Jerry and The Mermaid Menu

Mild, medium, hot, make me cry Jerry's famous 'not your ordinary' buffalo sauce, served with blue cheese and celery.

Topped with crispy fried onions, served with waffle fries and coleslaw on a toasted bun. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have a medical condition. Management advises that food prepared here may contain or have come in contact with peanuts, tree nuts, soybeans, milk, eggs, wheat, shellfish, or fish. Our customer's safety is of our utmost importance. Please do not take any unnecessary risks. Management cannot assure any cross-contamination of these ingredients with your dish.

Char-Grilled Cheese Burger on Brioche with Waffle Fries, Cole Slaw and Pickle

Fresh picked lobster, celery, touch of mayo on toasted brioche. Served with waffle fries, homemade slaw and pickle.

Mild, medium, hot, make me cry Jerry's famous 'not your ordinary' buffalo sauce, served with blue cheese and celery.

Crispy Shrimp, Thai Chili Glaze, Julienne Veggies & Mixed Greens.

Breaded Mozzarella Sticks with homemade Marinara!

old family recipe with chopped clams,bacon and shrimp

Creme Brulee Cheesecake with Caramel Sauce & Whipped Cream

With roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese and balsamic reduction on garlic ciabatta.

Mixed Green & Shaved Vegetables.

A vibrant layered cake with red, yellow, and green hues, topped with chocolate ganache and accompanied by whipped cream.

Ricotta Gnocchi with Homemade Bolognese, Pecorino & Arugula

Pan Roasted with Shrimp & Citrus Butter

A refreshing blend of tequila, blackberry liqueur, and lime juice, garnished with a lime wheel and a salted rim.

A classic dark Irish stout with a smooth, creamy finish and notes of roasted malt and chocolate.

Shelter Island 114 IPA

Kraken Black Rum, White Rum & Tom's Special Mix!

Gray Whale Ube G & T

A refreshing blend of tequila, lime juice, and triple sec, garnished with a salted rim and a lime slice.

Redemption Bourbon, Lemonade, Triple Sec & Splash Sours

Montauk Watermelon Sesson Ale

A canned vodka and soda beverage infused with natural black cherry juice.

Featuring 1800 Coconut Tequila & Freshly Toasted Coconut!

Ciroc Colada Selter

Tom's Classic Long Island Ice Tea with Montauk Vodka, Silver Rum, Anejo Tequila & Grey Whale Gin!

Montauk Vokda, House Bloody Mix, Jumbo Shrimp!

A refreshing blend of vodka and soda infused with real watermelon juice, offering a light and crisp taste.

Vodka soda with a hint of real pineapple juice.

High Noon Bucket (Buy 4 + Get 1)

Fisher's Island Lemonade Bucket (5) buy 4 get 1

A zesty blend of vodka and whiskey with natural lemon flavors, served in a convenient 355mL size.

A refreshing tea-infused beer blend with a unique twist, from Great South Bay Brewery.

Great South Bay Cosmic Juicy IPA

A crisp, golden apple cider with a refreshing finish, from the Strongbow brand.

A crisp, pale lager with a refreshing finish, served in a clear glass bottle.

Ciroc Pineapple Passion Seltzer

Stella Artois

A classic, light American pilsner beer with a mild hoppy note and a crisp finish.

A savory blend of tomato juice, spices, and garnishes including shrimp, lime wedges, celery, and olives.

Aperol Spritz with Aperol, soda, and Prosecco, garnished with fresh orange slices.

Fresh mint leaves, muddled raspberries, and lime slices mixed with Stoli raspberry vodka and soda water.

A crisp India Pale Ale with a hoppy profile, offered in a convenient can.

Warm Molten Lava with Homemade Hot Fudge, Vanilla Bean Ice Cream & Whipped Cream

Ice Cream Stuffed Crepe with Homemade Hot Fudge & Whipped Cream

A layered rainbow cookie cake with vibrant red, green, and yellow tiers, topped with a chocolate glaze and accompanied by whipped cream.

Carrot Cake with Caramel Sauce & Whipped Cream

Freshly Baked Apple Tart with Caramel Sauce, Vanilla Bean Ice cream & Whipped Cream

Peanut butter Cake with Carmel Sauce, Fudge & Whipped Cream!

A scoop of rich, creamy vanilla ice cream.

Call to ask what fun variation of Creme Brulee Jerry has prepared today!

Jerry's homemade vanilla bean creme brulee.

Gluten Free Brownie, Vanilla Bean Ice Cream, Whipped Cream & Hot Fudge

Mild, medium, hot, make me cry Jerry's famous 'not your ordinary' buffalo sauce, served with blue cheese and celery.

Breaded Mozzarella Sticks with homemade Marinara!

Served with remoulade sauce and baby veg garnish.

Hand breaded and lightly fried. Served with honey aioli.

Lightly Fried Hand Breaded Squid with mild, medium, or hot marinara sauce on side.

1 Dozen Little Neck Clams Steam in Garlic, Wine, Herb Compound Butter

old family recipe with chopped clams,bacon and shrimp

Crispy Calamari, Baby Arugula, Banana Peppers & Thai Chili Sauce

Broiled in garlic, butter, white wine, and herbs.

Crispy duck wings glazed with a savory sauce, sprinkled with sesame seeds, accompanied by a side of creamy dip.

Crispy Shrimp with shaved baby vegetables and Thai chili sauce

Panko Breaded Jumbo Shrimp Tossed in Jerry's 'Buffalo' With Celery & Bleu

Crispy Calamari & Banana Peppers with Plum Tomato Sauce

Freshly shucked littlenecks with crispy bacon, onions, mushrooms, and compound butter.

Crispy Edamame Pot Stickers with Soy Glaze & Wasabi Drizzle

White wine and garlic compound butter or marinara sauce.

Broiled Oysters with Bechamel Sauce & Melted Mozzarella Cheese

Lightly pan-fried artichokes with white wine and lemon reduction beurre Monte.

Local broiled oysters with bacon, caramelized onions, and baby spinach.

3 Local Oysters, 3 Littleneck Clams, 2 Shrimp Cocktail & Cocktail Sauce!

Dozen Local Clams on 1/2 Shell (Large or Small)

Half Dozen Local Clams on 1/2 Shell (Large or Small)

Wild, Local Oysters 6 pieces. On the 1/2 shell.

Mixed Greens, Shaved Vegetables, Tomatoes, Feta, Kalamata Olives & House Vinn

Local Clams, hickory-smoked bacon, vegetables, potatoes & cream..Yum!

Brooklyn's Finest Burrata with Baby Arugula, Roasted Peppers, Arugula Pesto & Balsamic Reduction

Mixed Green & Shaved Vegetables.

Mixed Green and seasonal vegetables with choice of dressing.

Local Clams, Hand Cut Veg, Potato, Tomato, Herbs & Love!

Gluten Free. Shredded green leaf, julienne carrots, cabbage, radish, broccoli, cauliflower, quinoa, and legume blend. Balsamic Vinn.

1 Quart Size of Manhattan Clam Chowder. Local Clams, Hand Cut Veg, Potato, Tomato, Herbs & Love!

Call To Inquire About Today's Soup Du Jour

Quart Size of Homemade Seafood Bisque. Crab Meat, Shrimp, Seafood Stock, Sherry & Cream. Thick, creamy and delicious.

Crab Meat, Shrimp, Seafood Stock, Sherry & Cream. Thick, creamy and delicious.

1 Quart Size of New England Chowder. Local Clams, hickory-smoked bacon, vegetables, potatoes & cream..Yum!

Blackened Fish, Garlic Ciabatta, Remoulade Sauce with waffle fries, homemade slaw and pickle

Marinated, Sliced Sirloin. On Garlic Ciabatta with Gorgonzola & Crispy Fried Onions. With Waffle Fries, Cole Slaw & Pickle

Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Toasted Brioche, Chipotle Aioli, Pepper Jack & LTO

Quinoa blend, Thai chili glazed vegetables, shredded green leaf, carrots and radish, on a herb wrap with pickle.

Crispy Shrimp, Thai Chili Glaze, Julienne Veggies & Mixed Greens.

Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & House Vinaigrette!

Topped with crispy fried onions, served with waffle fries and coleslaw on a toasted bun. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have a medical condition. Management advises that food prepared here may contain or have come in contact with peanuts, tree nuts, soybeans, milk, eggs, wheat, shellfish, or fish. Our customer's safety is of our utmost importance. Please do not take any unnecessary risks. Management cannot assure any cross-contamination of these ingredients with your dish.

Sauteed Chicken Breast with Lemon, Wine & Butter. Served with vegetables and choice of starch.

Char-Grilled Cheese Burger on Brioche with Waffle Fries, Cole Slaw and Pickle

Crispy chicken wings with a golden-brown coating, accompanied by two dipping sauces.

Served with waffle fries and coleslaw.

Vegan 'Beyond' burger served on toasted brioche with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and waffle fries.

Chargrilled Angus Burger with choice of toppings. Waffles Fries, Cole Slaw & Pickle.

Marinated NY Strip with Cajun Shrimp, Potato Du Jour & Veg Fricasee

Beer battered haddock. Served with waffle fries and coleslaw.

Hand Breaded, Crispy Jumbo Shrimp with Waffle Fries, Homemade Tarter & Slaw

Rigatoni ala Vodka with Crimini Mushrooms. Add Chicken or Shrimp for a good time.

Nonna's Original Recipe. Tender, Slow Cooked Scungelli with Plum Tomato Sauce Served Over Linguini!

Broiled Jumbo Shrimp with breadcrumbs, scampi compound butter & white whine. Served over linguine.

Hand Breaded Shrimp (5) with tomato sauce & melted mozzarella over linguini

Hand Breaded Squid, Lightly Fried Over Linguini with Marinara Sauce

Local (Shucked To Order) Chopped Clams, Garlic, Butter, Wine, EVOO & Herbs!

Sauteed Mussels in Plum Tomato Sauce over Linguini

Served with soy ginger glaze and wasabi aioli.

Fresh Picked Lobster Poached in Butter & Herbs on Toasted Brioche. Served with waffle fries, homemade slaw and pickle.

Pan Roasted Norwegian Salmon Served with wasabi aioli.

Broiled Shrimp, Scallops, Fish & Baked Clam with Bread Crumbs and Compound Butter. Vegetable Fricasee and choice of starch included.

Mild flavored, white fish with crushed almonds, breadcrumb, compound butter, and white wine.

Grilled Swordfish with Roasted Peppers, Tomatoes, Mozzarella & Garlic Compound Butter. Rice Pilaf & Vegetables (Gluten Free)

Broccoli, Cauliflower, Shaved Carrots & Assortment of Season Vegetables Glazed in Butter

Crispy, Seasoned Waffle Cut French Fries

Garlic Bread (4pc)

Crispy Coated Traditional Cut French Fries!

Homemade Cole Slaw with Pickle Purple Cabbage

A side of seasoned rice mixed with savory mushrooms.

Kosher Dill

Extra Cup Blue Cheese

Lightly fried, breaded thick cut onion rings.

Not so traditional, 'Jerry's Famous' Buffalo Sauce

Panko Breaded Flounder with Choice of Side

Char-grilled Cheese Burger on brioche with choice of sides

Kids Rigatoni with Butter or Marinara Sauce

Char-grilled Burger on brioche with choice of sides

All Beef Sabrette Hot Dog on Brioche with Choice of Side

Breaded Mozzarella Sticks with Choice of Side

Kids Linguini with Butter or Marinara Sauce

8oz buffalo sauce customizable with options including extra sauce, no blue cheese or celery, various heat levels (hot, medium, mild, plain), and specific parts like drums or tips.

A medley of fresh greens topped with ripe tomato slices, shredded carrots, and crisp radish rounds, served with a side of dressing.

Half tray of fish encrusted with a crunchy nut coating, accompanied by a selection of fresh vegetables. Suitable for large gatherings.

Arugula salad mixed with dried cranberries, sliced almonds, and crumbled blue cheese, accompanied by a side of dressing.

Full Tray Rigatoni ala Vodka

Full Size Tray of Shrimp Scampi Over Linguini

1/2 Tray of Jerry's Shrimp Scampi Served Over Linguini

Full Tray (Approx 40 pcs) Jerry's Homemade Baked Clams

1/2 Tray (Approx 20 pcs) Jerry's Homemade Baked Clams

A quart of our creamy, tomato-based vodka sauce, typically includes a blend of tomatoes, cream, and a touch of vodka for flavor.

1/2 Tray Rig Vodka

Full Tray (Approx 40 pcs) Jerry's Buffalo Fingers with Celery & Blue

1 Quart Size Container of 'Jerry's' Non Traditional Buffalo Sauce

40 pieces of Jerry's Wings!Mild, medium, hot, make me cry Jerry's famous 'non traditional' buffalo sauce, served with blue cheese and celery.

A generous mix of fresh greens topped with ripe tomato slices, shredded carrots, and crisp radish rounds, served with a side dressing. Suitable for large gatherings.

1/2 Tray (Approx 20 pcs) Jerry's Buffalo Fingers with Celery & Blue

80 Pieces of Jerry's Wings. Mild, medium, hot, make me cry Jerry's famous 'non traditional' buffalo sauce, served with blue cheese and celery.

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

A sweet mixture of ginger ale, a splash of grenadine, garnished with maraschino cherries.

A carbonated soft drink infused with ginger flavor.

Freshly squeezed orange juice with a vibrant citrus flavor.

Bottled natural spring water, refreshing and clear.

A refreshing glass of cranberry juice with a vibrant red hue.

A refreshing iced tea garnished with a slice of lemon.

The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

The same great taste but with zero calories.

A refreshing tonic water garnished with a fresh lemon slice.

Carbonated soft drink infused with the spicy-sweet flavor of ginger.

Pineapple Juice

Freshly pressed apple juice with a clear, golden hue and a natural sweetness.

Refreshing blend of iced tea and lemonade, a classic thirst quencher.

A clear, effervescent drink garnished with a fresh lemon slice.

A can of Red Bull, a caffeinated energy drink with a unique taste.

A tangy, citrus-filled, refreshing juice

A classic, smooth, and rich whole milk, freshly served.

Chocolate milk, typically includes a blend of milk and chocolate syrup.

A cup of 100% natural Lipton tea accompanied by a fresh lemon slice.

Decaf tea accompanied by a fresh lemon slice.

A freshly brewed cup of coffee with a deep, rich aroma.

A mug of decaffeinated coffee, freshly brewed.

A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

A refreshing blend of freshly squeezed lemon juice, water, and a touch of sweetness, garnished with a slice of lemon.