I Love NY Pizza Menu

4.4
(400+ Reviews)
$Pizza
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • NY Cheese X-Large 18"

      A generous 18-inch pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a classic hand-tossed crust.
      $22.23
      NY Cheese X-Large 18"
    • NY Cheese Medium 12"

      Golden crust topped with melted mozzarella and a rich tomato sauce.
      $16.67
      NY Cheese Medium 12"
    • NY Cheese Large 14"

      A generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese atop a classic tomato sauce, spread evenly on a large 14-inch hand-tossed pizza crust.
      $19.45
      NY Cheese Large 14"
    • Mozzarella Stick

      With marinara sauce
      $8.33
      Mozzarella Stick
    • Greek Salad

      Vegetarian. Feta, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, and onion.
      $12.50
      Greek Salad
    • Deluxe Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, mushroom, onions, green peppers, and black olives.
      $26.35
      Deluxe Pizza
    • NY White Pizza

      Vegetarian. Ricotta and mozzarella (no red sauce).
      $18.01
      NY White Pizza
    • Meat Lover's Pizza

      Pepperoni, ham and bacon
      $26.35
      Meat Lover's Pizza
    • Homemade Meatballs

      Homemade meatballs or sausage, choice of protein. Side order. Italian cuisine.
      $6.89
      Homemade Meatballs
    • Caesar Salad

      Vegetarian. Lettuce, croutons and parmesan cheese.
      $10.44
      Caesar Salad
  • Cheese Pizza

    Cheese Pizza
    • NY Cheese Medium 12"

      Golden crust topped with melted mozzarella and a rich tomato sauce.
      $16.67
      NY Cheese Medium 12"
    • NY Cheese Large 14"

      A generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese atop a classic tomato sauce, spread evenly on a large 14-inch hand-tossed pizza crust.
      $19.45
      NY Cheese Large 14"
    • NY Cheese X-Large 18"

      A generous 18-inch pizza topped with melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a classic hand-tossed crust.
      $22.23
      NY Cheese X-Large 18"
    • Sicilian Pizza Lg. 14"

      A 14-inch, thick crust square pizza, traditionally topped with cheese and a robust tomato sauce.
      $23.57
  • Specialty Pizza

    Specialty Pizza
    • Stuffed Veggie Pizza

      Spinach, broccoli, and mushrooms.
      $24.96
    • Specialty Pizza

      Ham, pepperoni, sausage, and meatballs.
      $24.96
    • Margherita Pizza

      Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, and tomatoes. please note that no modifications can be accommodated.
      $18.68
      Margherita Pizza
    • Stuffed Meat Pizza

      Peperoni,sausage,ham
      $24.04
      Stuffed Meat Pizza
    • Stuffed Chicken Pizza

      Chicken, bacon, tomato, cheddar, and ranch.
      $24.04
      Stuffed Chicken Pizza
    • NY White Pizza

      Vegetarian. Ricotta and mozzarella (no red sauce).
      $18.01
      NY White Pizza
    • Lasagna Pizza

      Ricotta, meatball, mozzarella, and sauce.
      $22.18
      Lasagna Pizza
    • Rio Ranch Pizza

      Bacon, tomato, and ranch.
      $19.40
    • Eggplant Parmigiana

      X-mozzarella, tomato, ricotta, and marinara sauce.
      $18.68
      Eggplant Parmigiana
    • Roma Spinach Pizza

      Spinach, fresh garlic, mozzarella, feta, and tomato.
      $19.40
      Roma Spinach Pizza
    • Italian Chicken Pizza

      Chicken, roma tomato and garlic.
      $20.02
      Italian Chicken Pizza
    • BBQ Chicken Pizza

      Chicken, BBQ sauce, garlic.
      $23.57
      BBQ Chicken Pizza
    • Hawaiian Pizza

      Ham and pineapple
      $23.57
      Hawaiian Pizza
    • Meat Lover's Pizza

      Pepperoni, ham and bacon
      $26.35
      Meat Lover's Pizza
    • Primavera Pizza

      Broccoli, spinach, roma tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers.
      $24.96
      Primavera Pizza
    • Deluxe Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, mushroom, onions, green peppers, and black olives.
      $26.35
      Deluxe Pizza
    • Steak and Cheese Pizza

      Steak, mushrooms, green peppers, and cheddar
      $23.57
      Steak and Cheese Pizza
  • Appetizers

    Appetizers
    • Mozzarella Stick

      With marinara sauce
      $8.33
      Mozzarella Stick
    • I Love NY Fries

      With mozzarella,cheddar and tomato sauce.
      $8.28
      I Love NY Fries
    • Hummus

      With fresh pita
      $6.94
    • Mixed Rolls Basket

      4 peperoni rolls 4 sausage rolls 4 spinach rolls with extra marinera/ranch sauce
      $37.53
      Mixed Rolls Basket
    • Zucchini Sticks

      With ranch or marinara sauce dipping.
      $8.33
      Zucchini Sticks
  • New York Stromboli

    New York Stromboli
    • Create your Own Stromboli

      Pick any toppings you like.
      $12.16
      Create your Own Stromboli
    • Broccoli

      Broccoli and cheese.
      $11.11
      Broccoli
    • Steak and Cheese Stromboli

      Steak, mushrooms, green peppers, and cheddar cheese.
      $13.55
      Steak and Cheese Stromboli
    • Great Western Stromboli

      Ground beef, green peppers, BBQ sauce, and cheddar cheese.
      $13.55
      Great Western Stromboli
    • Italian Meatball Stromboli

      Meatball, extra cheese and sauce.
      $13.55
      Italian Meatball Stromboli
    • New York Sausage Stromboli

      Italian sausage, green peppers, and pepperoni.
      $13.55
    • Original New York

      Ham, green peppers, and pepperoni.
      $13.55
      Original New York
  • Calzone

    Calzone
    • Broccoli Calzone

      Freshly baked dough filled with broccoli, a blend of cheeses, and typically includes a hint of garlic and herbs.
      $11.11
    • Cheese Calzone

      Mozzarella, ricotta cheese (no sauce).
      $12.16
    • Ham Calzone

      Mozzarella, ricotta, ham.
      $13.05
      Ham Calzone
    • Meatball Calzone

      Mozzarella, ricotta, meatball.
      $13.55
    • Pepperoni Calzone

      Mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni.
      $13.55
    • Spinach Calzone

      Mozzarella, ricotta, spinach.
      $13.05
      Spinach Calzone
  • Cold Sub

    Cold Sub
    • Ham, Turkey and Cheese Sub

      Ham, turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo serving with french fries.
      $13.84
      Ham, Turkey and Cheese Sub
    • Ham and Cheese Sub

      Ham, cheese. Lettuce, tomato, mayo. Serving with french fries.
      $12.45
      Ham and Cheese Sub
    • Italian Mix

      Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Serving with french fries.
      $13.84
      Italian Mix
    • Veggie Sub

      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and provolone, typically includes Italian dressing on a freshly baked sub roll.
      $12.50
    • Salami and Cheese Sub

      Salami, cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo serving with french fries.
      $12.45
    • Turkey and Cheese Sub

      Turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo serving with french fries.
      $12.45
  • Salads

    Salads
    • Antipasto Salad

      Pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, black olives, and onion.
      $12.50
      Antipasto Salad
    • Caesar Salad

      Vegetarian. Lettuce, croutons and parmesan cheese.
      $10.44
      Caesar Salad
    • Chef Salad

      Ham, turkey, roast beef, provolone, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, black olives, and onion.
      $12.50
      Chef Salad
    • Garden Salad

      Vegetarian. Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, black olives, and onion.
      $11.11
      Garden Salad
    • Caprese Salad

      Fresh mozarella,sliced tomato,basil,olive oil
      $12.50
    • Greek Salad

      Vegetarian. Feta, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, and onion.
      $12.50
      Greek Salad
    • Gyro Salad

      Gyro meat,lettuce,cucumber,tomato, peperonchini
      $13.89
      Gyro Salad
    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      Grilled chicken, feta cheese,lettuce, tomato, cucumber, black olives, and onion.
      $13.89
      Grilled Chicken Salad
  • Hot Subs

    Hot Subs
    • Chicken Milanese Sub

      Breaded chicken cutlet with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
      $12.04
      Chicken Milanese Sub
    • Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich

      Chicken, marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
      $15.23
      Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
    • Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich

      Eggplant, marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
      $15.23
    • Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich

      Meatball, marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
      $14.66
      Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
    • Sausage and Peppers Sub

      Sausage, green peppers, marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
      $15.23
    • Sausage Parmigiana Sandwich

      Sausage, marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
      $15.23
    • Steak and Cheese Sub

      Serving with lettuce, tomato, and mayo and side french fries.
      $14.66
      Steak and Cheese Sub
  • Italian Entrees

    Italian Entrees
    • Baked Spaghetti

      With ricotta and mozzarella.
      $14.39
    • Baked Ziti Anna Maria

      With sausage and meatball
      $18.41
      Baked Ziti Anna Maria
    • Baked Ziti Blanco

      With ricotta, mushrooms, and mozzarella
      $14.61
    • Homemade Baked Ziti

      Tender ziti pasta baked with rich tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and fresh basil.
      $14.39
      Homemade Baked Ziti
    • Baked Ziti Sicilian

      With eggplant
      $14.66
      Baked Ziti Sicilian
    • Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken

      Tender fettuccine coated in creamy Alfredo sauce, topped with succulent chicken pieces and a sprinkle of parsley.
      $16.00
      Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
    • Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta

      Breaded chicken breast, topped with marinara sauce and melted cheese, served alongside pasta.
      $18.01
    • Eggplant Parmigiana with Pasta

      Breaded eggplant, layered with marinara sauce and cheese, served alongside pasta.
      $16.62
    • Eggplant Rollatini with Pasta

      Breaded eggplant rolls filled with ricotta, typically served over pasta with a marinara sauce.
      $18.01
    • Fettuccine Alfredo

      Fettuccine coated in creamy Alfredo sauce, topped with tender chicken pieces and a garnish of finely chopped parsley.
      $14.66
      Fettuccine Alfredo
    • Homemade Meat Lasagna

      Layers of pasta, ground meat, tomato sauce, and melted cheese, garnished with fresh basil.
      $14.94
      Homemade Meat Lasagna
    • Penne Alla Vodka

      Penne pasta tossed in a creamy vodka sauce, often enriched with tomatoes, onions, and a hint of garlic. Prosciutto or pancetta may be included for added flavor.
      $13.84
    • Ravioli

      With cheese, meat or spinach
      $11.06
    • Homemade Veggie Lasagna

      Layers of homemade pasta, filled with a medley of garden vegetables such as spinach, mushrooms, and broccoli, complemented by rich ricotta cheese and a vibrant tomato sauce.
      $12.16
    • Spaghetti or Ziti with Meat Sauce

      Pasta topped with meat sauce, choice of spaghetti or ziti.
      $19.40
      Spaghetti or Ziti with Meat Sauce
    • Spaghetti or Ziti with Meatball or Sausage

      Pasta choice of spaghetti or ziti, served with either meatballs or sausage.
      $19.40
  • Lunch Specials

    Lunch Specials
    • 2 Large Cheese Pizzas

      2 Large cheese pizzas!
      $29.19
    • Med Pizza 1 Top + 10Wingz

      Medium-sized pizza with one selected topping, accompanied by 10 wings, typically prepared in Italian style.
      $22.23
    • 2 Med Pizza 1 Topping

      2 Medium cheese pizzas!
      $30.58
  • Side Orders

    Side Orders
    • Extra Sauce

      Selection of Italian sauces: balsamic, blue cheese, Italian dressing, marinara, ranch.
      $0.77
      Extra Sauce
    • French Fries

      Crispy golden strips of deliciousness served hot and seasoned to perfection.
      $4.10
    • Garlic Bread

      Crisp, buttery toasted bread infused with aromatic garlic and herbs.
      $5.49
    • Garlic Knots (3)

      Pizza dough tied into knots, brushed with garlic and olive oil, seasoned with herbs, and baked.
      $2.77
    • Homemade Meatballs

      Homemade meatballs or sausage, choice of protein. Side order. Italian cuisine.
      $6.89
      Homemade Meatballs
    • Side Salad

      Small portion of garden salad.
      $5.29
    • Side of Spaghetti or Ziti

      Choice of pasta served with spaghetti or ziti options. Ideal as a side order.
      $5.49
  • Wings

    Wings
    • 10 wings&Fries combo

      With ranch&marinera sauce
      $17.39
    • 12 Wings

      12 chicken wings, available in a variety of flavors including hot, mild, spicy, BBQ, honey garlic, plain, sweet chili Thai, buffalo, sweet and sour, salt and pepper, lemon and pepper.
      $18.06
    • 24 wings

      Twenty-four chicken wings, typically served with a variety of sauces to cater to different tastes.
      $33.36
    • 6 wings

      Tender chicken wings coated in a tangy, spicy sauce, served with a side of creamy dipping sauce.
      $8.33
      6 wings
  • Dessert

    Dessert
    • Cannoli

      Crispy pastry shells filled with sweet ricotta cheese, drizzled with chocolate sauce, and dusted with powdered sugar.
      $4.87
      Cannoli
    • NY Cheesecake

      Creamy cheesecake slice with a graham cracker crust, drizzled with rich chocolate sauce.
      $5.49
      NY Cheesecake
    • Tiramisu

      Layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone cheese, and cocoa powder, drizzled with chocolate syrup.
      $6.26
      Tiramisu
  • Catering

    Catering
    • Baked Ziti(feeds 8-10)

      Ziti pasta mixed with marinara sauce and ricotta, generously topped with Italian cheeses and baked to perfection.
      $45.87
    • Chicken Parm Pasta(feeds 15)

      Spagetti or Ziti or Fetucchine
      $68.12
    • Greek Salad(feeds 16-20)

      A generous Greek Salad designed to serve 16-20, featuring a blend of crisp romaine and iceberg lettuce, ripe tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, kalamata olives, and feta cheese, dressed in a traditional Greek vinaigrette.
      $58.39
    • Greek Salad(feeds 8-10)

      lettuce,tomato,cucumber,onion,kalamata olives,peperonchini peppers,feta cheese
      $30.58

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Milton Mediterranean Cuisine
Milton Mediterranean Cuisine
4.3
(52 Reviews)
Mediterranean
China Sky
China Sky
4.0
(88 Reviews)
Chinese
Tokyo Sushi
Tokyo Sushi
4.1
(115 Reviews)
Sushi
Subway
Subway
3.7
(43 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Wing SZN - Milton
Wing SZN - Milton
3.4
(8 Reviews)
Chicken wings, Restaurant
7 Acre BarnGrill
7 Acre BarnGrill
4.7
(931 Reviews)
New American, Bar
The Cafe at Scottsdale Farms
The Cafe at Scottsdale Farms
4.7
(35 Reviews)
Brunch
Scottsdale Farms Garden Center
Scottsdale Farms Garden Center
4.6
(401 Reviews)
Cafe
Bloom Roadside
Bloom Roadside
4.6
(319 Reviews)
Donut shop, Breakfast, Coffee shop

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms