I Love New York Pizza of Route 4 Menu

4.0

(225+ Reviews)

Pizza Gourmet Pizza Sicilian Pizza Pizza by the Slice Appetizers Salads Buffalo Wings Calzones Strombolis Quesadillas Hot Subs Cold Subs Wraps Pasta Dinners Desserts Beverages Catering Trays

Pizza
- Build Your Own Pizza
  Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
- Build Your Own Sicilian Pizza
  Sicilian thick crust pie.
- Gluten Free Crust Pizza
  Gluten free pizza with classic cheese.
  $15.99
Gourmet Pizza
- Margherita Pizza
  Fresh mozzarella, hand crushed tomatoes, fresh basil & extra virgin olive oil.
- Italian Supremo Pizza
  Marinated artichokes, eggplant, roasted red peppers, black olives, and spinach.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
  Crispy chicken, bacon and ranch.
- Meat Lovers Pizza
  Pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon.
- Steak & Veggie Pizza
  Steak, mushrooms, green peppers, onions & mozzarella cheese.
- Broccoli Chicken Ranch Pizza
  Crispy chicken, fresh broccoli, and ranch.
- White Broccoli Ricotta Pizza
  Fresh garlic, broccoli, and ricotta.
- Veggie Pizza
  Mushrooms, black olives, onions, and green peppers.
- Four Cheese Pizza
  Our signature pizza that features the mix of four cheeses, American, Provolone, Mozzarella & Cheddar cheese.
- Tomato Bacon Ranch Pizza
  White with bacon, tomato, ranch dressing & mozzarella cheese.
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
  Crispy chicken and house-made Buffalo sauce.
- Deluxe Pizza
  Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
- Fra Diavolo Pizza
  Signature spicy pizza sauce, jalapeno peppers, and Italian sausage.
- Potato Bacon Cheddar Pizza
  New world pizza has mashed potato as a base with crispy bacon topped with our premium mozzarella and yellow cheddar cheese.
- Spicy Red Rooster Pizza
  Signature spicy sauce, provolone, grilled chicken roasted red peppers, and red pepper flakes.
- Baked Ziti Pizza
  Ziti with marinara sauce, grated parmesan cheese, and ricotta.
- Bruschetta Pizza
  Raw tomatoes with onions tossed in herbed extra virgin olive oil with fresh garlic over white cheese pizza topped with fresh basil.
- BBQ Pizza
  Crispy chicken, and bbq sauce.
- Moonshine Pizza
  Crispy chicken, and moonshine sauce.
- Hawaiian Pizza
  Ham, and pineapple.
- Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
  Marinara sauce, crispy chicken, parmesan cheese and ricotta.
- Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza
  Marinara sauce, eggplant, parmesan cheese and ricotta.
Sicilian Pizza
- Sicilian Italiano Supreme Pizza
  Marinated artichokes, eggplant, roasted red peppers, black olives, spinach.
- Sicilian Fra Diavolo Pizza
  Signature spicy pizza sauce, jalapeno peppers & Italian sausage.
- Sicilian Vegetarian Pizza
  Mushrooms, black olives, onions, & green peppers.
- Sicilian Baked Ziti Pizza
  Ziti with marinara sauce, grated parmesan & ricotta.
- Sicilian Buffalo Chicken Pizza
  Crispy chicken & house made buffalo sauce.
- Sicilian Chicken Broccoli & Ranch Pizza
  Crispy chicken, broccoli, and ranch.
- Sicilian BBQ Chicken Pizza
  Crispy chicken & BBQ sauce.
- Sicilian Deluxe Pizza
  Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.
- Sicilian Moonshine Chicken Pizza
  Crispy chicken & moonshine sauce.
- Sicilian Margherita Pizza
  Fresh mozzarella, hand crushed tomatoes, fresh basil & extra virgin olive oil.
- Sicilian Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
  Crispy chicken, bacon & ranch.
- Sicilian Meat Lover's Pizza
  Pepperoni, sausage, ham & bacon.
- Sicilian Spicy Red Rooster Pizza
  Signature spicy pizza sauce, provolone cheese, grilled chicken, roasted red peppers & red pepper flakes.
- Sicilian White Broccoli Ricotta Pizza
  Fresh garlic, broccoli & ricotta.
- Sicilian Hawaiian Pizza
  Ham & pineapple.
- Sicilian Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
  Marinara sauce, crispy chicken, parmesan cheese & ricotta.
- Bruschetta Sicilian Pizza
  Raw tomatoes with onions tossed in herbed extra virgin olive oil with fresh garlic over white cheese pizza topped with fresh basil.
Pizza by the Slice
- Regular Cheese Pizza Slice
  $3.50
- Pepperoni Pizza Slice
  $3.75
- Sausage Pizza Slice
  $3.75
- Mushroom Pizza Slice
  $3.75
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice
  $3.75
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice
  $3.75
Appetizers
- Garlic Knots
  A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.
  $4.50
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite!
  $8.99
- Jalapeno Poppers
  Juicy jalapeno poppers breaded and filled with cheese and fried to golden perfection.
  $8.99
- Fried Cheese Ravioli
  $8.99
- Fried Mushrooms
  $8.99
- Chicken Tenders
  BBQ sauce on the side.
  $8.99
- Buffalo Tenders
  With blue cheese on the side.
  $9.99
- Mac & Cheese Bites
  $8.99
- French Fries
  Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!
- Sweet Potato Fries
- Onion Rings
  Crispy onion slices deep-fried until golden-brown.
- Zucchini Fries
  $7.99
- Fried Pickles
  $8.99
- Beef Patty
  $2.99
- Beef Patty With Cheese
  $3.99
- Garlic Bread
  Bread, topped with garlic, herb seasoning, baked to perfection.
  $4.99
- Garlic Bread With Cheese
  A cross between garlic bread and pizza, cheesy bread is a quick, easy, and delicious party snack.
  $5.99
- Meatballs
  $6.99
Salads
- House Salad
  House croutons, tomato, olives, cucumber, onion on the bed of lettuce.
- Antipasto Salad
  Italian meats, provolone, pepperoncini, tomato, olives, cucumber, onion, on the bed of lettuce.
- Chef's Salad
  Turkey, ham, mozzarella, house croutons, tomato, olives, cucumber, onion, on the bed of lettuce.
- Crispy Chicken Salad
  Crispy chicken, house croutons, tomato, olives, cucumbers, onion on the bed of lettuce.
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  Grilled chicken, house croutons, tomato, olives, cucumbers, onion on the bed of lettuce.
- Chicken Caesar Salad
  Grilled chicken, parmesan cheese, house croutons, on the bed of lettuce.
- Greek Salad
  Feta cheese, kalamata olives, green peppers, tomato, cucumber, onion on the bed of lettuce.
- Spring Salad
  Artichokes, grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, tomato, olives, cucumber, onion on the bed of lettuce.
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  Crispy or grilled chicken, banana peppers, tomato, olives, cucumber, onion on the bed of lettuce.
- BBQ Chicken Salad
  Crispy or grilled chicken, banana peppers, tomato, olives, cucumber, onion on the bed of lettuce.
Buffalo Wings
- Bone In Wings
- Boneless Wings
Calzones
- Cheese Calzone
  Mozzarella & ricotta, served with marinara sauce.
  $11.99
- Buffalo Chicken Calzone
  $12.99
- Vegetable Calzone
  Mozzarella, ricotta, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions & peppers.
  $12.99
- Steak Calzone
  With mushrooms, onions, and peppers.
  $12.99
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone
  $13.99
- Deluxe Calzone
  Mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms.
  $13.99
Strombolis
- Cheese Stromboli
  Mozzarella cheese, served with marinara sauce.
  $12.99
- Ham Stromboli
  $12.99
- Turkey & Bacon Stromboli
  $12.99
- Steak Stromboli
  With onions and peppers.
  $13.99
- Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
  $13.99
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli
  $13.99
- Deluxe Stromboli
  Pepperoni, sausage and green peppers.
  $14.99
Quesadillas
- Grilled Chicken Quesadilla
  $10.99
- Crispy Chicken Quesadilla
  $10.99
- Steak Quesadilla
  $10.99
- Cheese Quesadilla
  $9.99
- Vegetable Quesadilla
  $9.99
Hot Subs
- Philly Steak Sub
  Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, & mozzarella cheese.
  $12.99
- Buffalo Chicken Sub
  Buffalo chicken toasted with mozzarella cheese.
  $11.99
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
  $12.99
- Meatball Parmigiana Sub
  $12.99
- Chicken Parmigiana Sub
  $12.99
- Sausage Parmigiana Sub
  $11.99
- Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
  $11.99
- Sausage, Peppers, Onions Sub
  $11.99
Cold Subs
- Turkey & Cheese Sub
  $10.99
- Ham & Cheese Sub
  $10.99
- Italian Mix Sub
  Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, oil & vinegar.
  $12.99
- Turkey & Bacon Sub
  $11.99
- Chicken Cutlet Sub
  $11.99
- Salami & Cheese Sub
  $10.99
Wraps
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap
  $8.99
- Grilled Chicken Wrap
  $8.99
- Crispy Chicken Wrap
  $8.99
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  $8.99
- Turkey Club Wrap
  $9.99
- Roasted Crumbled Turkey Wrap
  $9.99
- Veggie Wrap
  $7.99
Pasta
- Spaghetti
  $9.99
- Ziti
  $9.99
- Manicotti
  A large tube of fresh pasta stuffed with a blend of soft cheese.
  $9.99
Dinners
- Chicken Parmigiana
  $15.99
- Meatball Parmigiana
  $15.99
- Sausage Parmigiana
  $15.99
- Eggplant Parmigiana
  $15.99
- Beef Lasagna
  $15.99
- Baked Ziti
  Ziti with mozzarella and tomato sauce baked to perfection in our oven.
  $14.99
Desserts
- Fried Dough Balls
  $3.99
- New York Cheesecake
  Classic New York cheesecake with a creamy satiny texture.
  $4.99
- Big Cannoli
  $4.99
- Three Layer Carrot Cake
  $4.75
- Triple Chocolate Cake
  $4.75
- Lava Cake
  $4.99
Beverages
- Soda
  Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.
- Iced Tea
Catering Trays
- House Salad Catering
  House croutons, tomato, olives, cucumber, onion on the bed of lettuce.
- Baked Ziti Catering
- Ziti With Marinara Catering
- Spaghetti With Marinara Catering
- Meatballs Catering
- Sausage, Peppers & Onions Catering
- Penne Ala Vodka Catering
- Chicken Eggplant Parmigiana Catering
- Lasagna Catering
- Chicken Tenders Catering
- Mozzarella Sticks Catering
- Garlic Knots Catering
- Fried Dough Bites Catering
- Caesar Salad Catering
- Specialty Salad Catering

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

I Love New York Pizza of Route 4 Menu

Pizza

Build Your Own Pizza

Build Your Own Sicilian Pizza

Gluten Free Crust Pizza

Gourmet Pizza

Margherita Pizza

Italian Supremo Pizza

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Meat Lovers Pizza

Steak & Veggie Pizza

Broccoli Chicken Ranch Pizza

White Broccoli Ricotta Pizza

Veggie Pizza

Four Cheese Pizza

Tomato Bacon Ranch Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Deluxe Pizza

Fra Diavolo Pizza

Potato Bacon Cheddar Pizza

Spicy Red Rooster Pizza

Baked Ziti Pizza

Bruschetta Pizza

BBQ Pizza

Moonshine Pizza

Hawaiian Pizza

Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza

Sicilian Pizza

Sicilian Italiano Supreme Pizza

Sicilian Fra Diavolo Pizza

Sicilian Vegetarian Pizza

Sicilian Baked Ziti Pizza

Sicilian Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Sicilian Chicken Broccoli & Ranch Pizza

Sicilian BBQ Chicken Pizza

Sicilian Deluxe Pizza

Sicilian Moonshine Chicken Pizza

Sicilian Margherita Pizza

Sicilian Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Sicilian Meat Lover's Pizza

Sicilian Spicy Red Rooster Pizza

Sicilian White Broccoli Ricotta Pizza

Sicilian Hawaiian Pizza

Sicilian Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

Bruschetta Sicilian Pizza

Pizza by the Slice

Regular Cheese Pizza Slice

Pepperoni Pizza Slice

Sausage Pizza Slice

Mushroom Pizza Slice

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice

Appetizers

Garlic Knots

Mozzarella Sticks

Jalapeno Poppers

Fried Cheese Ravioli

Fried Mushrooms

Chicken Tenders

Buffalo Tenders

Mac & Cheese Bites

French Fries

Sweet Potato Fries

Onion Rings

Zucchini Fries

Fried Pickles

Beef Patty

Beef Patty With Cheese

Garlic Bread

Garlic Bread With Cheese

Meatballs

Salads

House Salad

Antipasto Salad

Chef's Salad

Crispy Chicken Salad

Grilled Chicken Salad

Chicken Caesar Salad

Greek Salad