Appetizers
- French Fries$2.50
- Waffle Fries$2.75
- Jailhouse ChickenOur homemade Fiery Pulled Chicken in a bag of Fritos$3.25
- Onion Rings$3.75
- Cheddar Pints$4.25
- Chicken Tenders$5.75
- NachosAdd Salsa, Jalapenos, or extra Nacho Cheese for .75 each$3.50
Sandwiches
- Authentic Sheboygan Butter-BurgerOn a real West Side Bakery Hardroll$4.25
- Double Butter-Burger$6.75
- Patty MeltOn Rye or Texas Toast$5.25
- Grilled Ham And Cheese$4.25
- Mushroom And Swiss Burger$5.75
- Miesfeld's Pork Butterflied Pork Chop$6.50
- Chicken Breast$5.75
- Breaded Chicken Tenderloin$4.50
- Chicken Cordon Blue$8.00
- Miesfeld's 8oz Steak$7.75
- Cow & SowAuthentic Butter Burger topped with a Miesfeld's Pork Chop$8.25
- Add Bacon To Any Sandwich For$1.75
- Add Mushrooms Or Jalapenos To Any Sandwich For$1.00
- Add Cheese To Any Sandwich For
Pizza's
- Cheese Pizza$7.25
- 2lbs Mini-Mess$13.75
- Add Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Or Ham For$2.00
- Add Black Olives, Green Peppers, Red Onions, Mushrooms, Or Jalapenos For$1.00
Fish Fry
- Large Beer Battered Cod6 pieces with French Fries, Coleslaw, and Rye Bread$15.00
- Small Beer Battered Cod4 pieces with French Fries, Coleslaw, and Rye Bread$11.00
- Large Breaded Perch6 pieces with French Fries, Coleslaw, and Rye Bread$16.00
- Small Breaded Perch4 pieces with French Fries, Coleslaw, and Rye Bread$12.00
Traditional Pub Wings
- Sweet Chili, BBQ, Mild, Or Hot$7.75
Specialty Drinks
- Black Creek Shandy$3.25
- The Wisconsinite$4.75
- The Sno-ConeShot $3.5 Single $4.00 Double $5.25
- Grape Ape$4.00
- Plumb BombMr. Carr's favorite$3.75
- Ice Cream ShotsA Water St. Pub original brought out to the Holy Land$3.50
- Jovan's LemonaidesTraditional, Blue Raspberry, or Strawberry$4.00
- Tropical Trash CansA Rewind (Speakeasy) original brought out to the Holy Land$7.00
- Holy Land Hand GrenadeA Plumb twist on the original Trash Can$7.00
