I Like Pie Bakeshop Menu

With brown sugar custard and chocolate chips, Chocolate Chip Chess has all the gooey goodness of a warm cookie in our buttery, sweet crust. We double the cookie goodness with a chocolate chip cookie on top. Checkmate!

It’s all about that crunchy, buttery, sweet cinnamon crumble. Ohhhh, and tart Granny Smith apples caressed by cinnamon sugar sauce. Perfectly topped with a crust cookie garnish. Not too sweet, and perfect for any season.

Meet our most popular fruit pie. It’s sweet, tart, and brimming with blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, and cherries. Baked in our traditional crust and topped with our classic shortbread crumble.

This is sweet + salty at its tastiest. Dig into a layer of ripe bananas, homemade pastry cream, and a dollop of salted caramel in our traditional crust. Topped with whip and salted toffee bits. (It’s OK to drool.)

You know this one: classic key lime filling, salty sweet graham crust, and a must-have mound of fresh whipped cream. Tart, creamy and here year-round thanks to customer pleas.

A tart and sweet strawberry rhubarb filling baked in our traditional pie crust, topped with a shortbread crumble and dusted with powdered sugar. Pairs well with our vanilla ice cream.

Made in our traditional pie crust with a lemon buttermilk custard, topped with a crust cookie and powdered sugar.

Modeled after the Good Humor ice cream bar, the Strawberry Shortcake is made with our traditional pie crust, layered with shortbread crumble, a sweet strawberry filling and our homemade vanilla pastry cream, and is topped with our shortbread crumble and a fresh whipped cream.