Jimmy's Frozen Custard Menu

4.7

(550+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Jimmys Specialty Soups Flurries Sundaes Shakes And Malts Cold Drinks Custard Cups Jimmys Cakes Bulk Quantities Jimmy's Specialties

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Candy Flurries Flavors
  Custard.
  $5.69
- Hot Fudge Brownie
  Homemade Brownie, frozen custard, hot fudge, and whipped cream on top.
  $5.99
- Upside Down Banana Split Custard
  Banana split custard with an upside-down twist. Available in small or regular size.
  $5.99
- Jimmys 35 Signature Custard
  **Jimmy's 35 Signature Custard** Available in Small, Medium, Large sizes. Choose from flavors like Amaretto, Black Cherry, Caramel, Espresso Coffee, Pistachio Nut, and many more.
  $3.89
- Red Velvet Cake Sundae
  Homemade red velvet cake, frozen custard, hot fudge, drizzled marshmallow topping, and topped with whipped cream.
  $7.39
- Turtle Sundae
  Custard.
  $5.99
- Jimmys Cookie Bowl
  Homemade chocolate chip cookie bar, frozen custard, hot fudge, sprinkles, and whipped cream on top.
  $5.99
- Jimmys Bars
  Vanilla custard covered in: butterscotch, cherry or chocolate.
  $3.49
- Shake
  Small, Medium, Large, Jumbo. Multiple flavors like Banana, Mocha Cappuccino, Vanilla, Chocolate, Hot Fudge, Creme De Menthe, Strawberry.
  $4.59
- Cheesecake Flurries Flavors
  Custard.
  $5.69
Jimmys Specialty Soups
Chicken noodle.
- Chicken Noodle Everyday
  Chicken Noodle Soup - Available in cup, bowl, pint, or quart sizes.
  $4.99
Flurries
- Candy Flurries Flavors
  Custard.
  $5.69
- Cheesecake Flurries Flavors
  Custard.
  $5.69
Sundaes
- Sundae
  Custard.
  $4.49
Shakes And Malts
- Shake
  Small, Medium, Large, Jumbo. Multiple flavors like Banana, Mocha Cappuccino, Vanilla, Chocolate, Hot Fudge, Creme De Menthe, Strawberry.
  $4.59
Cold Drinks
- Ice Cold Bottled Water
  Pure, refreshing bottled water, ideal for quenching your thirst and staying hydrated.
  $1.25
Custard Cups
- Custard Cups
  Vanilla, chocolate, or twist-flavored custard in various sizes.
  $1.59
- Jimmys 35 Signature Custard
  **Jimmy's 35 Signature Custard** Available in Small, Medium, Large sizes. Choose from flavors like Amaretto, Black Cherry, Caramel, Espresso Coffee, Pistachio Nut, and many more.
  $3.89
Jimmys Cakes
- Jimmys Cakes
  You can write cake message in the special instructions box for 8" and 9" cakes only.
  $18.99
Bulk Quantities
- Custard Bulk Quantities
  Custard offered in pint or quart sizes. Chocolate, twist, or vanilla flavors.
  $4.69
- Flavored Custard Bulk Quantities
  Bulk portions of flavored custard available in pint or quart sizes.
  $5.89
Jimmy's Specialties
- Parfait
  Black Forest, Peanut Buster, Peanut Mountain, Praline Pecan, or Fruit.
  $5.99
- Tin Roof
  Custard.
  $5.99
- Strawberry Shortcake
  Custard.
  $5.99
- Turtle Sundae
  Custard.
  $5.99
- Jimmys Bars
  Vanilla custard covered in: butterscotch, cherry or chocolate.
  $3.49
- Jimmys Bars 6 Pack
  Jimmys bars 6 pack vanilla custard covered in: butterscotch, cherry or chocolate.
  $19.99
- Only Pastie
  Variety of frozen or hot savory fillings.
  $10.99
- Pastie Meal Deal
  Includes a hot beef pastie, a cup of soup, a jimmy made brownie, and a bottle of water.
  $13.99
- Take Home 6 Frozen
  Beef, chicken, or veggie. Mix and match your choice of flavors.
  $59.99
- Upside Down Banana Split Custard
  Banana split custard with an upside-down twist. Available in small or regular size.
  $5.99
- Hot Fudge Brownie
  Homemade Brownie, frozen custard, hot fudge, and whipped cream on top.
  $5.99
- Jimmys Cookie Bowl
  Homemade chocolate chip cookie bar, frozen custard, hot fudge, sprinkles, and whipped cream on top.
  $5.99
- Jimmys Buster Bars
  Fresh vanilla custard with fudge and spanish peanuts. Single bar.
  $4.79
- Red Velvet Cake Sundae
  Homemade red velvet cake, frozen custard, hot fudge, drizzled marshmallow topping, and topped with whipped cream.
  $7.39