks of platters sponge candy