Keys Fisheries Menu

Slice of a delicious Keys traditional dessert. Our Key Lime Pie is homemade on site and award-winning locally, domestically, and abroad!

Our made-from-scratch fritters are made with 100% ground conch, fried crispy brown on the outside with a soft chewy center. Served with our signature Keys Fish Remoulade

Key West pinks seasoned with our Keys Fisheries Old Florida Bay. Can be served hot or cold

The classic sandwich with a Keys Fish twist! Cooked lobster meat, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Thousand Island dressing on toasted rye bread

Choose a locally caught fish, prepared either blackened, fried, or grilled. Served with choice of 2 sides

Exactly what it sounds like! Our dip is made with shredded lump crab meat. Served with tri-colored tortilla chips made fresh daily

Our 16/20 size shrimp butterflied and coated with coconut flakes and fried to perfection. Served with our signature Keys Fish Mango Chutney

Tender calamari, lightly breaded and fried golden brown

Chicken breast prepared your way (blackened, fried, grilled), on toasted Texas toast with our delicious Keys Fish Spicy Mayo

Ice cold 12 oz can of Diet Pepsi

Ice cold 12 oz can of Mountain Dew

Ice cold refreshing bottle of water

Our 16/20 size shrimp butterflied and coated with coconut flakes and fried to perfection. Served with our signature Keys Fish Mango Chutney

Tender calamari, lightly breaded and fried golden brown

Key West pinks seasoned with our Keys Fisheries Old Florida Bay. Can be served hot or cold

Hands down one of our most popular items! Smoked wahoo mixed with cream cheese, sour cream and special seasoning. Served with captain wafer crackers

Made with 100% ground conch, bell peppers, and onions marinated in lime juice with special spices. Served with tri-colored tortilla chips made fresh daily

Ceviche with 100% ground conch, peppers, and onions marinated in lime juice with special spices. Served on a bed of spring mix inside a fried tortilla bowl, topped with cilantro lime sauce

Romaine lettuce mixed with Caesar dressing, croutons and parmesan cheese. Have it as is or add a protein for an additional charge

Spring mix topped with cucumbers, tomatoes, green peppers, and red onions. Served with choice of dressing. Enjoy it as is or add a protein for additional charge.

Made in-house. Cream based soup loaded with stone crab, corn and potatoes. Served with oyster crackers

Made in-house. Red based chowder loaded with 100% ground conch and vegetables. Served with oyster crackers

Our most POPULAR soup that is made in-house with locally caught Florida lobster. Served with oyster crackers

3 tortillas topped with lightly battered & fried mahi strips, red and green cabbage, pickled onions, queso fresco and chipotle sauce

Hoagie roll loaded with fried tenderized 100% conch, topped with lettuce, tomato, and drizzled with Keys Fish Island Sauce

Toasted Boston bun loaded with lobster salad

Timeless classic with local twist. Seared yellowfin tuna, bacon, lettuce, tomato and wasabi aioli on toasted Texas toast

Chicken breast prepared your way (blackened, fried, grilled), on toasted Texas toast with our delicious Keys Fish Spicy Mayo

Grilled 8-ounce beef patty on a toasted kaiser bun

Choose a locally caught fish, prepared your way (blackened, fried, grilled), on toasted Kaiser bun. Voted best fish sandwich in Marathon 4 years straight!

100% white chicken breast fried golden brown, served plain or tossed with choice of sauce. Accompanied with french fries and coleslaw

Choose from 3 different options: breaded, coconut or buffalo shrimp! Accompanied with french fries and coleslaw

100% tenderized conch lightly breaded and fried golden brown. Served with our Keys Fish Island Sauce and accompanied with french fries and coleslaw

Hogfish fillets prepared with egg batter, garlic, butter and white wine. Served with choice of 2 sides.

Grouper fillets coated with our Keys Fisheries panko blend and parmesan, and baked superbly. Served with choice of 2 sides

Enjoy a little bit of everything! Grilled locally caught half of Florida lobster, shrimp, scallops and mahi fillet. Served with choice of 2 sides

Locally caught Florida “spiny” lobster 8-ounce tail prepared impeccably. Served with choice of 2 sides. Add another tail for additional charge

Our deliciously rich home-made mac and cheese mixed with locally caught Florida lobster tail meat. Be prepared to slip into a food coma afterwards!

Classic Spanish dish prepared Keys Fish style – all seafood! Grilled locally caught half of lobster, shrimp, scallops, clams, and mussels with white wine and sofrito. Served over yellow rice

Choose a locally caught fish, prepared either blackened, fried, or grilled. Served with choice of 2 sides

Slice of our homemade rum cake. Comes with an extra side of our delicious rum sauce to dunk, drizzle or both!

What’s better than a slice of our delicious homemade Key Lime Pie? A WHOLE PIE!! Share this amazing dessert or keep it to yourself, we won’t judge!