Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington Menu

4.4

(850+ Reviews)

Authentic PA Hoagies Cheesesteaks Nathan's All Beef Hot Dogs Vegetarian/Vegan Options PA Sides & Snacks Shredded Salads Beverages Kids' Menu

Authentic PA Hoagies
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Brotherly Love (Small 7 Inch)
  Turkey, D&W black forest ham, salami, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Brotherly Love (Regular 9 Inch)
  Turkey, D&W black forest ham, salami, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Brotherly Love (Large 18 Inch)
  Turkey, D&W black forest ham, salami, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Hog Island (Small 7 Inch)
  D&W black forest ham, salami, prosciutto, capicola, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Hog Island (Regular 9 Inch)
  D&W black forest ham, salami, prosciutto, capicola, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Hog Island (Large 18 Inch)
  D&W black forest ham, salami, prosciutto, capicola, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Zern's (Small 7 Inch)
  Dietz & Watson sliced ring bologna, house red beet pickled egg, muenster, mayo, & whole grain beer mustard.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Zern's (Regular 9 Inch)
  Dietz & Watson sliced ring bologna, house red beet pickled egg, muenster, mayo, & whole grain beer mustard.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Zern's (Large 18 Inch)
  Dietz & Watson sliced ring bologna, house red beet pickled egg, muenster, mayo, & whole grain beer mustard.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Keystone (Small 7 Inch)
  D&W london broil, provolone, house horseradish mayo, & lto.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Keystone (Regular 9 Inch)
  D&W london broil, provolone, house horseradish mayo, & lto.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Keystone (Large 18 Inch)
  D&W london broil, provolone, house horseradish mayo, & lto.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Pitt Twist (Small 7 Inch)
  D&W black forest ham, provolone, & mayo, topped with house slaw & chips.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Pitt Twist (Regular 9 Inch)
  D&W black forest ham, provolone, & mayo, topped with house slaw & chips.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Pitt Twist (Large 18 Inch)
  D&W black forest ham, provolone, & mayo, topped with house slaw & chips.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Dutch Country (Small 7 Inch)
  Seltzer’s lebanon bologna, muenster, whole grain beer mustard, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Dutch Country (Regular 9 Inch)
  Seltzer’s lebanon bologna, muenster, whole grain beer mustard, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Dutch Country (Large 18 Inch)
  Seltzer’s lebanon bologna, muenster, whole grain beer mustard, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Market St (Small 7 Inch)
  D&W turkey & black forest ham, house slaw, muenster, & 1000 island.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Market St (Regular 9 Inch)
  D&W turkey & black forest ham, house slaw, muenster, & 1000 island.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Market St (Large 18 Inch)
  D&W turkey & black forest ham, house slaw, muenster, & 1000 island.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Shipyard (Small 7 Inch)
  House tuna salad, peppadew peppers, provolone, parm, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Shipyard (Regular 9 Inch)
  House tuna salad, peppadew peppers, provolone, parm, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Shipyard (Large 18 Inch)
  House tuna salad, peppadew peppers, provolone, parm, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Reading Terminal (Small 7 Inch)
  Italian marinated tomatoes, banana peppers, parmesan, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Reading Terminal (Regular 9 Inch)
  Italian marinated tomatoes, banana peppers, parmesan, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Reading Terminal (Large 18 Inch)
  Italian marinated tomatoes, banana peppers, parmesan, provolone, & ltoo.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Lancaster (Small 7 Inch)
  Creamy cucumber dill, bacon bits, muenster, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Lancaster (Regular 9 Inch)
  Creamy cucumber dill, bacon bits, muenster, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Lancaster (Large 18 Inch)
  Creamy cucumber dill, bacon bits, muenster, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - The "Always Sunny" (Small 7 Inch)
  Bacon bits, D&W turkey, muenster, horseradish mayo, banana peppers, peppadew peppers, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - The "Always Sunny" (Regular 9 Inch)
  Bacon bits, D&W turkey, muenster, horseradish mayo, banana peppers, peppadew peppers, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - The "Always Sunny" (Large 18 Inch)
  Bacon bits, D&W turkey, muenster, horseradish mayo, banana peppers, peppadew peppers, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Ham (Small 7 Inch)
  D&W ham, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Ham (Regular 9 Inch)
  D&W ham, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Ham (Large 18 Inch)
  D&W ham, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Turkey (Small 7 Inch)
  D&W turkey, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Turkey (Medium 9 Inch)
  D&W turkey, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, & lt.
- Authentic PA Hoagie - Turkey (Large 18 Inch)
  D&W turkey, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, & lt.
Cheesesteaks
- Cheesesteak - The Traditional Cheesesteak (Small 7 Inch)
  With or without fried onions. Choose: whiz, American, or provolone. Add sharp provolone or cooper sharp American, for extra charge.
- Cheesesteak - The Traditional Cheesesteak (Regular 9 Inch)
  With or without fried onions. Choose: whiz, American, or provolone. Add sharp provolone or cooper sharp American, for extra charge.
- Cheesesteak - The Traditional Chicken Cheesesteak (Small 7 Inch)
  With or without fried onions. Choose: whiz, American, or provolone. Add sharp provolone or cooper sharp American, for extra charge.
- Cheesesteak - The Traditional Chicken Cheesesteak (Regular 9 Inch)
  With or without fried onions. Choose: whiz, American, or provolone. Add sharp provolone or cooper sharp American, for extra charge.
- Cheesesteak - Cheesesteak Hoagie (Small 7 Inch)
  Choice of cheese, served with mayo on a roll, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, raw onions, & Italian seasonings.
- Cheesesteak - Cheesesteak Hoagie (Regular 9 Inch)
  Choice of cheese, served with mayo on a roll, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, raw onions, & Italian seasonings.
- Cheesesteak - Chicken Cheesesteak Hoagie (Small 7 Inch)
  Choice of cheese, served with mayo on a roll, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, raw onions, & Italian seasonings.
- Cheesesteak - Chicken Cheesesteak Hoagie (Regular 9 Inch)
  Choice of cheese, served with mayo on a roll, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, raw onions, & Italian seasonings.
- Cheesesteak - The Very Best Cheesesteak (Small 7 Inch)
  House spicy sauce, American cheese, & fried onion.
- Cheesesteak - The Very Best Cheesesteak (Regular 9 Inch)
  House spicy sauce, American cheese, & fried onion.
- Cheesesteak - Philly Special Cheesesteak (Small 7 Inch)
  Aged sharp provolone, banana peppers, fried onion, tomatoes, hint of house spicy sauce, & parmesan.
- Cheesesteak - Philly Special Cheesesteak (Regular 9 Inch)
  Aged sharp provolone, banana peppers, fried onion, tomatoes, hint of house spicy sauce, & parmesan.
- Cheesesteak - The Zaire #44 Cheesesteak (Small 7 Inch)
  He's from North Philly & line back for the Colts! American, fried onion, mayo, ketchup, yellow mustard, salt, & pepper.
- Cheesesteak - The Zaire #44 Cheesesteak (Regular 9 Inch)
  He's from North Philly & a linebacker for the Colts! American, fried onion, mayo, ketchup, yellow mustard, salt, & pepper.
Nathan's All Beef Hot Dogs
- Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog - Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog
  Choose from various toppings. Add letchup, mustard, and/or relish, No charge. Add other toppings for extra charge.
- Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog - Very Best Dog
  House spicy sauce, American cheese, or fried onions.
- Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog - Texas Tommy Dog
  Bacon & American wrap dog, deep fried & topped with raw onions.
- Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog - Dutch Dog
  Smoked lebanon bologna, muenster, horseradish mayo, & pickle.
- Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog - Phreedom Dog
  Nathan’s hot dog, topped with ribeye, fried onions, cheez whiz, & pepper relish.
- Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog - Chilly & Cheese Dog
  Beer chili & cheese, made with chilly water brew. Built to last pilsner.
Vegetarian/Vegan Options
- Vegan Option - Vegan Italian "Sausage" On A Hot Dog Bun
  Soy & plant based sausage, with Italian seasonings, fried onions, & sweet peppers, topped with our house spicy sauce.
- Vegan Option - Vegan Spinach Wrap
  House blood orange IPA hummus, sauteed broccoli rabe, pepper relish, tomatoes, & raw onions.
- Vegetarian Option - Little It's Grilled Veggie (Small)
  Sauteed broccoli rabe, fried onions, pepper relish, sharp provolone, house Italian oil, & parmesan.
- Vegetarian Option - Little It's Grilled Veggie (Regular)
  Served on a regular sized hoagie roll. Sauteed broccoli rabe, fried onions, pepper relish, sharp provolone, house Italian oil, & parmesan.
PA Sides & Snacks
- PA Side - Herr's Chips
  Regular, bbq, sour cream & onion, jalapeno kettle, habanero ranch.
- PA Side - Nan's Red Skin Potato Salad
  Grandmothers recipe.
  $3.25
- PA Side - Crinkle Cut Fries (Side)
  $3.90
- PA Side - Crinkle Cut Fries (Basket)
  $7.48
- PA Side - Bacon & Beer Cheese Crinkle Cut Fries
  $10.08
- PA Side - Veggie Crinkle Cut Fries
  tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, & beer cheese.\n
  $10.08
- PA Side - Cheesesteak Crinkle Cut Fries
  Sliced ribeye, cheez whiz, & fried onions.\n\n
  $11.70
- PA Side - Chili Cheese Fries
  Homemade chili & beer cheese.
  $10.40
- PA Side - D&W Whole Deli Pickle
  $3.58
- PA Side - House Coleslaw
  $3.25
- PA Side - Creamy Cucumber Dill
  $3.25
- PA Side - PA Dutch Box
  Ring bologna, lebanon bologna, muenster cheese, bread, salted butter, whole grain beer mustard, & pickled red beet egg.
  $18.20
- PA Side - Onion Rings (Side)
  $5.20
- PA Side - Onion Rings (Basket)
  $8.45
- PA Side - Peppadew Pepper Shooters (2)
  Prosciutto & provolone, with a splash of balsamic.
  $1.63
- PA Side - House Red Beet Pickled Eggs (2)
  Family PA Dutch recipe.
  $3.90
- PA Side - Blood Orange IPA Hummus Basket
  Chilly water brewing blood orange IPA hummus, with cucumbers, garlic toast, & cheese cubes.
  $10.40
Shredded Salads
- Shredded Salad - Valley Forge Salad
  Shredded lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, onions, peppadew peppers or banana peppers, & parmesan. Choice of dressing: house Italian, balsamic, ranch, or thousand island.
- Shredded Salad - Mr. Nittany Salad
  Shredded lettuce, tomato, cucumber, tuna, parmesan, & house oil.
Beverages
- Beverage - Fountain Drink
  Coke, cherry coke, diet coke, or lemonade.
- Beverage - Hank's Craft Sodas
  Choose your Hank's soda.
- Beverage - Pellegrino (Bottle)
  $4.55
- Beverage - Mexican Coke (Bottle)
  $4.55
Kids' Menu
- Kids' Menu - Kids' Grilled Hot Dog
  Comes with fries & kids' fountain drink.
- Kids' Menu - Kids' Turkey & Cheese Hoagie
  Comes with fries & kids' fountain drink.
- Kids' Menu - Kids' Ham & Cheese Hoagie
  Comes with fries & kids' fountain drink.
- Kids' Menu - Kids' Grilled Cheese W/American Cheese
  Comes with fries & kids' fountain drink.