Josie's Pizza Hilltop Menu

3205 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43204
  • Pizza

    • Cheese Pizza (10" Small)

      $9.00
    • Cheese Pizza (14" Large)

      $15.50
    • One Item Pizza (10" Small)

      Toppings: Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Ham, Pineapple, Jalapenos, Anchovies, Tomato, Cheese, Bacon, Grilled Chicken, Hamburger, Cheddar Cheese, Spicy Italian Sausage, Crispy Chicken, Hot Ham, Salami, Smoked Ham
      $9.75
    • One Item Pizza (14" Large)

      Toppings: Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Ham, Pineapple, Jalapenos, Anchovies, Tomato, Cheese, Bacon, Grilled Chicken, Hamburger, Cheddar Cheese, Spicy Italian Sausage, Crispy Chicken, Hot Ham, Salami, Smoked Ham
      $16.50
  • Specialty Pizzas

    • Small Old Fashion (10" Small)

      Add some spice to your life with our spicy nickel-sized pepperoni served on top of the cheese. Our most popular specialty pizza!
      $10.50
    • Large Old Fashion (14" Large)

      Add some spice to your life with our spicy nickel-sized pepperoni served on top of the cheese. Our most popular specialty pizza!
      $18.50
    • Grilled Chicken "Butter Garlic Sauce" (10" Small)

      Served "white" (garlic butter sauce instead of pizza sauce) with lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing
      $10.50
    • Grilled Chicken "Butter Garlic Sauce" (14" Large)

      Served "white" (garlic butter sauce instead of pizza sauce) with lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing
      $18.50
    • Combination (10" Small)

      Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion & Green Peppers. An old Josie's tradition!
      $11.50
    • Combination (14" Large)

      Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion & Green Peppers. An old Josie's tradition!
      $19.50
    • Supreme (10" Small)

      All the Way! Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, Ham & Extra Cheese
      $13.00
    • Supreme (14" Large)

      All the Way! Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, Ham & Extra Cheese
      $23.00
    • B.L.T. (10" Small)

      You guessed it! Lots of bacon, lettuce & tomato served with ranch dressing
      $11.50
    • B.L.T. (14" Large)

      You guessed it! Lots of bacon, lettuce & tomato served with ranch dressing
      $19.50
    • Gut Buster (10" Small)

      Regular Pepperoni, Old Fashion Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Ham, & Extra Cheese - not for the timid. A meat lover's paradise!
      $13.00
    • Gut Buster (14" Large)

      Regular Pepperoni, Old Fashion Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Ham, & Extra Cheese - not for the timid. A meat lover's paradise!
      $23.00
    • Veggie (10" Small)

      No meat here! Tomato, Onion, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, & Mushrooms
      $10.75
    • Veggie (14" Large)

      No meat here! Tomato, Onion, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, & Mushrooms
      $18.75
    • Hawaiian (10" Small)

      In the mood for something different? Ham & Pineapple - give it a try!
      $10.50
    • Hawaiian (14" Large)

      In the mood for something different? Ham & Pineapple - give it a try!
      $18.50
    • Mexican (10" Small)

      Taco-Seasoned Hamburger, Jalapenos, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Sour Cream
      $11.75
    • Mexican (14" Large)

      Taco-Seasoned Hamburger, Jalapenos, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Sour Cream
      $19.75
    • Pizza Bowl

      Gluten-free option! Pizza sauce, cheese & up to 3 toppings of your choice! Additional toppings, $1.00ea.
      $7.50
    • Butter Garlic Sauce

  • Calzones

    • What Is A Calzone? Cheese & Your Favorite Topping Wrapped Inside Our Homemade Dough, Smother With Butter, Garlic, Romano Cheese & Baked!

      Owner favorite!!!
    • Small Calzone (Additional Toppings- Small Add $.50 Ea.)

      Served with cheese plus any two toppings, served with marinara sauce for dipping
      $9.75
    • Large Calzone (Additional Toppings- Large Add $1.00 Ea.)

      Served with cheese plus any two toppings, served with marinara sauce for dipping
      $16.50
  • Appetizers & Side Items

    • Chicken Nuggets

      $6.00
    • Chicken Wings (6)

      A customer favorite! Deep fried with a little kick! Best in town!
      $7.75
    • Cheese Sticks (6)

      $6.75
    • French Fries

      Wide-cut
      $4.50
    • Fried Mushrooms

      $4.75
    • Fried Cauliflower

      $4.75
    • Onion Rings

      $4.75
    • Mini Corn Dogs

      $5.00
    • Fried Broccoli & Cheese

      $5.75
    • Cheddar Or Cream Poppers

      $5.75
    • Garlic Bread With Sauce

      $4.25
    • Garlic Bread With Cheese & Sauce

      $5.50
  • 9-Inch Submarines

    • Italian Sub

      Salami, hot ham, provolone cheese & veggies (Add pepperoni - $.50)
      $8.75
    • Super Sub

      Sam as Italian but with double meats & cheese! (Add pepperoni - $.50)
      $9.75
    • Stromboli (Double Stromboli - Add $2.00)

      Nine-inch seasoned meat patty with veggies. A long-time Josie's customer favorite!
      $9.75
    • "The Beast" Sub

      Combine the Italian & Stromboli subs - a meat lover's dream!
      $11.50
    • Meatball Sub

      Three meatballs, spaghetti sauce & provolone cheese
      $8.75
    • Crispy Chicken Sub

      Fried chicken filets with provolone cheese & veggies
      $9.75
    • Ham & Cheese Sub

      Ham, provolone cheese & veggies
      $8.75
    • Fish Sub

      Fried fish patty, American cheese, veggies & tartar sauce
      $8.75
    • Grilled Chicken Sub

      Chicken, provolone cheese, and veggies
      $9.75
    • Veggie Sub (For Our Vegetarian Friends!)

      Provolone cheese, American cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, hot peppers, black olives, lettuce & tomato
      $8.25
    • Pizza Sub

      Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, & pizza sauce baked in oven. (Additional items - $.50)
      $8.75
    • Add Bacon To Any Sub For Just $2.00

  • Salads

    • Garden Salad (Small In A Cup)

      Garden mix with tomato
      $5.00
    • Garen Salad (Large)

      Garden mix with tomato
      $6.50
    • Chef Salad (Small)

      Ham, salami, mozzarella cheese, tomato & pepperoni
      $7.00
    • Chef Salad (Large)

      Ham, salami, mozzarella cheese, tomato & pepperoni
      $8.50
    • Grilled Chicken Salad (Small)

      Grilled chicken, tomato & cheese
      $8.00
    • Grilled Chicken Salad (Large)

      Grilled chicken, tomato & cheese
      $9.50
    • Crispy Chicken Salad (Small)

      Deep fried chicken strips, bacon, tomato & cheese
      $8.00
    • Crispy Chicken Salad (Large)

      Deep fried chicken strips, bacon, tomato & cheese
      $9.50
    • Crispy Pepperoni Salad (Small)

      Tomato, hot peppers, black olives, mozzarella cheese & fried pepperoni
      $7.00
    • Crispy Pepperoni Salad

      Tomato, hot peppers, black olives, mozzarella cheese & fried pepperoni
      $8.50
    • Large Salads Include 3 Dressings, Small Salads Include 2 Dressings. Extra Packets Of Dressings - Add $.75 Ea

      Dressings: Golden Italian, House Italian, Light Italian, Fat Free California French, Thousand Island, Dijon Honey Mustard (call for availability)
  • Dinners

    • All Dinners Served With Side Salad And Dinner Roll

    • Spaghetti

      $9.75
    • Lasagna

      $9.75
    • Fish Dinner

      2 pieces of cod, served with French fries
      $9.75
    • Shrimp Dinner

      21 Pieces of fried shrimp, served with French fries
      $9.75
    • Chicken Wing

      6 chicken wings served with French fries
      $9.50
  • Sandwiches

    • Hamburger

      Served with pickle, lettuce & onion (Make it a double for just $1.50 more.)
      $6.25
    • Cheeseburger

      Served with American cheese, pickle, lettuce & onion. (Make it a double for just $1.50 more.)
      $6.75
    • Meatball Sandwich

      Served with provolone cheese
      $5.50
    • Chicken Sandwich

      Served with provolone cheese & veggies
      $6.75
    • Grilled Chicken Sandwich

      Served with provolone cheese & veggies
      $6.75
    • Grilled Cheese Sandwich

      $4.00
    • Ham & Cheese Sandwich

      Served with provolone cheese & veggies
      $5.75
    • Add Bacon To Any Sandwich For $1.50

  • TIDBITS:

    • Hours & Prices Subject To Change Without Notice. Delivery Ends 45 Minutes Before Closing

      Minimum delivery $6.00, excluding soda pop. $3.00 delivery charge. Ask about our gluten-free pizza crust (based on availability) or try our pizza bowl as a gluten-free option!. 1 large flap = 2 small flaps (no exceptions).

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms