Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Papa's Pizza Oven - Hamburg Menu

4.2
(375+ Reviews)
$Pizza
Order Online
Call
(716) 646-6655
Order Online

  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.

    • Dash App: Half Cheese (Top-Your-Own) Pizza

      A rectangular pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce.
      $15.34

    • Dash App: Cheese (Top-Your-Own Pizza) (Large)

      Golden-brown crust topped with melted mozzarella cheese and rich tomato sauce, cut into slices.
      $28.30

    • Dash App: Half Pizza(6 slices) + 10 Wings (Toppings $2.36)

      Half pizza (6 slices) and 10 wings special. Toppings available for an additional charge.
      $30.65

    • Dash App: Bread Sticks (5)

      Typically includes garlic butter and parmesan cheese, made from our pizza dough and baked to a golden finish.
      $5.89

    • Dash App: Chicken Wings (10)

      Breaded and fried chicken wings, typically served with a variety of sauces such as buffalo, BBQ, or garlic parmesan.
      $19.46

    • Dash App: Fries

      Thin-cut, crispy golden fries seasoned lightly with salt.
      $5.61

    • Dash App: Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Large)

      Generous layers of melted cheese topped with abundant pepperoni slices on a classic round pizza crust.
      $33.93

    • Dash App: Chicken Wings (20)

      Breaded and fried chicken wings, typically served with a variety of sauces such as buffalo, bbq, garlic parmesan, and sweet chili.
      $34.86

    • Dash App: Half Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza

      Double layers of pepperoni and cheese on a classic pizza crust, typically featuring house-made tomato sauce.
      $21.24

    • Dash App: 1/4 Pizza (3 slices) + 10 Wings (Toppings $1.77)

      1/4 pizza (3 slices) with optional toppings and 10 wings.
      $23.90

  • pizza

    • Calzones

      Garlic butter Mozzarella Ricotta and your choice of 2 ingredients
      $13.99

    • Dash App: 5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (Large)

      A round pizza typically topped with a blend of five cheeses and garlic.
      $33.63

    • Dash App: 5 Cheese Garlic Pizza (sheet)

      Garlic butter base topped with a blend of five cheeses, featuring mozzarella, cheddar, parmesan, provolone, and gouda, on a sheet pan.
      $52.51

    • Dash App: Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (Large)

      Chicken fingers, buffalo sauce, and blue cheese on a round pizza.
      $39.50

    • Dash App: Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza (sheet)

      Buffalo chicken finger pizza typically includes breaded buffalo chicken, blue cheese crumbles, and a drizzle of buffalo sauce on a sheet pizza crust.
      $70.21

    • Dash App: Cheese (Top-Your-Own Pizza) (Large)

      Golden-brown crust topped with melted mozzarella cheese and rich tomato sauce, cut into slices.
      $28.30

    • Dash App: Cheese (Top-Your-Own) Pizza (sheet)

      Housemade marinara sauce and a blend of cheeses on a sheet pan pizza.
      $45.99

    • Dash App: Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (Large)

      Ranch dressing base topped with grilled chicken, crispy bacon, and melted cheese.
      $35.99

    • Dash App: Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza (sheet)

      Ranch dressing, chicken, bacon, and extra cheese on a sheet pizza.
      $64.90

    • Dash App: Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (Large)

      Generous layers of melted cheese topped with abundant pepperoni slices on a classic round pizza crust.
      $33.93

    • Dash App: Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza (sheet)

      Double cheese and double pepperoni on a sheet pizza with a house cheese blend and tomato sauce.
      $56.64

    • Dash App: Half 5 Cheese Garlic Pizza

      Garlic butter base with a blend of five cheeses, typically including mozzarella and provolone.
      $18.29

    • Dash App: Half Buffalo Chicken Finger Pizza

      Grilled chicken fingers tossed in buffalo sauce, typically complemented by cheese and ranch dressing.
      $20.65

    • Dash App: Half Cheese (Top-Your-Own) Pizza

      A rectangular pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce.
      $15.34

    • Dash App: Half Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

      Grilled chicken, chopped bacon, and ranch dressing on a pizza base.
      $20.65

    • Dash App: Half Double Cheese Double Pepperoni Pizza

      Double layers of pepperoni and cheese on a classic pizza crust, typically featuring house-made tomato sauce.
      $21.24

    • Dash App: Half Papa's White Pizza

      Garlic oil base with ricotta cheese, parmesan, and mozzarella on half of a classic white pizza.
      $19.47

    • Dash App: Half Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza

      Topped with steak, a blend of five cheeses, onions, and green peppers.
      $23.01

    • Dash App: Half Steak in the Grass Pizza

      Steak, spinach, onions, and banana peppers on a garlic butter base.
      $23.01

    • Dash App: Half Stinger Pizza

      Hot honey garlic sauce glazed crust, topped with house recipe sauce and cheese, drizzled with hot honey garlic glaze.
      $24.19

    • Dash App: Half Veggie Pizza

      Banana peppers, black olives, cherry peppers, green olives, mushrooms, onions, spinach, sweet peppers, tomatoes.
      $18.29

    • Dash App: Half White Pizza

      Garlic oil base with ricotta cheese and a blend of cheeses.
      $18.29

    • Dash App: Papa's White Pizza (Large)

      Fresh garlic, a blend of oregano and other seasonings, and our special cheese mix on a round crust.
      $33.63

    • Dash App: Papa's White Pizza (sheet)

      Square deep dish. Broccoli, mushrooms, chicken, and semi-dried tomatoes.
      $60.18

    • Dash App: Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (Large)

      Steak and five cheeses on a round pizza crust, typically including onions, green peppers, and mushrooms.
      $37.47

    • Dash App: Steak + 5 Cheese Pizza (sheet)

      Grilled steak with a blend of five cheeses, typically includes onions, peppers, and mushrooms on a sheet pizza.
      $68.44

    • Dash App: Steak in the Grass Pizza (Large)

      Grilled steak, spinach, and garlic butter base on a round pizza with onions and banana peppers.
      $37.47

    • Dash App: Steak in the Grass Pizza (sheet)

      Grilled steak with garlic, spinach, and onions, topped with pizza cheese on a sheet pizza.
      $68.44

    • Dash App: Stinger Pizza (Large)

      Crust glazed with hot honey garlic sauce, topped with house recipe sauce and cheese, drizzled with hot honey garlic glaze.
      $43.07

    • Dash App: Stinger Pizza (sheet)

      Hot honey garlic sauce, house recipe sauce, and cheese on a sheet pizza, finished with a hot honey garlic glaze.
      $74.34

    • Dash App: Veggie Pizza (Large)

      Variety of vegetable toppings like black olives, mushrooms, onions, spinach, and more.
      $32.45

    • Dash App: Veggie Pizza(sheet)

      Banana peppers, black olives, cherry peppers (hot), green olives, mushrooms, onions, spinach, sweet peppers, and tomatoes.
      $60.18

    • Dash App: White Pizza (Large)

      Ricotta cheese, olive oil, and fresh garlic on a round pizza crust.
      $28.91

    • Dash App: White Pizza (sheet)

      Ricotta cheese, garlic, and olive oil on a sheet pizza.
      $49.56

  • Large Pizza (12 Slices)

    • Dessert Pizza

      $25.99

  • Common

    • Gatorade 28oz

      A thirst-quenching sports drink that typically includes flavors like orange, lemon-lime, fruit punch, and cool blue. Ideal for rehydration and replenishing electrolytes.
      $3.25

    • Onion Rings

      Battered and deep-fried onion rings, typically golden and crisp.
      $5.99

    • Reese’s Cookie

      A soft-baked cookie typically includes chunks of Reese's peanut butter cups.
      $3.99

  • specials

    • Dash App: 1/4 Pizza (3 slices) + 10 Wings (Toppings $1.77)

      1/4 pizza (3 slices) with optional toppings and 10 wings.
      $23.90

    • Dash App: 1/4 Pizza (3 slices) + 10 Wings Boneless (Toppings $1.77)

      1/4 pizza (3 slices) typically with cheese or one topping, paired with 10 boneless wings. Additional toppings available for an extra charge.
      $22.70

    • Dash App: Half Pizza(6 slices) + 10 Boneless Wings (Toppings $2.36) (1)

      Half pizza (6 slices) and 10 boneless wings. Toppings available for an additional charge.
      $27.72

    • Dash App: Half Pizza(6 slices) + 10 Wings (Toppings $2.36)

      Half pizza (6 slices) and 10 wings special. Toppings available for an additional charge.
      $30.65

    • Dash App: Large Cheese + 20 Boneless Wings (Toppings $3.54)

      Large cheese pizza and 20 boneless wings. Additional toppings available for an extra charge.
      $47.20

    • Dash App: Large Cheese + 20 Wings (Toppings $3.54)

      Large cheese pizza and 20 chicken wings, with additional toppings available for an extra charge.
      $53.00

    • Dash App: Sheet Cheese + 50 Wings (Toppings $5.90)

      Sheet cheese pizza with 50 wings. Toppings available for an additional cost.
      $87.32

    • Dash App: Sheet Cheese + 50 Wings (Toppings $5.90)

      Sheet cheese pizza and 50 wings. Additional toppings available for $5.90 each.
      $99.12

  • dessert

    • 2 Cookies

      Freshly baked cookies, typically featuring chocolate chips or other delightful ingredients.
      $4.99

    • Cake

      Please inquire about today's available flavors.
      $4.99

    • Cookie

      Deliciously baked, classic sweet treat perfect with milk or coffee.
      $2.99

  • sides

    • Blue Cheese (side)

      House-made blue cheese dressing with fresh blue cheese crumbles, ideal for dipping or drizzling.
      $1.50

    • Cinnamon Sticks

      $8.99

    • Dash App: Blue Cheese (side)

      House-made blue cheese dressing featuring fresh blue cheese crumbles, ideal for dipping or drizzling.
      $1.80

    • Dash App: Blue Cheese 12oz (side)

      House-made blue cheese dressing with fresh blue cheese crumbles, ideal for dipping or drizzling.
      $5.90

    • Dash App: Bread Sticks (5)

      Typically includes garlic butter and parmesan cheese, made from our pizza dough and baked to a golden finish.
      $5.89

    • Dash App: Ranch (side)

      House-made ranch dressing typically includes buttermilk, sour cream, and a blend of herbs and spices.
      $1.80

    • Fried Dough

      Dough fried golden brown topped with butter powdered sugar and cinnamon
      $8.99

    • Loaded Ranch Fries

      Fries topped with ranch cheddar and bacon
      $13.99

    • Pizza Sauce (side)

      Homemade pizza sauce typically includes tomatoes, garlic, and a blend of herbs.
      $1.50

    • Ranch (3.25 oz)

      House-made ranch dressing typically includes buttermilk, sour cream, and mayonnaise, along with garlic and a mix of herbs and spices.
      $1.50

  • slices

    • Dessert Slice

      $5.99

  • fried food

    • Dash App: Boneless Chicken Wings (10)

      Pick your flavor for finish and indulge in pure satisfaction.
      $15.57

    • Dash App: Boneless Chicken Wings (20)

      Pick your flavor for finish and indulge in pure satisfaction.
      $27.85

    • Dash App: Boneless Chicken Wings (30)

      Pick your flavor for finish and indulge in pure satisfaction.
      $36.34

    • Dash App: Boneless Chicken Wings (50)

      Pick your flavor for finish and indulge in pure satisfaction.
      $60.42

    • Dash App: Chicken Fingers (10)

      Breaded and fried chicken tenders, typically served with honey mustard or BBQ sauce.
      $33.63

    • Dash App: Chicken Fingers (5)

      Breaded and golden fried chicken tenderloins, typically served with honey mustard sauce.
      $19.76

    • Dash App: Chicken Wings (10)

      Breaded and fried chicken wings, typically served with a variety of sauces such as buffalo, BBQ, or garlic parmesan.
      $19.46

    • Dash App: Chicken Wings (20)

      Breaded and fried chicken wings, typically served with a variety of sauces such as buffalo, bbq, garlic parmesan, and sweet chili.
      $34.86

    • Dash App: Chicken Wings (50)

      Breaded and deep-fried chicken wings, served with a variety of sauces including BBQ, hot, mild, medium, and garlic parmesan.
      $75.50

    • Dash App: Finger Dinner

      Breaded chicken fingers, french fries, salad, and a side of dipping sauce.
      $19.50

    • Dash App: Fries

      Thin-cut, crispy golden fries seasoned lightly with salt.
      $5.61

    • Dash App: Jalapeno Poppers (5)

      Stuffed with cheese and breaded, these jalapeño poppers are deep-fried for a crispy, golden finish.
      $10.60

    • Dash App: Pizza Logs (4)

      Pepperoni pizza stuffed eggrolls, typically served with marinara sauce.
      $8.20

    • Dash App: Pizza Logs (8)

      Fried pizza logs typically filled with pepperoni and cheese, served with dipping sauce.
      $15.30

    • Dash App: Pizza Logs with Fries (4)

      Pizza logs typically filled with cheese and pepperoni, served with crispy fries.
      $10.30

    • Dash App: Pizza Logs with Fries (8)

      Crispy pizza logs typically filled with cheese and pepperoni, served with a side of golden fries and marinara dipping sauce.
      $17.40

    • Slices and 5 wings

      $15.50

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Savory's Family Restaurant
Savory's Family Restaurant
4.7
(1,235 Reviews)
American, Breakfast, Diner
Waterstone Grill
Waterstone Grill
4.3
(1,152 Reviews)
Steak house, Grill, Bar
Subway
Subway
4.1
(130 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Pita Gourmet
Pita Gourmet
4.5
(85 Reviews)
Restaurant
Mexico City
Mexico City
3.5
(898 Reviews)
Mexican, Restaurant
Burger King
Burger King
3.4
(677 Reviews)
Restaurant
Tim Hortons
Tim Hortons
4.0
(357 Reviews)
Coffee shop, Bakery, Breakfast
EJ's Bar & Grill
EJ's Bar & Grill
4.6
(23 Reviews)
Bar & grill
The Alibi Bar & Grill
The Alibi Bar & Grill
4.3
(206 Reviews)
Bar
G. G.'s Diner
G. G.'s Diner
4.9
(126 Reviews)
American
https://www.papaspizzaoven.com/
(716) 646-6655

507 Sunset Dr, Hamburg, NY 14075

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms