Just Homemade Ice Cream Menu

4.8

(225+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Ice Cream Sundaes Banana Splits Ice Cream Cakes Water Ice Cones

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- 4 Scoops
  four scoops of ice cream
  $8.00
- 3 Scoops
  Three scoops of any flavor of our home made ice cream
  $7.00
- Milkshake
  $8.00
- Pint
  $8.50
- 2 Scoops
  Pictured is two scoops in a sugar cone.
  $6.00
- Quart
  $13.00
- 1 Scoop
  Pictured is one scoop of ice cream (kids size) served in a cold glass cup.
  $4.50
- 5 Scoop Sampler Tray
  $9.00
- Banana Split Supreme
  Chocolate syrup, wet nuts, strawberry, pineapple and crushed cherry.
  $10.50
- Large Water Ice
  $4.50
Ice Cream
Ice cream sizes. For No Sugar Added or Non-Dairy Flavors please choose the correct flavor option.
- 1 Scoop
  Pictured is one scoop of ice cream (kids size) served in a cold glass cup.
  $4.50
- 1 Scoop No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $6.50
- 2 Scoops
  Pictured is two scoops in a sugar cone.
  $6.00
- 2 Scoops No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $7.50
- 3 Scoops
  Three scoops of any flavor of our home made ice cream
  $7.00
- 3 Scoops No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $9.00
- 4 Scoops
  four scoops of ice cream
  $8.00
- 4 Scoops No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $10.50
- 5 Scoop Sampler Tray
  $9.00
- 5 Scoop Sampler No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $14.50
- Milkshake
  $8.00
- Milkshake - NSA/ND - Made with Real Milk
  $12.00
- Float
  $8.00
- Float No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $12.00
- Pint
  $8.50
- Pint No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $16.75
- Quart
  $13.00
- Quart No Sugar Added/Non Dairy Ice Cream
  $21.50
Sundaes
- Brownie Nut Sundae 2 Scoop
  Brownie pieces, hot fudge, and wet nuts.
  $7.00
- Brownie Nut Sundae 3 Scoop
  Brownie pieces, hot fudge, and wet nuts.
  $9.50
- Brownie Nut Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Brownie pieces, hot fudge, and wet nuts.
  $10.75
- Brownie Nut Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Brownie pieces, hot fudge, and wet nuts.
  $14.50
- CMP Sundae 2 Scoop
  Chocolate syrup, marshmallow sauce, and peanuts.
  $7.00
- CMP Sundae 3 Scoop
  Chocolate syrup, marshmallow sauce, and peanuts.
  $9.50
- CMP Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Add/Non Dairy
  Chocolate syrup, marshmallow sauce, and peanuts.
  $10.75
- CMP Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Chocolate syrup, marshmallow sauce, and peanuts.
  $14.50
- Dusty Road Sundae 2 Scoop
  Hot fudge and malt.
  $7.00
- Dusty Road Sundae 3 Scoop
  Hot fudge and malt.
  $9.50
- Dusty Road Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Hot fudge and malt.
  $10.75
- Dusty Road Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Hot fudge and malt.
  $14.50
- Fluffernutter Sundae 2 Scoop
  Peanut butter, marshmallow, and peanuts.
  $7.00
- Fluffernutter Sundae 3 Scoop
  Peanut butter, marshmallow, and peanuts.
  $9.50
- Fluffernutter Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Peanut butter, marshmallow, and peanuts.
  $10.75
- Fluffernutter Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Peanut butter, marshmallow, and peanuts.
  $14.50
- Neumann Sundae 2 Scoop
  Warm blend of three chosen ice cream flavors. Select from classics like Vanilla, Chocolate, unique Teaberry, New York Cheesecake, or Cookie Monster.
  $7.00
- Neumann Sundae 3 Scoop
  $9.50
- Neumann Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Warm blend of three chosen ice cream flavors. Select from classics like Vanilla, Chocolate, unique Teaberry, New York Cheesecake, or Cookie Monster.
  $10.75
- Neumann Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  $14.50
- Old Time Sundae 2 Scoop
  Banana and chocolate syrup.
  $7.00
- Old Time Sundae 3 Scoop
  Banana and chocolate syrup.
  $9.50
- Old Time Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Banana and chocolate syrup.
  $10.75
- Old Time Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Banana and chocolate syrup.
  $14.50
- Reese's Pieces Sundae 2 Scoop
  Chocolate syrup, peanut butter, and Reese pieces.
  $7.00
- Reese's Pieces Sundae 3 Scoop
  Chocolate syrup, peanut butter, and Reese pieces.
  $9.50
- Reese's Pieces Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Chocolate syrup, peanut butter, and Reese pieces.
  $10.75
- Reese's Pieces Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Chocolate syrup, peanut butter, and Reese pieces.
  $14.50
- Rocky Road Sundae 2 Scoop
  Chocolate syrup, caramel sauce, and peanuts.
  $7.00
- Rocky Road Sundae 3 Scoop
  Chocolate syrup, caramel sauce, and peanuts.
  $9.50
- Rocky Road Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Chocolate syrup, caramel sauce, and peanuts.
  $10.75
- Rocky Road Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Chocolate syrup, caramel sauce, and peanuts.
  $14.50
- Speak Easy Sundae 2 Scoop
  Hot fudge, coconut, wet or dry nuts (please specify).
  $7.00
- Speak Easy Sundae 3 Scoop
  Hot fudge, coconut, wet or dry nuts (please specify).
  $9.50
- Speak Easy Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Hot fudge, coconut, wet or dry nuts (please specify).
  $10.75
- Speak Easy Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Hot fudge, coconut, wet or dry nuts (please specify).
  $14.50
- S'mores Sundae 2 Scoop
  Hot fudge, marshmallow, and graham cracker.
  $7.00
- S'mores Sundae 3 Scoop
  Hot fudge, marshmallow, and graham cracker.
  $9.50
- S'mores Sundae 2 Scoop - No Sugar Added/ Non Dairy
  Hot fudge, marshmallow, and graham cracker.
  $10.75
- S'mores Sundae 3 Scoop - No Sugar Added/ Non Dairy
  Hot fudge, marshmallow, and graham cracker.
  $14.50
Banana Splits
Banana splits are served on top of a banana, with vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry ice cream, designated toppings, whip cream, and a cherry
- Banana Split "Strawberry Royale"
  Strawberry topping and wet nuts.
  $10.50
- Banana Split "Strawberry Royale" - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Strawberry topping and wet nuts.
  $13.75
- Banana Split "Ship of Fudge"
  Hot fudge and wet nuts.
  $10.50
- Banana Split "Ship of Fudge" - No Sugar Added/Non Dairy
  Hot fudge and wet nuts.
  $13.75
- Banana Split Supreme
  Chocolate syrup, wet nuts, strawberry, pineapple and crushed cherry.
  $10.50
- Banana Split Supreme - No Sugar Added/ Non Dairy
  Chocolate syrup, wet nuts, strawberry, pineapple and crushed cherry.
  $13.75
Ice Cream Cakes
- 7 Inch Ice Cream Cake
  All 7" ice cream cakes are made of vanilla and chocolate, with cookie crumble in the middle. Serves 8-10. Please let us know if you would like something written on it!
  $33.00
- 8 Inch Ice Cream Cake
  All 8" ice cream cakes are made of vanilla and chocolate, with cookie crumble in the middle. Serves 12-14. Please let us know if you would like something written on it!
  $39.00
- 10 Inch Ice Cream Cake
  All 10" ice cream cakes are made of vanilla and chocolate, with cookie crumble in the middle. Serves 20-23. Please let us know if you would like something written on it!
  $54.00
Water Ice
- Small Water Ice
  $3.00
- Large Water Ice
  $4.50
Cones
On the side
- Sprinkle Cake Cone
  $1.00
- Waffle Cones
  $1.50
- Sprinkle Sugar Cone
  $1.00
- Pretzel Cone - Cone Guys
  $2.40
- Chocolate Chip Cone - Cone Guys
  $2.40
- Mini-M&M Cone - Cone Guys
  $2.40
- Oreo Cone - Cone Guys
  $2.40
- Baked in Sprinkle Cone - Cone Guys
  $2.40