Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe Menu

Salted peanut butter ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten, Peanuts & Soy

Brown sugar sweet cream ice cream loaded up with homemade chocolate chip cookies Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Brown butter chocolate ice cream mixed with homemade crispy brownie corner pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Mint ice cream loaded with Oreos, house-made double chocolate cookies, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips & Golden Oreos Dairy: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, & Soy

Our bold cold brew based ice cream loaded up with Oreos! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

2023 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Salted butterscotch ice cream loaded with house-made caramelized Biscoff bark! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

2024 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Honey-infused pistachio butter base, with roasted pistachio toffee and bits of crispy phyllo dough Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Tree Nuts

Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Spiced Chai ice cream loaded with house-made chocolate orange "Tiger Bark"  Contains: Dairy & Soy

National Award-Winning Chocolate: NAICA Blue Ribbon Chocolate ice cream made with super premium Republica Del Cacao cocoa powder.   Contains: Dairy

Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream loaded with house made “Muddy Buddies” and peanut butter swirl!

Brown sugar buttercream ice cream loaded with mini oatmeal cream pies Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Spiced pumpkin ice cream mixed with house-made graham cracker cookie crust Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

2022 North American Ice Cream Association National Flavor of the Year (1st Place) Salted Butter Cracker ice cream loaded with house-made Ritz Cracker Toffee Bark Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

2024 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Honey-infused pistachio butter base, with roasted pistachio toffee and bits of crispy phyllo dough Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Tree Nuts

2023 North American Ice Cream Association Flavor of the Year (Northeast Region) Salted butterscotch ice cream loaded with house-made caramelized Biscoff bark! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

2022 North American Ice Cream Association National Flavor of the Year (3rd Place) Lemon curd ice cream loaded with house-made lemon bars Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Fruity Pebbles steeped ice cream mixed with colorful cereal marshmallows. Colored with all natural Blue Spirulina! Contains: Dairy & Soy

National Award-Winning Chocolate: NAICA Blue Ribbon Chocolate ice cream made with premium Dutch chocolate Contains: Dairy

Cinnamon brown sugar ice cream loaded with cinnamon churro dough chunks Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Our bold cold brew based ice cream loaded up with Oreos! Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Creamy vanilla ice cream mixed with chunks of cookie dough and chocolate chips Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten & Soy

Brown butter chocolate ice cream mixed with homemade crispy brownie corner pieces Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

National Award-Winning Vanilla: NAICA Blue Ribbon Vanilla bean ice cream made with pure Madagascar vanilla beans Contains: Dairy

Brown sugar sweet cream ice cream loaded up with homemade chocolate chip cookies Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten & Soy

Mint ice cream loaded with Oreos, house-made double chocolate cookies, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips & Golden Oreos Dairy: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, & Soy

Salted peanut butter ice cream loaded with Oreos Contains: Dairy, Gluten, Peanuts & Soy

National Award-Winning Strawberry: NAICA Red Ribbon Rich strawberry ice cream made with house-made strawberry reduction Contains: Dairy

National Award-Winning Vanilla: NAICA Blue Ribbon Classic, creamy vanilla ice cream made with all natural Madagascar Vanilla Contains: Dairy

Iced coffee ice cream. Extra Cream. Extra Sugar. Contains: Dairy

Coconut based ice cream loaded with GLUTEN FREE Oreos.

Coconut based cookie butter ice cream loaded with speculoos cookies Contains: Gluten, Soy & Tree Nuts

Vegan peppermint ice cream loaded with GLUTEN FREE Oreos and crushed candy cane Contains: Soy & Tree Nuts